Robinson,
The only thing (besides advertising) you've posted that supports your statement that
"I was surprised to find so much interest in this matter, and that one extract keeps showing an effect, in repeated studies. Large, double blind, placebo studies."
is the review article in the Archives of Internal Medicine. And that review referred to two studies on Remifemin - one positive and one negative - but the authors decided that it was okay to ignore the negative study.
"A single large trial showed a benefit for vasomotor symptoms with the black cohosh Remifemin(R) (Enzymatic Therapy Inc., Green Bay Wisconsin) and is consistent with older German studies," the reviewers wrote, indicating that the remaining three studies showed no benefits from black cohosh. Results from two "were confounded by concurrent use of tamoxifen, known to exacerbate hot flashes," while another used a "more unusual (research) preparation, BN01055."
The rest of your references have been to studies that showed no difference from placebo, studies on safety (rather than efficacy), or studies which allow for multiple conclusions to be drawn - none of which support your statement that "using a quality extract (Remifemin), and using the correct dosage, you get the same results, that it works."
The reasons you have given for drawing conclusions not supported by the research were:
"See? The people that write in professional journals know more than I do, and have greater access to data, so I bow to their judgment."
"In this case I tend to trust the Medical Journals."
"They have vastly superior data to draw on, and expertise in the field."
"There are many more studies, but I tend to trust experts in this case, because I have little interest in actually taking the stuff."
The best piece of advice I can give you is this....
Do not trust the conclusions of the author(s) of research articles. Ignore them and look at the results instead. Seriously.
Linda