Business Astrology

You would have to ask Schroedinger's cat, or, maybe Fat Freddie's cat. The answer is a binary outcome, more or less.
 
What does biting ankles and grabbing tape recorders have to do with anything??
 
Zep said:
I am willing to bet that even Claus, strident though he might be, has never actually wanted to hurt you - he just has a forceful way of arguing that you don't seem to like, that's all.

Of course I have never wanted to hurt Karen or anyone else.

It's not merely my way of arguing. It's simply because Karen gets (easily) frustrated from her lack of ability to answer simple, basic questions about astrology, and not just from me. Take a look at this thread.

And this is not merely Karen who responds this way. Proponents of paranormal phenomena often have very short fuses. I'm sure psychologists could explain why.

magicflute said:
This demonstrates at least to me that talking to Karen is a total waste of time. She creates her own reality and nothing anyone says or does will change it.

Precisely.

Pyrrho said:
Basically, because you personally do not speak for Mr. Randi.

That is true. I do not speak for anyone else but myself. Are you using indisputable logic against me? :)

If Karen feels a crime has been committed against her, she should most definitely at the very least seek legal advice.

She claims to do that very often, although nothing ever seems to come of it. Frankly, I've never heard of anyone with a business spending quite that much time with his/her lawyer, discussing possible lawsuits and legal action.

She's gotta do what she's gotta do.

Zep said:
C'mon! I made a nice pun! Don't I get any cred for that?? :)

Yes, yes, you're so funny. You should write for "Roseanne" or "Father Knows Best". ;)

T'ai Chi said:
What does biting ankles and grabbing tape recorders have to do with anything??

Nothing. They are only ways of shifting focus away from the hard issues.

(waiting for the penny to drop)
 
Karen Boesen said:
Good night Genttlemen! It is late in Copenhagen.

If you get the impression that I have met Mr. Larsen, you are wrong, and hopefully that will never happen either.

Now I know that the guy is complete insane. He not only beats people. He also bites. Very nice fellow. Maybe he is just an ordinary skeptic?
Karen,

It appears you have decided that you WILL stay and talk with us after all. That is good.

Could you please confirm here what you said in the second sentence of your post that I have highlighted for you. In it you say that you have never met Mr Claus (CF) Larsen. Is that absolutely, really true? You really have not ever met him face to face? You have never seen or met him anywhere in the world at all?

And have you ever personally met Mr Dann? Or Mr Modens Winther? Or any of the other Danish skeptics?

thank you
zep
 
ZEP:

I don`t know, why that is important, but no, I have never met any skeptic at all.

Danish or from a foreign country.
 
Oh bye the way. I better have to confess that, otherwise I will be accused of lying.

At our congress in NYC - 1999, there was a skeptic present. He was suppossed to speak for 15 - 20 minutes. But the American astrologers got so angry, that they started to shout at him, before he got a chance to open his mouth. We Europeans were very ashamed. IN fact we had invited him ourselves, so at least he should have had the chance to say, what he wanted to say.

But you know Americans are much more aggressive than the rest of us. ;)
 
Zep said:
And have you ever personally met Mr Dann? Or Mr Modens Winther? Or any of the other Danish skeptics?

To my knowledge, Karen has never met any Danish skeptic. However, she has launched a frantic search for our photos, so they can be sent around the world to other astrologers.

These photos are used for two purposes:
  1. To warn astrologers about how skeptics look, just in case they show up where astrologers lectures, etc.
  2. To interpret personal characteristics, solely negative.

Some comments about photos of skeptics, made by astrologers:
  • "But, he looks like a criminal. I mean - with that head shape."
  • "How about placing the photo of Dann in the monkey's cave (in a zoo)?"
  • "Extremely funny with that photo of Dann "the wildman". Is there also one of Mogens Winther in the archives?"

Make no mistake, astrologers do not merely judge people by their sign, they also characterize them based on physical appearance.

Karen Boesen said:
Oh bye the way. I better have to confess that, otherwise I will be accused of lying.

At our congress in NYC - 1999, there was a skeptic present. He was suppossed to speak for 15 - 20 minutes. But the American astrologers got so angry, that they started to shout at him, before he got a chance to open his mouth. We Europeans were very ashamed. IN fact we had invited him ourselves, so at least he should have had the chance to say, what he wanted to say.

But you know Americans are much more aggressive than the rest of us. ;)

Did you stand up and defend this skeptic's right to speak? After all, you invited him, but you accepted what happened?

What kind of "congress" do you run, if it can degenerate into mob rule?
 
From the congress Karen mentions, here is what the skeptic in question had to say:
Unfortunately, it’s hard to present ideas while you’re being shouted at, and while you’re being summarily dismissed. In truth, they asked some good questions, like ‘Why you – what are your credentials?’ I leaned heavily on my list of advisers. ‘What kind of astrology are you going to test?’ I thought I had that one narrowed down to natal (rather than sun-sign) astrology, but it seems there are as many brands of astrology as there are astrologers. ‘See,’ I said, ‘that’s why I came to you. I would never have known that otherwise.’ My flattery fell on deaf ears. I was told by one gentleman that a lunar link to the stock market was well established, and that he would send me data – I never got it. Another gentleman presented me with an article that was supposed to show the same link – when I had time to read the article, I discovered that it proved nothing of the sort. Still, I got out my test protocol, and when I got a little exasperated I said the following: ‘You folks are selling something, here. You say that astrology gives you an advantage over regular analysis – well, let’s find out how much of an advantage. Don’t you want to be able to tell your customers about it?’ They agreed to that, at least, but I still had the sense that not many of them would be interested in MY test.

After my 15 minutes were over, and after the next speaker defiantly tossed some predictions my way (vague ones that turned out, over the next four days, to be dead wrong), I had some pleasant conversations with individual members of the audience about what I was trying to do. I discovered a few things – they don’t like James Randi, they don’t like Shawn Carlson, and they don’t know how astrology works, but that doesn’t bother them very much.
Source:Stars in My Eyes By Jon Blumenfeld

Mogens Winter has already pointed to Blumenfeld's account, so at least that's one point where MW speaks the truth. Still no word on the evidence that MW lies?
 
KB : “Oh bye the way. I better have to confess that, otherwise I will be accused of lying. At our congress in NYC - 1999, there was a skeptic present.”


I already mentioned that – but thanks for this confirmation of my <a href ="http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=35498&perpage=40&pagenumber=6">note </a> above .


/MW
 
No, I did not stand up and defended Mr. Blumenfelds right to speak. But of course I should have done so. We did not excatly invite him. But he asked if it was possible to get a chance to speak and I said yes.

He was supposed to speak after me, and because of the fact that I had spoken extremely bad, I needed a break, before I was able to say anything at all. Furthermore all these aggressive feelings took me by surprise, and after 1 - 2 minutes the poor man had to sit down. I don`t know if he left shortly after that.
But believe me, he did not get a chance to say a word. I have read the stuff you present here. But it is not true.
I assume that he did not have the courage to tell that he was kicked out.
 
Karen Boesen said:
No, I did not stand up and defended Mr. Blumenfelds right to speak. But of course I should have done so. We did not excatly invite him. But he asked if it was possible to get a chance to speak and I said yes.

Karen, Karen....

Karen Boesen said:
IN fact we had invited him ourselves
02-21-2004 08:46 AM

Did you invite him or not?

Karen Boesen said:
He was supposed to speak after me, and because of the fact that I had spoken extremely bad, I needed a break, before I was able to say anything at all. Furthermore all these aggressive feelings took me by surprise, and after 1 - 2 minutes the poor man had to sit down. I don`t know if he left shortly after that. But believe me, he did not get a chance to say a word. I have read the stuff you present here. But it is not true. I assume that he did not have the courage to tell that he was kicked out.

OK, so Joe Blumenfeld lies? He is simply telling us lie after lie after lie? Given the fact, that you have not been able to present evidence for a single one of your own accusations about skeptics lying, why should we believe you now?
 
No, you don`t have to believe me. In fact you can believe, what you want. I could not care less.

Mr. Larsen, among other nicknames, you are called " the ant-f**ker" here in Denmark. Do you have any idea why?
 
Karen Boesen said:
No, you don`t have to believe me. In fact you can believe, what you want. I could not care less.

Mr. Larsen, among other nicknames, you are called " the ant-f**ker" here in Denmark. Do you have any idea why?

"Nit-picker" in English. Yes, I do: Whenever I detect any kind of contradiction, I want to know which point was right, A or B? Or, in your case, did Blumenfeld speak or not?

The reason why this is important to know is you have called another person a liar, without backing it up with evidence. If you can present evidence that Blumenfeld is lying, then he has a serious credibility problem. If, on the other hand you can not present evidence that Blumenfeld is lying, then the credibility problem is yours.

You can't just throw out an accusation like that and expect people to believe it - and that it isn't really important after all.

Oh, well....maybe you can. It's by far not the first time you have thrown out accusations with no evidence to show for them.
 
Karen Boesen said:
No, you don`t have to believe me. In fact you can believe, what you want. I could not care less.

Mr. Larsen, among other nicknames, you are called " the ant-f****r" here in Denmark. Do you have any idea why?

(My ***s)

Oh really! Is THIS the level that this discussion has dropped to??

Edited to add...Oh! It's translated.....I thought it was stating a preference for insects :D :o
 
Well, Claus, I am glad you straightened that out! That form of insectoid beastiality could get you in serious trouble in certain states in the US.
But I did wonder why you occasionally smelt of formic acid.:p
edited to add: Maybe you know my friend Needle Dick?
 
I have no intention to accuse Mr. Blumenfeld of anything. If it is important to him to tell that he did a speech. Ok, fine with me. He can tell you whatever he wants.
No I have no evidence. No interest in this case at all.

But it was a pitty that he did not get a chance to speak, because quite a few people were interested in his lecture. They wanted to hear, what he had to say. But they did not get a chance either.

And - Mr. Larsen. I have never said that Blumenfeld lies and lies and lies. I have no idea if the man is a liar. What I am saying is, that he lies about this lecture. Or lack of lecture.
He seemed to be a nice man.
And remember: I was there! You were not!
 
"Oh really! Is THIS the level that this discussion has dropped to??"

Please notice that Mr. Larsen got that very nice name from one of his fellow-skeptics. NOT from an astrologer.

We astrologers call him: " beetroot-Larsen " because he turns red every time a women is mentioned.
 
Mercutio said:

I have a simple question for you...

Is there any evidence whatsoever (not necessarily which does exist, but which could exist) that would convince you that astrology does not work?

I see in this thread already a handful of people who have stated what evidence they would like to see that might convince them that astrology does work. This is open-mindedness. Are you open-minded?

Karen, are we likely to get an answer to this? It is a question I myself have asked of believers in the paranormal, and the answer has often been "no". I would be very interested to hear your take on the subject.

On the other hand, you could just carry on with your rabid attacks on Mr Larsen.
 
Reginald said:
Edited to add...Oh! It's translated.....I thought it was stating a preference for insects :D :o

Well, for once, Danish has a more colorful term than English. Admittedly this doesn't happen often...! :)

Karen Boesen said:
I have no intention to accuse Mr. Blumenfeld of anything. If it is important to him to tell that he did a speech. Ok, fine with me. He can tell you whatever he wants. No I have no evidence. No interest in this case at all.

But you are accusing him of lying: You say he did not speak, and he says he did. Since you maintain that you are right (without a shred of evidence, as usual), you are calling him a liar. You can't both be right.

Karen Boesen said:
But it was a pitty that he did not get a chance to speak, because quite a few people were interested in his lecture. They wanted to hear, what he had to say. But they did not get a chance either.

No, mob rule seems to be an accepted form of argument in Astrology circles.

Karen Boesen said:
And - Mr. Larsen. I have never said that Blumenfeld lies and lies and lies. I have no idea if the man is a liar. What I am saying is, that he lies about this lecture. Or lack of lecture. He seemed to be a nice man. And remember: I was there! You were not!

True, you were. However, I was present at the "KB hallen" lecture, and you were not, yet you are able to determine what happened, and I am not.

If you want to use the argument now "I was there, you were not" (and it is perfectly valid), then how come you have argued the exact opposite before?

Karen Boesen said:
We astrologers call him: " beetroot-Larsen " because he turns red every time a women is mentioned.

How do you know that, if you have never met me? Another character assassination. I think that people at both Amazing Meetings can testify that I do not turn red at any time, be it a woman is mentioned, or otherwise.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom