Black Swan Event Under Way

I'm seriously considering moving most of my portfolio to cash (leaving only the big winners and likely survivors). I believe the confluence of upcoming events -- increased death toll, bankruptcies, mortgage implosion, and new jobless numbers as lockdowns are reimposed -- will result in a crash of sorts.

Selling now will mean realizing losses, and if my investment horizon were 30 years instead of 5, I'd say the best plan would be to wait it out. My concern is that it may take many years for the market to stabilize and work its way out of this mess, although I expect a good bounce (hopefully not a dead cat) when a vaccine is widely available. Still, since I'll need to be drawing money out starting about 4 years from now, I think I'm better off avoiding the black pits of hell and (to mix my metaphors), riding the tide back up when that starts.

Comments? Suggestions? Advice? Prognostications?

I think coronavirus related disasters are only a couple of years out. In other words, I think two years from now we will be in whatever new normal exists at the time. I'm pretty sure that will be a lot like the old normal, but even if it isn't, it won't be lockdowns and economic stagnation. We'll be back to work, even if work looks a little different. We'll be earning and spending, and any economic collapse caused by the epidemic will be short lived.

So, if you aren't trying to do "market timing", anticipating a short term drop and trying to avoid it and get back in when it's low, I would say there's no need to liquidate stocks. Corporations will be making money four years from now.

And if you don't care to guess which corporations, that's what mutual funds are for. There will be a lot of shakeups in the economy due to coronavirus. Somebody will be making money, but it might not be the same people that are making it today.

Conventional wisdom would be that, at your age, you shouldn't be 100% in on stocks right now anyway, so if you are, most people would suggest partial divestment.
 
I'm currently 60% in stocks, 10% bonds, 30% cash (money market that pays about 1.2%). With the exception of a few outliers, stocks and bonds are in mutual funds.
 
Comments? Suggestions? Advice? Prognostications?

With the markets at ridiculously high levels on the back of gambling investors, I'd say now is the ideal time to sell.

Prices may ever head higher, but when the earnings start to come in, we'll see more bears than Jellystone.

And it's not just Covid - the US/China spat will have a major effect on the markets and current prices aren't sustainable under any scenario.

Look at it this way - by moving to cash, you might miss out on a 5-10% appreciation, but you also might miss out on a 50% depreciation.

I switched all our funds to cash a couple of weeks ago. A bird in the hand and all that.
 
Look at it this way - by moving to cash, you might miss out on a 5-10% appreciation, but you also might miss out on a 50% depreciation.

That's the thinking that caused me to cash out some funds, but when I was done, I ended up pretty close to where Dallas Dad is already. I started out with about 90% stocks.

I do have individual stocks with stop orders on them, though, so that a slight dip in the market would result in a slight loss for me, and a cash position probably around 50%. The danger with those sorts of orders is that a quick dip downward in a stock price results in selling at the bottom. It has happened to me many times, but it's a chance I'll take right now. I have also had cases where my stop order hit as 10.00/share, and within a few weeks the stock was down to 6.00/share. So sometimes they work.

But, right now, I definitely agree that the potential short term down side is bigger than the potential short term up side. I'm doing a bit of market timing, even though everyone says to avoid that.

On the other hand, in my 401k plan, it's almost all stock investment. That part of my investing ends up being "dollar cost averaging", i.e. I just always buy and always hold.
 
This month's update on my stocks and shares ISA. I've started a new column so the table expands in width rather than length.

Date | % +/- | Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3|7.20|7.8
8.18|3.4|8.20|8.1
11.18|-3.1
2.19|-0.8
5.19|1.9
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8
 
Ok, I'm going to agree this isn't a Black Swan.

The reason for that is that it's unique and requires an entirely new term, so I'm going with "Zebra Swan". No, they don't exist, which is the point, because nobody saw the possible outcome of this one, just like nobody expects to see a zebra-striped swan.

It's a cross between a black swan and a white knight.

Black swans are extremely rare negative events, while white knights are friendly takeovers of listed entities, and this event has both elements.

The negative effects are stark - hundreds of millions of people having their incomes slashed and being driven into homelessness and/or extreme poverty, while the positive effects are equally stark - sharemarkets hitting historical highs on the back of app-based gambling.

This event is exposing all the problems of the Friedman Doctrine, with trillions of dollars of quantitative easing money gushing up to the wallets of the rich. Musk, Zuckerberg & Bezos are raking in trillions as the bottom 40% of people see their money, homes and prospects swallowed up by the system.

No matter what model I try to use I can't see a way out and I have no idea where it will all end up. Traditionally, events of this magnitude and fallout cause revolutions, but with the enormous numbers of people at the bottom totally outgunned by law enforcement, I can't see that as an option.

We are creating an underclass that may well become the norm for up to half of all populations.
 
Ok, I'm going to agree this isn't a Black Swan.

The reason for that is that it's unique and requires an entirely new term, so I'm going with "Zebra Swan". No, they don't exist, which is the point, because nobody saw the possible outcome of this one, just like nobody expects to see a zebra-striped swan.

It's a cross between a black swan and a white knight.

Black swans are extremely rare negative events, while white knights are friendly takeovers of listed entities, and this event has both elements.

The negative effects are stark - hundreds of millions of people having their incomes slashed and being driven into homelessness and/or extreme poverty, while the positive effects are equally stark - sharemarkets hitting historical highs on the back of app-based gambling.

This event is exposing all the problems of the Friedman Doctrine, with trillions of dollars of quantitative easing money gushing up to the wallets of the rich. Musk, Zuckerberg & Bezos are raking in trillions as the bottom 40% of people see their money, homes and prospects swallowed up by the system.

No matter what model I try to use I can't see a way out and I have no idea where it will all end up. Traditionally, events of this magnitude and fallout cause revolutions, but with the enormous numbers of people at the bottom totally outgunned by law enforcement, I can't see that as an option.

We are creating an underclass that may well become the norm for up to half of all populations.
The housing situation is a catastrophe.
Mortgage rates at 2.25% fuelling landlords hoovering up properties as their yields rise, rents at record highs, and tenants getting no benefit from the mortgage rates, rent is always head of the queue for the desperate because no misery like lack of power food or petrol comes close to the misery of eviction, which is easily achieved despite contrary suggestions.
Property managers and landlords are armed with forms for tenants to demand the government borrows billions more to pay rent to the disgustingly greedy residential property owners who pass on not a skerrick of their windfall guaranteed gains. And mortgage rates are set to fall further.
The black swan that would delight me would be 7% interest rates that is the level banks nominally stress test borrowers to.
 
Ok, I'm going to agree this isn't a Black Swan.

The reason for that is that it's unique and requires an entirely new term, so I'm going with "Zebra Swan". No, they don't exist, which is the point, because nobody saw the possible outcome of this one, just like nobody expects to see a zebra-striped swan.

It's a cross between a black swan and a white knight.

Black swans are extremely rare negative events, while white knights are friendly takeovers of listed entities, and this event has both elements.

The negative effects are stark - hundreds of millions of people having their incomes slashed and being driven into homelessness and/or extreme poverty, while the positive effects are equally stark - sharemarkets hitting historical highs on the back of app-based gambling.

This event is exposing all the problems of the Friedman Doctrine, with trillions of dollars of quantitative easing money gushing up to the wallets of the rich. Musk, Zuckerberg & Bezos are raking in trillions as the bottom 40% of people see their money, homes and prospects swallowed up by the system.

No matter what model I try to use I can't see a way out and I have no idea where it will all end up. Traditionally, events of this magnitude and fallout cause revolutions, but with the enormous numbers of people at the bottom totally outgunned by law enforcement, I can't see that as an option.

We are creating an underclass that may well become the norm for up to half of all populations.

I kind of foresaw it. As you predicted calamity, I said that companies ought to have a really awful year, but there's no reason to think that they will collapse in the long run, so the stock market shouldn't be in complete collapse. It's just a short term hiccup.

I certainly didn't see it recovering the way it did, and I think it is overvalued right now, but my opinion isn't always reliable in such matters.

As for the disastrous effects you predict, I don't see it being as bad as you make it out to be. I do think, unfortunately, that inflation is in the future, but I don't think it's society changing. The most likely scenario I see is that the Democrats return to power, either this year or four years from now. Taxes on the rich get raised. Inflation eats away at the national debt, and a huge number of retirement accounts, and eventually the US gets national health care.

However, my opinion and 4 bucks will buy you a cup of coffee, so take it for what it's worth.
 
The housing situation is a catastrophe.
Mortgage rates at 2.25% fuelling landlords hoovering up properties as their yields rise, rents at record highs, and tenants getting no benefit from the mortgage rates, rent is always head of the queue for the desperate because no misery like lack of power food or petrol comes close to the misery of eviction, which is easily achieved despite contrary suggestions.
Property managers and landlords are armed with forms for tenants to demand the government borrows billions more to pay rent to the disgustingly greedy residential property owners who pass on not a skerrick of their windfall guaranteed gains. And mortgage rates are set to fall further.
The black swan that would delight me would be 7% interest rates that is the level banks nominally stress test borrowers to.

I agree with all that - the system is ******.

I kind of foresaw it. As you predicted calamity, I said that companies ought to have a really awful year, but there's no reason to think that they will collapse in the long run, so the stock market shouldn't be in complete collapse. It's just a short term hiccup.

Lots of companies will collapse, though, and outside of some tech companies, earnings will be savaged.

What nobody foresaw was the app trading platforms boosting the markets the way they have.

I certainly didn't see it recovering the way it did, and I think it is overvalued right now, but my opinion isn't always reliable in such matters.

As for the disastrous effects you predict, I don't see it being as bad as you make it out to be.

Despite the fact we already know it's happening?

Rents are massively overdue, evictions will happen and millions of people will have nowhere to go.

You might not be seeing it because you're protected from the problems, but they're there.

I already posted UN data on hundreds of millions being driven into extreme poverty, and all at a time when charitable donations have dried up.

I do think, unfortunately, that inflation is in the future, but I don't think it's society changing.

There should have been inflation from the QE going on since the GFC, but it never happened, because shares and housing aren't counted. The inflation is all hidden by people investing in assets. The upwards flow of money is a torrent and people on the bottom have no funds to fuel inflation.

I just hope your thoughts on regime change in the US are correct, because another four years of the current one would cause mayhem.
 
There should have been inflation from the QE going on since the GFC, but it never happened, because shares and housing aren't counted. The inflation is all hidden by people investing in assets. The upwards flow of money is a torrent and people on the bottom have no funds to fuel inflation.

I think this is incorrect. In most countries, cost of housing is a component of the consumer basket used to calculate CPI. Category is labeled "shelter."

In Canada, we just got our last quarter's results, inflation was at 0.01%, which is essentially zero, and that included a 14% increase in real estate prices in the major urban centres. (Meaning: GTA, GVA, Montreal) Meanwhile, rents are falling.

I think the real danger at the moment is deflation, which is the actual reason QE has not resulted in inflation - it's doing what it's supposed to and stabilizing prices. But I'm worried about for how long, because there's not much room for further interest rate reductions.
 
Oh, probably also worth pointing out that the stock indexes are probably a little overpriced but not bubble territory.

If you look at the S&P500, it's about even for the February peak, but it's been six months. Normally it'd up on average 5%. So, it's 5% down from expectation. That's actually a lot.

And that's an average across the whole index, which hides the fact that a handful of tech stocks have been doing extremely well vs the rest are down probably an average of another 15%, which is more like what we can expect given the problems listed above.

What I think this represents is a forecast by investors that we're seeing a permanent shift away from certain business models and toward others. Specifically, away from businesses involving crowds in the public space and toward more online socialization and commerce.

I'm also forecasting a churn in real estate and auto as WFH becomes more prevalent and white collar can conduct work without being close to a physical office. Fewer offices, fewer commuter cars, more scope in geography for dwellings, more need for space for home offices.
 
I think this is incorrect. In most countries, cost of housing is a component of the consumer basket used to calculate CPI. Category is labeled "shelter."

Wrong.

Your own government statistics prove the point: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/62f0014m/62f0014m2017001-eng.htm

Rents are the major "shelter" component, and since they will be falling, the affect on inflation will be to reduce it further.
_______________________

Meanwhile, to back up my point about the bottom end faring very badly, NZ's median income has fallen for the first time since records began: https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/mo...e-since-records-started-in-1998-stats-nz-says
 
I'm seeing older companies like fossil fuel companies switch to alternative green and ethical practices and assets.

I'm also seeing ethical investments doing well.

Not to mention the big tech companies always on the rise.

Plus, the growth and more ethical practices in the Asian region.


We are creating an underclass that may well become the norm for up to half of all populations.

Texas sharpshooter fallacy?
 
We are well into Modern Monetary Theory as the heterodox becomes the orthodox. Helicopter money is here to stay. Since most every first world country is in the same boat it may be surprisingly stable for quite a while.
 
Since most every first world country is in the same boat it may be surprisingly stable for quite a while.

Shares, maybe; real estate... who the hell knows?

I agree the flow of money into shares won't dry up when interest rates for deposits are zero, or close enough to it not to matter, but real estate is a different beast.

First off, there are lots of mortgage payers in arrears, and secondly, rentals will fall simply due to people not being able to afford rent. That may not matter as owners will be prepared to wait it out and assume capital gains in the future.

I made the comment to several people lately that the real trouble hasn't even started yet, and the fallout of job losses will be immense and long lasting.

We've created the perfect confluence of rising asset prices and falling incomes and something has to break.
 
Shares, maybe; real estate... who the hell knows?

I agree the flow of money into shares won't dry up when interest rates for deposits are zero, or close enough to it not to matter, but real estate is a different beast.

First off, there are lots of mortgage payers in arrears, and secondly, rentals will fall simply due to people not being able to afford rent. That may not matter as owners will be prepared to wait it out and assume capital gains in the future.

I made the comment to several people lately that the real trouble hasn't even started yet, and the fallout of job losses will be immense and long lasting.

We've created the perfect confluence of rising asset prices and falling incomes and something has to break.
There is a surplus of disgusting greed in the residential landlord class.
Their investmentments are secured by government grants of money the government is stealing.
From the poorof the endless future.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom