Black Coshosh: Another herbal cure proves worthless

Vaidya - What do you mean by the "differential assessment of typology"? Do you mean, e.g. that English are "cold and damp" and Italians "hot and warm"?

Could you explain the difference between empirical and traditional use of herbs?

Is BC an example of Phytoestrogen and what influence it has on the LH, FSH, E2 and Prl?
Thank you.
 
please provide evidence that BC was prescribed in the 1920's for menopausal sx - i have never seen it and i have done an extensive review of the literature

I didn't say 'prescribed'. It was a 'natural vitamin source' recommendation in Adelle Davis' early circulars, first published in 1922. It is also a recommendation in her 1935 book, Optimum Health.

The 1930s was a slow market for health fads, as so many people were economizing their food budget.

While Davis tried to work from scientific findings, it looks like most of her work was confirmation-seeking popular wives' tales.
 
More adverse affects are mentioned here. If the efficacy is in doubt, and in this case it is, the risk benefit from even a small number of adverse events should preclude its use.

you (perhaps) unknowingly apply a double standard - why is acetaminophen still on shelves?

see: http://www.whale.to/a/acetaminophen.html

"In 1996 alone, 74,000 cases of acetaminophen toxicity were reported in the United States, according to United States Poison Control Centers figures."

Let me get this straight.
1) Chinese medicine adds an herb and that eliminates all side effects from all other herbs? This is remarkable, I wonder why it's not used for every drug.

ignorance?

2) Medical herbalists (whatever that means) mix herbs for synergy even though they don't know what is happening?

its not that they don't "know" what's happening, its how the qualities of one herb counters or influences another

qualitative distinctions are the primary model by which herbalists have traditionally classified their herbs - read Galen's "De Simplicibus" or Hippocrates

as for specific examples about how traditional methods of processing applied in herbal medicine affect the resultant outcome (to also address point 2 above), you may find the following study is interesting:

J Postgrad Med. 1991 Jul;37(3):157-9.

Can we dispense with Ayurvedic samskaras?

Thorat S, Dahanukar S.

Department of Pharmacology, Seth G. S. Medical College, Bombay, Maharashtra.

Crude aconite is an extremely lethal substance. However, the science of Ayurveda looks upon aconite as a therapeutic entity. Crude aconite is always processed i.e. it undergoes 'samskaras' before being utilised in the Ayurvedic formulations. This study was undertaken in mice, to ascertain whether 'processed' aconite is less toxic as compared to the crude or unprocessed one. It was seen that crude aconite was significantly toxic to mice (100% mortality at a dose of 2.6 mg/mouse) whereas the fully processed aconite was absolutely non-toxic (no mortality at a dose even 8 times as high as that of crude aconite). Further, all the steps in the processing were essential for complete detoxification.
 
Are you saying that you are unaware of the multiple case reports published in the medical literature, or of the many ADR reports to the relevant monitoring bodies in different countries where liver toxicity occured in patients taking black cohosh? Or of the precautionary statements issued by these monitoring bodies after investigating the possibility of whether the hepatotoxicity was related to the Black Cohosh?

how many people take BC? get these numbers and then look at the 6-7 case reports of liver issues with BC

then, take into consideration that in the six cases presented in one paper:

"Patient 3 was taking temazepam, and Patient 4 had been taking long term low dose aspirin. No other concurrent medication was reported. Two patients had notable comorbidities: Patient 3 suffered from Huntington's chorea, and Patient 2 was diagnosed with ovarian adenocarcinoma shortly after presenting with hepatitis, but had no evidence of metastatic involvement of the liver on biopsy, computed tomography scan or at laparotomy."

which reasonably reduces the number that could be attributed directly to BC to be be 3 or 4, which i will repeat again, is no better than random

the numbers are not on your side linda
stop applying double standards
 
Vaidya - What do you mean by the "differential assessment of typology"? Do you mean, e.g. that English are "cold and damp" and Italians "hot and warm
"?

no, i mean "constitutional" assessment, such as prakriti in ayurveda

Could you explain the difference between empirical and traditional use of herbs?

Is BC an example of Phytoestrogen and what influence it has on the LH, FSH, E2 and Prl?
Thank you.


no
 
Vaidya - What do you mean by the "differential assessment of typology"? Do you mean, e.g. that English are "cold and damp" and Italians "hot and warm"?

Could you explain the difference between empirical and traditional use of herbs?

Is BC an example of Phytoestrogen and what influence it has on the LH, FSH, E2 and Prl?
Thank you.


sorry, i hit the wrong button
re: typology, refer to the concept of "prakriti" in ayurveda

since my participation in his forum is really more of a distraction, i don't have time to present a thorough exegesis on empirical practices vs. traditional beliefs, but there is basic evidence out there

for e.g., if you are familiar with the literature of Ayurveda, you will see that in the 3000+ years that Ayurvedic knowledge has been consigned to text (note that is also a mnenomic tradition), scholar physicians have continually reassessed and recontextualized the knowledge that was passed down from generation to generation, sometimes modifying practices or adding in new knowledge for new diseases, such as syphilis that was brought to india by the portuguese - but to know this you have to be knowledgeable of Sanskrit, and I suspect that many on this forum haven't a clue about what Sanskrit is, nor are familiar with the corpus of Ayurvedic literature

just because something is traditional doesn't mean it is empirical - however, when you provide medical care you either are successful or not, and just following a tradition without knowledge won't serve successful clinical outcomes

interesting story in TCM is the use of Ephedra (Ma Huang), which is also known by another synonym as "Ask For Trouble" - a story is related, about a young apprentice using the herb to treat fever, and this story is told to new practitioners to illustrate how this herb has specific set of indications that must be carefully regarded, otherwise you are just asking for trouble - incidentally, weight loss was never a traditional indication, but if the traditional AND empirical knowledge had been understood by MLM companies, Ephedra would still be available in the US (actually, it still is, you just need to know where to get it)
 
I didn't say 'prescribed'. It was a 'natural vitamin source' recommendation in Adelle Davis' early circulars, first published in 1922. It is also a recommendation in her 1935 book, Optimum Health.

The 1930s was a slow market for health fads, as so many people were economizing their food budget.

While Davis tried to work from scientific findings, it looks like most of her work was confirmation-seeking popular wives' tales.

you said it was prescribed for menopause
is this true or not?

if you are simply talking about its usage period, its use is almost certainly pre-Columbian, as evidenced by ample ethnobotanical data:

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Abortifacient) Used to stimulate menstruation. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Analgesic) Used as an anodyne. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Analgesic) Infusion of root "in spirits" used for rheumatic pains. Witthoft, John 1947 An Early Cherokee Ethnobotanical Note. Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences 37(3):73-75 (p. 73, 74)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Antirheumatic (Internal)) Infusion of roots in alcoholic spirits used for rheumatism. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Antirheumatic (Internal)) Infusion of root "in spirits" used for rheumatic pains. Witthoft, John 1947 An Early Cherokee Ethnobotanical Note. Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences 37(3):73-75 (p. 73, 74)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Cold Remedy) Infusion taken for colds. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Cough Medicine) Infusion taken for coughs. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Dermatological Aid) Given for hives. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Dermatological Aid) Infusion of slightly astringent plant taken for rheumatism. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Diuretic) Used as a diuretic. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Laxative) Infusion taken for constipation. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Pediatric Aid) Given to make babies sleep. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Sedative) Given to make babies sleep. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Stimulant) Given for fatigue. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Tonic) Used as a tonic. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Cherokee Drug (Tuberculosis Remedy) Infusion taken for colds, coughs, "consumption" and constipation. Hamel, Paul B. and Mary U. Chiltoskey 1975 Cherokee Plants and Their Uses -- A 400 Year History. Sylva, N.C. Herald Publishing Co. (p. 30)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Delaware Drug (Tonic) Used with elecampane and stone root to make a tonic. Tantaquidgeon, Gladys 1972 Folk Medicine of the Delaware and Related Algonkian Indians. Harrisburg. Pennsylvania Historical Commission Anthropological Papers #3 (p. 33)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Delaware Drug (Tonic) Combined with elecampane and stone roots to make a tonic. Tantaquidgeon, Gladys 1972 Folk Medicine of the Delaware and Related Algonkian Indians. Harrisburg. Pennsylvania Historical Commission Anthropological Papers #3 (p. 39)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Delaware, Oklahoma Drug (Tonic) Compound containing root used as a tonic. Tantaquidgeon, Gladys 1942 A Study of Delaware Indian Medicine Practice and Folk Beliefs. Harrisburg. Pennsylvania Historical Commission (p. 32, 74)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Iroquois Drug (Antirheumatic (External)) Decoction of roots or plants used as a soak and steambath for rheumatism. Herrick, James William 1977 Iroquois Medical Botany. State University of New York, Albany, PhD Thesis (p. 320)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Iroquois Drug (Blood Medicine) Root used as a blood purifier. Herrick, James William 1977 Iroquois Medical Botany. State University of New York, Albany, PhD Thesis (p. 321)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Iroquois Drug (Gynecological Aid) Infusion of roots taken to "promote the flow of milk in women." Herrick, James William 1977 Iroquois Medical Botany. State University of New York, Albany, PhD Thesis (p. 320)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Iroquois Drug (Orthopedic Aid) Poultice of smashed leaves applied to babies with sore backs. Herrick, James William 1977 Iroquois Medical Botany. State University of New York, Albany, PhD Thesis (p. 320)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Iroquois Drug (Pediatric Aid) Poultice of smashed leaves applied to babies with sore backs. Herrick, James William 1977 Iroquois Medical Botany. State University of New York, Albany, PhD Thesis (p. 320)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Micmac Drug (Kidney Aid) Root used for kidney trouble. Chandler, R. Frank, Lois Freeman and Shirley N. Hooper 1979 Herbal Remedies of the Maritime Indians. Journal of Ethnopharmacology 1:49-68 (p. 56)

Actaea racemosa var. racemosa Black Bugbane; Ranunculaceae Penobscot Drug (Kidney Aid) Root used to make a medicine and taken for kidney trouble. Speck, Frank G. 1917 Medicine Practices of the Northeastern Algonquians. Proceedings of the 19th International Congress of Americanists Pp. 303-321 (p. 310,311)
 
Mechanism Of Black Cohosh Versus Hot Flashes Revealed

Mechanism Of Black Cohosh Versus Hot Flashes Revealed

ScienceDaily (Dec. 26, 2006) — The natural herb black cohosh is commonly used by women to treat menopausal symptoms such as hot flashes, but the molecular mechanisms underlying its action have eluded scientists -- until now.

Researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago and the National Institutes of Health Center for Botanical Dietary Supplements Research have discovered that black cohosh may act on human opiate receptors, which play a role in regulating a body's temperature.

Z. Jim Wang, assistant professor of pharmacology and pharmaceutics, led the study, which will be published in an upcoming issue of the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry; the paper is currently available on the journal's web site.

Opiate receptors are chemical sensors that respond to opiates like morphine and endorphins, Wang said. Chemical substances with opiate activity bind to the receptors and produce the appropriate response, including the regulation of pain, temperature and appetite.

"We used several extracts of black cohosh and found that elements of the herb could bind to the human 'mu' opiate receptor," Wang said. "The opiate receptor system affects several aspects of female reproductive neuroendocrinology, such as the levels of sex hormones and neurotransmitters that are important for temperature regulation."

Black cohosh (known as both Actaea racemosa and Cimicifuga racemosa) is a member of the buttercup family. A perennial plant, it is native to North America. It has been used by Native Americans to treat malaise, gynecological disorders, kidney ailments, malaria, rheumatism and sore throat, as well as colds, cough, constipation, hives and backaches, and to induce lactation.

Women experience a variety of symptoms of menopause, but the hot flash is the most common. Although the exact mechanism of the hot flash is unclear, estrogen withdrawal during menopause clearly plays an important role, Wang said. It is assumed that declining estrogen concentrations may change the levels of brain chemicals called neurotransmitters.
As a result, the thermoregulatory center located in the hypothalamus functions irregularly, which leads to inappropriate peripheral vasodilatation that causes hot flashes.

"The hypothalamic thermostat setting can be controlled directly or indirectly by the opiate system," Wang said.

Wang said this is the first time black cohosh has been linked to the activity of the opiate receptors. The ethanol extract used in this study, he said, is currently being used in a phase II clinical trial conducted by researchers from the UIC/NIH Center for Botanical Dietary Supplements Research.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/12/061222092334.htm
 
how many people take BC? get these numbers and then look at the 6-7 case reports of liver issues with BC

I didn't provide a list of all the case reports available (there were more), I just wanted to demonstrate that there was more than one. And then there are the many ADR's reported to the relevant monitoring agencies.

then, take into consideration that in the six cases presented in one paper:

"Patient 3 was taking temazepam, and Patient 4 had been taking long term low dose aspirin. No other concurrent medication was reported. Two patients had notable comorbidities: Patient 3 suffered from Huntington's chorea, and Patient 2 was diagnosed with ovarian adenocarcinoma shortly after presenting with hepatitis, but had no evidence of metastatic involvement of the liver on biopsy, computed tomography scan or at laparotomy."

which reasonably reduces the number that could be attributed directly to BC to be be 3 or 4, which i will repeat again, is no better than random

the numbers are not on your side linda
stop applying double standards

This is how uncommon side-effects are discovered. Sometimes further investigation shows an association, sometimes it doesn't. Two things that make me nervous about your cavalier attitude - the cases that force their way to our attention represent the tip of the iceberg, and finding something is made difficult by not looking for it in the first place.

Fewer reports than those made against Black Cohosh led to warnings and then the withdrawal of Hismanal, for example.

Linda
 
I want to add in another piece - this is from a respected colleague:

"The clearest, uncomplicated cases show elevated liver enzymes appearing within a few week in some cases of taking Remifemin, and then going away when it is discontinued, in women who are not taking any other meds. A number of other cases where statin drugs, which were previously tolerated well, began to show elevated liver enzymes when Remifemin was added. Of course none of us would suggest that anyone take black cohosh in doses of, say 40 drops, bid, long term, like -forever- which is how the MDs prescribe the Remifemin. Many other side effects are more common, especially muscle tension and pain and headaches"

Herbalists DON'T use Remifemin, because most of us think its a pharmaceutical, and as such, has a smaller therapeutic window. The logic behind its use it highly reductionist, and as every herbalist knows, you cannot attribute a _herbal_ action to one particular constituent, in this case, 27-deoxyactein. Beside which, no herbalist would recommend hat it be taken BY ITSELF (see my brief discussion of herbal synergy and processing), or for an extended duration.

The physiology of menopause is complex and deserves a complex approach. It is the magic bullet thinking of modern medicine hat has reduced herbal medicines such as BC/remifemin to such reductionist levels.

I have treated hundreds of cases of menopause, and use a host of different approaches, each of which is tailored to the patient. BC has only figured to be a minor component in a minority of cases. I stand by my original statements that the _reason_ why we might see problems with BC is because its modern usage does not respect traditional uses. Why? Because of the kind of ignorance that demonstrates itself on this forum.
 
I didn't provide a list of all the case reports available (there were more), I just wanted to demonstrate that there was more than one. And then there are the many ADR's reported to the relevant monitoring agencies.



This is how uncommon side-effects are discovered. Sometimes further investigation shows an association, sometimes it doesn't. Two things that make me nervous about your cavalier attitude - the cases that force their way to our attention represent the tip of the iceberg, and finding something is made difficult by not looking for it in the first place.

Fewer reports than those made against Black Cohosh led to warnings and then the withdrawal of Hismanal, for example.

Linda

this post are simply irrelevant - you are attempting to save face and that is all

the numbers are against your argument - ALL your arguments

once again, please explain to the enlightened rationalists why acetaminophen is still OTC drug with 74,000 cases of poisoning in the US, in 1996 ALONE

is it really rational in the face of these kind of numbers to single out OTC black cohosh? with a handful of ADRs? and we haven't even talked about other antiinflammatories like paracetamol, or antihistamines, or children's cough syrup...? get real

"rationalists" such as yourself continuously demonstrate your bias, ignorance, and irrationality by starting and then defending threads such as this one

read some thomas kuhn and get back to me
its time for all of you to have a paradigm shift
 
Probably because normal use doesn't lead to toxicity. The toxic effects of Black Cohosh (if present) occurred during normal use.

Linda

that's a bold-face LIE
and you know it

are you telling us that every single one of those 74,000 cases of acetaminophen toxicity were caused by overdose?? that is just plain banal
 
you (perhaps) unknowingly apply a double standard - why is acetaminophen still on shelves?

see: http://www.whale.to/a/acetaminophen.html

"In 1996 alone, 74,000 cases of acetaminophen toxicity were reported in the United States, according to United States Poison Control Centers figures."
In the UK OTC acetaminophen(paracetamol) has been restricted for this reason. However it demonstrably shows benefit for headache and fever. BC on the other hand has no demonstrable benefit so why risk taking any?


its not that they don't "know" what's happening, its how the qualities of one herb counters or influences another

qualitative distinctions are the primary model by which herbalists have traditionally classified their herbs - read Galen's "De Simplicibus" or Hippocrates
Hell, I didn't misread it. You do dose people with mixtures and you do not know the consequences.

as for specific examples about how traditional methods of processing applied in herbal medicine affect the resultant outcome (to also address point 2 above), you may find the following study is interesting:

J Postgrad Med. 1991 Jul;37(3):157-9.
Can we dispense with Ayurvedic samskaras?
I wish we could but wait while I find out what they are.....right.

Thorat S, Dahanukar S.

Department of Pharmacology, Seth G. S. Medical College, Bombay, Maharashtra.

Crude aconite is an extremely lethal substance. However, the science of Ayurveda looks upon aconite as a therapeutic entity. Crude aconite is always processed i.e. it undergoes 'samskaras' before being utilised in the Ayurvedic formulations. This study was undertaken in mice, to ascertain whether 'processed' aconite is less toxic as compared to the crude or unprocessed one. It was seen that crude aconite was significantly toxic to mice (100% mortality at a dose of 2.6 mg/mouse) whereas the fully processed aconite was absolutely non-toxic (no mortality at a dose even 8 times as high as that of crude aconite). Further, all the steps in the processing were essential for complete detoxification.

OK, the aconite alkaloids are very poisonous, this study takes the root and boils it in cow's urine for seven hours twice and then boils it in cows milk. It says for the same period, doesn't say once or twice. (Now I know why they keep all those sacred cows around) The root is then washed in lukewarm water and dried. The root is then ground up and administered. Surprise, surprise, the root is now less toxic. I wonder why that could be, perhaps the alkaloids have been extracted. A pretty inefficient method as they are much more soluble in alcohol. Interestingly, they didn't do the praying thing recommended in the Samskaras, so at least that's not necessary. They also didn't show any clinical effectiveness. What is this paper supposed to show? I can make ANY non-heavy metal containing herb safe in 10 minutes.
 
ok, let's look at more stats linda:

Annual consumption of black cohosh fluctuates dramatically, as illustrated from 1998 to 2001. In 1998, approximately 700,000 lb of dried black cohosh root were consumed worldwide. In 1999, it dropped to about 183,000 lb and then rebounded sharply to approximately 420,000 lb in 2001. It is estimated that the demand for black cohosh will increase in the next three-to-five years. In 2001, it was estimated that the black cohosh market, in consumption dollars, reached $2.25 million. Projections of consumption well in excess of 500,000 lb per year are common. Black cohosh prices have been slowly increasing since the autumn of 1999."

source: http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/depts/hort/hil/hil-135.html

so, you can produce maybe 10 cases of liver issues with BC (most of which have concommitant factors, but i will give you it anyway), for an estimated 500,000 lbs (226,796.18kg) sold annually

here is the basic math, assuming 1:1 ratio:

clinical studies on remifemin have used an 80mg dose
and so given annual sales, that's exactly 2,834,952.3 doses

in other words, your risk is about 0.00000353% per dose of liver injury

statistically INSIGNIFICANT
 
In the UK OTC acetaminophen(paracetamol) has been restricted for this reason. However it demonstrably shows benefit for headache and fever. BC on the other hand has no demonstrable benefit so why risk taking any?

bullcrap - look at three most recent clinical studies that i posted
stop repeating things that aren't true - it just means you don't do your research and shows you up as an irrational fundamentalist


OK, the aconite alkaloids are very poisonous, this study takes the root and boils it in cow's urine for seven hours twice and then boils it in cows milk. It says for the same period, doesn't say once or twice. (Now I know why they keep all those sacred cows around) The root is then washed in lukewarm water and dried. The root is then ground up and administered. Surprise, surprise, the root is now less toxic. I wonder why that could be, perhaps the alkaloids have been extracted. A pretty inefficient method as they are much more soluble in alcohol. Interestingly, they didn't do the praying thing recommended in the Samskaras, so at least that's not necessary. They also didn't show any clinical effectiveness. What is this paper supposed to show? I can make ANY non-heavy metal containing herb safe in 10 minutes.

the samskaras are found in the extant Ayurvedic literature - just do a little research there bud

the "praying" thing (its not praying) has, in part, to do with timing of the different procedures, i.e. a particular mantra takes x minutes to complete, before moving on to stage two processing, etc. - but i will not debate the virtues or lack thereof for mantra because you would have to have some familiarity with its principles, practices and history before you could utter even a slightly intelligent comment about it

besides which, the fact that you CANNOT explain why it is less toxic demonstrates that you are running out of ideas - your response is irrelevant and quite frankly laughable

aconite is EXTREMELY toxic - the fact that you can purify it and then give it at doses 8 times the toxic doses WITHOUT ANY toxic effects speaks to the efficacy of the procedure - that is what was at issue, that traditional methods are used to render herbs less toxic

this is a FACT, inasmuch as any "fact" can be said to be TRUTH

QED

deny it, and you become a fundamentalist skeptic just like all the others
 
They also didn't show any clinical effectiveness. What is this paper supposed to show? I can make ANY non-heavy metal containing herb safe in 10 minutes.

classic bait and switch argument
the point was being made about purification, not efficacy

if you want to start another thread on the efficacy of purified aconite start another thread and i will destroy your argument there are well

as for your supposed skills on plant purification, that means nothing because since you know nothing about the actual clinical usage of the herb you wouldn't have a clue if the end-result would be efficacious
 
Mechanism Of Black Cohosh Versus Hot Flashes Revealed

The abstract of the paper you quoted is here.

Your post shows a common extrapolation of herbalists from not very much to a justification for dosing people with a preparation you know little about.

The paper shows that an alcoholic extract of BC can inhibit the uptake of a synthetic opioid in human receptors in hamster ovarian cells. This is interesting but to extend that as a mechanism for climacteric problems in humans is speculative to say the least. Before that mechanism can be proved lets look at the steps along the way.

Purification and structuring of the chemical causing the effect.
Demonstration of the same effect in human cells.
Toxicological trials in animals.
Phase I studies in humans
Phase II studies to show an effect.

The problem with herbalists is that blithely ignore all these stages and just give the non-standardised preparation, without knowing a) what they are prescribing and b) what its action will be.
 
this post are simply irrelevant - you are attempting to save face and that is all

the numbers are against your argument - ALL your arguments

once again, please explain to the enlightened rationalists why acetaminophen is still OTC drug with 74,000 cases of poisoning in the US, in 1996 ALONE

is it really rational in the face of these kind of numbers to single out OTC black cohosh? with a handful of ADRs? and we haven't even talked about other antiinflammatories like paracetamol, or antihistamines, or children's cough syrup...? get real

"rationalists" such as yourself continuously demonstrate your bias, ignorance, and irrationality by starting and then defending threads such as this one

read some thomas kuhn and get back to me
its time for all of you to have a paradigm shift

Being concerned about acetaminophen overdose does not preclude one from being concerned about other drugs. Even small numbers of preventable deaths are of concern in medicine.

Linda
 
The abstract of the paper you quoted is here.

Your post shows a common extrapolation of herbalists from not very much to a justification for dosing people with a preparation you know little about.

The paper shows that an alcoholic extract of BC can inhibit the uptake of a synthetic opioid in human receptors in hamster ovarian cells. This is interesting but to extend that as a mechanism for climacteric problems in humans is speculative to say the least. Before that mechanism can be proved lets look at the steps along the way.

Purification and structuring of the chemical causing the effect.
Demonstration of the same effect in human cells.
Toxicological trials in animals.
Phase I studies in humans
Phase II studies to show an effect.

The problem with herbalists is that blithely ignore all these stages and just give the non-standardised preparation, without knowing a) what they are prescribing and b) what its action will be.

i posted three recent papers earlier that demonstrated efficacy of BC in menopausal sx in human clinical trials - read them, and get back to me - these directly challenge the assertion of the original author of the thread

take up THAT argument instead chasing windmills

its amazing how few of you actually read the entire thread instead of having knee-jerk responses and wild assumptions about what herbalists know or don't know
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom