I'm sorry if this post's rubbish. I wrote it in my sleep. ... Or was I just half asleep?
Ocelot said:
I'm referring to every verse in the bible which takes a stand against homosexuality or fornication. Homosexual sex is fornication: sex outside of marriage.
Surely that's indisputable given the bibles stance on marriage as a covenant between a man and a woman.
If you challenge me to come up with verses to support this I'm sure I'll be able to. What should my target be ten from each testament for a total of 20. Would that convince you that the bible is consistently against homosexuality?
No. Certainly there aren't that many about homosexuality specifically. The few that exist in the Old Testament are obviously about sex, not homosexuality itself. There are a few ambiguous ones in the New Testament that some people have taken to be condemnations of homosexuality, but others have argued meant things more akin to male prostitution and abuse of boys. For instance, in this article:
Greek Culture and Homosexuality.
The famous passage in Romans chapter 1 about homosexual sex seems to be in the context of idolatry.
So the biblical take on a consenting monogamous long-term committed gay relationship isn't clear-cut.
But even people who don't know about any cultural context there might have been to the verses but are familiar with the Bible itself will know that the Bible doesn't mention homosexuality anywhere near as much as it does other things like wealth inequality. I don't know if Fred Phelps ever says anything about that.
Ocelot said:
As for the story of Sodom and Gomorrah I will point out that it wasn't everyone in the city. It was all the men. If this was the crime for which Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed then pity all the innocent women of Sodom and all the innocent people of Gomorrah. Of course it wasn't this crime for which Sodom and Gomorrah were punished. God revealed his intentions to Abraham and Sarah before this happened, if anything the men of Sodom provided the "last straw" so to speak.
There's a Bible verse purporting to explain why Sodom was destroyed, which says:
Ezekiel chapter 16 (NLT)
1 Then another message came to me from the LORD: ...
49 Sodom's sins were pride, laziness, and gluttony, while the poor and needy suffered outside her door. 50 She was proud and did loathsome things, so I wiped her out, as you have seen.
Other translations use phrases like "prosperous ease" that emphasise their alleged lack of concern for the poor.
Ocelot said:
We do know from that earlier meeting that God would have spared Sodom if he found 30 righteous people there. Of course we also know from elsewhere how little it takes to fall away from righteousness in gods eyes. You don't have to be a rapist, a harmless liaison with Mrs Palm and her five lovely daughters is enough and in the eponymous case such Onanism is a capital offense - another counter example where God bypassed the warning stage and went straight
for the terminate-with-extreme-prejudice option.
Yes, in the case of Onan, the Bible makes no mention that he was warned. But it doesn't say he was killed for coitus interruptus but for refusing to give his wife children, which could have led to his and her destitution in their old age, in the days when there was no welfare state to support people who could no longer work. The offence would have been understood to have a serious connotation in those days that it just wouldn't have now.
The Bible doesn't mention masturbation. The closest it comes is the vague-but-probably-lost-something-in-translation wordd "impurity". It seems to imply any behaviour that makes you more likely to fornicate. Where masturbation leads to fantasies that make one more likely to commit fornication under temptation, it's covered by the term. Given that people would be fornicating with some knowledge of the risks, you can't blame the Bible for not smiling on such people.
Ocelot from previous post said:
1) Accept that god hates homosexuals and all forms of fornication with a passion ...
Sure there may be other parts of the bible that have a different focus but don't kid yourself that the new testament is free from strictures against fornication.
It isn't. But the Bible doesn't say God hates homosexuals, and the Bible can't be faulted for warning against fornication. It wasn't just an abstract thing. The Bible's moral commands tend to be about cutting down risks to the community and individuals. People would be safeguarded by obeying its prohibitions of fornication. Here are some examples that illustrate risks they'd avoid:
Here's an article on maternal death rates. Obviously they'd be high for married women also, but throughout much of the world today and throughout history, fornication increased the risk.
Here's an article on how sexually active teenagers are at greater risk for certain problems.
Here's an article on
A Hierarchy of Risks (of anal sex) Warning: It's quite graphic.
And here are more articles that illustrate the risks increased by fornication:
Neglected Heart: The Emotional Dangers of Premature Sexual Involvement.
Failure Rates of Contraceptives.
Sexually Transmitted Infections.
Condoms - A quick overview of condoms, their effectiveness, and issues around their uses.
Adolescents—At Risk for Sexually Transmitted Infections.
Stories of girls’ upset over having an abortion.
Post Abortion: Regrets of Women Who Had an Abortion.
Research on grief reactions to abortion.
Losing Our Promiscuity (an article on regrets of people who think they started having sex too early).
Psychological and practical reasons why it’s not such a good idea to get sexually involved too soon.
Surviving An Affair.
Relate - Coping with Affairs.
Infidelity: The Lessons Children Learn.
If Fred Phelps actually cared about the risks though, he'd be trying to publicize them, not focusing on people rather than risks and just condemning them.
Ocelot said:
Worshiping other gods doesn't harm anyone but that's one of the big no-nos.
Ocelot said:
That's weak, (referring to my stated reasons as to why the worship of other gods in Bible times was in fact harmful so it's understandable that it was condemned harshly) there's already provision for punishing murder, we know how God treats idolaters even in the New Testament it's the saem whetehr they sacrifice virgins or dance naked round a mulberry bush on a full moon. "But the cowardly, the unbelieving, the vile, the murderers, the sexually immoral, those who practice magic arts, the idolaters and all liars-- their place will be in the fiery lake of burning sulphur. This is the second death." (Revelation 21:8)
Idolatry was also sometimes taken to mean anything that took the place of a relationship with God. So greed was referred to as idolatry in Colossians 3:
Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)
5 Don't be greedy for the good things of this life, for that is idolatry.
The implication in what you say seems to be that there isn't any need for the worship of other gods in itself to be prohibited. One key issue is that abandoning the worship of God wouldn't have simply been something abstract, but may have involved turning from Bible commands about behaviour that promoted communal well-being. You can see that in the numerous rants of the prophets, who condemned the people for breaches of the Law of Moses and basic decency by doing such things as exploiting the poor because of their greed, who then said that God was saying,
"Come back to me", the implication being that doing so would improve their behaviour. A couple of cases in point:
Hosea chapter 14 (NIV)
1 Return, O Israel, to the LORD your God. Your sins have been your downfall!
Jeremiah chapter 8 (CEV)
4 The LORD said: People of Jerusalem, when you stumble and fall, you get back up, and if you take a wrong road, you turn around and go back.
5 So why do you refuse to come back to me? Why do you hold so tightly to your false gods? 6 I listen carefully, but none of you admit that you've done wrong. 8 You say, "We are wise because we have the teachings and laws of the LORD." But I say that your teachers have turned my words into lies! 9 Your wise men have rejected what I say, and so they have no wisdom.
10 Everyone is greedy and dishonest, whether poor or rich. Even the prophets and priests cannot be trusted. 11 All they ever offer to my deeply wounded people are empty hopes for peace. 12 They should be ashamed of their disgusting sins, but they don't even blush.
In fact, it was taken as a given that if you believed in a god, you would try to do what it wanted. Belief wasn't considered to be something separate from action, but it was thought that true belief would naturally involve action. So when the Bible mentions the worship of other gods, it isn't talking about thought crime. Worship is an act of submission to a god. If temple prostitution, consultation with scammers (in the form of mediums), child sacrifice and other things are a traditional part of the worship of the gods in the culture all around you, it wouldn't make sense for anyone to be commanded, "You may worship other gods, as long as you don't actually do any of the things it's traditional to sometimes do in the worship of those gods." Instead, the Bible warned harshly against worshiping them partly
because of what they might do if they did:
Deuteronomy chapter 12 (TEV)
30 After the Lord destroys those nations, make sure that you don't follow their religious practices, because that would be fatal. Don't try to find out how they worship their gods, so that you can worship in the same way. 31 Do not worship the Lord your God in the way they worship their gods, for in the worship of their gods they do all the disgusting things that the Lord hates. They even sacrifice their children in the fires on their altars.
It seems one has to make a value-judgment with insufficient evidence in deciding whether destroying those nations was like the proverbial cure being much worse than the disease. :-7 But
this article points out that most similar verses are about "driving the people out of the land" rather than killing them, arguing that one goal seems to have been disrupting their harmful worship practices by destroying the worship centres.
As for the verse in Revelation you quote, I suppose it's possible for biblical literalists to interpret that as meaning that just atheism in itself could lead to a very nasty end for some. But to focus on that, they'd have to be ignoring the vast majority of New Testament scriptures that have a positive feel, a focus on encouraging others to join in a movement which aimed to make life better.
I quote lots of verses in this post, from about paragraph 6 onwards. (Paragraphs 1-5 are only tiny, so there won't be much to skip.)

But more than that, it's possible to read the entire New Testament, apart from Revelation, and not find many passages that would suggest people's focus should be on wrath and condemnation.
As for that hell verse in Revelation, perhaps you're right that if people are confronted with such things and asked if they really believe them, it might make them think about their beliefs more and eventually become more compassionate in their attitudes. There are interpretations of verses like that that throw a completely different light on them, such as the ones explained in this article:
Is It All Greek to You? It argues that the original Greek meanings of the words hell, destruction and punishment in the New Testament indicate that hell is not eternal and is in fact a corrective experience that leads to repentance so it will make people eventually fit for heaven. It argues that the fire is metaphorical, symbolising incisive purification. Others have different takes on the passages.
This has no bearing on biblical literalism, because the article argues that the words themselves have been translated in a way that was never intended. The issue is whether it's correct.
Ocelot said:
And don't make me mention that whole Jephthah affair or other human sacrifices Yaweh ordered or accepted in the OT.
But nowhere in the Bible does it say God wanted or accepted Jephthah's sacrifice of his daughter. I think some people make the mistake of thinking that just because the Bible says something happened, it must have been something God was said to have approved of. The Bible makes no comment on the reception Jephthah's action might have got in heavenly places, but simply says it happened. It does suggest he wasn't a particularly scholarly chappy. Anyone who was one would have known not to sacrifice their child, because of the stern way such things are prohibited in the Law of Moses, for instance in the Deuteronomy passage I quoted just now.
As for the Abraham/Isaac thing, God can be charged with deceiving Abraham, but it's clear that it was never intended to be a real human sacrifice, or it would have gone ahead.
Ocelot quoting from Religioustolerance said:
Blessed is he who preferreth his brother before himself." Baha'u'llah
"In happiness and suffering, in joy and grief, we should regard all creatures as we regard our own self." Lord Mahavira, 24th Tirthankara
Roman Pagan Religion: "The law imprinted on the hearts of all men is to love the members of society as themselves." ...
It's nice to know followers of other religions had nice things to say. I was thinking of the phraseology the Golden Rule actually used. But I could be wrong. It's unfortunate that more Romans didn't know about and feel obliged to live up to the ideal of "Roman Pagan religion" mentioned.
Very unloving! Still, you could say that about the members of any religion.
Ocelot said:
Obviously I'll have to withdraw my suggestion that there's no biblical support for the God of the OT preferring to change people's ways than punish them. (Sometimes at least)
I forgot to mention the most classic example of all - the Book of Jonah.
Ocelot said:
However do you note a theme in how he goes about convincing people? ...
I agree that the punishments prescribed in the Bible are horrific and non-discriminatory, and grossly unimaginative. God comes across as very cruel in some places. In fact, the only thing that makes them seem anything less than barbaric is
reading things like this about human cruelty. The page is full of modern-day examples of the kinds of things Old Testament prophets condemned. Reading that for a while makes God's punishments seem justified. It's the same phenomenon as when police start to think there must be criminal activity everywhere after they've dealt with it for a while. But the Old Testament prophets give the impression they thought it was like that as well. If so, harsh punishments would seem more understandable. Where Fred Phelps goes wrong and goes far beyond the Bible is where he imagines that such harsh punishments would be meted out for much much less provocation. There isn't a contradiction in the behaviour of the God of the Bible, because it depends on the degree of provocation, and also, it's been argued, on the types of people who were supposed to be learning the lesson. See
Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development.