Bill O'Reilly weighs in on Shawn

Sir! Please show a little propriety, and call her by her real name, Greta van Horseface!
I shall, sirrah.

Let's see what we have here:

Greta Van Horseface
O'Reilly's words smelling worse than a horse apple
Prospects of more dead horse beating on this topic
BOR confirming my grandad's old adage: "This world has more horse's asses than it has horses."

I'd vote neigh to further haymaking, but it appears the horse has left the stable, and the digested oat count will increase.

DR
 
The boy in the My Name is Steven case (Steven Stayner? His brother became a mass murderer), also had ample opportunity to escape after a period of time. He did not. He was controlled by his captor and told how his parents had given up on him, didn't want him -- especially after he had been sexually assaulted. That he was bad, etc.

The point is, he was 11. A very manipulable age. We may never know the full story...but I am disturbed by the seeming effort to blame a kid for something he did not perpetrait or ask for, for conditions that were imposed upon him...etc. The foucus should be on the creep who took him...our lurid interest in why he stuck around, while perhaps understandable, should not take away from the ugliness of the crime.
 
Everything you say is plausible. I get it. My point is, OK. this merits discussion, vs. "end of discussion."

By "end of discussion", I was referring to the general speculation that Shawn ran away on his own, and was hiding out from his parents. That's evidently not the case.
 
Any decent human that is interacting with Bill O'Reilly on his show or anywhere else, when Bill starts to expound on Shawn Hornbeck's willing captivity, should immediately change the subject to O'Reilly's penchant for sexual harrassment, loofah and all. Yes, I am advocating shutting him down when he even brings it up. Of course, he owns that mic, and it won't happen.
 
My first thought when the kid was found was the Stockholm Syndrome. I just don't see how it would be possible for someone to keep anyone in captivity for four years with no opportunity for escape presenting itself to the victim.

Again, Stockholm Syndrome necessarily involves emotional bonding with the captor, and I haven't seen it here. If the kid was manipulated into not trying to escape - either through fear, or having been told so many times that escape was impossible that he just took it for granted, or even merely being too lazy or apathetic or conforming to attempt escape - it's not Stockholm.
 
Again, Stockholm Syndrome necessarily involves emotional bonding with the captor, and I haven't seen it here. If the kid was manipulated into not trying to escape - either through fear, or having been told so many times that escape was impossible that he just took it for granted, or even merely being too lazy or apathetic or conforming to attempt escape - it's not Stockholm.


My point would be that it is ultimately irrlevent to the crime...and therefore so much speculations seems to be a bit cruel to a relatively young person.
 
According to NPR, Hornbeck had access to the internet, the telephone, and may have even interacted with a cop during his captivity.

If so, he did have opportunities to escape or to at least cry for help.

Everyone involved is being silent on the matter, and rightly so. Don't want to give the kidnapper an out.

My first thought when the kid was found was the Stockholm Syndrome. I just don't see how it would be possible for someone to keep anyone in captivity for four years with no opportunity for escape presenting itself to the victim.
I only meant to scan the link in the following quote, but I ended up reading every word. If a grown woman can become this controled, how much easier must it be to control an 11 year old?

He 'doesnt believe in stockholm'? what a moron. Its very real, it happens quite often to children. Its a lot easier for the mind to handle the idea that they are in an affectionate relationship with an abuser than to think they are being abused and hurt.

http://www.crimelibrary.com/criminal_mind/psychology/sex_slave/


there is a story of a woman who was kidnapped and kept in a box for 7 years, being used as a sex slave. there is a chapter at the end about stockholm. Not for the faint of heart.
No, it isn't for the fait of heart at all. I have no idea whether or not this kid was put this this level of physical and mental torture, but I'm willing to think it is possible that he was very deeply controlled even if he was allowed to go out on his own sometimes.

Hell, the woman in the above link was even allowed to go visit her family and was unable to tell them what was going on.
 
Is known sex harrasser Bill O'Reilly a rapist? Just asking a question. No harm done.
That's not a good analogy. It's still in the form of a question. A closer example would be:

I think known sex harrasser Bill O'Reilly is a rapist. Just asking a question. No harm done.
 
I shall, sirrah.

Let's see what we have here:

Greta Van Horseface
O'Reilly's words smelling worse than a horse apple
Prospects of more dead horse beating on this topic
BOR confirming my grandad's old adage: "This world has more horse's asses than it has horses."

I'd vote neigh to further haymaking, but it appears the horse has left the stable, and the digested oat count will increase.

DR

Will Shawn be returned to a stable home?
Did his captor drive a Mustang?
Shawn's future is ruined, as he will be saddled with this the rest of his life.
This case leaves the prosecutor chomping at the bit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom