Brian Good Challenge: Name one independent architect or engineer who agrees with NIST

What good would calling do? The person behind number 031769 could be anybody from a cook to a janitor to a dog walker.
No. The Institute of Engineers does not certify those. They certify engineers. Put your money where your mouth is. Pick up the phone and make that call, unless you are afraid.

I never claimed to have any credentials in the relevant areas, but so what?
You called me out on mine, and I provided my credentials, so it is only fair that I ask you what credentials you have. Not only that, you failed to follow up and verify mine, even though you were handed them on a plate. One phone call to the relevant professional institute was all that was needed, yet you failed to even rising to the challenge of operating a telephone for a few minutes.

There are 1830 others who agree with me and DO have the credentials! This challenge isn't about that, however. It's about finding an independent, verified architect or engineer who agrees with NIST. So far, there are none.
Wrong. You blindly believe the nonsense. I am one, and not only am I not alone, the vast majority of engineers and architects are with me. When will you get more than 0.01% of engineers and architects to agree with this crackpot notion?

Why is this so hard for you guys? Shouldn't you be able to find somebody who is well known in his or her field, maybe from a university or a reputable firm, who has publicly endorsed the NIST report?
Plenty have. You simply like to pretend they don't. I have, and I am an accredited engineer. Trying to pretend I am not is just your fantasy at work. I provided you with the relevant qualifications. What have you provided? Nothing. Nada.
If not, why not?
In the engineering profession, among my colleagues and peers, 911 truthers are regarded as crackpots unworthy of attention. That's why not.

Could it be that nobody is willing to jeopardize their professional reputation by supporting something that they - and all of their colleagues - know is a sham?
No. Just no. All of us sign up to a code of professional ethics. You have no idea what that means.
 
No. The Institute of Engineers does not certify those. They certify engineers. Put your money where your mouth is. Pick up the phone and make that call, unless you are afraid.

What could a phone call possibly prove? Let's say someone can somehow verify that "David Burke" is an engineer. How would I know that's you? How would I know that "David Burke" holds opinions in support of, and is independent of, NIST?
 
Lol, this is typical truther.

So when presented with evidence, it's dismissed as false.

No wonder truthers think no one has met the challenge :D LMFAO
 
Come back when you get 50 percent of engineers. Good luck.

It already is over 50 percent. Way over.

Look, if you poll a hundred people in the USA on whether the sky is blue and all of them give you the same answer, that's pretty good evidence that the majority of people in the USA agree on that answer. It doesn't matter that 100 is only a tiny percentage of the US population.

Likewise, if you have 1830 independent architects and engineers on record as disagreeing with the NIST report and 0 on record as supporting it, that's a pretty darn good indication of general agreement in the architecture and engineering communities.

Still waiting for that one name.
 
What could a phone call possibly prove? Let's say someone can somehow verify that "David Burke" is an engineer. How would I know that's you? How would I know that "David Burke" holds opinions in support of, and is independent of, NIST?
LOL. Nothing is capable verification? Really? You are just in a snit, because you did not expect real people, with real qualifications to be here. Tough.

It already is over 50 percent. Way over.

Look, if you poll a hundred people in the USA on whether the sky is blue and all of them give you the same answer, that's pretty good evidence that the majority of people in the USA agree on that answer. It doesn't matter that 100 is only a tiny percentage of the US population.

Likewise, if you have 1830 independent architects and engineers on record as disagreeing with the NIST report and 0 on record as supporting it, that's a pretty darn good indication of general agreement in the architecture and engineering communities.

Still waiting for that one name.
1830 out of how many others? What questions were asked?
 
heck there are over 144,000 members of the American Civil Engineers Society alone. Millions of engineers and architects just in the USA.

1830 is probably abut how many of them you would expect to be insane
 
What could a phone call possibly prove? Let's say someone can somehow verify that "David Burke" is an engineer. How would I know that's you? How would I know that "David Burke" holds opinions in support of, and is independent of, NIST?

You want my cell phone number? Sure, I will PM it to you if you need it. Other than that you could see my patents in various jurisdictions, or facebook if you want pics, or linkedin or whatever. Bottom line is, your are scared by a real person with verifiable credentials. That is why you refuse to make that call. Just one call. That's all you need.

What is your real name? Scared to say it? Scared to identify yourself? Afraid to step up to your anonymous claims? Of course you are.
 
Mr. Marvin J. Malecha, FAIA, President
American Institute of Architects (AIA)

“We believe that the NIST investigation and the resulting NIST report are valid and credible.”

Challenge met.
 
Last edited:
... Look, if you poll a hundred people in the USA on whether the sky is blue and all of them give you the same answer, ...
The sky is not blue; there you go confusing opinion with science. No wonder you are fooled by 911 truth; Gage says something and you see blue sky, when Gage spreads lies.

I have not seen any credentials on any of Gage's engineers. Where is the proof they are real? Prove they are real. Go ahead. You are holding at zero engineers in Gage's fake movement who have proved any of Gage's claims. Big zero.


Why does 911 truth fail? https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/pe...-building-collapsed-due-office-fires/K3Yfqnph

Why can't 911 truth make a point after 11 and half years?

Millions of engineers, and Gage has how many?
 
Last edited:
so now that you lost this chalenge, do you reconsider your beliefs about 9/11?
 
You want my cell phone number? Sure, I will PM it to you if you need it. Other than that you could see my patents in various jurisdictions, or facebook if you want pics, or linkedin or whatever. Bottom line is, your are scared by a real person with verifiable credentials. That is why you refuse to make that call. Just one call. That's all you need.

What is your real name? Scared to say it? Scared to identify yourself? Afraid to step up to your anonymous claims? Of course you are.

OK, fine then, my name is Barack Obama, and I have a law degree from Harvard. To verify, just call the White House or visit my Wikipedia page and you'll instantly see that it's true. If you don't believe that I'm Mr. Obama, you can call me on the phone and I'll tell you.

Get the point yet?
 
how would one have to prove all those things to you? you lost your challenge already.
 
Challenge met.

Marvin Melecha? LOL. Need I remind you that I asked for an INDEPENDENT architect or engineer. NIST and the AIA have collaborated on many occasions in the past and their interdependent relationship continues to this day. NIST recommendations affect AIA building codes, etc. Needless to say that Marvin Malecha, as head of the AIA, has a conflict of interest that disqualifies him from independent status. Of course Malecha is going to say he supports the NIST report! Does he have any other choice? All his "support" proves is that the AIA cares more about its own reputation than anything else and is too cowardly to question the system.

Challenge NOT met.
 
OK, fine then, my name is Barack Obama, and I have a law degree from Harvard. To verify, just call the White House or visit my Wikipedia page and you'll instantly see that it's true. If you don't believe that I'm Mr. Obama, you can call me on the phone and I'll tell you.

Get the point yet?
You like to lie? We don't lie.

We got the point when you started your first post. You prefer fantasy and lies from Gage and silly people who agree with him. Fantasy.

You think you are the president; now the NSA is most likely adding you to the long list of people with a president complex; sorted by IP address.

You only lost by a few million. Like Bigfoot believers, you think you have have evidence for your fantasy. Where is it?

You lost your challenge, you ignore the evidence. Why did you fail to go to engineering school? Brian Good failed too?

No one in 911 truth counts using your logic. You disqualify rational engineers and architects, so you can't have 911 truth nuts; they are not independent. Your logic, you lost again.
 
Last edited:
Challenge NOT met.


So only non AIA members opinions are qualified ? That's funny.

You do know that Marvin Melecha was speaking for all of AIA (with the exception of a few kooks) when he said this.

Let me guess. If they are not members of AIA then they opinions are not credible ?
 
Last edited:
...There are 1830 others who agree with me and DO have the credentials!...

Can you show us proof of those credentials?

Pick any one of those 1830, and show us his or her credentials the way you want to have proof of ours :)
So far, I see just a list of names. Anyone could have copied or invented them :p

Did you see the diploma of David Burke, MIEI? You seem to have missed it, or the fact that abaddon is David Burke - he personally provided you his name and credentials along with his opinion.
 
Last edited:
Marvin Melecha? LOL. Need I remind you that I asked for an INDEPENDENT architect or engineer. NIST and the AIA have collaborated on many occasions in the past and their interdependent relationship continues to this day. NIST recommendations affect AIA building codes, etc. .

Hahaha.

NIST recommendations also affect all the architects and civil, structural and fire protection engineers among the 1830 you cite.
All the rest is irrelevant as they are not experts in the pertinent fields.

You want us to present you 1 element from an empty set - the set of all building engineers and architects not affected by NIST's recommendations.




What a despicably dishonest act you are putting up! Shame on you ;)
 
It already is over 50 percent. Way over.

You keep on going on about those 1830 engineers, but lets pretend for a second that each and every one of them were in the relevant fields with the relevant credentials who could make a determination on the NIST report...

There are over two-and-a-half million engineers in America alone (and no, I'm not an engineer). 1830 engineers isn't even remotely close to being 50% of engineers, never mind being over it.

Like Bigfoot believers, you think you have have evidence for your fantasy. Where is it?

Bigfoot believers are worlds apart from Truthers. I don't think it's fair comparing them to Truthers in the least.
 
Last edited:
You keep on going on about those 1830 engineers, but lets pretend for a second that each and every one of them were in the relevant fields with the relevant credentials who could make a determination on the NIST report...

There are over one-hundred thousand engineers in America alone (and no, I'm not an engineer). 1830 engineers isn't even remotely close to being 50% of engineers, never mind being over it.



Bigfoot believers are worlds apart from Truthers. I don't think it's fair comparing them to Truthers in the least.

according to this, there are 2.5 million engineers in the USA.

http://www.numberof.net/number-of-engineers-in-the-usa/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom