Brian Good Challenge: Name one independent architect or engineer who agrees with NIST

Oh I see what kind of challenge this is. It's a "look how much I can move these goalposts around" challenge.

Not playing this one, it's like playing board games with a three year old.
 
Go on punch me in the stomach, go on I bet you can't hurt me, go on punch me in the stomach.

Wack!

Cough splutter, see cough, urrgh, see I cough told you, weez you couldn't hurt me.

This is just another moronic truther drive by. I wish mods would just bin worthless threads like this especially when the OP is so dishonest and refuses to acknowledge that his challenge has been met.
 
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

Good luck!

Your first problem......there are only about 200 architects and 400 engineers that are licensed professionals......the rest are wannabes.

Why would I post my credentials so that a few hundred cranks could harass me?
Been there done that in the past........not worth the bother for the brain dead troofers.
 
And you know this because they told you so.................:rolleyes:

That's a good little believer.

Is this true nomasters? Is the only reason you believe any of those 1800 people is qualified to disagree with NIST because Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth said they were? And here you are chiding us about how we know anybody is really an expert? Really?
 
I'd like to second the request to see independent verification of the people on Gage's list. Until that happens, we should assume that there are zero people on it.
 
Brian Good? Are you *********** serious? That guy is a bigger clown than the Mayor or Clown Town. Case in point, lets take a look at our hero:

"What is proposed is that the giant core structure of the WTC, built to carry 10X the weight of the entire tower above, should have captured the disorganized wreckage of the WTC wreckage that was disintegrated core above it, rather than collapsing under this relatively small amount of wreckage.

Meatball on a fork is a metaphor."

Meat Ball on a fork is a metaphor.

And what, pray tell are Brian's qualifications?

"I'm not an engineer. I've worked in construction and read lots of books on building and I operate a lot in the failure mode through taking on the repair of hopelessly broken stuff other people consider garbage, and when I'm building stuff for my own use I deliberately underbuild it to try to generate instructive failures. My first project was as a five-year-old--a chair that provided an interesting (and instant) shear failure when I sat on it."

Lolz
 
Brian Good? Are you *********** serious? That guy is a bigger clown than the Mayor or Clown Town. Case in point, lets take a look at our hero:

"What is proposed is that the giant core structure of the WTC, built to carry 10X the weight of the entire tower above, should have captured the disorganized wreckage of the WTC wreckage that was disintegrated core above it, rather than collapsing under this relatively small amount of wreckage.

Meatball on a fork is a metaphor."

Meat Ball on a fork is a metaphor.

And what, pray tell are Brian's qualifications?

"I'm not an engineer. I've worked in construction and read lots of books on building and I operate a lot in the failure mode through taking on the repair of hopelessly broken stuff other people consider garbage, and when I'm building stuff for my own use I deliberately underbuild it to try to generate instructive failures. My first project was as a five-year-old--a chair that provided an interesting (and instant) shear failure when I sat on it."

Lolz

Yup, those qualifications easily surpass those of us who have engineering degrees, licenses and lots of experience.
 
Yup, those qualifications easily surpass those of us who have engineering degrees, licenses and lots of experience.
Come-on. 5 years old and he designs a chair to fail to prove a principle?

That's impressive stuff. When I was that age I only did it because I didn't know any better. :p

ETA: There was that one time I did build one for my little sister. :D
 
Last edited:
Yup, those qualifications easily surpass those of us who have engineering degrees, licenses and lots of experience.

Well, according to our good friends at Screw Loose Change, Brian is a wee bit of a stalker. So... yeah.... might want to not answer his "challenge" thoughtfully brought to us by the US Goal Post Moving Company.

Rake on Rake, man! It is all rakes all the way down.
 
Well, according to our good friends at Screw Loose Change, Brian is a wee bit of a stalker. So... yeah.... might want to not answer his "challenge" thoughtfully brought to us by the US Goal Post Moving Company.

Rake on Rake, man! It is all rakes all the way down.

Most jurisdictions tie an individual license # to a name and work address. I'd prefer not to make that information easily accessible.
 
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

The challenge, hereby named for its creator Brian Good (not me, btw), is to name one independent architect or engineer who has publicly expressed agreement with NIST's collapse sequence.

The conditions are as follows:
  1. The architect or engineer must be free of professional ties to NIST. People who have worked for or with NIST in any capacity do not qualify as independent.
  2. The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
It is worth noting that nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge. Can any of you?

Good luck!

So nomasters, what are your credentials and identity?

And why should we take up this challenge, considering that Brian Good is a total idiot, liar and nut job? Additionally, he has been kicked out of several truther groups for his extreme views.

BTW...I will give my name and credentials (in person) at Gage's presentation in Denver, this coming June.
 
So nomasters, what are your credentials and identity?

And why should we take up this challenge, considering that Brian Good is a total idiot, liar and nut job? Additionally, he has been kicked out of several truther groups for his extreme views.

BTW...I will give my name and credentials (in person) at Gage's presentation in Denver, this coming June.

Really? Well grandfather me in please. I cannot attend, but would be willing to step up vicariously.
 
By the way, OP, Brian Good was kicked out of Ae911.

You'll forgive me if we are wee bit suspicious about just what the **** you are pulling here.
 
Those credentials have been painstakingly verified by Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth.



LOL. How do I know that "abaddon" is the same person whose name is seen on the diploma? If "abaddon" says he is David Burke over the telephone, how do I know he's telling the truth?

So what exactly do you want?

You asked for a certified engineer, you were given one. How exactly is one supposed to prove they are a certified engineer to your satisfaction?
 
To answer the OP - The Arup firm, in their presentation to the New Civil Engineer conference in 2005:

It is our view that the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s (NIST) report into the events of 9-11 is a critically important document for tall building design worldwide.

Its conclusions will have a major influence on the Regulatory environment, and on clients’ expectations for tall building design. We believe it will provide invaluable data for future design validation.​


Is that public enough?
 
But to riff on my prior post: What really constitutes agreement? Public statements, such as Arups that I gave above? Or action?

Let's talk about action. NIST made a number of recommendations for code changes. The International Code Council has been discussing those, and has implemented many already. So if you take action rather than outright statement as being a sort of "publically expressed agreement", then you can count in all the members of the ICC who've worked on those code modifications.

Further? This goes back to Arup, but it also includes the Chinese State Construction and Engineering Corporation: The building of the Beijing CCTV complex, including the Television Cultural Center, epitomizes a group of professionals who unquestionably support the NIST findings. The reason it's unquestionable is, again, action: They designed the building with the lessons learned from 9/11 - many of which were published in the NIST reports - in mind. It is exaggeration to cite the entire Arup or CSCE Corp for this - that's just number padding - but it is not to point out that whoever was involved with the CCTV/TVCC design in both firms definitely demonstrated agreement, in spite of not verbalizing or stating it in writing.

I can go onto the Purdue Researchers, the Weidinger Associates, and on and on, but really... is that needed?

My ultimate point is that I'd advise conspiracy advocates to not look for statements, because those tend to be few and far between. When, for example, was the last time the American Society of Clinical Oncology or any individual members ever publicly stated "I agree with National Comprehensive Cancer Network's studies establishing the rationale behind the current clinical practice guidelines"? Whether in writing, or on TV, the radio, on the 'net, etc.? Watch what they do. When discussing professionals exercising their expertise in their fields, that's far more telling.
 
So what exactly do you want?

You asked for a certified engineer, you were given one. How exactly is one supposed to prove they are a certified engineer to your satisfaction?

Bluntly, you cannot. The goalposts will simply shift all the time. The original demand was for an accredited engineer with no links to the US gov or NIST.

I fit that criteria, being an accredited engineer, not living in the US, having no more relationship with the US, or it's government, other than having visited a few times. Credentials and identity provided including the means to verify them.

Suddenly, NO, THAT IS INSUFFICIENT. Well what in hell is sufficient to fill these rocket propelled goalposts? You don't see nomasters posting his real name, nor his credentials, nor anything, not even any evidence. That is because he is exactly what GLP deems Anonymous Coward.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom