Business Astrology

Karen Boesen said:
No, I am sorry. I am not prepared to answer questions about business astrology. I posted my thread under: Latest comm. etc.

If I should answer all these questions, I could stay in here for 3 -4 hours a day, and to be honest, there are lots of things in my life, which are much more interesting.
Originally posted by Zep
Hello again, Karen.

Would you please just confirm to us that you are now refusing to discuss business astrology. If you are, this is a problem because we thought that was why you were here - to make sure we were all accurately informed about that subject first-hand from yourself. We certainly wanted to hear it that way ourselves.
With regret, I have decided to give up on this thread.

I had hoped to have a frank discussion about the topic at hand, which I thought was business astrology. I have concluded that such a discussion is hopeless.

Ms. Boesen is not interested in explaining what I would consider to be some relatively simple aspects of her business. That is, of course, her right. But her reason, "I could stay in here for 3 -4 hours a day, and to be honest, there are lots of things in my life, which are much more interesting," rings hollow. She seems to have plenty of time for swapping trivial insults with other members of this forum. And yet, she asserts that she cannot find any time to answer the straight questions I have put to her.

In my view, my questions have been directly related to the topic at hand. No one has suggested that my questions are deceitful or in any way unfair. I have asked about founding time, the merits of a company horoscope (with and without an exact founding time), tests to which business astrologers submit themselves, and so on. As far as I can tell, these inquiries are directly related to the reasons that Ms. Boesen started this thread. And yet, my questions have been ignored.

If I were in charge of a business, and if I were considering hiring a business astrologer for help with my business decisions, the questions posed in this thread are the kind of questions that I would want to have answered before hiring the business astrologer. Ms. Boesen's refusal to answer would result in my not hiring her. Refusal to explain one's business is not what good businesspeople do.

It would be easy for Ms. Boesen to blame others for her refusal to explain her business. But such blame would be unwarranted. She could have ignored these individuals. Better still, she could have shut them up by showing everyone the merits of her business. There is no one to blame for Ms. Boesen's refusal to explain except for Ms. Boesen herself.

A person who refuses to provide straight answers to straight questions is called "evasive." An evasive person is not a credible person. An evasive person is not necessarily lying. But an evasive person is not an honest and credible person, because an evasive person avoids telling the straight truth.

Ms. Boesen, you have been an evasive person. In my opinion, you are not credible.

Based upon the content of this thread, it is my opinion that business astrology is nonsense. Why? Because I have seen no coherent evidence or argument that business astrology is anything other than nonsense.

I am sorry if these conclusions sound harsh. But the fact is that I put considerable thought and effort into my questions, so that I could learn more about the topic. But I find I have been deliberately ignored. I cannot help but feel somewhat offended as a result.

Good-bye, Ms. Boesen.
 
I have said this before – the only way of getting information out of Karen is by making her angry.

There is however one more interesting page belonging to mr Zimmel – who was claimed as having a <a href =”http://www.businessastrologers.com/Listofmembers.htm“>“Degree in business administration, doctoral thesis on astrology in personnel recruiting” </a>
<a href =http://www.amanita.at/e/reading/03/e-0304-gz.htm>
Mr Zimmels pages </a> even introduces the galactic centre into astrology

And Heureka - there is indeed a most convincing correspondance between galactic centre aspects – and <a href =http://money.cnn.com/markets/sandp.html>S&P 500 Stock Index</a> ?


<a href =http://www.amanita.at/images/charts/spx-gz.gif>
Click to see image </a>


Amazing, isn’t it ?

However – as mr Zimmel writes in the <a href =http://www.amanita.at/e/reading/03/e-0304-gz.htm>
very same article</a> – there are “16 aspects of this type every year “

So – on a 3 year scale – we should have nearly 50 astrological Galaxy aspects !


But the graph above only shows 12 such aspects ?

Apparently, the rest – who didn’t fit that theory – have been throwen away ????

That is how business astrologers work - really convincing..
 
This really is quite surreal.

My business partner is retiring this week, and we are selling the business to a new group who are incorporating it as a company, with me becoming a shareholder and director and all that jazz. We signed the exchange of contracts this afternoon. Various matters have conspired to delay things, and things which were going to happen at one time always ended up happening at another. And the final completion has to have an official date and time which I think is 9 am on Monday 1st March.

This afternoon, during our meeting, I finally had to explain why I was collapsing in helpless giggles every time an official time of handover of the business was mentioned.

After I had explained, the entire meeting was in helpless giggles.

Rolfe.
 
Mogens Winther said:
Mr Zimmels pages </a> even introduces the galactic centre into astrology

Interestingly enough, Zimmel also has:

theoretical knowledge and personal experience in the following areas:
astrology, meditation, reincarnation, reiki, yoga, tai chi, qui gong, shamanism, clairvoyance, transpersonal breathwork, psychotherapy, psychedelic journeys, rebirthing, Tarot, Feng Shui, homeopathy

There is seemingly nothing this guy does not believe in.
 
OK, I will try one last time.

Dear Ms Boesen,

This is a final request for you to continue to participate in this or indeed any other topic on our forum.

As you can see, quite a number of us have many unanswered questions we would like to discuss about business astrology, and we have as much time available as you wish to spend any day. And as you can also see, you are not impressing people with your manners - threatening to leave because of imagined slights, bad language about people, threats of violence, outright rudeness...is this really the impression that you want to make with the world? Is this how a professional "business astrologer" works?

If you leave, we can only conclude that you cannot or will not answer questions about your own line of work - business astrology. This suggests very strongly that you simply don't have confidence in your own knowledge of business astrology (of which you say you are a known expert), or that business astrology could not stand up to even a simple examination in the open market. Or both. I would hope you can prove me wrong by responding to us and discussing with us. Will you do that?

I have just checked - your logon here is still active and has not been banned or removed. Therefore no-one here has removed your access, and you can still participate in our forum any time you wish. If you no longer wish to answer us and discuss stuff with us then that is your choice, but please be clear: You left this discussion of your own accord, you were not pushed out by us. And you have threatened to leave quite a few times before, so why are we to believe you when you say that one more time?

Hello, Karen? Are you still there?

zep
 
Business astrology and KB

Hello !

(I should maybe start by stating that KB and I haven't talked about my posting here....)

My name is Karsten and I live in Denmark.(in Europe :) )

I have been studying astrology for a period of 15 years seriously.
I do not specialize in business astrology nor do i make a living from being an astrologer. I make my living being a teacher...

But i must react when i feel someone has been treated unfairly...

And i realley feel that KB has been treated unfairly by Randi in his commentary on feb 6th...

Randi takes what KB said in Oct 2002 on ISBA conference: that Lego has a superhoroscope in relation to it's toy making ablities.

And then Randi goes on to make it appear as if KB just switches her attitude towards Lego's superhoroscope --- when she learns that Lego is now in trouble financially --- apparantly on the same conference 2 or 3 days later.

This is simply not true...

And i have the evidence right here: (sorry it is in Danish)


"Anni Frank (Gæst)

Gæst
Sendt af: 80.63.228.216
Torsdag den 08. januar 2004 - 21:52

Hej Karen

Du har Lego's horoskop i din bog: Ledelse i astrologisk perspektiv.

Og idag blev Poul Plougman fyret - kan man se det i Lego's horoskopet... Jeg kan se at Saturn tramper rundt på Venus/Mars i Krebsen og Venus er 10 hus hersker. Kan det aspekt virkelig fyre Poul P.

Eller har du nogle mere interessante bud.

Håber du har tid til at se lidt på det, da jeg er interesseret i høre om aspekterne i denne sag.

:-)
Anni"

As you can see the question about Lego's financial situation was asked on jan 8th 2004 (more than 1 year after the ISBA conferenvce in oct 2002)

The nature of Anne's question is that a Lego director has been fired with immedialtely termination of his engagement/contract.

And then she asks an astrological question about how come these aspects that apparently is working in Lego's horoscope right now (jan. 2004) could be enough to have triggered this firing of the Lego director.

On friday the 9th of Jan. 2004 KB wrote:(sorry again, this is in also inDanish)

"Fredag den 09. januar 2004 - 10:35

Kære Anni,

jeg fik lige lidt ekstra tid, mens jeg venter på en klient. Den har jeg brugt til at finde Legos horoskop frem og hurtigt kigge på det.

De transitter, du nævner fra Saturn, er set i relation til min erfaring, ikke nok til at udløse en fyring af koncernlederen. Der skal mere til end transitter, bortset fra, hvis vi taler om transitpluto. Jeg har ikke haft tid til at læse de forskellige artikler i dagspressen om Lego endnu.

MEN, hvis vi går ud fra, at datoen 13. august holder, er den progressive Sol i kvadrat til Saturn, hvilket jo er et særdeles stærkt, spændingsbetonet aspekt, der på meget fin vis beskriver den situation, som man i virksomheden oplever for nuværende. Inerti, lav vækst, eliminering af alt det, der ikke på nogen måde er overskudsgivende, indskrænkning over hele linien, begrænsning ( i dette tilfælde ) i udviklingssektoren etc. etc.
Mange erhvervsastrologer betragter Solen som dispositor over lederen. Det gør jeg også. + Mars ( styrer urhoroskopets 1. hus/Ascendanten ) + den individuelle hersker over Ascendanten. I dette tilfælde Merkur. Dog Solen, hvis tidspunktet skal flyttes et par minutter tilbage.

Kigger vi på de kortvarige progressive aspekter i øjeblikket er det progressive Lykkepunkt i opposition til Mars. ( 1. hus`hersker i urhoroskopet) . Men Lykkepunktets placering er jo helt og holdent afhængigt af, at etableringstidspunktet er 100 % præcist. ( Det var det, der gik galt i sin tid med Socialdemokratiet ).

Der er også mange positive aspekter i det progressive horoskop for 2004, men erfaringsmæssigt er det således, at spændingsaspekterne SKAL virke.

Transitpluto er bl. a. i tiltagende trigon til Radix-Sol. Progressiv Sol i tiltagende trigon til Jupiter. Etc.

Kh
Karen"

Here KB mentions a progressive SUN, in what astrologers calls a challenging aspect (90 degree angle), a square to Lego's Radix Sun. (if the date and time for Lego's *birth* are valid; the date is 13 th of August (1933???) and the time is 06 00 (CET)

And they further discuss if this, astrologically speaken is 'enough' to get a director/CEO fired from a company such as Lego. (and i really do not know --- as i'm not a business astrologer).

But again as you can se Mr. Randi's claims that KB apparently switches her information for lego's future as she gets news on Lego's dire financial situation/the firing of the CEO/director of Lego in oct. 2002 is simply not VALID --- simply because the firing of the director/CEO just took place a a few weeks ago (on jan 7th or 8th 2004).

And this is why I feel that Mr. Randi has done a great injustice to KB in his commentary on feb 6th 2004.

(and don't get my wrong: of a skeptic had been accused of doing something that I knew was wrong; i too would have taken action
and try to correct it immediately --- this is what i'm doing now. (in KB's case) The reason why it didn't do sooner is very simple.

As English is not my native language I needed a little time to
sort out my thoughts and write them down in a manner so that may meaning/intention would/could be clear to you. Also it took a little while longer to get my account registered than i thought it would)

But now i've havd said my piece...and i'll leave you again..

PS: I do not know why KB has taken it upon herself to fight with MW, CFL or Dann, (Simonsen). I just know that I (last summer)
intensively and fully covering any and all astrological aspects
tried to convey this to among others, MW and CFL. (and all i seemed to get back was more questions which i answered patiently...untill i simply could not anymore...)

PPS:
In short I can say thay my own idea/taking on astrology is that is definetely not a sciene, nor a humanist, social or a natural science. And the way I see astrology is that for me and only for me; astrology is an integrated part of my BELIEF SYSTEM,(a sort af my basis value system,) which I use to navigate in the world.

I do not however, ask the horoscope if I should get out of my bed every day...There is REASON why people have gotten MINDS, (or frontol lobes if you like) We are meant, either by chance, by God, or by Nature, to use them...

This is all for now. Maybe i'll be back later...

Karsten
 
Hi Karsten and welcome to the forums! :)

I hope that you will stay to discuss with us. As you have realized we are quite skeptical about astrology so expect to receive questions but astrologers are used in receiving questions anyway, also I remember that astrologers and friends of astrology enjoy talking about it. :)

I hope that somebody translates your message for us.
 
Karen,

Have you ever heard of the Phillipson Interview? Here is a link where you can download it in PDF format:
Phillipson Interview
If you haven't read it before you might find it quite interesting. I don't recommend it to you because I think it will change your mind about astrology. I think you should read it because it demonstrates the kind of objective, unbiased search for evidence that most skeptics are looking for.

If you read it and find that you disagree with their methods or their findings then explain why. Devise your own tests, I'm sure there are members of this Forum who would be willing to help. I'll tell you one method that will NEVER convince a skeptic and that is seeking out testimonials from people who already claim to believe in astrology. You might as well start a petition proclaiming the moon is made of cheese - no number of signatures will make it so.
 
Allow me to add Blondin that what makes Phillipson Interview so interesting is the fact that it sums up the opinions of people--scientists mostly--who spent years in studying Astrology systematically.

What I liked most is the part of the introduction in which they declare that they despise the nasty attacks against the astrologers and that their attitude is skeptical and not hostile towards them.
 
Cleopatra said:
I hope that somebody translates your message for us.

Not tonight, dear. I have a headache! :)

Aries, I find your English more than adequate to translate the posts yourself.

(Shhh....de fleste her er amerikanere...bare du ikke bruger 3-stavelsesord....)
 
CFLarsen said:
Zep,
Karen's email is [email protected]
Thanks Claus, but I'm not interested in pursuing her for answers. She came here of her own choice, and it appears she has left the same way, and doesn't want to talk to us any more. So be it.

And she has left all the "hard" questions unanswered. She has also left the "easy" questions unanswered. In fact, I don't recall that she properly answered ANY questions, really, just came back with more astrological stuff that made little or no sense.

All in all, a significant pity - she always claimed that skeptics lied about her all the time and made up stories and stuff, but when she was given an open forum and freedom to present her own facts, she has given nothing at all. I can only guess that either she was being very dishonest about skeptics in the past, or her "facts" are suddenly very weak when faced with the reality of having to publicly explain and support them.

But who knows! She may suddenly reappear! Like Victor Zammit's ectoplasm!
 
Aries, would you please translate Karen's messages in your previous post. The rest of your story seems to make little sense without these. As Claus says, you seem to have a very good grasp of English, so we are happy to accept your translations as being very near to the original intention in Danish. (We know that no languages translate absolutely perfectly!) What a pity we can't speak Danish that well too... Oh for a babelfish.

many thanks
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom