Brian Good Challenge: Name one independent architect or engineer who agrees with NIST

Relevant field: structural engineering. The Journal of Structural Engineering published a special issue dedicated to 9/11 and engineering research that resulted. This was published in September 2011 to commemorate the tenth anniversary. Below I post the journal info so you can find the issue (if you have access), along with the opening paragraph. Notice a two things: (1) The engineers writing this intro point out that a great deal of work in engineering has been done as a result of 9/11. (2) There is no hint that any of the research to which they refer supports CD, "inside job" or calls into question the "official story". This suggests that every contributor to this issue is satisfied that the collapses were caused by impacts and fires.

Here is the info:

Special Issue: Commemorating 10 Years of Research since 9/11

DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0000453

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING © ASCE / SEPTEMBER 2011


by Maria E. Moreyra Garlock, M.ASCE
Associate Professor, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Princeton Univ., Princeton, NJ 08544 (corresponding author). E-mail: [email protected]

Andrea Surovek, M.ASCE
Associate Professor, South Dakota School of Mines and Technology, Civil and Environmental Engineering, 501 E. St. Joseph St., Rapid City, SD 57701.


This special issue of the Journal of Structural Engineering commemorates 10 years since the attacks of September 11, 2001, by focusing on research that was motivated by the impacts of events of that day. Primarily, in response to the collapse of the World Trade Center towers, the damage and collapse of neighboring structures and the damage to the Pentagon, national organizations and structural engineers have performed substantial amounts research in the area of progressive collapse with an emphasis on the response of structures to extreme loads. The ultimate objective of this research is to provide the means to design more robust and redundant structures that can resist progressive collapse under extreme loads, such as blast, impact, and fire, by considering both member and system response to extreme events and increasing the database of experimental results. This special issue focuses on some recent research in these areas. The papers and their list of references combined are a rich source of information and a state-of-the-art representation of structural engineering for extreme loads.
 
Marvin Melecha? LOL. Need I remind you that I asked for an INDEPENDENT architect or engineer. NIST and the AIA have collaborated on many occasions in the past and their interdependent relationship continues to this day. NIST recommendations affect AIA building codes, etc. Needless to say that Marvin Malecha, as head of the AIA, has a conflict of interest that disqualifies him from independent status. Of course Malecha is going to say he supports the NIST report! Does he have any other choice? All his "support" proves is that the AIA cares more about its own reputation than anything else and is too cowardly to question the system.

Challenge NOT met.

So you're eliminating all AIA members?
 
Those credentials have been painstakingly verified by Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth.



LOL. How do I know that "abaddon" is the same person whose name is seen on the diploma? If "abaddon" says he is David Burke over the telephone, how do I know he's telling the truth?

So now the challenge is to prove to you something you do not want proved?
 
The goalposts are somewhere near the Oort Cloud by now.

Yep, looks like the OP will have to meet the engineer and personally vet all his qualifications. Probably will then want to meet his maternal great great grandfather's third cousin, once removed.
 
So what exactly do you want?

You asked for a certified engineer, you were given one. How exactly is one supposed to prove they are a certified engineer to your satisfaction?

Can't be done because he'll just keep changing what is proof so he can't get no satisfaction.
 
Wow, look what we have here.

beachnut: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials.

abbadon: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials. Shows some sort of official looking paper, which could be real or fake, from someone named "David Burke", who could be anyone. Sorry, no dice.

Oystein: mentions a name, but provides no verification of identity or credentials. We don't even know that "Christian Feist" really agrees with NIST.

Disbelief and Spanx: can't name anybody.

Strike four, strike five, strike six, strike seven, strike eight. Lucky for you guys this ain't baseball.

Let's apply the same standards to that 1800 figure. How many of those have you verified are real? How did you do so?

You've made no effort to check Abbadon's claimed credentials, so of course they're unconfirmed (by you).
 
I’m sure,”nomasters” has declared himself the winner and moved on.

I played this same stupid game once before. I gave my real name, education, employment, professional licenses and internet links to confirm all the information. That wasn’t good enough for the forum truther (troll) at the time. However, for several months after that, a truther used that information to track down my home email address, and started sending me harassing messages. No physical threats, but email after email, filled with insults and real stupid stuff. For a small group of people, this truth movement is their whole life, and arguing with people is all they have left.
 
Let's apply the same standards to that 1800 figure. How many of those have you verified are real? How did you do so?

You've made no effort to check Abbadon's claimed credentials, so of course they're unconfirmed (by you).

"Those whom I agree with" is the how he verifies credentials.
 
So we have a poster here who supplied his name and the process by which his identity and credentials could positively confirmed(anon poster nomasters looks up and calls the licensing agency, they call the named engineer and verify that he has agreed online to have his info released, nomasters gets in contact with this agency and receives confirmation of credentials and online presence)
however nomasters has not indicated any desire to act on this.
If my characterization is correct it indicates that poster nomasters is definitively insincere in his stated quest and thus there is no logical reason to engage him further in this regard

IMHO
 
Last edited:
So we have a poster here who supplied his name and the process by which his identity and credentials could positively confirmed(anon poster nomasters looks up and calls the licensing agency, they call the named engineer and verify that he has agreed online to have his info released, nomasters gets in contact with this agency and receives confirmation of credentials and online presence)
however nomasters has not indicated any desire to act on this.
If my characterization is correct it indicates that poster nomasters is definitively insincere in his stated quest and thus there is no logical reason to engage him further in this regard

IMHO

Seems like that to me.

Demanding credentials then rejecting them with apparently no intention of making any attempt to verify them lies somewhere on a line between really-didn't-think-it-through and not-actually-interested-in-facts.

Any further engagement for entertainment purposes only, perhaps to see how fast the goalposts can move.
 
The display of insincerity is amazing in that it is shown again in another thread in which Christopher7 tries to argue that he need not demonstrate an extrodinary claim that concrete can be heated and undergo a phase change from solid to liquid
 
I knew that the OP would end up denying any architect or engineer who agrees with the NIST is really "independent". Standard Truther Tactic since the day the Nist Report came out....
 
nomasters,

1. Do you really believe that your ridiculous criteria for credentials do anything but undermine your cause? If abaddon showed up in person at your door with his complete college transcripts, 7 employees, his mother and 5 of his clients you would claim that they all could be reptilian shapeshifters pretending to be people.

2. I suspect that you were surprised by how quickly your challenge was met, and now you are just pretending to doubt abaddon's credentials rather than admit you were wrong.
 
Last edited:
Further, since NCSTAR 1-9 was released after the petition was started and it includes an investigation into "Hypothetical Blast Scenarios" it would appear the demands of the petition have been met. Further, that Tricky Dick fails to inform potential signers that NCSTAR 1-9 exists means an unknown number of those 1,800 may have signed under false pretenses.

Wouldn't competent engineers, specializing in the relevant field(s), and interested in the topic, already know about NCSTAR 1-9 and its import?

It seems to me that anyone who signed the petition in ignorance of NCSTAR 1-9 is probably not qualified to opine on the subject, and their signature can be safely ignored as irrelevant.

Also: Would Bazant qualify for the OP's request (if the request were made in good faith)?
 
"nomasters", is this some kind of performance art? What do you hope to accomplish here? Do you think "The Whole World Is Watching", ready to march in the streets demanding that the government grant a millions of dollars, and subpoena power to Richard Gage or Alex Jones?
 
nomasters,

1. Do you really believe that your ridiculous criteria for credentials do anything but undermine your cause? If abaddon showed up in person at your door with his complete college transcripts, 7 employees, his mother and 5 of his clients you would claim that they all could be reptilian shapeshifters pretending to be people.
Of course he would. Heaven forfend that anything that challenges his crackpot beliefs would be considered at all. And make a phone call? Oh no, we can't be having with that, tut, tut. The house of mythical cards would collapse.

2. I suspect that you were surprised by how quickly your challenge was met, and now you are just pretending to doubt abaddon's credentials rather than admit you were wrong.
I am not the only engineer here. By and large, all of those members who are engineers are entirely happy to step up. (I will name no names, you know who you are)

I am fully aware that self identifying may expose me to nonsense abuse, but equally, should such occur, you will all read it here in public.
 
There is still a list of which JREF posters have verified their credentials with regard to 9/11 discussion here. Given that the OP doesn't appear too interested in this subject, I'm not going to bother to sort it for engineers only.
And that is a most constructive list of expertise. However did you come to assemble it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom