Black Swan Event Under Way

It'll be paywalled and my subscription is lapsed, so no.

Mm.



Here's a piece with some numbers from Axios, who are pretty reliable and well-sourced: https://www.axios.com/robinhood-retail-stock-trading-ddbc5880-5e0c-4022-98e0-910bfef26358.html

OK... that article does not say a single thing about pricing being affected. It does jibe with my earlier interpretation of the data that institutional investing is giving ground to retail investing. Overall volume is about the same, and from what I can tell, there's no evidence of impact on pricing.

I'm still looking for something to substantiate the theory that this has something to do with an alleged overvaluation.



Robinhoods aren't day traders in that sense - they're people investing small amounts in large companies.

So, this is where I'm confused, right? Because the Bloomberg articles I read were mostly describing Robinhood as a platform for penny stock day traders. And the Axios article you linked to above even goes further, stating they're not even trading stocks. It's at 91.2% options. Options have even less impact on pricing because the majority aren't struck.





They're probably not driving it so much any more, but what they did was lift the market when it dropped a long way, encouraging the major traders to get back on board. The app traders now form a useful lifebelt for the market as a whole.

When interest rates for deposits are worth nothing, it makes sense to put money into shares, and that's why the small investor in 2020 isn't after penny stocks, but blue-chips.

Maybe. I circle back to the original question: is there any data showing this might be true?
 
Start buying Dow Jones Industrial Average and S&P 500 index fund shares regularly. When the market inevitably crashes or corrects at any point in the future, DO NOT sell your index shares and buy more at the discounted price.
 
Cash is actually an increase in risk for long retirement timeframes. This is what the Trinity Study was about. The more cash (or equivalent low yield instruments like bonds) in a portfolio, the faster it's exhausted in retirement.

This is why Buffet referred to bonds as 'returnless risk' - and cash is slightly worse.

I'm just going to post a link to an analysis on that topic:

https://earlyretirementnow.com/2016/12/07/the-ultimate-guide-to-safe-withdrawal-rates-part-1-intro/

There's a chart partway down the page comparing the prospects of bond:equity asset allocation ratios in a retirement with varying percentages of drawdowns. You can run their data for a cash allocation as well, and the few times I've taken a stab at it, any cash percentage makes it worse.
 
I'm still looking for something to substantiate the theory that this has something to do with an alleged overvaluation.

I'd suggest starting a thread on the subject, because it's not really relevant here any more.

I think it's established now that the sharemarkets are largely ignoring the disease, and as has been noted many, many times, the sharemarket isn't the economy.

The economic fallout by way of unemployment, closed businesses and long-term damage will start become apparent in the next three months, and that's what matters.
 
Literally, people have won Nobel prizes proving that most stock picking is essentially gambling.

Didn't someone, years ago, get a chimp to pick stocks by throwing darts, and it came in as one of the top five fund managers that year?
 
Didn't someone, years ago, get a chimp to pick stocks by throwing darts, and it came in as one of the top five fund managers that year?

There have been some variations on that theme done. I don't know about the specifics of what you said, but back when I read Smart Money (remember magazines?) a regular feature was to get some investing experts together to have a stock picking option, and one of the "contestants" was always "dartboard". Sometimes the dartboard won.

In general, most mutual funds trail indices. Even index funds generally trail the inidices, because they skim money off the top.
 
Normally you do not need a pilot.
Sometimes you want a pilot.
Hudson River.

Here is a fact
Ftse is trading same number as first achieved March 1998

I'm thinking you mean the UK one? (there are many FTSEs)

So, two things:

1: dollar cost averagers have achieved a good yield from investing in the UK FTSE index during that period. People always forget two things... time - short down, long up, dollar cost averagers have seen nice gains - and dividends. Yield has been 3% after adjusting for inflation during the interim. FTSE was better than bonds, for example.

and

2: almost all managed funds have done worse, which is the reason indexes are still recommended


Small investors do not need a pilot
 
Last edited:
Didn't someone, years ago, get a chimp to pick stocks by throwing darts, and it came in as one of the top five fund managers that year?

There are lots of exercises like this, but they're transient.

They're very hostile to the managed brokerages, so often get shut down on threat of pulled advertising.

Here in Canada, the Financial Post used to do it with a wind up toy on the floor covered with the stock pages. They'd buy the stocks where it stopped when the spring wound down.
 
I'd suggest starting a thread on the subject, because it's not really relevant here any more.

I'm willing to consider it... I think the subject you're describing is whether the market's reaction is appropriate for COVID19? Not sure why this is 'not really relevant here anymore' ?




I think it's established now that the sharemarkets are largely ignoring the disease, and as has been noted many, many times, the sharemarket isn't the economy.

The economic fallout by way of unemployment, closed businesses and long-term damage will start become apparent in the next three months, and that's what matters.

I'm not sure that's "established" - the interpretation on my end is that investors are incorporating the impacts of COVID19, and definitely not 'ignoring' them. The market is the economy in the sense that it's anticipating future profits, which depend on expectations about the economy.

I think this interpretation is consistent with what we're seeing: the pandemic has accelerated existing trends toward remote working, remote shopping &c. The big winners are companies like Amazon and Shopify. The losers are smaller retailers &c. The S&P500 and here in Canada, the TSX FTSE have reflected this in stock pricing.

A question about why the total asset valuations would rise is a good one and I think you're proposing that there's more money moving into the market because of low interest rates diverting capital from something (I'm not sure what you had in mind) to equities and real estate.

However, I don't agree with that interpretation. Firstly because the trend is actually a net flow of capital out of equities and into cash. There are more withdrawls than inflows over the last 6 months. (Meadmaker is an example of this - this is a real trend).

No, I think the underlying rationale for increased valuations in the indexes is that the consumer economy's shift toward these online giants has created an increase in efficiency that produces higher profits on the same capital base.

Only time will tell, and my investment strategy is based on me not knowing until 30 years after the fact, if ever. I just trust the collective business competence that is managing these thousands of companies in the index portfolio to adapt and do their best.
 
I've been periodically buying a little bit more of boring old Vanguard's boring old S&P 500 index fund the whole time this thread has been going. It's pretty nice, actually.
 
Excellent piece here on the challenges facing governments trying to deal with the economic fallout, and while it's specifically about NZ, the problems are relevant everywhere: https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/mo...t-finance-minister-faces-a-daunting-challenge

Heartland offered the first-ever sub-two-per cent mortgage rate of 1.99 per cent on Tuesday
Awesome!

Even now, unemployment is expected to double to nearly 8 per cent and our GDP cratered more than 12 per cent in the June quarter.
Golly, something terrible must have happened - I wonder what it was was? Obviously something that was building up for a long time and isn't going away soon - which is why GDP for this one quarter extrapolates to a 'cratered' economy. It's not like it might be a 'black swan' event that won't play out exactly the same as all those other economic downturns.

Yet on Tuesday the Real Estate Institute reported that more houses sold in September than in any month since March 2017, which was another boom month.
Wow, another weird trend. What could be causing people to move house more than in any time since March 2017 (a whole 3 and a bit years ago)? Could it be a combination of lockdowns preventing people from selling for a month, moving to new jobs, or coming in from overseas because New Zealand is Covid free? Nah, it has to be some strange disturbance in the force economy that defies explanation!

The stunning inflation of asset prices because of lower interest rates is exactly what the Reserve Bank wanted because it makes home owners feel richer, especially those who fund their small businesses from the equity in their homes.
Yeah, that's it. Your Reserve Bank just wanted home owners to feel richer!

"All the job losses have been for under 30s. They're the renters and they're being priced out of the housing market."
Now see, if only you had a nice high inflation rate this wouldn't be problem. Young people could easily afford to pay off a mortgage at say 20% interest because their wages would constantly be going up, and the fact that they might end up paying more in interest than capital is irrelevant. Also there's no way house prices would go up if there was nice healthy inflation!

But more importantly, as we all know a used house is always cheaper than building a new one. The reason for this is that - unlike existing dwellings - the cost of materials and labor to build a house is constantly going up. But if used house prices go up faster than building costs, new houses could become (relatively) cheaper! Then with mortgage rates so low, people would start building instead of buying! This cannot be allowed of course, because then the population would have to increase to avoid a glut of empty houses. :(

But the common theme of the last 20 years both here and overseas is increasingly large amounts of money in the economy, but circulating at a slower and slower rates as increasingly aged asset owners take fewer and fewer business and investing risks.

They are more likely to park their money in a 100-year bond than to build a new factory.
Yeah, all those old folk just sitting in their homes, rather than mortgaging them them up to the hilt to build new factories! A tragedy for sure, because we really need new factories churning out stuff for people to consume, which they must do in order to get work in the factories to earn money to buy the stuff.

That's how we get full employment and a growing GDP, which we desperately need because in the future overpopulation, resource depletion and global warming is going to cost an enormous amount to fix. Just imagine what the future would be like without more factories churning out stuff for us to consume!
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that's it. Your Reserve Bank just wanted home owners to feel richer!

In their defence, they don't mention it explicitly, but there's an economic theory that consumer confidence can be linked to property valuation. Such that taking steps to mitigate a potential real estate crash is part of staving off a domino effect toward larger economic contraction.

The term is "wealth effect" - Link: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/wealtheffect.asp
 

Not when you've already got one of the highest pay/house price ratios in the world.

Golly, something terrible must have happened...

How droll.

The point is the unemployment rate of 8% (and likely to be more) will be around for some time. With tourism unlikely to recommence in the next year, that's a major problem.

Wow, another weird trend. What could be causing people to move house more than in any time since March 2017 (a whole 3 and a bit years ago)?...

Can you point me to where the article says anything about people moving house, because I'm bloody sure it doesn't.

The reason it doesn't is because house sales are being driven by investors using their equity, not people shifting house.

Then with mortgage rates so low, people would start building instead of buying! This cannot be allowed of course, because then the population would have to increase to avoid a glut of empty houses. :(

I hope your post is satirical, because if not, it's just plain nonsense.

Our house is valued at $1.1 million. That is made up of 400 m2 of land, valued at $950k and a house valued at $150k.

The value of the building is irrelevant - it's the land that's the problem.
 
Interesting article:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/15/sme...aluations-driven-by-young-dumb-investors.html

Summary: Stocks are overvalued, with prices being driven by millennials who don't know anything about investing.

It's really beginning to feel like 2000 to me, except that back then it was loads of ,com companies with no products pushing the stock market up. Today, it's a small number of companies that people think can't lose. Either way, it's a flood of money from people with no knowledge, seeking something for nothing.

A few months ago, I was arguing that this one really awful year shouldn't shove the market too far down. It wasn't incredibly overpriced, just because this year was going to be bad. Now, I look at how far it jumped, in the face of weak growth prospects, and it just seems a bit crazy to me.

Get rid of millennials?

You must be retired and 60 to be in the market?

There are no dumb 40-year-olds?
 
Not when you've already got one of the highest pay/house price ratios in the world.



How droll.

The point is the unemployment rate of 8% (and likely to be more) will be around for some time. With tourism unlikely to recommence in the next year, that's a major problem.



Can you point me to where the article says anything about people moving house, because I'm bloody sure it doesn't.

The reason it doesn't is because house sales are being driven by investors using their equity, not people shifting house.



I hope your post is satirical, because if not, it's just plain nonsense.

Our house is valued at $1.1 million. That is made up of 400 m2 of land, valued at $950k and a house valued at $150k.

The value of the building is irrelevant - it's the land that's the problem.
Which is why this black swan event that has crashed interest rates and thus escalated land values can only be remedied with a universal land tax.
This can be deferred if payment is not possible and the people progressively become larger shareholders in your land.
 
Which is why this black swan event that has crashed interest rates

Interest rates crashed in 2012. It's just been further downhill all the way there.

I see the continuing rise in the market as perhaps a rise in the people's ownership of the market.

and thus escalated land values can only be remedied with a universal land tax.
This can be deferred if payment is not possible and the people progressively become larger shareholders in your land.

Not a bad idea.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom