Black Swan Event Under Way

A simple technical view says this is the exact moment to get rid of stocks and shares.

However I will not ring the bell at the end of the decline.
 
A simple technical view says this is the exact moment to get rid of stocks and shares.

The rulebook has been thrown out the window by Robinhood and zero interest rates. The market will keep going up - fundamentals are dead.
 
My fund has averaged over 10% for the past 10 years.
Yeah, but think what it would be without all those fees!

The Don said:
And don't get me started...the fees you have to pay (buy, sell and management)

I should be able to invest my money in a managed fund without them skimming bogus 'buy, sell and management' fees off it. Why should they make money out of my investment? I'm doing all the work of providing the capital, they should manage it for free! :rolleyes:
 
The market fell 600 points today, 400 of which were in the 10 minutes after Trump tweeted that there wouldn't be a stimulus plan until after the election.

In addition to provoking speculation that The Donald is on some pretty intense medication, it shows that the stock market is currently nuts. The idea that the delay of a stimulus plan by a month ought to affect stock prices is crazy. The idea that a tweet about a delay would significantly affect prices show that there's just no connection to reality.

ETA: And it looks like at close it was only down 400 points. All other observations still apply.
 
Last edited:
This month's update on my stocks and shares ISA.

Date | % +/- | Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3|7.20|7.8
8.18|3.4|8.20|8.1
11.18|-3.1|9.20|7.9
2.19|-0.8|10.20|9.9
5.19|1.9
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8
 
Interesting article:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/15/sme...aluations-driven-by-young-dumb-investors.html

Summary: Stocks are overvalued, with prices being driven by millennials who don't know anything about investing.

It's really beginning to feel like 2000 to me, except that back then it was loads of ,com companies with no products pushing the stock market up. Today, it's a small number of companies that people think can't lose. Either way, it's a flood of money from people with no knowledge, seeking something for nothing.

A few months ago, I was arguing that this one really awful year shouldn't shove the market too far down. It wasn't incredibly overpriced, just because this year was going to be bad. Now, I look at how far it jumped, in the face of weak growth prospects, and it just seems a bit crazy to me.
 
Either way, it's a flood of money from people with no knowledge, seeking something for nothing.

It seems like a self-fulfilling prophecy, though: their very actions in flooding money into the market seems to be making the market do well. Who cares if they're not thinking the right thoughts when they do it? It's the effect that matters.
 
It seems like a self-fulfilling prophecy, though: their very actions in flooding money into the market seems to be making the market do well. Who cares if they're not thinking the right thoughts when they do it? It's the effect that matters.


Today. This is what bubbles are made of.


For the record, I don't claim to know which way the stock market is going next. I've got a lot of money in it right now, although I have about 30% of my retirement fund in cash because I suspect the stock market is due for a correction. If I knew, instead of suspecting, I would have a lot more than 30% in cash. I would also be fabulously wealthy.
 
Today. This is what bubbles are made of.


For the record, I don't claim to know which way the stock market is going next. I've got a lot of money in it right now, although I have about 30% of my retirement fund in cash because I suspect the stock market is due for a correction. If I knew, instead of suspecting, I would have a lot more than 30% in cash. I would also be fabulously wealthy.

I'm still sticking with the model that nobody can market time, including myself.

In the interest of disclosure like Pixel42, these are my 2020 MOM results to date:

Jan-20 7%
Feb-20 -8%
Mar-20 -5%
Apr-20 14%
May-20 6%
Jun-20 11%
Jul-20 3%
Aug-20 27%
Sep-20 -7%
Oct-20 0%

Buy and hold, sticking to the plan, ignoring the clickbait articles, has returned 50% YTD.

And it's a *lot* more relaxing than trying to reverse engineer a post hoc explanation for every up and down.

Could it go down? Sure. Maybe. Who knows. If so: it'll be a tiny dimple on my chart in 40 years, just like all the others.
 
Interesting article:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/15/sme...aluations-driven-by-young-dumb-investors.html

Summary: Stocks are overvalued, with prices being driven by millennials who don't know anything about investing.

It's really beginning to feel like 2000 to me, except that back then it was loads of ,com companies with no products pushing the stock market up. Today, it's a small number of companies that people think can't lose. Either way, it's a flood of money from people with no knowledge, seeking something for nothing.

A few months ago, I was arguing that this one really awful year shouldn't shove the market too far down. It wasn't incredibly overpriced, just because this year was going to be bad. Now, I look at how far it jumped, in the face of weak growth prospects, and it just seems a bit crazy to me.

"Fund manager who is not paid when people invest by themselves says people who invest by themselves are dumb. Added bonus for his Boomer clients: he takes a swipe at Milennials."


Basic rule: anybody who shares their predictions about what the market will do within a secular cycle is either deluded or lying. My advice is to ignore them and the clickbait they ride in on.
 
Last edited:
Summary: Stocks are overvalued, with prices being driven by millennials who don't know anything about investing.

That's exactly what I said months ago, but it's not just millennials - a lot of boomers have taken money from 0.01% interest-bearing accounts and stuck it in Robinhood.

Which segues nicely into the fact that Robinhood has been hacked, exposing at least thousands of accounts.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...do-if-money-in-robinhood-other-apps-is-stolen
 
That's exactly what I said months ago, but it's not just millennials - a lot of boomers have taken money from 0.01% interest-bearing accounts and stuck it in Robinhood.

I've heard this story a lot, and nobody's ever produced credible evidence (just fluff op/ed pieces like in the post you replied to).

What's the empirical basis for this belief?
 
"Fund manager who is not paid when people invest by themselves says people who invest by themselves are dumb. Added bonus for his Boomer clients: he takes a swipe at Milennials."


Basic rule: anybody who shares their predictions about what the market will do within a secular cycle is either deluded or lying. My advice is to ignore them and the clickbait they ride in on.

I don't think that's what he's really saying. A fund manage makes money if people invest more, and if those investments are worth more. By saying that the stock market is overvalued, he is encouraging people to take money out of his fund, thus cutting his paycheck.

Of course, that assumes he doesn't have money invested elsewhere that will make money if the stock market goes down. Your central point, that it isn't wise to trust advice from people who have money riding on how you choose is perfectly valid.

What I would say is that last year, I saw very few "bearish" comments in news stories. There were almost no "bulls", either. General sentiment was that the market as a whole was at most slightly overpriced. As the market plunged in the early days of pandemic, I still saw very few bearish comments, except for an occasional "sky is falling" comment, such as what inspired the OP of this thread. Today, I'm seeing more and more bears coming out. The general feeling is that the state of the world's businesses is certainly no better, and is probably worse, than it was in February, and yet the stock market has gone way up from a place where it was probably overvalued to begin with.

But, once again, if I actually knew what would happen, I would be rich.

It is actually possible to market time. However, the few people who do it well are very rich, and their profits were made from the hordes of people who thought they could do it. I mostly leave my money in mutual funds just sitting there. For individual stocks, I try to gauge whether the company is doing well, or poorly, which actually is possible. When I draw cash out, it is partly because I believe a "correction" is likely, and partly based on whether or not I might need the money and might not be able to wait for a recovery. As it turns out right now, the possibility of job loss in the near future is not extremely high, but it's high enough and I am old enough that I don't want to take a chance that I will have to sell depressed shares in a down market. Young people can leave it in, reasonably certain that even if the value crashes, it will recover eventually.
 
Last edited:
I've heard this story a lot, and nobody's ever produced credible evidence (just fluff op/ed pieces like in the post you replied to).

What's the empirical basis for this belief?

Volume and size of trades. Bloomberg did a piece on it a while back that was extensively researched.
 
I don't think that's what he's really saying. A fund manage makes money if people invest more, and if those investments are worth more. By saying that the stock market is overvalued, he is encouraging people to take money out of his fund, thus cutting his paycheck.

No, he operates what's called a hedge fund. The sales pitch is that they select stocks that are a hedge against what the market indexes do. You buy into his fund to protect yourself against a market crash.

(narrator's voice: it doesn't end up doing this but they get paid anyway)



Of course, that assumes he doesn't have money invested elsewhere that will make money if the stock market goes down.

One would believe he has money in his own fund, but research shows that most hedge fund managers do not. They tend to be in real estate, index funds, and private ventures.



What I would say is that last year, I saw very few "bearish" comments in news stories. There were almost no "bulls", either. General sentiment was that the market as a whole was at most slightly overpriced. As the market plunged in the early days of pandemic, I still saw very few bearish comments, except for an occasional "sky is falling" comment, such as what inspired the OP of this thread. Today, I'm seeing more and more bears coming out. The general feeling is that the state of the world's businesses is certainly no better, and is probably worse, than it was in February, and yet the stock market has gone way up from a place where it was probably overvalued to begin with.

The key word there is 'probably'. It was 'probably' overvalued every day for the last 50 years for all we know. But on average, it has been going up anyway. So, maybe it wasn't overvalued, is an alternative explanation.


But, once again, if I actually knew what would happen, I would be rich.

Obviously.


It is actually possible to market time.

I disagree, and I think the research shows this pretty clearly. That is, I think the 'successful' market timers are a survivorship bias, like people who picked the right lottery ticket numbers. They didn't do it on purpose, they don't have a system, a broken clock is right twice a day, &c. I posted an analysis a few pages back showing that market timers who time dips *well* do worse than dollar cost averagers who just buy biweekly.



However, the few people who do it well are very rich, and their profits were made from the hordes of people who thought they could do it. I mostly leave my money in mutual funds just sitting there. For individual stocks, I try to gauge whether the company is doing well, or poorly, which actually is possible. When I draw cash out, it is partly because I believe a "correction" is likely, and partly based on whether or not I might need the money and might not be able to wait for a recovery. As it turns out right now, the possibility of job loss in the near future is not extremely high, but it's high enough and I am old enough that I don't want to take a chance that I will have to sell depressed shares in a down market. Young people can leave it in, reasonably certain that even if the value crashes, it will recover eventually.

Hm. Well, I'm assuming you're American? So, this is what Roth Ladders and Bond Tents are for, right - to mitigate Sequence of Returns Risk? Rather than an ad hoc percentage pullout into cash?

But even then, arguably, even older people should remain fully invested. I intend no change to my portfolio surrounding retirement. The old rules of thumb about "one hundred minus your age in bonds" do not apply today for many reasons. Low interest rates, and longer retirements change the source of risk from dealing with stock market volatility to dealing with low returns. Cash is actually an increase in risk for long retirement timeframes. This is what the Trinity Study was about. The more cash (or equivalent low yield instruments like bonds) in a portfolio, the faster it's exhausted in retirement.

This is why Buffet referred to bonds as 'returnless risk' - and cash is slightly worse.
 
Last edited:
Volume and size of trades. Bloomberg did a piece on it a while back that was extensively researched.

Could you point me there? I've read about three pages worth of google results for Bloomberg articles about Robinhood at this point and none of them are connecting any dots about there being a real impact on equities pricing. At least not beyond op/ed quality sans data.

Volume and size of trades are certainly growing in the retail sector, but at the corresponding decline in the institutional sector. How do they say this affects pricing?

Actually, the articles I've read suggest the opposite: day traders seem to focus on penny stocks. Not S&P500.
 
Last edited:
No, he operates what's called a hedge fund.

Oh....[Emily Laetella voice] Never mind [/]


RE: Market timing

I suppose it is probably impossible to "time the market", because "the market" does weird things. Individual investors, though, can "time" companies. i.e. they can assess fair values of companies, and only buy when the prices are below fair values. The stocks may still go down, because that's market psychology, but if they get it right, they will eventually yield strong returns.

And if lots and lots of companies are overvalued, and very few are undervalued, you can probably get an insight into where things are going, in general, but that is even more subject to market whims.
 
Could you point me there?

It'll be paywalled and my subscription is lapsed, so no.

Here's a piece with some numbers from Axios, who are pretty reliable and well-sourced: https://www.axios.com/robinhood-retail-stock-trading-ddbc5880-5e0c-4022-98e0-910bfef26358.html

Actually, the articles I've read suggest the opposite: day traders seem to focus on penny stocks. Not S&P500.

Robinhoods aren't day traders in that sense - they're people investing small amounts in large companies.

They're probably not driving it so much any more, but what they did was lift the market when it dropped a long way, encouraging the major traders to get back on board. The app traders now form a useful lifebelt for the market as a whole.

When interest rates for deposits are worth nothing, it makes sense to put money into shares, and that's why the small investor in 2020 isn't after penny stocks, but blue-chips.
 
Oh....[Emily Laetella voice] Never mind [/]


RE: Market timing

I suppose it is probably impossible to "time the market", because "the market" does weird things. Individual investors, though, can "time" companies. i.e. they can assess fair values of companies, and only buy when the prices are below fair values. The stocks may still go down, because that's market psychology, but if they get it right, they will eventually yield strong returns.

And if lots and lots of companies are overvalued, and very few are undervalued, you can probably get an insight into where things are going, in general, but that is even more subject to market whims.

OK, I agree but there's a qualification: Yes, stock picking has potential. But not for you and me.

The main reason is that value investing is a strategy employed by entire staffs of investment companies with billions of dollars in buying readiness and negotiators who can make private deals to do leveraged buyouts or poison pill purchases of entire companies at a time. They have automation to scan the entire marketplace a thousand times a second for opportunities, and buy them across fiberoptic connections directly into the trading platforms in a millionth of a second.

I agree it's a good business model. The difference is they've invested in execution and can do it. We don't have the processing power or access.

This is why Warren Buffet was very honest about the difference between his company that does exactly what you're describing - with expensive access to databases and PhDs in data analytics and commerce and management... and he *still* goes years paying these employees where they say, "Nothing worth buying this year," because rivals scooped the up first.

That times a hundred hedge funds and private equity funds, doing this as their full-time jobs with staffing in the dozens or hundreds.

Versus you and me and google.

Buffet's pretty honest and I think rare in the investment world to just say it like it is and admit that you and me, we are best off investing in index funds instead of managed funds like his. And this is aligned with research inquiring into the same questions. Literally, people have won Nobel prizes proving that most stock picking is essentially gambling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom