Bigoted church members protest outside NYC Synagogue

Every time a reporter reports on Phelps, he gets what he wanted: attention.

I disagree. The man is in terror of being discussed on thousands of blogs around the world. If he realised that we were all talking about him, he'd be ashamed and embarassed.

If we really want to stop Phelps, we need to be constantly talking about what a jerk he is, and showing five minute clips at the end of the news. It hasn't quite worked yet, but if we can generate another few thousand posts I'm sure he'll retire.
 
I disagree. The man is in terror of being discussed on thousands of blogs around the world. If he realised that we were all talking about him, he'd be ashamed and embarassed.

If we really want to stop Phelps, we need to be constantly talking about what a jerk he is, and showing five minute clips at the end of the news. It hasn't quite worked yet, but if we can generate another few thousand posts I'm sure he'll retire.

Is there any evidence that Phelps lives in anything anywhere near approaching "terror"?

On the face of it, I don't see how what you say could be true. He must have been fully aware he'd get a bad reaction when he started picketing funerals. How could he possibly have thought he'd get away with it without bad publicity? There are some people who have no shame. It's possible he could fit the profile of a psychopath or subclinical psychopath. If so, he'd have the personality type of someone who didn't feel shame and wasn't about to blame himself for anything he did.

From Sociopaths and Psychopaths: Have you no shame?

Early experts in psychopathy documented that the absence of shame is part of the disorder. According to Dr. Cleckley, author of The Mask of Sanity, psychopaths are incapable of feeling shame. Because they do not feel shame, they blame everyone else for their problems. “The psychopath apparently cannot accept substantial
blame for the various misfortunes which befall him and which he brings down upon others,” Cleckley says. “Whether judged in the light of his conduct, of his attitude, or of material elicited in psychiatric examination, he [the psychopath] shows almost no sense of shame.“

More recent researchers also recognize the fact that psychopaths accept no personal blame. Item 16 on the “gold-standard” psychopathy measure, the Hare Psychopathy Checklist–Revised (PCL–R), assesses a failure to accept responsibility for actions. Item 16 of the PCL–R identifies “an individual who is unable or unwilling to accept personal responsibility for his own actions (both criminal and non-criminal) or for the consequences of his actions.” Instead of
accepting responsibility for his/her actions, the psychopath produces “some excuse for his/her behavior, including rationalizing and placing the blame on others” (Hare, 2003).

If Phelps fits the profile, he could easily attribute the bad publicity to "fag-lovers" and say it's proof of the degeneracy of humanity, and even think it's proof his flock need to campaign harder.

There's evidence he does in fact have psychopathic traits. See Phelps' son speaks out

Nate Phelps, the estranged son of Fred Phelps, said the church's protests at the funerals of American soldiers killed in Iraq had driven him to speak out about his father's actions. Nate Phelps said he left home for good in 1980 after a terror-filled childhood in which Fred Phelps beat him and his siblings during outbursts of violence. ...

Nate Phelps' allegations about violent behavior by Fred Phelps aren't new. In a 1994 story in The Topeka Capital-Journal, he and his brother Mark Phelps said they and their siblings grew up in a violent household in which they were frequently beaten by their father. Mark Phelps, who also cut ties with Fred Phelps, said he used to beat his own siblings under orders from his father.
 
Oh blimey! I've just looked at the article Parky linked to! Contrast the first few posts in this thread with this:

Congregation Counters Hate Protest With Message Of Peace

... A half dozen members of the Westboro Baptist Church brought their protest to the streets of the West Village. They demonstrated at The Congregation Beth Simchat Torah -- a temple known to be accepting of gay congregants. ...

But a much larger group of temple members and their supporters came outside, singing songs about love. ...

"I bring my son here because I think it's important for him to see that in the face of this type of messages of hate that you need to confront it and show them love," said one member of The Congregation Beth Simchat Torah.

Unfortunately, one congregant ruined what could have been an inspirational article by saying,

" "I am going to say they should go back to the rock they crawled out of, and the rabbi asked us not to say anything more provocative than that," said one member of The Congregation Beth Simchat Torah."

:D

http://www.ny1.com/content/top_stor...te-protest-with-message-of-peace/Default.aspx

they held signs saying "God hates Fags" and "God hates Jews".

oh man do I pray they come back again. I'd have a few words and a few gallons of spit to give to them.

************

boy this makes me mad. to come to New York City, and hold up a sign saying "God hates Jews". They really deserve to get beaten.

=(
 
The Westboro Baptist Church is a "church" made up of extended family members led by a hate filled and hateful old man based in Kansas(of all places). They don't just target synagogues, they also target schools, and they protest military funerals. I don't think the regular Baptist denomination recognizes them at all(in spite of the fact that they use Baptist as part of their title). These folks are just a splinter-group of zealots with their own extreme interpretation of God and the Bible. These people are on a "watch-list" by the Jewish Defamation League, and other watch dog organizations formed against hate-mongers. At least this was the case last time I checked.
 
Fred Phelps is the best recruiting sergeant the atheist movement have ever had. Were the WBC a false flag operation intended to highlight the sickening truth about the wrathful jealous God of the Old Testament I can't see how it could be more effective. Where Landover Baptist church fails is in it's comedy. True believers can laugh it up and laugh it off without ever addressing the issues. The WBC operates in a different genre - horror. Horror cuts much deeper, it keeps you awake at night, more so if you don't have the comforting reassurance that it's all special effects and actors. The Westborough Baptist Church is apparently very real.

I'd love to know how many fundamentalists have questioned their own literal interpretation of the bible simply because of Pastor Phelps' wicked genius in exposing the less palatable side of the so called Good Book. He may be a twisted closeted basket case but you can't fault his command of scripture. He doesn't have to torture his meanings out of the text. It all right there: hatred of sexual variation: collective punishment and genocide. Yaweh is every bit as hateful and bigoted a his loyal mimic Fred Phelps.

Really and truly what did Sodom and Gommoragh do that western democracy hasn't equalled? If you truly believe the bible and believe in a consistent God then he will have no qualms in killing everyone for sins no greater than taking a backwards glace as you flee his wrath.

I don't believe that. I perceive bible literalists being evangelically opposed to science and determined to retard the progress of human enlightenment. I'd love to oppose them on rational and logical grounds but such things don't cut any ice against deeply entrenched faith. However Phelpsy baby makes a fantastically convincing argument to consequences and all he wants in return is publicity. I say give it to him.

I want him to try to spread his hateful message. It's a horrific message, people recoil from it. He's not getting any takers. When family Phelps is in town, you see right wing patriots in outspoken opposition to homophobia. I find that a beautiful sight.

I want to see a camera crew at every WBC protest; I want advance notice in every newspaper. I want more lawsuits reported in detail. I want the news reports to move from the two minute filler slot to the half hour special. I want every last American to know about Fred Phelps and I want him and his message of hate to be the first thing they associate with bible literalism.

It may not be a logical or rational approach, it may have a moral cost in the upset and distress caused to families whose funerals are picketed but if it does hamper the growth of Christian fundamentalism in the USA, that may well be a price worth paying. Sometimes the ends do justify the means.
 
I don't understand that post. Are there people in America who think it's right and good that someone should have been turned into a pillar of salt just for looking behind them? If so, why are they going to be shocked by what Phelps is doing? If on the other hand they think Phelps goes beyond what the Bible teaches, why are they going to be put off the Bible by what he does?

And it isn't true that Phelps' scriptural understanding can't be faulted. Even the most literal understanding of the Old Testament and a complete disregard of the New wouldn't lead anyone to believe that homosexuals are at the root of all evil. Homosexual activity is only mentioned a couple of times, which is a minute proportion of the number of times things like poverty are condemned. And scripture doesn't teach that God hates everyone, but that he gets extremely angry with any behaviour that's hurtful to others, so much so that he wants to ... hurt ... well, the perpetrators, and ... God help the collateral damage. But it teaches that he'd much rather people turn from their hurtful ways. Does Phelps ever teach that?
 
I don't understand that post. Are there people in America who think it's right and good that someone should have been turned into a pillar of salt just for looking behind them? If so, why are they going to be shocked by what Phelps is doing? If on the other hand they think Phelps goes beyond what the Bible teaches, why are they going to be put off the Bible by what he does?

And it isn't true that Phelps' scriptural understanding can't be faulted. Even the most literal understanding of the Old Testament and a complete disregard of the New wouldn't lead anyone to believe that homosexuals are at the root of all evil. Homosexual activity is only mentioned a couple of times, which is a minute proportion of the number of times things like poverty are condemned. And scripture doesn't teach that God hates everyone, but that he gets extremely angry with any behaviour that's hurtful to others, so much so that he wants to ... hurt ... well, the perpetrators, and ... God help the collateral damage. But it teaches that he'd much rather people turn from their hurtful ways. Does Phelps ever teach that?

That was your 1000 post...

I belive that there are bible literalists in the USA, people who believe in a literal interpretaion of the creation account in Genesis etc. I must admit that from here in the UK my impression of them is coloured by hearsay and the fickle selctions of the spotlight. I guess you'd have to ask them how they square a literal interpretation of the bible with a God who creates such suffering, though I suspect "mysterious ways" might come into it.

I didn't use the phrase "scriptuaral understanding" I said "command of scripture." He knows the book inside out from what I've seen and can cite passages by heart to support his contentions. That's what I mean. Whereas these citations are irrelavent in argument with atheists and agnostic and the moderate can shy away from a literal interpretaion the fundamentalist has only two options.

1) Accept that god hates homosexuals and all forms of fornication with a passion and has a past history of genocide entirely in keeping with causing the deaths of soldiers fighting for a nation which has turned its back on the prohibition of sexual wickedness.

2) Reject a literal interpretation.

Sure there may be other parts of the bible that have a different focus but don't kid yourself that the new testament is free from strictures against fornication.

Having read the bible a few times I'm not sure where you get the idea that the main things God objects to are hurting other people. Sure the golden rule is there. "Do unto others..." Why wouldn't it be - it's been in pretty much every religion and ethical philosophy since the beginning of history. That's one of the things god objects to. Just as much prominence however is given to unconditional love of God as to loving neighbours. It's the old faith vs works thing. Worshiping other gods doesn't harm anyone but that's one of the big no-nos. Even if you are worshipping the correct god you can come a cropper by doing it the wrong way, making the wrong sacrifice. That doens't harm anyone but it can still land you in smiting teritory if the bible is to be believed.

Perhaps more dubious is the suggestion that God prefers to divert people from their wicked ways than punish them. It may be true but we're not talking about any individual conception of how God might be or even should be but what the Bible says he is. As such I can't find any reference from the bible which supports that contention. What I can find is a passage which suggests the exact opposite. Exodus 7:1 explains why Pharoh didn't relent in the face of all these plagues. Was it because God prefered to divert pharoh from his wicked course of action than punish the egyptians for holding his chosen people in bondage or dig God actively stop pharoh from relenting by hardening his heart?

Exodus 7:3

And I will harden Pharaoh's heart, and multiply my signs and my wonders in the land of Egypt.
 
Maybe I'm a bad person for thinking this, but I think "God Hates Midgets" would be a hysterical spoof website.
 
Maybe I'm a bad person for thinking this, but I think "God Hates Midgets" would be a hysterical spoof website.

There are already spoof websites, including God Hates Shrimp.

Ocelot said:
the fundamentalist has only two options.

1) Accept that god hates homosexuals and all forms of fornication with a passion and has a past history of genocide entirely in keeping with causing the deaths of soldiers fighting for a nation which has turned its back on the prohibition of sexual wickedness.

I'm not sure what you mean by that. If you're thinking of the Sodom story, the story appears to be about a whole town clamouring to commit gang rape against a couple of males. I'd say such "sexual wickedness" invites punishment. :-7 I've heard there are people who somehow take the Sodom story to be about ordinary homosexual relations. I don't know how they can do that. Anyone who does is not a Bible literalist but a distorter of scripture. That goes for Fred Phelps if he does that.

If you're referring to Canaan, there's more to that story as well. Want to hear it? :-7

Ocelot said:
Worshiping other gods doesn't harm anyone but that's one of the big no-nos.

Not actually the case. The Bible itself mentions the kinds of things people of those days did in the worship of other gods. Some people in Pagan cultures today still do the kinds of things some of those cultures used to do in the old days. Here’s some info:

Human Sacrifice (Britannica Concise Encyclopedia).
Human Sacrifice to Appease Gods Continues in Nigeria, (First published by The News, Lagos, May 2002).
Servants of God (BBC News, Jun 2002).
Human Rights for the "Children of God" (WCAR, Sept 2001).
Idolatry in the Ancient Near East.
Baal.

Ocelot said:
Sure the golden rule is there. "Do unto others..." Why wouldn't it be - it's been in pretty much every religion and ethical philosophy since the beginning of history.

Actually I think the focus of most is on prohibiting the negative rather than encouraging the positive - i.e. Don't do to others what you wouldn't want done to you. The Golden Rule takes it further.

Ocelot said:
Having read the bible a few times I'm not sure where you get the idea that the main things God objects to are hurting other people.

I'll show you. I get that impression from the many verses I quote in that post and more. You can ignore all the stuff at the beginning of the post. If you use your browser's search function to find the word Amos you'll find the beginning of the verses I'm talking about. It would be interesting if someone were to challenge Fred Phelps on whether he actually knows those, and if he does, how he accounts for his obsessive and disproportionate focus on homosexuality.

Ocelot said:
Perhaps more dubious is the suggestion that God prefers to divert people from their wicked ways than punish them. It may be true but we're not talking about any individual conception of how God might be or even should be but what the Bible says he is. As such I can't find any reference from the bible which supports that contention.

I can find several. For instance:

Jeremiah chapter 26 (NIV)

1 Early in the reign of Jehoiakim son of Josiah king of Judah, this word came from the LORD :
2 "This is what the LORD says: Stand in the courtyard of the LORD's house and speak to all the people of the towns of Judah who come to worship in the house of the LORD . Tell them everything I command you; do not omit a word. 3 Perhaps they will listen and each will turn from his evil way. Then I will relent and not bring on them the disaster I was planning because of the evil they have done.

12 Then Jeremiah said to all the officials and all the people: "The LORD sent me to prophesy against this house and this city all the things you have heard.
13 Now reform your ways and your actions and obey the LORD your God. Then the LORD will relent and not bring the disaster he has pronounced against you.

16 Then the officials and all the people said to the priests and the prophets, "This man should not be sentenced to death! He has spoken to us in the name of the LORD our God." 17 Some of the elders of the land stepped forward and said to the entire assembly of people, 18 "Micah of Moresheth prophesied in the days of Hezekiah king of Judah. He told all the people of Judah, 'This is what the LORD Almighty says:

" 'Zion will be plowed like a field, Jerusalem will become a heap of rubble, the temple hill a mound overgrown with thickets.'

19 "Did Hezekiah king of Judah or anyone else in Judah put him to death? Did not Hezekiah fear the LORD and seek his favor? And did not the LORD relent, so that he did not bring the disaster he pronounced against them? We are about to bring a terrible disaster on ourselves!"

Ezekiel chapter 18 (TEV)

30 "Now I, the Sovereign Lord, am telling you ... that I will judge each of you by what you have done. Turn away from all the evil you are doing, and don't let your sin destroy you. 31 Give up all the evil you have been doing, and get yourselves new minds and hearts. Why do you Israelites want to die? 32 I do not
want anyone to die," says the Sovereign Lord. "Turn away from your sins and live."

Ezekiel chapter 33 (TEV)

1 The Lord spoke to me. 7 "Now, mortal man, I am making you a lookout for the nation of Israel. You must pass on to them the warnings I give you. 8 If I announce that an evil person is going to die but you do not warn him to change his ways so that he can save his life, then he will die, still a sinner, and I will hold you responsible for his death. 9 If you do warn an evil person and he doesn't stop sinning, he will die, still a sinner, but your life will be spared."

10 The Lord spoke to me. "Mortal man," he said, "repeat to the Israelites what they are saying: "We are burdened with our sins and the wrongs we have done. We are wasting away. How can we live?' 11 Tell them that as surely as I, the Sovereign Lord, am the living God, I do not enjoy seeing sinners die. I would rather see them stop sinning and live. Israel, stop the evil you are doing. Why do you want to die?

Jeremiah chapter 7 (NLT)

1 The LORD gave another message to Jeremiah. He said, 2 "Go to the entrance of the LORD's Temple, and give this message to the people: 'O Judah, listen to this message from the LORD! Listen to it, all of you who worship here! 3 The LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says:

"Even now, if you quit your evil ways, I will let you stay in your own land. 4 But do not be fooled by those who repeatedly promise your safety because the Temple of the LORD is here. 5 I will be merciful only if you stop your wicked thoughts and deeds and are fair to others; 6 and if you stop exploiting foreigners, orphans, and widows; and if you stop your murdering; and if you stop worshiping idols as you now do to your own harm. 7 Then I will let you stay in this land that I gave to your ancestors to keep forever.

Isaiah chapter 33 (TEV)

15 You can survive if you say and do what is right. Don't use your power to cheat the poor and don't accept bribes. Don't join with those who plan to commit murder or to do other evil things. 16 Then you will be safe; you will be as secure as if in a strong fortress. You will have food to eat and water to drink.
17 Once again you will see a king ruling in splendor over a land that stretches in all directions. 18 Your old fears of foreign tax collectors and spies will be only a memory.

Hosea chapter 11 (NLT)

8 "Oh, how can I give you up, Israel? How can I let you go? How can I destroy you like Admah and Zeboiim? My heart is torn within me, and my compassion overflows. 9 No, I will not punish you as much as my burning anger tells me to. I will not completely destroy Israel, for I am God and not a mere mortal.
I am the Holy One living among you, and I will not come to destroy.

10 "For someday the people will follow the LORD. 11 ... And I will bring them home again," says the LORD.

Isaiah chapter 1 (TEV)

15 "When you lift your hands in prayer, I will not look at you. No matter how much you pray, I will not listen, for your hands are covered with blood.

16 Wash yourselves clean. Stop all this evil that I see you doing. Yes, stop doing evil 17 and learn to do right. See that justice is done-help those who are oppressed, give orphans their rights, and defend widows."

18 The Lord says, "Now, let's settle the matter. You are stained red with sin, but I will wash you as clean as snow. Although your stains are deep red, you will be as white as wool. 19 If you will only obey me, you will eat the good things the land produces. 20 But if you defy me, you are doomed to die.
I, the Lord, have spoken."

And there are more. Perhaps Fred Phelps could be confronted as to how God can hate everyone when he'd prefer not to punish people really.

As for that Exodus passage you quoted, yes, that sounds dubious, although how much difference it was supposed to make is open to question, given Pharaoh's later apparently independent decision to send armies after them.

It seems to me that Fred Phelps is very selective in the Bible verses he pays attention to, and goes way beyond what the Bible suggests is valid in his interpretation of them.
 
Last edited:
wow. you haven't met very many Jews then.

most of the Jews I know would never proclaim atheism.

I went to school with Jews, mostly. My first girlfriend was Jewish. my two best friends and my closest neighbor are Jews. I'm the token goy. I remind them when its a Jewish holiday, and to call their moms. All atheists. Purely anecdotal, of course.
Parky, do you consider yourself to be an atheist?
 
If, like me, you find none of them funny - I got no problems there, either.


I do find Shirley funny, at least when she's used as the spiritual advisor for the Ron and Fez show.



The best was the day they called her to comfort Fez (the gay one) when Heath Ledger died.

Shirley: He made that fag cowboy movie which is going to be single-handedly responsible for sending millions of people straight to Hell.

Ron: True, but you have to admit the cinematography was amazing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom