Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
New Member here, so please excuse any etiquette issues..

If I may..Being a former zoo keeper and having 30 years of field research under my belt, I have 1 major problem with the authenticity of the "creaure" in the PGF..Namely the full swing motion of it's arms while walking. This movement is NOT natural in NHP's (Non-human primates). Even for those taxa that may be bipedal for short amounts of time. This is a Human characteristic. I grew suspicious of the PGF footage when I first saw the film. Now, call me crazy, but has anyone ever seen the old TV show "Greatest American Hero" strarring William Katt?? The "full swing" of the arms and position of the actors hands can been seen in the shows intro, while Katt is filmed striding along. One particular end frame catches him in stop motion which is 100% identical to the creatures in the PGF. I know, it sounds weird, but check it out if possible. Sorry for the interuption ...

HA! Freeze this Youtube video at about 1:32 - the man in the suit has been identified as William Katt:

 
Last edited:
I never noticed that WP. That is the same log. Patty sure acts odd...

I realized that the log in 352 is the same as LTC1&2 about two years ago. I thought the Titmus map was very strange the first time I saw it about two years ago as well. The Murphy model looked strange the first time I saw it as well. This stuff does not jive very well with the Patty walk scenes in the PGF.

It was only in the past few days when I have been concentrating on Bob Titmus' testimony and map. that I decided to put the strangeness into graphic form (using his map and other correlating images). I started gathering up this stuff and making pencil sketches on paper just yesterday.

It isn't just that Patty acts odd (more like wandering about rather than heading for cover), it is also becoming clear that Patterson acts odd. The Titmus map pretty much has Roger trailing her alongside her trackway. But the film seems to show that Roger films periodically while also making significant progress travelling almost parallel to her path right around where we see Frame 352.

This is obviously a work in progress for me. The Titmus map is so misleading that it a real problem to simply make my additions seen above. I think he shows an incorrect pathway of Patty as well as incorrect positioning and pathway of Patterson.

LTC said:
These tracks are in wet ground. I guess we can't even say approximately where they'd be on the map, though. Assuming the casting is happening as claimed, I mean.

Look at his boots and pantleg bottoms. They are essentially dry. If he did not step into that flowing creek to cross it (he had to do this more than once before the plaster scene), then this absorbant clothing and footwear thoroughly dried out before he started to pour the plaster.

I love this stuff!
 
Shouldn't Patty appear appreciably larger in the frame in WP3 than in 352? Eh, maybe not.

Are there full frames available to make a comparison?

Unfortunately, my PGF viewing experience is still limited to what can be seen on the web as I still refuse to buy any DVD's. I should check my library, though.
 
Last edited:
Drew, I have concluded that the shadow is blocked by the branch. That branch is much closer to the camera, imo, than the one that is making the shadow. So that when Roger jogs the camera, it blurs the closer branch so much that it effectively disappears.

I concur.
What is confusing in WP3 with the flow arrows, where does the river go?

Back around to the left, and then back in between patty and the camera?
 
"A complete lie" hasn't been ruled-out....but this debate started with this statement of mine...
In other words, her report can very well be a (complete or partial) fabrication...

In other words, it adds nothing, or very little, to the cause. Discussing it is futile- to use LTC8K6's Borg line.

"If Joyce saw anything....she saw a real Bigfoot." (As opposed to a Bear.)
Not necessarily, I think. You can't rule out a misidentification coupled with changes in her recollections of the sighting (be these changes intentional or not). All you have is her version- and it may not be completely faithfull to the truth.

...which kitakaze replied to with the question "how has the possibility of a hoax been ruled-out?"
Another pertinent question, I think. A question that has not been propperly answered, I think.

Note that if her sighting is a fabrication, the whole thing is a hoax. No ape suits may be involved and the whole thing can still be a hoax.

I was just using an extreme figure.
But there is a way to determine a figure, scientifically. As in the example of the Loch Ness sighting experiment....you can determine the odds, or probability factor, of people misidentifying a man-in-a-monkey-suit for a real Bigfoot by running a simple test.
Have people watch a video...or witness a staged event...of a man in a suit, and record the results of what they think they saw. It's as simple as that.
Its far from being as simple as that. Lets look a bit closer.

First, the test would only be valid if the subjects (witnesses) were a statistically representative sample of an universe composed of people with the same characteristics of those who claim to be bigfoot eyewitnesses. Factors such as age, sex, sexual orientation, religion, education level, income, etc. of witnesses will have to be taken in to account when selecting the test subjects.

Second, the results would only be valid for sightings whose conditions were similar to the test- illumination, time, distance, environment, hour, lenght, etc.

As you see, its far from being simple as that.

As I explained in a post from earlier today....concerning the .0001% figure...
You must show the math if you attribute a number to a variable. Attributing numbers to variables you can not quantify (and your answer implies you think you can quantify the probability), variables which actually can only be qualifyed is pretty bad science, at least. Normally I would let this pass, assuming you used a figure of language, but since you seem to be seeking a scientific approach...

So, next time write
"I consider the probability of Joyce, and her daughter, both 'seeing a guy-in-a-suit incorrectly as a real Bigfoot' as being very low...given the combination of the extremely clear, and lengthy look they had of it....and the hokiness of your average gorilla suit."
if you are really trying to be precise.

I won't touch in the other obvious problems with your assessments- the actual lenght of a decades-old sighting and if the "hokiness of your average gorilla suit" would or not be recognized by Joyce. Other posters already discussed these issues.

I honestly think that given those conditions....that only 1 person in a thousand, or maybe even less, would misidentify a man in a hokey, baggy gorilla or Bigfoot suit for a real creature.
See above.
Personally I think the claim above is at least debatable, since you have nothing but your personal opinion to back it.
 
It isn't just that Patty acts odd (more like wandering about rather than heading for cover), it is also becoming clear that Patterson acts odd. The Titmus map pretty much has Roger trailing her alongside her trackway. But the film seems to show that Roger films periodically while also making significant progress travelling almost parallel to her path right around where we see Frame 352.
Did you see my post on this over at BFF ..
http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=21716

I's gone on for 16 pages - but the original thrust of my post was quickly lost ..

My main point:
Why did Patterson, who had scrambled to catch up to Patty for the ' turn and look ' bit; stop and take some relatively steady
footage of those trees for seven seconds, waiting for Patty to emerge, rather than keep moving to get her into view?

Besides, why should he think she was going to emerge from behind those trees, rather than amble off in some other direction,
that would keep her out of clear view of the camera ?
 
Shouldn't Patty appear appreciably larger in the frame in WP3 than in 352? Eh, maybe not.

Only if Patterson told the truth and the Titmus/Krantz map is correct. That map shows Titmus' analysis of what he saw within the sandy creek wash (this is a much bigger theater than the flowing creek itself... Titmus tries to define both with the outlines of his "creek bed margin" and the flowing creek itself).

Alongside Titmus' map is the Krantz map. This map is no less strange than the one created by Titmus. This is because Krantz used the Titmus map to arrive at his map. Garbage in... garbage out. With his map, Krantz tries to reconcile Titmus' map with what he sees in the PGF and then adds coinciding PGF frame numbers relative to Roger's position. But Krantz's map is almost certainly incomplete just the same as Titmus' map is incomplete. Patterson probably was not in the indicated "stop" position when he captured Frame 352.

Yes, we should expect Patty to be much closer to Roger in WP3 as compared to Frame 352. But we only expect that because we also expect that the Titmus/Krantz maps are close to accurate. They are way screwed up when you compare them to the P&G testimonies and watch the PGF itself.

Are there full frames available to make a comparison?

Hell yes, and you can see them on the web, but they do not present themselves as streaming film clips (perfect for grabbing still frames) in the same way that LMS : DVD does. Did you not take close PGF-student notice of my Sunday gushings concerning the CBC archives? Episode 2 shows Dahinden's (possibly) full-frame PGF being shown by a projector. Watch that archive.

At about 11:32, Dahinden and the reporter (Peter Reilly) will see Perfectfoot (PF). This PF moment (still frame) comes very very close to WP3 and 4. It looks like these guys are watching a full-frame Dahinden copy of the Patty walk. At about 11:35, the scene changes suddenly and dramatically to LTC2.

LTC, from what I can see on Dahinden's (possibly full frame) copy, Patterson is about the same distance from Patty in WP1-4 as he is in LTC2 and Frame 352. This does not jive with the Titmus/Krantz maps... but then again, those maps don't show the full pathway of Patterson. The (possibly) full-frame Dahinden-copy PGF film indicates that these maps need some kind of important revision.

Unfortunately, my PGF viewing experience is still limited to what can be seen on the web as I still refuse to buy any DVD's. I should check my library, though.

I am in the same boat. I don't own a single Bigfoot book (including Long's book), nor possess any Bigfoot VHS or DVD (including LMS). All of my analysis comes from what I see on the web. That's why I am so hungry for anything I can find online.

Now we can place the perfectfoot 61 and blockfoot 72 frames in context as well.

Yes, these are very close to WP3&4. They (Perfectfoot and Blockfoot) will roll by (too small to see for us) as Dahinden and Reilly watch the projected film.
 
Last edited:
New Member here, so please excuse any breach of etiquette..

Welcome. No etiquette breaches yet from you. The double-post by you is only a mistake that was probably caused by the slowness of the JREF server. Click only once on the "Submit Reply" button, and then sit back for a possibly multi-minute wait for your post to appear in the thread. This puppy can sometimes run like molasses.

I have 1 major problem with the authenticity of the "creaure" in the PGF..Namely the full swing motion of it's arms while walking. This movement is NOT natural in NHP's (Non-human primates). Even for those taxa that may be bipedal for short amounts of time. This is a Human characteristic. I grew suspicious of the PGF footage when I first saw the film. Now, call me crazy, but has anyone ever seen the old TV show "Greatest American Hero" starring William Katt?? The "full swing" of the arms and position of the actors hands can been seen in the shows intro, while Katt is filmed striding along. One particular end frame catches him in stop motion which is 100% identical to the creatures in the PGF. I know, it sounds weird, but check it out if possible. Sorry for the interruption ...

Right. The exaggerated arm swing is what screen actors did to look like a gorilla or chimp when wearing a costume. It's a unique cliched characteristic of "Hollywood" (any 'early' mass-market visual production for a general audience) apes, and has little to do with actual apes in nature. The reason I put 'early' into quotations is because nowadays that exaggerated ape arm swinging looks contrived and cliche.

But we are talking about 1967. Hyper-realistic "Hollywood" depictions of real apes was non-existent or very rare. Even the technologically advanced film, "2001: A Space Odyssey" (1968) blew it. The pre-modern man costumes were visually realistic, but the actors still swung their arms around like "Hollywood" apes. Even Stanley Kubrick could not break from this "Hollywood" cliche in spite of having very sophisticated ape costume designers and actors. Please take note that when I use the term "Hollywood", I do not specifically mean that the production originated on a Hollywood studio. "2001" was produced in the UK. It was years later that the crazy arm swinging went away. I'm curious to know about when this happened.

zooman63 said:
Now, call me crazy, but has anyone ever seen the old TV show "Greatest American Hero" starring William Katt?? The "full swing" of the arms and position of the actors hands can been seen in the shows intro, while Katt is filmed striding along.

Starrman said:
HA! Freeze this Youtube video at about 1:32 - the man in the suit has been identified as William Katt...

Did you guys know that a Yakima guy named Bob Heironimus walks with crazy swinging arms in real life? Do you know who this guy is (Google his name)?

Would you like to see a video clip of Heironimus doing his everyday arm-swinging ape walk in real life?
 
I thought this pic from the old Argosy magazine article was kinda interesting, check out the top of the thigh.
 

Attachments

  • Argosy%20image%20352 (Medium).jpg
    Argosy%20image%20352 (Medium).jpg
    76.9 KB · Views: 8
...check out the top of the thigh.

Yep, it's a padding malfunction... and the hands look more sea otter than huge hominoid biped.

Do you have an actual copy of that Feb. 1968 Argosy magazine?
 
Last edited:
I'm almost fascinated how one gets by being so credulous. It's like your mind is so set to believe in bigfoot that simple common sense just takes a walk. You come out with numbers and make an effort to appear rational but even the simplest rational thought is just gone.

Let's walk through this a little, Sweaty. You can provide some numbers if you like. Between 5:30 and 6:00 pm on a May early evening, 1983, Joyce and her then 15 year old daughter come to the corner of NY 203 and State Farm Road in Valatie and, crap my pants, there's the Boss of the Woods, sasquatch! He's getting up from crouching, glances back, and he takes off through the cow pasture. Was he taking a dump? I don't know. WTF was that!?

Let's analyze, Sweaty! So bigfoot made it into Valatie undetected. How'd he get in there? He rollin' around in the daytime. Stupid, stupid, stupid. He better lay low, hide behind some trees. Wait till nightfall. Yeah, that's the ticket. But wait! Bigfoot got to 203 and State Farm and decided to saunter out to the corner and squat. Bigfoot, you crazy bastard, are you insane!? You're in the middle of a human neighbourhood in broad daylight, you jackass! Why do you have to poo here? Is it spite? Is it roadkill? A car! The jig is up! Damn dirty humans.

Seriously, Sweaty, have you made any effort to look at this area? It's in the middle of civilization. A bigfoot to get through there, all the while feeding, and being intelligent enough to avoid detection... It's staggering stupidity on the order of Martian architecture.

BTW, A couple places in the immediate vicinity to have a look at. A little ways down NY 203, The First Presbyterian Church
Valatie, New York. Photo:

http://www.valatie.presbychurch.org/graphics/church.jpg

Map:

http://www.valatie.presbychurch.org/standard/direction.htm

Over on State Farm Road here's lovely Ichabod Crane Primary School. Watch out for the Boss of the Woods, kids!:

http://www.berk.com/ichabod/icPSHome.html

While I'm won't say that there was a Sasquatch sighting in Valatie NY 25 years ago I will say this If in 1982 anyone on this thread was blindfolded tossed in the trunk of a car in New York City and driven the 135 up to Valatie in the middle of the night and dumpped in the darkness on the outskirts of town you most certainly would have been looking over your shoulder and hoping that The Boss Of The Woods was just a fairy tale used to intimadate the kids at the what was that? The Ichabod Crane little brat school? Better check you shorts too. Obviously some folks don't know that area.
 
Last edited:
WP, I've posted about those CBC archives before. I guess I have just gone around and around about bigfoot so many times on so many topics, I just didn't make the connections this time.

Okay, I didn't remember Diogenes' BFF question although I did read it at the time.

I see how it fits with WP's work now.

This line of thought is very interesting. There's still stuff to learn about the PGF and it's creation.
 
Last edited:
WP, I've posted about those CBC archives before. I guess I have just gone around and around about bigfoot so many times on so many topics, I just didn't make the connections this time.

I know what you mean. Both of us (and Dfoot) talked about these archives in the past. I made a joke last year about Dahinden wanting no less than $1 million for a Bigfoot body. That comment was made after I had just seen Episode 2.

The thing is, there has been so much material produced by Bigfootery over many decades that it is hard to put it all into perspective (the big picture). For the most part, a BF skeptic deals with the specific topic-of-the-day presented by some specific BF believer-of-the-day. You could easily lose yourself in the daily ticky-tacky bullcrap argument coming from Sweety, Crowlogic, Luminous, Huntster, LAL, or whoever is the Pattycake du jour. This grinding waste of time could easily pull a skeptic into totally worthless minutae with no chance of a 'woo conversion' to skepticism.

You can see that after a few years here on the JREF forum there are only a handful of devoted and lingering BF and PGF skeptics. Each one of us is highly skeptical of the BF animal existing. At the same time, each of us has evolved into areas of specialty. Each devoted skeptic shows specialized interest in tackling specific facets of BF belief. At the moment, AMM, KKZ and Correa Neto are going after Sweety and his New York Joyce affair. That is good and important applied skepticism. I just don't have the stomach for it anymore, because I do not think that any explanation or appeal to rationality or reason will cause Sweety to budge one inch. This is no kind of criticism of those JREF BF skeptics, even though I think it is ultimately a losing battle no matter how excellent the presentation could be. Honestly, I doubt that Sweety actually believes that Bigfoot exists. I think he likes to argue against skeptics and has made a small hobby out of it.

The PGF looked like a hoax from the moment it was released. It tragically flopped in front of all critical thinkers. That happened in 1967. Nothing has really changed since then. We still have a small cadre of goofballs that think this film shows a genuine Bigfoot. It's big fun to expose new viewpoints and evidences that point to the hoax, such as what happens in this forum. But strong belief in the film never seems to vanish. I do believe that the PGF believer cult is shrinking rapidly and becoming more bizarre by the day. Five years from now, all the existing Pattycakes might be forced to act just like completely blind idiots. The only real refuge for them is to totally ignore capable PGF skepticism and act like it doesn't exist at all.

I'm getting long-winded and this starts to sound like that sociology thesis on Bigfootery that hasn't happened yet. A BF skeptic needs to deal with the trees and the forest. Both are prime targets for skepticism. But I think now that the forest is more satisfying to me. The modern Bigfooters are nearly identical to the Classic Bigfooters. This is one big folk tale that spreads by irresitable contagion. I love the Bigfoot myth, and I think I could convincingly play the part of a believer just for fun. I think that I now know the nuts and bolts of BF belief enough to pretend to be one of them. That is also why I try to be very careful with the arguments I present to them.

A rational BF skeptic probably can see this coming just by watching the behavior of the believers. You really have to devote expendable time and effort to present a good argument... all the while knowing that you will never make a significant dent into Bigfootery. The fresh batch of BFF Bigfooters is a vivid example of this.

I must be plumb crazy to be doing this, and that is why I made my signature read as it does.
 
While I'm won't say that there was a Sasquatch sighting in Valatie NY 25 years ago I will say this If in 1982 anyone on this thread was blindfolded tossed in the trunk of a car in New York City and driven the 135 up to Valatie in the middle of the night and dumpped in the darkness on the outskirts of town you most certainly would have been looking over your shoulder and hoping that The Boss Of The Woods was just a fairy tale used to intimadate the kids at the what was that? The Ichabod Crane little brat school? Better check you shorts too. Obviously some folks don't know that area.
I do know that area, or did once. Sure, it's rural, and I'd find it scary at night too. Parts of the area could even be described as wild. That doesn't really address the issue of whether it's reasonable to believe that sasquatches are roaming about there. In any case, if there are 'squatches in Valatie, then it is demonstrably false that the failure to get better evidence, trapped animals, clear pictures, bodies, artifacts, nests, bones, etc. is due to their frequenting only trackless wildernesses such as the Pacific Northwest, or even the remoter parts of the Adirondacks. You cannot have it both ways. They cannot be both common and scarce, local and widespread, bold and reclusive.
 
I do know that area, or did once. Sure, it's rural, and I'd find it scary at night too. Parts of the area could even be described as wild. That doesn't really address the issue of whether it's reasonable to believe that sasquatches are roaming about there. In any case, if there are 'squatches in Valatie, then it is demonstrably false that the failure to get better evidence, trapped animals, clear pictures, bodies, artifacts, nests, bones, etc. is due to their frequenting only trackless wildernesses such as the Pacific Northwest, or even the remoter parts of the Adirondacks. You cannot have it both ways. They cannot be both common and scarce, local and widespread, bold and reclusive.

I'm not a ready believer in NY State having had the company of Sasquatch in the past 200 years.
 
While I'm won't say that there was a Sasquatch sighting in Valatie NY 25 years ago I will say this If in 1982 anyone on this thread was blindfolded tossed in the trunk of a car in New York City and driven the 135 up to Valatie in the middle of the night and dumpped in the darkness on the outskirts of town you most certainly would have been looking over your shoulder and hoping that The Boss Of The Woods was just a fairy tale used to intimadate the kids at the what was that? The Ichabod Crane little brat school? Better check you shorts too. Obviously some folks don't know that area.
It doesn't really matter if one thinks Valatie is dark and scary at night, it is now and was in 1983 a populated area. We're being asked to put stock in a claim that there is a race of 8ft giant bipedal primates that populate the continent. We're told that science has not classified these massive beasts because they are too shy and elusive yet we're told at the same time that they'll stroll out in the open to corner of 203 and State Farm in broad daylight. It's an appalling contradiction that people like Sweaty will not even flinch at.

I'm not a ready believer in NY State having had the company of Sasquatch in the past 200 years.
Again, I would love to here your take on Joyce.
 
Last edited:
Sweaty, did you talk to Joyce's daughter independantly to see if she tells a similar story?


No, I didn't.
When I called out there, Joyce's husband answered the phone, and I talked to him for a while. (Joyce wasn't home.) He fully supported her story....which includes their daughter in the alleged sighting. So, logically, if he's backing her up....then he believes his daughter saw the creature also. If Joyce is lying...then she, and her daughter, would have to be lying to their husband/father.
The other option is all 3 of them are in on it together, making-up a story.

But, it would be interesting to talk to her daughter, also, to get her version of the event...to see if any details vary from Joyce's account.


One thing that impressed me is that, after he took my number and told me Joyce would call me back....she actually did. I figured I'd never hear from her, but approx. 1 1/2 weeks later, she called....and told me all about her Bigfoot sighting. :)
Just the fact that she took time out of her day to make a long-distance call to a total stranger, and was as friendly, and assuring as she was, made a very strong impression on me that she's telling the truth.
 
Last edited:
While I'm won't say that there was a Sasquatch sighting in Valatie NY 25 years ago I will say this If in 1982 anyone on this thread was blindfolded tossed in the trunk of a car in New York City and driven the 135 up to Valatie in the middle of the night and dumpped in the darkness on the outskirts of town you most certainly would have been looking over your shoulder and hoping that The Boss Of The Woods was just a fairy tale used to intimadate the kids at the what was that? The Ichabod Crane little brat school? Better check you shorts too. Obviously some folks don't know that area.


If I dropped you in the middle of the small PARK near my home in the middle of the night , it would be scary too. Heck I even got scarred by some fox running away while cycling through that small bit of "forest". That does not make bigfoot anymore real, it only makes us human fearful of darkness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom