The lack of a placebo-control, blinding and randomization means that reliable conclusions cannot be drawn about the source of any 'effects'. It could just as easily be wishful thinking as Black Cohosh.
.. Your studies are not sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of Black Cohosh.
The three studies quoted here
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3307525#post3307525 show an obvious effect. Claiming "it could be wishful thinking" is not scientific, nor along the lines of evidence based medicine. This sort of blindness about scientific studies, where a conclusion is reached before looking at evidence, is the opposite of the scientific method.
Studies, especially ones that test the difference between two herbal formulas, do not exist in a vacuum. When research is done on differences, it is to examine what adding something does, not looking for an effect. Black Cohosh is already known to have an effect, the one study was looking at what adding another herb did.
Even a casual look at the wealth of data on Black Cohosh shows scientific evidence for having biological activity, that can both be measured, as well as understood.
The abstract of the paper you quoted is
here.
... The paper shows that an alcoholic extract of BC can inhibit the uptake of a synthetic opioid in human receptors in hamster ovarian cells. This is interesting but to extend that as a mechanism for climacteric problems in humans is speculative to say the least. Before that mechanism can be proved lets look at the steps along the way.
Thanks for the link to the abstract.
http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/abstract.cgi/jafcau/2006/54/i26/abs/jf062808u.html
These results demonstrate for the first time that black cohosh contains active principle(s) that activate hMOR, supporting its beneficial role in alleviating menopausal symptoms.
The double standard used by skeptics when it comes to science they don't like, is often amusing. Rather than admit a point, they want to move the goalpost, or focus on unrelated issues. A study that used the exact same method to determine the toxicity of a known drug, Taxol, wouldn't raise an eyebrow.
Taxol is a clinically active anticancer drug, which exerts its cytotoxicity by the unique mechanism of polymerizing tubulin monomers into microtubules and stabilizing microtubules. Our studies with ovarian (hamster CHO and human A2780) cells showed that taxol is a phase-specific agent that is much more cytotoxic to mitotic cells than interphase cells.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/u87p68017244m315/
See? Human ovarian cells in hamsters are used all the time to do testing. But when a result goes against your belief system, somehow it doesn't mean anything. Madness.
...
The problem with herbalists is that blithely ignore all these stages and just give the non-standardised preparation, without knowing a) what they are prescribing and b) what its action will be.
Such claims, while they sound good, are just something you made up. You don't actually know anything about the millions of herbalist worldwide, or how they think, work and research science. Your sweeping statement is simply woo. You have no research, no evidence, nothing to base your claim on. Yet such behavior is exactly what you purport to be against.
Even a cursory look at the vast amounts of research on medicinal herbs shows a keen interest in both establishing potency, standards, and finding ways to isolate and extract the active ingrediants from plants.
In the past, herbalist faced huge problems with obtaining and storing plants and their extracts. As well as knowing the potency of the product. This same problem exist today. Anyone who has bought a bag of herb knows the importance of determining quality, hopefully before the transaction. And you who have indeed bought and consumed a medicinal herb, might laugh along with us, when some skeptic tries to tell you that the effect might just be wishful thinking....
Humans can become quite adept at evaluating the potency of an herbal product. Be it Coffee, or some other potent brew nature serves up, on a regular basis.