Karen Boesen said:
Reg. Mr. Winther`s post.
It will take me more than an hour to prove that he is passing on more lies, lies and lies,
I give up. These extremely skeptics are amazing. I have never met anyone, who is THAT dishonest.
Karen,
Here is the heart of our problem.
You have come here to our forum at your own request, you have been (and still are) welcome to talk with us. You have accused one of the posters of being dishonest but have not provided evidence, just your own version of the story with rude accusations. That person has responded to that by (a) not being rude to you, and (b) responding to each of your points with
facts and references to support his viewpoint (including, I note, your own ISBA website). In total, he has backed up his claims with
evidence - he has shown that he knows about what he is saying. And I'm willing to bet it has taken more than an hour for him to gather that evidence - days, weeks, months, more likely.
You see, that is all we are asking of you, whatever your claim. Evidence, please. Just acting exasperated and pretending to go off in a huff every time you post is really rather childish, is it not? But at least you have posted some stories about your successes - that is a start.
And I have read your long posts about the two success stories. Alas, they are not actually evidence that has a lot of weight here. They are anecdotes - stories - only. They are good pointers towards something interesting, but
for all we know, you may have made them up yourself. I'm not saying here that you
did do that, but you have given us no way to tell if they are fake or not (most of us here can write wonderful stories too - we have a forum on creative writing, if you look around). More solid evidence would be
independent things like a
testing of your work in company websites, reputable journals, or even just newspaper stories to start with.
Further, these stories certainly raise far more questions than they answer (such is the case with all scientific research, actually). We could talk for days about each one - I certainly have many questions about them myself. But I would only do that if you remain willing to stay here and talk with us and not act like we are trying to hurt you. Our questions are because we are curious, not because we want to hurt you. You are the only one acting like we are hurting you. I am willing to bet that even Claus, strident though he might be, has never actually wanted to hurt you - he just has a forceful way of arguing that you don't seem to like, that's all. (We skeptics have tougher skins - we don't mind!)
So, Karen, are you willing to stay here and answer questions and talk with us?