Bill O'Reilly weighs in on Shawn

Joined
May 31, 2004
Messages
610
Bill O'Reilly: You know the Stockholm syndrome thing, I don't buy it, I never bought it, I don't think It happened in the Patty Hearst Case. I don't think it happened here...

Greta van Susteren: Woah, Can I just say something?

Bill O'Reilly: Yeah go ahead and jump in.

GVS: First of all we don't know all the facts, Don't forget that Elizabeth Smart likewise had an opportunity to leave and she did not. She was on the public street for some reason when young people are picked up and taken under the influence of adults they are very receptive of what adults do. So I would not dismiss the Stockholm syndrome --

BOR: The difference in the Smart case, and correct me if I am wrong, was this guy was always around the little girl and she wasn't gone for the long period of time as this guy was. Now what we have learned -- and this is why I don't believe in Stockholm -- this guy Shawn Hornbeck gone four years from 11-15. Authorities actually say that he taunted his own parents on his website. He's got these piercing this is a troubled kid in my opinion --

GVS: The piercings, a lot of kids do the piercings. As far as the taunting goes on the website I think what can be established is that someone on this particular login taunted the parents. Was it done from this particular computer? If it was done from this particular computer that means that Michael Devlin did it, or Shawn did it or someone with access to the computer... let's not forget he is a kid.... He may be 15 now...

BOR: No, I am not buying this if you're 11 years old or 12 years old or 13 and you have a strong bond with your family. Even if the guy threatens you this and that. You're riding your bike around, you got friends -- the kid didn't go to school. There's all kinds of stuff, if you can get away, you get away. If you're 11 --

GVS: Bill it seems bizarre to me, I agree it seems bizarre. Why not run, why not yell, why not scream? But the thing I keep going back to is, what was Patti Hearst's story...

BOR: I didn't buy that Patti Hearst story for a second.

GVS: Why was she so willing to sign up with her kidnappers and like wise Elizabeth Smart, she had opportunity -- nice kid, nice family, why was she unwilling to run...?

BOR: Let me answer your question. This is what I believe in the Hearst case and in this case. The situation that Hearst found herself in was exciting. She had a boring life, child of privilege. All of a sudden she's in with a bunch of charismatic thugs and she enjoyed it. The situation here with this kid is looks to me to be a lot more fun then when he had under his own parents. He didn't have to go to school, He could run around and do what he wanted.

GVS: Some kids like school --

BOR: Well I don't believe this kid did. And I think when it all comes down what's going to happen is there was an element here that this kid liked about his circumstances...
 
mr rosewater said:
BOR: Let me answer your question. T

his is what I believe in the Hearst case and in this case. The situation that Hearst found herself in was exciting. She had a boring life, child of privilege. All of a sudden she's in with a bunch of charismatic thugs and she enjoyed it. The situation here with this kid is looks to me to be a lot more fun then when he had under his own parents. He didn't have to go to school, He could run around and do what he wanted.

GVS: Some kids like school --

BOR: Well I don't believe this kid did. And I think when it all comes down what's going to happen is there was an element here that this kid liked about his circumstances...
I don't make it a habit to agree with O'Reilly, as he annoys me, but I think he's looking at this more objectively than Greta Van Stretch Face is.

DR
 
Bill O'Reilly might have been well-advised to review the circumstances of another true kidnapping, with surprising similarities (far more similarities than the other mentioned cases), which was dramatized in the book and movie I Know My First Name Is Steven.
 
I don't make it a habit to agree with O'Reilly, as he annoys me, but I think he's looking at this more objectively than Greta Van Stretch Face is.
I disagree. If you look at the first interjection from GVS, she says "First of all we don't know all the facts". That is the most objective statement in the whole piece.

O'Reilly is asking the question that is puzzling most - Why didn't the kid run before now? - but with his answers to that question, he is talking out of his rectal oriface with no actual facts.
 
It is this type (O'Reilly's type) of analysis that irks me more than most any other.

Why didn't he do such and such? Any reasonable person would have done such and such unless he was in on it or had an ulterior motive or this or that or whatever.

Rubbish. This is the worst kind of egotism.

I know exactly not only what the proper response should be but also exactly how every type of person would respond in every situation.

If you haven't been kidnapped when you're eleven, then you haven't the foggiest idea what an eleven year old would do when kidnapped. And if you have been kidnapped when you're eleven, then you only know what you would do, not what another eleven year old with different upbringing in a different emotional state and different mental faculties in different circumstances would do.

People are not always rational. We strive to lean toward reasonable but reason is not the only force within our brains nor is it always the strongest.

O'Reilly is a self-inflated s*** and demonstrates it once again.
 
I disagree. If you look at the first interjection from GVS, she says "First of all we don't know all the facts". That is the most objective statement in the whole piece.

O'Reilly is asking the question that is puzzling most - Why didn't the kid run before now? - but with his answers to that question, he is talking out of his rectal oriface with no actual facts.
Neither is a fave of mine, but I think Greta is trying to paint as pretty a picture as she can, for reasons of her own I suppose.

Granted her first utterance was as you say, but she did not stick to that line. She, instead played "we don't know all the facts, but . . . " and proceeded to speculate. With two meat puppets speculating, I looked at the flavor of speculation and gave BOR a slight nod.

Then again, I don't think either of them is too troubled with facts. That's why I rarely ever watch Fox News.

DR
 
Neither is a fave of mine, but I think Greta is trying to paint as pretty a picture as she can, for reasons of her own I suppose.

Granted her first utterance was as you say, but she did not stick to that line. She, instead played "we don't know all the facts, but . . . " and proceeded to speculate. With two meat puppets speculating, I looked at the flavor of speculation and gave BOR a slight nod.

Then again, I don't think either of them is too troubled with facts. That's why I rarely ever watch Fox News.

DR
I don't know. I think that BOR is as crazy and dangerous a sh$thead in this case as he is in just about everything else he expounds on. Just read this...

You're riding your bike around, you got friends -- the kid didn't go to school. There's all kinds of stuff, if you can get away, you get away. If you're 11 --
What's his focus? How the kid is getting away with not going to school. You know, BOR used to be a teacher. I feel sorry for any kids who were subjected to his hatred in the classroom.
 
What's his focus? How the kid is getting away with not going to school. You know, BOR used to be a teacher. I feel sorry for any kids who were subjected to his hatred in the classroom.
I am willing to bet his classroom was fun, as he's colorful. I hope he was able to keep his arseholiness in check as a teacher, but maybe he didn't. Maybe it is as you suggest, and best that he is no longer in that arena.

I think it'd be interesting to find a few of his old students and interview them. :)

DR
 
I am willing to bet his classroom was fun, as he's colorful. I hope he was able to keep his arseholiness in check as a teacher, but maybe he didn't. Maybe it is as you suggest, and best that he is no longer in that arena.

I think it'd be interesting to find a few of his old students and interview them. :)

DR

I'll take that bet. I bet he was, as he is now, a first class dl<k, blowing hard over those unfortunate enough to be forced to listen to him. He aptly demonstrates what a hard blower he is in the rant in the OP.

It reminds me of people saying, "I experienced the same situations as that guy with PTSD did and it did not mess me up. Therefore, he is faking it." We are not all the same, and different people are equipped to deal with situations differently. Unless 11 year bill'o was abducted and subjected to the same situation as Shawn???? That just might explain something...?

Daredelvis
 
I'll take that bet. I bet he was, as he is now, a first class dl<k, blowing hard over those unfortunate enough to be forced to listen to him. He aptly demonstrates what a hard blower he is in the rant in the OP.

It reminds me of people saying, "I experienced the same situations as that guy with PTSD did and it did not mess me up. Therefore, he is faking it." We are not all the same, and different people are equipped to deal with situations differently. Unless 11 year bill'o was abducted and subjected to the same situation as Shawn???? That just might explain something...?

Daredelvis
Whatever BOR ever was, he is most certainly a world class prick now.

DR
 
It is this type (O'Reilly's type) of analysis that irks me more than most any other.

Why didn't he do such and such? Any reasonable person would have done such and such unless he was in on it or had an ulterior motive or this or that or whatever.

Rubbish. This is the worst kind of egotism.

I know exactly not only what the proper response should be but also exactly how every type of person would respond in every situation.

If you haven't been kidnapped when you're eleven, then you haven't the foggiest idea what an eleven year old would do when kidnapped. And if you have been kidnapped when you're eleven, then you only know what you would do, not what another eleven year old with different upbringing in a different emotional state and different mental faculties in different circumstances would do.

People are not always rational. We strive to lean toward reasonable but reason is not the only force within our brains nor is it always the strongest.



O'Reilly is a self-inflated s*** and demonstrates it once again.
May I then assume that he blows himself?!:jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp
 
I am willing to bet his classroom was fun, as he's colorful. I hope he was able to keep his arseholiness in check as a teacher, but maybe he didn't. Maybe it is as you suggest, and best that he is no longer in that arena.

I think it'd be interesting to find a few of his old students and interview them. :)

DR


I had a teacher once who was "colourful" in the same brash, loudmouthed way that Bill O'Reilly is. He loved to belittle students, announcing test scores in front of the whole class, telling students that their results were "shameful" and "pathetic". His classes were not fun. However, of course, I do not know Mr. O'Reilly personally, so this is speculation on my part, and perhaps the comparison is not apt. I'm judging by his on-screen persona. It could be that Mr.O'Reilly is a gifted teacher and was well-liked by his students. If that is the case, then I apologise.
 
I heard BOR on the radio tonight. He replayed the whole thing. He read about a dozen emails from listeners who told him he was as big a jerk as you all are stating here. He said they ran ten to one against him. OK. He's egotistical and makes too much money, but I thought he had balls to admit that his position, which he stands by, was unpopular. He showed fairness by taking, and sharing all the heat he was getting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom