Bill O'Reilly weighs in on Shawn

He 'doesnt believe in stockholm'? what a moron. Its very real, it happens quite often to children. Its a lot easier for the mind to handle the idea that they are in an affectionate relationship with an abuser than to think they are being abused and hurt.

http://www.crimelibrary.com/criminal_mind/psychology/sex_slave/


there is a story of a woman who was kidnapped and kept in a box for 7 years, being used as a sex slave. there is a chapter at the end about stockholm. Not for the faint of heart.
 
Does everybody assume Devlin was a pediophile? I havent heard nuthin about such activities. Was he just a big-brother/ daddy fantasy?
 
I guess all of those kids abused by priests only came forward in the last couple of years because they secretly liked it.

I suppose women who don't struggle in a rape secretly like it. Or who don't report the rape secretly like it.

BORe is an idiot.

The starting point with this kid is that he is a victem. He was kidnapped and taken out of everything he knew about life. Whatever happened, whateverhe became, whatever he thinks about it comes out of the fact that he is a victem. This changed his life's trajectory in a huge way...no telling how far it has gone of track and I fear for the future. But the fact that the kid didn't run away is part and parcel of his being a victem.

Sadly, the media does turn. But we should have nothing but sympathy for this kid. He's only 15, for BORe's sake, he was taken when he was 11. God knows what was done to him or how he's been manipulated.
 
But we should have nothing but sympathy for this kid. He's only 15, for BORe's sake, he was taken when he was 11. God knows what was done to him or how he's been manipulated.

I, too, am a victim. My parents did everything in their power to manipulate me between age 11-15. Now I am an utter mess. Help.:boggled:
 
If there's been any official acknowledgment of sexual assault in this case so far I haven't seen it. The authorities are playing this one very safe; so far they have only charged Devlin with kidnapping the younger boy, and they are hinting that all they want is a life sentence, not necessarily to charge him with every possible crime and force the boys to testify.

However, there is a huge amount of circumstantial evidence pointing to sexual assault.

  • Devlin is not known to have any interest in either men or women.
  • People who are feeling paternal towards kids don't usually need to kidnap one to find a child to hang out with.
  • Devlin kidnapped an eleven year old, and kept him for four years, but right around the time Shawn started to grow underarm hair, he kidnapped another prepubescent.
  • Children who have been raped are often afraid that their parents will be like Bill O'Reilly and reject them.
  • The more disgusting and cruel the rape, the easier it is to convince the child that his parents don't want him back.
  • If the child is involved in sex acts with even younger children it's pretty easy to convince the child that he won't be going home, but rather to juvenile detention...
  • ...where he will of course be assaulted by the older boys.
  • The profiles posted by "Shawn Devlin" on various websites pointed to "mdevlin's" e-mail address. Abusers who get control of a child often use the child to attract other children.
  • Micheal Devlin allowed Shawn contact with other children his own age, but not with other adults.
  • Authorities have said that they are going to charge Devlin with child pornography charges. Details have not been given.

In short, it's hard to believe that there wasn't sexual assault in this case.
 
O'Reilly, as that what this thread is really about, is not giving Devlin a pass. Anyway, I think Devlin is the boogyman here, not O'Reilly, who is entitled to his opinion, allbeit flawed.
 
O'Reilly, as that what this thread is really about, is not giving Devlin a pass. Anyway, I think Devlin is the boogyman here, not O'Reilly, who is entitled to his opinion, allbeit flawed.
Attacking Devlin is easy. He's an obvious criminal of monstrous proportions. But attacking O'Reilly is well worth while too. He's using his postion to re-victimize this kid (accusing him of being complicit in his own captivity) because he personally can't comprehend what it's like to be a kidnapped child.

O'Reilly to get credit for doing the obvious - criticizing a child kidnapper? That's like giving a horse credit for dropping a road apple while walking.
 
Does O'Reilly not understand that this child was taken a hundred or so miles from his place of residence? Where on earth is the kid supposed to "escape" to? Another stranger's house? How likely is that, considering what happened the last time he met a stranger...?
 
BOR: The difference in the Smart case, and correct me if I am wrong, was this guy was always around the little girl and she wasn't gone for the long period of time as this guy was.


How come when I said Elizabeth Smart ran away, people got angry about it?

Now that these here kids done got themselves found, everyone say they might not be victims like Elizabeth Smart was(n't).

Yous owe me an apology.
 
Oh, well - the problem is solved:

Washington County, Mo., prosecutor John Rupp said in a statement that Devlin, 41, was charged with kidnapping and armed criminal action. The statement does not name Shawn, but uses the initials SDH.

A probable cause statement released by Rupp said Devlin "abducted SDH utilizing force for the purpose of terrorizing the victim. After securing SDH, Michael Devlin flourished a handgun in order to gain compliance of the minor child. Michael Devlin then transported him out of the county and concealed his whereabouts for four years and three months."

Rupp and Sheriff Kevin Schroeder would not discuss evidence in the case beyond the probable cause statement, but Rupp said he wanted to shoot down speculation that Shawn ran away on his own.

"Shawn was abducted against his will," Rupp said. "Period. End of story."

Discussion's over, Bill O'Reilly can kindly screw off. Knowing him, though, he'll probably say something brilliant like "even a 11 year old who has been threatened at gunpoint" would try to run at every opportunity.
 
Warning: product of a sick mind.

If I were Micheal Devlin, I'd deliberately give the kid a chance to escape, while secretly hiding nearby. After I caught him, I'd torture him.


And if that's not bad enough, there are now indications that Devlin may be implicated in the disappearance of yet another eleven year old boy who never got the chance to offend Bill O'Reily with his cowardly behavior.:mad:
 
How come when I said Elizabeth Smart ran away, people got angry about it?

Now that these here kids done got themselves found, everyone say they might not be victims like Elizabeth Smart was(n't).

Yous owe me an apology.
It's like Bill O'Reilly is REO Speedwagon to your Elton John. Or is that the other way around?
 
Discussion's over,

You are kidding, right? A boy is abducted at gunpoint. Time passes and he has ample chances to escape. It seems even odder to me that the boy did not try to escape with guns involved. You don't agree with me, fine. But don't silence me, either.
 
You are kidding, right? A boy is abducted at gunpoint. Time passes and he has ample chances to escape. It seems even odder to me that the boy did not try to escape with guns involved. You don't agree with me, fine. But don't silence me, either.

It's not that simple. Kid's a hundred miles from home, and is isolated from any sort of education, or contact with other adults. "Time passing" does not necessarily make one smarter or bolder all by itself. It's more likely that, after so many months, the kid simply realized that his circumstances weren't going to change, and adapted. There is precedent for this - the aforementioned case of Steven Stayner. He was kept by his kidnapper for 7 years before trying to escape, despite being subjected to horrific abuse (I will recommend the movie Brown mentioned; I will NOT recommend the book at all). He made it very clear that he didn't enjoy a single moment of his captivity. The alternative here is the oft-repeated Stockholm scenario (i.e., victim under duress begins to bond with perpetrator, even as far as to later defend him). I'm not convinced this is a case of Stockholm; Mr. Hornbeck has not indicated that he ever liked his abductor.
 
For the zillionth time: who cares what Bill O'Reilly thinks? He's a journalist. Does the fact that he appears on TV somehow makes him an oracle? The same goes, by the way, for other TV personalities.

(By the way, I always disliked the word "personality"--as in "TV personality", "Hollywood personality"--but now I wonder if it isn't the correct word to describe people who are famous for being famous. I mean, O'Reilly's opinion is taken seriously not because he is especially intelligent, or knowledgeable, or an expert in any field, but simply because he says it on TV. What, pray tell, does he actually do or know that makes his opinion worth more than Joe Schmoe's at the local bar?)
 
It's not that simple. Kid's a hundred miles from home, and is isolated from any sort of education, or contact with other adults. "Time passing" does not necessarily make one smarter or bolder all by itself. It's more likely that, after so many months, the kid simply realized that his circumstances weren't going to change, and adapted. There is precedent for this - the aforementioned case of Steven Stayner. He was kept by his kidnapper for 7 years before trying to escape, despite being subjected to horrific abuse (I will recommend the movie Brown mentioned; I will NOT recommend the book at all). He made it very clear that he didn't enjoy a single moment of his captivity. The alternative here is the oft-repeated Stockholm scenario (i.e., victim under duress begins to bond with perpetrator, even as far as to later defend him). I'm not convinced this is a case of Stockholm; Mr. Hornbeck has not indicated that he ever liked his abductor.

Everything you say is plausible. I get it. My point is, OK. this merits discussion, vs. "end of discussion." My other point is, just because O'Reilly chooses a point of view, I can agree with it even if I have mixed feelings about him. My best example is that both Dr. Adequate and Patrick Buchanan have been against the war in Iraq. :p
 
According to NPR, Hornbeck had access to the internet, the telephone, and may have even interacted with a cop during his captivity.

If so, he did have opportunities to escape or to at least cry for help.

Everyone involved is being silent on the matter, and rightly so. Don't want to give the kidnapper an out.

My first thought when the kid was found was the Stockholm Syndrome. I just don't see how it would be possible for someone to keep anyone in captivity for four years with no opportunity for escape presenting itself to the victim.

Stockholm Syndrome or not, whether the kid was a willing participant in his own disappearance or not (I heard he was snatched at gunpoint, though), what O'Reilly and Van Susteren don't get is that it doesn't matter. He was a pre-teen who cannot give consent. Period.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom