Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I didn't. When I called out there, Joyce's husband answered the phone, and I talked to him for a while. (Joyce wasn't home.) He fully supported her story....which includes their daughter in the alleged sighting. So, logically, if he's backing her up....then he believes his daughter saw the creature also. If Joyce is lying...then she, and her daughter, would have to be lying to their husband/father.

This is really not proper investigative technique. There are two claimed witnesses and you only talked to one of them. What you got from mom and dad is an agreement-by-proxy for the daughter. I know that you 'feel' it is safe to assume that the daughter would only corroborate and support mom's story - but you can't know that to be true unless you actually find that out from the daughter.

The other option is all 3 of them are in on it together, making-up a story.

No, that is not the only other option. The daughter may not agree with her mother (or father) about seeing a Bigfoot. The father wasn't there, so he can offer nothing of much value to the investigation.

But, it would be interesting to talk to her daughter, also, to get her version of the event...to see if any details vary from Joyce's account.

It would be more than interesting... it's absolutely necessary. The daughter may not even know that mom submitted a report to the BFRO. But it may be difficult to get to what could be the "bottom of it all" because you are talking to close family members and you are a stranger. Would the daughter tell you that her mom has always been prone to fantasies and delusions, if this were true? Would the daughter share her own feelings with you about her mother's state of mental health? Maybe the daughter never really was convinced she saw a Bigfoot, but just humors her mother's convictions about the event whenever it comes up in conversation.

What you have to do is try to create a comfortable situation for the daughter so that she can give her side of the story without the fear of hurting her mother. That's a problem when a stranger is handling the situation. Do mom and dad know that you are posting the details of your conversations with them on public Internet forums?
 
Look at his boots and pantleg bottoms. They are essentially dry. If he did not step into that flowing creek to cross it (he had to do this more than once before the plaster scene), then this absorbant clothing and footwear thoroughly dried out before he started to pour the plaster.

This was a typo made by me. I meant to say that if Roger stepped into that creek to cross it, we should expect to see wet pantleg(s) and boot(s) in the plaster pour scene. It's hard to get a sense of how wide and deep that flowing creek really was. Could he just leap across it without getting wet? Maybe.

It's the same situation with Patty. If she approached the creek by way of the hard packed road, she still has to ford the creek to get to the other side. Her feet and the hair covering them might have been soaked with water. Folks say that her visible soles show clinging sand because that would be expected. But all that hair down by the soles might also be expected to have visible clinging sand. It never really looks like that. To me, everything from the ankles down essentially looks clean with no apparent clinging sand (even on the soles). I think the guy in the suit didn't walk through the flowing creek at all. It might have added a realistic touch if he had done that, because wet and sandy feet/hair would add to the realism of an animal that supposidly crossed the creek to get a drink or whatever. Some say she was at the creek to get a drink, other say she may have been looking for fish.

Drewbot said:
What is confusing in WP3 with the flow arrows, where does the river go? Back around to the left, and then back in between patty and the camera?

LTC and I have a disagreement about the creek in WP1-4. He thinks it is still in front of Patterson but is concealed by a berm (big wall of sand). I don't see that at all. I think that RP has already crossed the creek when he films WP1-4. IMO, when he captured WP1-4, the creek is directly behind him. I think the Titmus map is incorrect because it shows a smooth gradually curving creek. I think the creek makes a small sharp bend immediately upstream from the root mass. I think we can see the outside edge of this bend in WP3, and this is why I put a sharp curves in my colored arrows.

This is a work in progress, and I am fully open to arguments that I am wrong. I actually want people to disagree with me, and explain their basis for the disagreement. Right now, working with MSPaint is a really good way to get any imaginary point across. Draw on the still frames and/or the maps to let everyone know what you are thinking.

The stark difference between JREF and BFF is that here you see fully transparent analysis. There is no secret squirrel stuff going on here in this forum. This could work as a disadvantage in the context of PGF believers. We are essentially showing our poker hand(s) to the other player(s). Never forget that the primary physical evidences (PGF copies, castings, related photos, etc.) are all held in the hands of PGF believers and promotors. That matters when trying to conduct work-in-progress skeptical critical analysis.
 
Below is my interpretation of the Titmus map as correlated with still frames from the PGF. All still frames are derived from actual scenes from the Patty walk in the PGF. The scene that coincides with WP1-4 should really be a bigger blue circle that includes the root mass. Sorry for the faint yellow arrows.

[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/e28d82b8.jpg[/qimg]

WP3
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/a78978be.jpg[/qimg]

LTC2 showing the log seen in Frame 352. After this moment, Patty makes an abrupt right turn, walks a few yards, then turns to look for the creation of Frame 352.
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/74154760.jpg[/qimg]

LTC1 (which is a crop of LTC2)
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/d898059a.jpg[/qimg]

Frame 352 with log seen in LTC1&2
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/cc10ff8c.jpg[/qimg]

Frame 352 (cropped)
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/f36963ec.jpg[/qimg]

Chris Murphy (partial) scale model of Patty walk theater with log seen in Frame 352
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/2e6fdc5a.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/051a0b20.jpg[/qimg]


Wow....just wow. What in the heck are we even looking at here? I mean...I'm following the discussion just fine, but I guess I am just kind of shocked.

In WP3 Patty seems to just be standing around and "getting the feel" for something. I don't even see how LTC2 relates to that, in terms of location, motion, etc. On top of that it seems to be in a totally different direction and looks pretty god awful. Even worse is the view of the zoom-in on the feet. I don't know what to say really other than I'd like to read some more analysis on that.

I think you guys should concentrate on this of this portion more, because it's pretty glaring. At first I thought who cares if one of the first frames was flipped, big deal, it's just a common editing error. However, those first frames seem to be taken from an entirely different angle, viewpoint, and potentially even starting location. It really points to the idea of "multiple takes" of footage.

I would conjecture that if it ISN'T multiple takes of footage, than there really has to be an ample amount of missing footage at the beginning when Patterson first falls from his horse and begins shooting.

That actually leads me to another problem that I just thought of....if he falls from his horse and then immediately begins filming and Patty strolls on into view, where did those other frames even come from? It would seem that the ORIGINAL original has far more data on it than what is available to the public today. Can someone help answer that for me?

Having said all of this, hopefully you'll recall that when I first began posting here I told you I was 50/50 on the PGF Footage being authentic and generally flop back and forth from the fence. I would definitely have to say at this moment in time I'm really leaning towards it's being a staged hoax..
 
LTC and I have a disagreement about the creek in WP1-4. He thinks it is still in front of Patterson but is concealed by a berm (big wall of sand). I don't see that at all. I think that RP has already crossed the creek when he films WP1-4. IMO, when he captured WP1-4, the creek is directly behind him. I think the Titmus map is incorrect because it shows a smooth gradually curving creek. I think the creek makes a small sharp bend immediately upstream from the root mass. I think we can see the outside edge of this bend in WP3, and this is why I put a sharp curves in my colored arrows.

This is a work in progress, and I am fully open to arguments that I am wrong. I actually want people to disagree with me, and explain their basis for the disagreement. Right now, working with MSPaint is a really good way to get any imaginary point across. Draw on the still frames and/or the maps to let everyone know what you are thinking.

Hate to disappoint, but I agree with you and see the creek as having a very sharp bend upstream from the root mass just as you've depicted. I don't buy LTC's description of it flowing behind the "closer" bank.

Edit: Upon closer review I think you can see some of the rocks in the creek in the far bottom left in the creek, and it's obviously flowing either towards or away from you meaning that it wouldn't flow to the right behind the berm. Also if the continuation of the creek was concealed behind a berm, then you'd see somewhat of a variation in the ground further to the right of the picture, but you don't. This would also point to it being a sharp cuve in the creek.

Some of the water may be concealed behind the berm (which we're kind of at an angle to), but this would just follow the curve of the stream and does not go in front of Patterson.
 
Last edited:
Hate to disappoint, but I agree with you and see the creek as having a very sharp bend upstream from the root mass just as you've depicted. I don't buy LTC's description of it flowing behind the "closer" bank.

You believe it's bending to the left, either under or just past the tree roots?

I'm liking this line of examination of these stills, that's for sure!
 
Parcher, this is what is decieving about the creek.

I put a top view to the right of each shot, with your red and blue dots placed there for reference.

Which one depicts how the creek is situated in that frame?
 
You believe it's bending to the left, either under or just past the tree roots?

I'm liking this line of examination of these stills, that's for sure!

It's hard to say, but those 2 shadows cast over the creek (depending if they're coming from the root system) could help in the analysis. I would say just past the roots.

So these are stills from the very very beginning of the footage correct?
 
Last edited:
The little creek that was six or seven feet across was now ten or twelve feet across and four feet deep! We were on the side of the creek which had to be crossed with the truck to get out to the main road. I said well I'm going to go ahead and cross the creek with the truck and get started out. And of course Roger thought it would stop raining and he suggested I leave him there and come back and pick him up.

Only reference I can find to the width of the creek Roger would have had to cross. It's also interesting where Gimlin says the truck was. The truck had been driven across the creek and had to be driven back across it.
 
Something just struck me..

Is Patty standing still in this frame, or beginning to take her first step ?

a78978be.jpg


If she had already been moving, wouldn't the left leg be bent more ?
One might argue that the left leg is moving forward ( albeit without the lower leg lift ),
but in that case the right arm should be swinging forward ..

I feel a new thread coming on at BFF ..

Wasn't Patty supposed to be well into her stroll before Rog' started filming ?
 
Last edited:
Diogenes, both legs nearly straight. Interesting....

So these are stills from the very very beginning of the footage correct?

They are early frames, yes.

Note that the story is that Patty was at the creek when first spotted when thinking about the creek's path and Roger's camera angle in the early frames.
 
LTC: So would this be before Roger even fell off of his horse? If so, then there is more footage that was blatantly edited out. How can there be only 2 completely separate stills, at a different angle, and then all of a sudden Patty appears and strolls out to the right.

Diogenes: That is exactly what I was trying to elude to a few posts ago. It really looks like Patty is just standing around, just beginning to walk, or stepping around trying to get a feel for the suit?
 
Last edited:
LTC, that second picture pretty much shows that the creek really does bend around. Also these 2 frames are in no way, shape, or form immediately sequential, so there is missing data. Look how much further Patty is from that fallen tree in the far background of pic. 1 as compared to pic. 2.

Also judging from the landmarks, wouldn't Patty have to change her path dramatically and almost come towards Patterson or at least further to the right to line up with the classic PG Footage?
 
Last edited:
Good catch sgoodman72 !! I remember you asking me if I didn't see a problem - and it didn't grab me at that time...


O.K., I'm going to BFF with this .. let the dancing begin ...

Both legs would never be almost straight like that with a walking subject..
 
Patty is strolling away in WP1-4. The still frames can trick you into thinking that she is motionless.

Again watch Dahinden's copy at 11:32. When you first see the projected footage, it has already gone just slightly past WP4 (you can't see the creek bend or root mass anymore). She is already walking away in WP1.

But the real mind-boggler is the very next scene that we see. It instantly changes from WP4 (plus a few frames... which would be something like a hypothetical WP6... which is very close to the Perfectfoot still frame) to LTC2. She is suddenly about to walk behind the log seen in Frame 352. If the Titmus/Krantz map is close to accurate - then there is a bunch of missing Patty walk footage.

I think I have that right.
 
Good catch sgoodman72 !! I remember you asking me if I didn't see a problem - and it didn't grab me at that time...


O.K., I'm going to BFF with this .. let the dancing begin ...

Both legs would never be almost straight like that with a walking subject..

Thanks Diogenes!

You know what actually just struck me...? Tell me if I'm wrong, but if I didn't know any better, I would say it almost looks as if Patty is looking down at that moment in the picture. I would say it almost looks as if Patty is stepping down to create footprints and seeing how they turn out. Maybe to see how they turn out, maybe seeing how deep they are, etc. I don't know, but it would definitely explain the absurd angle. It doesn't even look like walking, it looks like blantantly trying to step down hard on the left foot, doesn't it?

I know I'm getting carried away now, but still. Anyway, WP just read your post and I agree, I can't understand how the frames bounce around like that. Also does anyone else think the 2 other pictures of Patty walking just looks really wrong?
 
Last edited:
Also these 2 frames are in no way, shape, or form immediately sequential, so there is missing data.

The map does not depict Patty making a left turn after Roger starts filming, though.

Quite a bit of stuff doesn't seem to match the official maps of the trackway.

Also judging from the landmarks, wouldn't Patty have to change her path dramatically and almost come towards Patterson or at least further to the right to line up with the classic PG Footage?

Well, Roger ran towards Patty at least twice, according to the story.

What also is beginning to interest me is the stuff at the back of the scene in 352 which looks to be organized to me. It looks like 2 stumps set up on purpose and some cut logs in between them. It looks like an organized storage spot.

You can see what I mean in the upper right background here, and in the left center background of 352.


d898059a.jpg


cc10ff8c.jpg



With the truck "on the wrong side of the creek" and what I think I see in the background, I am wondering if Roger and Bob were actually camped right there.
 
WP,
I'm losing you on your image reference - WP1 -4 ..

You don't agree Patty, is at most taking her first step in the image I featured ?
The unbent knees will never be side by side like that in a walking figure unless
it is walking stiff legged ..

Try it yourself ..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom