Bigoted church members protest outside NYC Synagogue

Fair enough. You can lead a horse to water...

Get off your high horse.

Parky has nothing to apologise for. However, 'I invite you to think a little more deeply' on why you ought to apologise to him for your very unsubtle attempt to imply that he was homophobic.

I'd use the fine old Australian expression 'Jeez Louise' but then you'd probably get offended by that too.
 
Last edited:
Get off your high horse.

Parky has nothing to apologise for. However, 'I invite you to think a little more deeply' on why you ought to apologise to him for your very unsubtle attempt to imply that he was homophobic.

I'd use the fine old Australian expression 'Jeez Louise' but then you'd probably get offended by that too.


I'm of Jewish extraction and generally find anti-semitic behaviour repulsive, but I found Parky's comments just a little south of tolerable, to be honest.

"Hey, I think they're just a bunch of stupid morons when they insult other minorities, but by cracky when they insult my kin, them's fightin' words."

I think Terry's absolutely right to point out the inconsistency in the two stances. If Phelps protests at the funeral of "little people" with signs that say "God Hates Midgets", I guess that'd be funny, too? But we'll all get real mad when he protests at Randi's funeral saying "God Hates Atheists"? I guess some minorities are just funnier than others.

Apparently that high horse is a two-seater, as Terry's posts are not in the least bit insinuating that Parky's being homophobic.

(Now Terry cross-posts and calls him a homophobe to make me look stupid, right? :spjimlad::spjimlad: )
 
Apparently that high horse is a two-seater, as Terry's posts are not in the least bit insinuating that Parky's being homophobic.

I found the insinuation to be contained in these two posts:

So it's fine to hate fags, but not to hate jews? How come?

I invite you to think a little more deeply on why that may be.

Its pretty clear to me that Parky was not suggesting that it is fine or funny to hate fags.

Parky finds those people silly and stupid when they are campaigning against gays. That is fine and that is my reaction too.

On the other hand, when they campaign against Jews he gets violently angry because he has a personal stake in the issue. That is also a natural reaction but not one I share. I find them silly and stupid no matter who they are campaigning against. Does this make me a homophobic anti-semite?

Terry's problem is apparently with Parky not reacting equally to every form of bigotry; that is just silly and stupid unless Terry reacts equally vehemently towards any and every form of bigotry.
 
I found the insinuation to be contained in these two posts:
And I think, knowing Terry's posts, that he was picking holes in the logic of Parky's treatment of the topic. I can't speak for Terry, so I'll just leave it at that - it's my impression.

Its pretty clear to me that Parky was not suggesting that it is fine or funny to hate fags.

He wasn't saying it was fine, but he most assuredly was saying he found it funny. I mean, HE SAID SO, din't he?

Parky finds those people silly and stupid when they are campaigning against gays. That is fine and that is my reaction too.

On the other hand, when they campaign against Jews he gets violently angry because he has a personal stake in the issue. That is also a natural reaction but not one I share. I find them silly and stupid no matter who they are campaigning against. Does this make me a homophobic anti-semite?
No, your position is consistent if you think that derision is the best reaction to everything they do and every group they single out.

Parky didn't say that, though. Parky said it was funny when they singled out Gays and angering when they single out Jews. Because he's the latter and not the former (I assume - "not that there's anything wrong with that").

Doesn't the old "First they came for the - - - - " ring a bell, here?


Terry's problem is apparently with Parky not reacting equally to every form of bigotry; that is just silly and stupid unless Terry reacts equally vehemently towards any and every form of bigotry.

Again, ask Terry, as I don't presume to speak for him, but my point is that it's important to do just that. Which of the following would you find funny? (Not the statment itself, but the whole package of Phelps and his inbred miscreant followers waving signs and trying to rile people up.)

"God hates N*****s"
"God hates Fags"
"God hates K***s"
"God hates Midgets"
"God hates Atheists"
"God hates Women"


If you can answer "All" - I got not problems. If you find any one more offensive than the others, I might ask why. If, like me, you find none of them funny - I got no problems there, either.
 
If I had been told in advance I may have done the beating.

I have run into this group in NYC before but before I knew who they were.

Anyone heard the joke about the paramedic working tirelessly in unswerving dedication to saving the life of ... the person he's just beaten up?

If a group came to New York and stood on one of the main streets holding banners that said, "God hates new Yorkers", would that be violence-worthy, funny, or somewhere in between?

And what if you helped to beat those people to the ground, and then, looking up, you saw people holding placards behind them that said, "God hates violence". Would you beat those up too while you were at it, or would you stop and think, "Ah. ... Whoops!"

:)
 
And I think, knowing Terry's posts, that he was picking holes in the logic of Parky's treatment of the topic. I can't speak for Terry, so I'll just leave it at that - it's my impression.

We obviously have different impressions, I formed my impression on what Terry wrote and what he has written in the past.

He wasn't saying it was fine, but he most assuredly was saying he found it funny. I mean, HE SAID SO, din't he?

There is a difference between finding those people silly and stupid and finding homophobia funny.


No, your position is consistent if you think that derision is the best reaction to everything they do and every group they single out.

I think so but I don't think Parky's position is particularly inconsistent.

Parky didn't say that, though. Parky said it was funny when they singled out Gays and angering when they single out Jews. Because he's the latter and not the former (I assume - "not that there's anything wrong with that").

No. He was saying that he can laugh off their attacks on Gays because they are so silly and stupid (which I think they are) but he can't laugh off their attacks on Jews because he happens to be Jewish. It may be a failing of Parky's for several reasons but it doesn't make him homophobic any more than it would make Terry an anti-semite if he has a stronger reaction to their signs about Gays.


Doesn't the old "First they came for the - - - - " ring a bell, here?

I think that is over-dramatising these idiots.



Again, ask Terry, as I don't presume to speak for him, but my point is that it's important to do just that. Which of the following would you find funny? (Not the statment itself, but the whole package of Phelps and his inbred miscreant followers waving signs and trying to rile people up.)

"God hates N*****s"
"God hates Fags"
"God hates K***s"
"God hates Midgets"
"God hates Atheists"
"God hates Women"


If you can answer "All" - I got not problems. If you find any one more offensive than the others, I might ask why. If, like me, you find none of them funny - I got no problems there, either.

I think he is a figure of derision no matter what sign he is holding up (he hates me as well not to mention the entire world). I don't find the hatred of any of those groups funny but I find these guys silly and stupid.

Does Terry get as steamed up by watching the God Hates Australia video as he does hearing about the God Hates Fags signs?
 
Last edited:
Say, now that the Phelps' are doing international tours, isn't it time the went to nice Jewish settlement in Israel/Palestine and did the "God hates Jews" thing?

Would they drop the signs as they fled the volleys of small arms fire? Or would they try to use it as shields?

And why doesn't God hate blacks? That sounds like a real winner in South Central, LA.
 
Terry's problem is apparently with Parky not reacting equally to every form of bigotry; that is just silly and stupid unless Terry reacts equally vehemently towards any and every form of bigotry.
I react equally vehemently towards any and every form of bigotry. The phrase "God hates Jews" makes me just as mad as "God hates Fags", even though I am neither Jewish nor a fag. Actually I am closer to being the latter, but that's another story.

Bigotry is bigotry. Phelps is a dick. Let's just leave it at that.
 
I react equally vehemently towards any and every form of bigotry. The phrase "God hates Jews" makes me just as mad as "God hates Fags", even though I am neither Jewish nor a fag. Actually I am closer to being the latter, but that's another story.

Bigotry is bigotry. Phelps is a dick. Let's just leave it at that.

I have no problem with that.
 
I hadn't heard before that the Phelps gang were anti-semitic.

Not terribly surprised, of course. This just seems to be a new tack for them, even if it is technically just more of the same.
 
Oh geeze... I just had a thought... the residents of the Westboro insane asylum have sunk as low as they can possibly get without resorting to violence.

Someone tell me that law enforcement has these people under surveillance?
 
The Phelps gang is not just anti-semitic. They hate everyone and everything. They are catholic in their hatred. Their latest website says God Hates the World (won't link).

And it is true, they have never resorted to physical violence - their protests are always peaceful (if bigoted and hateful - you could call that a form of violence if you like). I'm sure all the relevant authorities are aware of them, but the problem is that Fred Phelps is also a very accomplished lawyer, and his children have followed his example. He does exactly what he is permitted to do under the law, always skirting on the legal side. And even if he did put a toe over the line he'd probably be able to successfully defend.

He's a hateful, bigoted dick, but he is not a lawbreaker.
 
There is a case to be made for "God Hates People" as judged by its actions in the Bible.*

* if one were of the bible believing persuasion, of course.
 
Oh geeze... I just had a thought... the residents of the Westboro insane asylum have sunk as low as they can possibly get without resorting to violence.

Someone tell me that law enforcement has these people under surveillance?

I don't think that's what they're up to. I think, at best (best is hard word to put in a paragraph about Westboro Baptist, I realize) they're hoping to get martyred - that someone will lose it entirely and off one of them. Actually, I doubt that Fred's ready to meet his maker just yet. But I bet dollars to donuts he'd happily see one of his flock get snuffed for the attention he'd get out of it. (Yes, I think he's that evil.)

And never assume with this crew that they've sunk as low as they can go. They will plumb new depths given the opportunity. I frankly wouldn't put it past them to picket the funeral of the next prominent black leader who dies with "God Hates Blacks". They are just dying (maybe literally so) to get the crap beat out of themselves on camera so they can ply the courts and the national media with their sickness.
 
To be honest, I don't see Parky saying that either sound is ok. He did say the "God hates fags" ones were stupid, and I can't disagree with that.

In effect, both are stupid, way i see it, and both are bigotted, and both are not ok. He's just personally more insulted by one than the other. I find that to be just, well, being a human. We're all insulted by one thing more than another thing.

E.g., I can tell you that if anyone held a "God hates nerds" sign... well, if I had the physique to beat them up I wouldn't be a nerd, but I'd give them a thorough bashing in a blog or such ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom