Black Coshosh: Another herbal cure proves worthless

Go to this web site and search for cohosh.
http://scienceblogs.com/terrasig/
If that is your response to my suggestion, it seems a tad selective. The most recent post at that site says
A clinical trial in Annals of Internal Medicine last December, showed that one black cohosh extract was no better than placebo for this indication. Lack of efficacy has been shown in other settings ...
And, if I may add, citing a press-release as your source of medical information detracts from whatever credibility you may have had.
 
...And, if I may add, citing a press-release as your source of medical information detracts from whatever credibility you may have had.

The blog you linked to had the press release as a source. I don't consider a blog to be a source already, but if you say so .. :D
 
Why Remifemin doesn't show hormone-like activity? Because it is extracted using isopropylic alcohol (40%) only from the rhizome of BC which is the poorest part of the plant in isoflavones. The active components are triterpenic glycosides standardized in 27-deoxyactein (2-3,5%). Therefore, Remifemin acts as agonist at CNS levels, agonist on bone level but no agonism is shown on mammary glands and uterus and vagina.
Other BC extracts have estrogenic effects that may reduces the luteinizing activity.

I prescribed Remifemin for almost 20 years to thousand of patients with 50% excellent results, 40% good results and with no side effects, no alterations in liver enzymes and hormone concentrations, LH, FSH, E2, Prl and SHBG. In about 80% i prescribed 1 tab bd and in about 20 % 2 tab bd for a period ranging from 3 to 6 months.
 
The blog you linked to had the press release as a source. I don't consider a blog to be a source already, but if you say so
I cited the blog because it is a useful discussion, with "leading references" you may have missed (they seem to be newer than yours). You waded past the citations that dispute the use of BC, and selected the weakest evidence in its favor. You should have found the article on which the press-release was based.
 
I found http://scienceblogs.com/terrasig/2006/12/more_on_black_cohosh_results.php
Posted on: December 21, 2006 1:30 PM, by Abel Pharmboy
which linked to http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/abstract/145/12/869
an irrelevant study. Also cited http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16782922?dopt=AbstractPlus
which was mentioned here before.
Alos used
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11352967?dopt=abstractplus
a 2001 study, again irrelevant.
Also linked to
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/health/4411223.html
a 404 error.

Blog did not mention recent AMA papers, nor extensive German, Japanese, Chinese, and Italian studies on Remifemin. Granted, this was a quick look. Searching for Remifemin finds the entry expressing confusion about results showing Remifemin might also have protective properties when it comes to breast cancer.
http://www.wisbusiness.com/index.iml?Article=94197

A far more interesting path than continuing to debate your claim that Remifemin is worthless.
 
That being said, I'm not 100% certain Remifemin (Black Cohosh extract) is 100% safe, and even the best results show it doesn't work with every woman. If the only studies showing benefit came from the Remifemin manufacturer, I would be far more skeptical. But when even studies trying to show it is worthless get results, that holds far more sway.
 
That being said, I'm not 100% certain Remifemin (Black Cohosh extract) is 100% safe, and even the best results show it doesn't work with every woman. If the only studies showing benefit came from the Remifemin manufacturer, I would be far more skeptical. But when even studies trying to show it is worthless get results, that holds far more sway.

So let me get this straight. You choose to accept the one study of Remifemin that showed benefit:

http://www.greenjournal.org/cgi/reprint/105/5/1074?ijkey=4a2baef6600afba6f3b8052fc5ae350e1dc73412
(I have to admit that I find the analysis of this study quite strange and wonder why we are never provided with the actual results, but rather a highly 'massaged' version of the results.)

And to ignore the study that did not:

http://jco.ascopubs.org/cgi/content...d1dd1d3cc38b9c5fc124aabf&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha

as well as any of the other Black Cohosh studies that did not show benefit that used the same extract but not that particular brand.

(None of the German studies referred to were placebo-controlled, double-blind, randomized trials).

And your reasoning for doing so is, "an 'expert' did it, so it must be okay"? (Just checking. Not planning on using this against you in the future. You can trust me. ;))

Linda
 
So let me get this straight. You choose to accept the one study of Remifemin that showed benefit ...
And to ignore the study that did not:

No. Please try not to put words in my mouth. I might bite. You can read, (and quote), what I said.

(None of the German studies referred to were placebo-controlled, double-blind, randomized trials).

Incorrect. I posted several links to valid studies. There are many more.

And your reasoning for doing so is, "an 'expert' did it, so it must be okay"?

Again, it is clear what I wrote. Anybody interested can read it.

The problem with herbal remedies is that even the ones that do something cannot be dosed in a standard way.

In this case, it appears a standardized extract works, when just taking ground herbs does not. Interesting.

Much to nobody's surprise, yet another herbal cure has proved to be no better than placebo for treating symptoms.

It was that statement that got me interested in the matter. Not that interested, but enough to look at some data. First, calling Cohosh an "herbal cure" is dumb. Second, taking one study and claiming it proves something is "worthless" is dumb. Science doesn't work that way.

It sounds like propaganda.

I was surprised to find so much interest in this matter, and that one extract keeps showing an effect, in repeated studies. Large, double blind, placebo studies.

This specialized extract seems to be more of a drug than an "herbal cure". The cancer connection will probably spur many more studies. Pragmatic Doctors who are interested in treating disease, especially such a huge problem as menopause and breast cancer, probably don't care what skeptics say. They want to know if something works or not.
 
Robinson,

The only thing (besides advertising) you've posted that supports your statement that

"I was surprised to find so much interest in this matter, and that one extract keeps showing an effect, in repeated studies. Large, double blind, placebo studies."

is the review article in the Archives of Internal Medicine. And that review referred to two studies on Remifemin - one positive and one negative - but the authors decided that it was okay to ignore the negative study.

"A single large trial showed a benefit for vasomotor symptoms with the black cohosh Remifemin(R) (Enzymatic Therapy Inc., Green Bay Wisconsin) and is consistent with older German studies," the reviewers wrote, indicating that the remaining three studies showed no benefits from black cohosh. Results from two "were confounded by concurrent use of tamoxifen, known to exacerbate hot flashes," while another used a "more unusual (research) preparation, BN01055."

The rest of your references have been to studies that showed no difference from placebo, studies on safety (rather than efficacy), or studies which allow for multiple conclusions to be drawn - none of which support your statement that "using a quality extract (Remifemin), and using the correct dosage, you get the same results, that it works."

The reasons you have given for drawing conclusions not supported by the research were:

"See? The people that write in professional journals know more than I do, and have greater access to data, so I bow to their judgment."

"In this case I tend to trust the Medical Journals."

"They have vastly superior data to draw on, and expertise in the field."

"There are many more studies, but I tend to trust experts in this case, because I have little interest in actually taking the stuff."

The best piece of advice I can give you is this....

Do not trust the conclusions of the author(s) of research articles. Ignore them and look at the results instead. Seriously.

Linda
 
I tend to look at studies, or do my own research, rather than blindly trust "experts", especially when there is a lot of money/politics/prestige involved. This matter is way down there on my list of GAS, so I took the easy way out. :D

I find it interesting that data shows an extract works when the whole herb doesn't seem to. This is the sort of event that leads to a new "drug". Many drugs come from herbs/plants. A lot of new "drugs" being developed are actually compounds either derived from plants or synthesized after being discovered in plants.

Looking to scientist/researchers
http://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/results?term=cohosh
it is obvious that the study and article mentioned in the OP as "proof", has not caused every scientist on the planet to drop all research.

Again, science doesn't depend on a press release or a single study. Looking at the history of Black Cohosh, it was interesting to discover why Germany led the way in research on this herb. As well as the history of this American herb.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom