Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
The most important point, I think, is that the quality of data is so bad (the PGF) that it all NEARLY becomes a matter of opinion and not of fact.

I say nearly, because frankly there are a lot of compelling argument that the tech *was* indeed available in the 60's for such costume, whereas up to now there are no compelling evidence whatsoever for Bigfoot (DNA, Bones, Cadaver, or even for low quality evidence : a recent good resolution non-hoaxed video etc...etc...). IMHO this is a really good reason to stay skeptic.

As for myth and "there is no smoke without fire the myth started somewhere", well how about : people made up stories to distract each other, shaman/priest made up story to put everybody back in ranks. That is far more probable than the following proposition "somewhere in the Mediterranean, there is an island with pigs and a woman called Circee on it" has some basis in reality. Even a remote one.
 
sgoodman72:
....How about Native American folklore centering around Bigfoot? How about the names they have for them and stories for the creature that would nowadays be described as Bigfoot? I guess we can just forget about them, afterall they smoked the peace pipe all day right? They must be completely dillusional. Please...they have nothing to hide and nothing to lie about at all.
Please... Do you realize how lame that is ?

With your rationalization, there are giant bipedal Otters in NA also ...

Want the whole list ?
 
How about Native American folklore centering around Bigfoot? How about the names they have for them and stories for the creature that would nowadays be described as Bigfoot? I guess we can just forget about them, afterall they smoked the peace pipe all day right? They must be completely dillusional. Please...they have nothing to hide and nothing to lie about at all.

Dragons for 100, Alex.
 
The most important point, I think, is that the quality of data is so bad (the PGF) that it all NEARLY becomes a matter of opinion and not of fact.

I say nearly, because frankly there are a lot of compelling argument that the tech *was* indeed available in the 60's for such costume, whereas up to now there are no compelling evidence whatsoever for Bigfoot (DNA, Bones, Cadaver, or even for low quality evidence : a recent good resolution non-hoaxed video etc...etc...). IMHO this is a really good reason to stay skeptic.

As for myth and "there is no smoke without fire the myth started somewhere", well how about : people made up stories to distract each other, shaman/priest made up story to put everybody back in ranks. That is far more probable than the following proposition "somewhere in the Mediterranean, there is an island with pigs and a woman called Circee on it" has some basis in reality. Even a remote one.

I'd love someone to prove to me that the tech *was* indeed available in the 60's, show me the data Aepervius.

I already explained to you why there are no bones or cadavers around, and there actually is DNA evidence that is currently being studied.

As for no recent footage that isn't hoaxed, that's probably your strongest argument. The sad part is that if Bigfoot does actually exist, the few left that actually kept them at a breeding population were probably killed off by farmers and hunters that have little to no connection with the outside world. Have you ever been hunting, have you ever lived or even been to the middle of NO-MAN's land? No. Think about it, if you live in the middle of nowhere Canada and actually miraculously shoot yourself a Bigfoot, how would you even begin to transport it, much less care to. Some people probably don't even know it's a big deal or care. Believe it or not, there are people in this world that don't have the internet, including people in the U.S. and Canada, gasp!

Part of the biggest problem is that there just isn't enough funding and there aren't enough extensive, lengthy field studies to turn up much. Remember the Manitoba incident not long back, I think they were on to something there.

Diogenes:
Please... Do you realize how lame that is ?

With your rationalization, there are giant bipedal Otters in NA also ...

Want the whole list ?

To Diogenes & Aepervius: No I would not like the whole list, I know it's extensive, I'm just saying there is a always some sort of basis. Want to talk Greek Mythology? I could go on for months about that, love it and studied it all the time. Mermaids were sea lions, sea monsters were giant squids, etc. All just stories that got told, and retold, and embellished through the years. I agree that the Native America myths should be taken with a grain of salt, and some are probably embellished as all stories are, I'm just saying that I believe "something" made them tell the stories other than just fear.

Aepervius: To "keep you in rank" why wouldn't the priests/shaman say something absolutely terrifying would come kill you if you disobeyed, why a hairy-bipedal human-like creature? That's not enough to scare people off that lived lives 24/7 in nature, that's just a horrible argument.
 
Last edited:
Parcher,

I think Dfoot is refering to this. Pesonally, I have no idea what is suppose to represent the the master copy at this point. All I can say for sure is that I seem to see quite a few splices when vewing the different edits, of course this is all speculation on my part.


m


[URL="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_826447926a64178fe.jpghttp://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_826447926aae551cb.jpg"]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_826447926a64178fe.jpg[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_826447926aae551cb.jpg[/URL][/URL]

Yep. That's one of the flips. There are others. I believe that one is from the original RON OLSON/PATTERSON documentary. Olson later merged that doc with the one on ROBERT MORGAN's search to make yet another feature length film.

I'd love for Olson to make a new flick using all of the footage of Ostman and other witnesses that he has on film. But Dahinden/Gimlin sued him to get payback and Patricia Patterson now guards all film rights like a hawk. As she told MK DAVIS, "I don't care what you do as long as you don't interfere with my money." Pretty clear there. MK signed a notarized document giving all his work to her soon after.

Nothing sinister about flipping part of a shot to create the lead up to seeing Patty. That particular shot was cut in two with one half flipped. Green's "original copy" , however, is supposed to show precisely what was on the original film just before Patterson turned his camera on when Patty was spotted. It shows a PAN FROM LEFT TO RIGHT to those "tent pole" trees. It also shows a flipped version of Patterson riding at Bluff Creek.

If that shot of Patterson is flipped (and it is) then how could that be original? It would mean someone had been editing the footage prior to Green getting his copy. It would mean the "original film" he watched only hours after it had been shot was phony as this is what would have to have been on it.

Yet another version of the film shows a pan in the OPPOSITE DIRECTION to the tent pole trees just before patty is shown. It had been flipped horizontally. That means it isn't an original copy as claimed either. Also, the Patty footage on that one starts later than other Patty footage. It cannot be a copy of the original.

I'm sure some rat-like smell must have flowed from the film canisters and 3/4 inch tapes surrounding this thing.:rolleyes:

Either way, Patterson could not have grown a beard and done all the other things to catch horses and made casts within 90 minutes so he could make it to Eureka and back by just after 6 pm to tell Hodgson how he'd just been to "the post office in Eureka" to mail the film to DeAtley (according to Hodgson). Plaster also doesn't vanish when you pull your cast out of the track. Can you smell that fish? I sure do.

All of these images are from MOTION PICTURE FILM shot by Gimlin of Roger at Bluff Creek immediately after the Patty encounter. By the middle of the night a massive storm moved in and they barely escaped the areas huge mud slides with their lives. So the film on the right could NOT have been shot the next morning. Yet it is supposedly on the infamous "second roll" footage at Bluff Creek.

The only way out of this is for Gimlin to tell audiences that this particular bit was shot later in Washington and all this info is a big mistake; just as he had to say he could not recall whether he drove to the post office or the airport. He's so smooth and his audience so willing that he should be able to keep pulling it off. His wife, however, is a different story...

It is a mess... which only helps the con men in the long run. As the Cottingley Fairie girls said, "We didn't have to lie to our dear believers; they would always come up with some reason for it to be true on their own whenever some reporter would point something out to them. These were very brilliant people."
 
sgoodman72
To Diogenes & Aepervius: No I would not like the whole list, I know it's extensive, I'm just saying there is a always some sort of basis.
Some sort of basis can be anything, including the right mushyroomies...

You are picking the ones you like and discarding the rest ..

Bigfoot, O.K. ...

Giant otter .. Not O.K. ...

Besides you are now backing down from your assertion that NA Natives had nothing to hide and would not lie; which is what I called into question ...

The fact that myths sometimes have basis in fact is beside the point, and not the one you tried to make..

We went through the " Are You Calling North American Natives liars ? " game with Kathy Strain ...

To stand by that assertion, you need to agree that Giant Otters that walk upright are just as likely as Bigfoot ...
 
Last edited:
....
The only way out of this is for Gimlin to tell audiences that this particular bit was shot later in Washington and all this info is a big mistake; just as he had to say he could not recall whether he drove to the post office or the airport. He's so smooth and his audience so willing that he should be able to keep pulling it off. His wife, however, is a different story............
I have seen Gimlin quoted as saying he doesn't remember ever operating the camera at all...
 
Noble Savage from Wikipedia...

The attributes of the "noble savage" often included:

* Living in harmony with Nature
* Generosity and selflessness
* Innocence
* Inability to lie, fidelity
* Physical health
* Disdain of luxury
* Moral courage
* "Natural" intelligence or innate, untutored wisdom.


The bit about lying doesn't even really address their own myths. Those aren't considered lies. Lies can be mixed with myths in real life.

Tribal Orator gathers the village children around the fire and tells them the legend of the Otter Men. Oohs and aahs. Next day a little boy comes running up to the Orator to say he just saw one of those Otter Men down by the river. Orator is very skeptical. He tells the boy that he must wait until he is older to have a vision of Otter Man. Now both are skeptical of each other. The Otter Men story gets told again by the Orator to other children the next week.

What is a lie, and what is a myth? No time to ponder and get all scoftical. There are salmon to be hung up to dry.
 
LMAO -- :D


You really should write a book WP, or at least start a BLOGG..

You are nominated...

There really should be a " Spewing On Your Keyboard " category in the language award .. I'm going to go suggest it now..
 
Last edited:
As far as CORRIGANVILLE goes: I can assure you that it was THE rodeo and film location spot of its day. Crash was the number one ape man during the heyday of jungle films and did indeed have them stored there in the 60's in white, black and brown.

Buck Maffei (who wore the head on Star Trek) did indeed work there as one of the cowboy actors (he wasn't a stuntman - just huge). Buck worked on the original LOST IN SPACE as well as other projects involving John Chambers and Janos.

Here he is at Corriganville.


Here's another shot of Roger that was flipped for a documentary. I flipped it back to the way it should have been.

The good thing about this one is that we can see the buttons on the shirt and tell which way he should be facing. Roger usually held the reins in his left hand (he was left-handed) so I think Olson's shot of him riding up and stopping at Bluff Creek is correct and the version Green has is flipped.

Anyway, I'm getting creamed once again over at the BFF. I'm being told I should provide proof that a pad I'm showing next to Patty is a pad. Good God man....

And I used to wonder how Conan Doyle ever believed in the Cottingley Fairies... it all looks clearer now.:covereyes
 
:D

I could do this stuff all day. Making funny fictionalized stories of everyday Indian life in the days of Otter Man. If you didn't know I was making them up they might sound plausible. Plus nobody can prove that these scenarios didn't happen. It's fun and you can weave messages and morals into them. I've always wondered why we don't hear tales of Native American skeptics. You know, folks that thought that Otter Man wasn't even real. Where were they? Here, I'll try another one...

The Doubter

As told by Spitting Eagle (village orator).

Long ago an elder orator named Wolf Clover Clouds was sitting by the fire telling the tale of Otter Men. All were enchanted and having a great time. Two Bear Cramps was young and fiesty and he just didn't believe that Otter Men really existed. He was nearly relentless in his skeptical questions and even was brave enough to ask for proof. Two Bear Cramps was shown the mask and totem pole, but it was no use. Everyone left to sleep in their teepees except for the arguing pair. They went on and on and everyone could hear them. "Shut up and go to sleep!" was yelled out from numerous homes. They wouldn't. Eventually, everyone else fell asleep. When the village awoke there was only silence. They must have stopped arguing and went to sleep after all. But when everyone crawled out of their teepees they noticed something odd where the two had been arguing. Between the two sitting logs was a great big mound of salmon roe. How strange a sight that was. Find those two guys now and have them explain the fish eggs. All the people looked and looked, but nobody could find Wolf Clover Clouds or Two Bear Cramps. Everyone gathered to try to understand what had happened. Just then, Cheif Frog Who Hops Backwards made an announcement of their fate. Both of them had turned into salmon eggs because of their argument over Otter Man. They were never seen again, and this confirmed that the Cheif had been right. From that day onwards, nobody in our tribe argues about the existence of Otter Man.

Moral for Otter Man skeptics: Just don't do it. You will turn into a pile of fish eggs.

Moral for Orators who tell the legend of Otter Man: Do not argue with Otter Man skeptics for more than a short time, and never argue at all during a passing moon. Show them the mask and totem pole, and if that doesn't work just shut up and walk away. You and the skeptic will both turn into salmon roe.
 
Skeptics have their work cut out for them

Bigfoot is still moving up in the world.
2 weeks ago, Bigfoot was on the Discovery channel at 9 pm
Prior to that, the History channel had Bigfoot on at 10 pm on Wednesdays
But tonight, History channel 2 upped the Discovery channel and has Bigfoot on at 7 PM. That's right! Read it and weap, 7 PM! hahahahahahahaha!
 
...snip...However, Correa Neto and William, your arguments appear to diverge.
I fail to see the problem with this.
With two skeptics you can get more than three opinions...

I'm not trying to divert or nit-pick, but it does raise an important issue. So William, by stating that Patterson (via Bob H's input) "admitted" to altering Patty's appearance to make it natural looking, this means that you see it as non-homogeneous as well. However Correa Neto feels otherwise.
You can use this example to get a better understanting of what I wrote about perceptions.
You have my perceptions, William's perceptions, your perceptions and Patterson's perceptions. It seems we use different criteria to define "realism". This, by itself is enough, in my opinion, to put to rest all the arguments based on Patty's alleged "realism". Unless, of course one manages to assemble a definite set of criteria that we all (or most of us) can agree with. In other words, we are talking about standards, its about good methodology. And this is rare in bigfootery.

On the other hand, if PGF subject were shown at a sufficient level of detail, such divergences would be more rare. The actual detail level -enhancements included- leaves too much room for interpretation and pareidolia.

Correa, do you still think it looks completely homogeneous?
From what I can inferr from the film and available frames, yes.
pattyrightfoot.jpg

Seems quite homogeneous to me when it comes to density, lenght and color.

I still stand by my opinion that Bob Heironimus and the whole lot of them are out for as much media attention and coverage as they can get. Convenient that he waited until Patterson died and that a long time had passed before he came out with this "supposed info."
There are many other fishy details in PGF other than Hieronimus' story. Even if his account is proven false, PGF's fishy smell will stand.
 
Nobody asked me, but...

...snip...I already explained to you why there are no bones or cadavers around, and there actually is DNA evidence that is currently being studied.
Well, the alleged PNW über scavenging activity was brought a number of times before as a reasoning to explain the absence of a body (the search function will point you to the discussions). Proponents say the preservation odds are very small, while skeptics say they are not that small. Personally, I find the reasonings presented to explain why we haven't grabbed a bigfoot body so far to be quite weak. Remember, the clock started to count as soon as the first bigfoot arrived at North America.

...snip... Have you ever been hunting, have you ever lived or even been to the middle of NO-MAN's land? No.

This argument has a deep flaw. Bigfeet are being reported at places that can hardly be called no-man's land. Sighting reports are scattered across most North America, including areas that can be described as suburban. How they manage to avoid being hit by a car, shot or being captured at such places? Even if they avoid these deaths, well, if its alive it will eventually die. PNW's alleged intense scavenging activity will not be present in the burbs... The alleged stealthy evolutionary adaptation and being more intelligent than standard apes reasonings won't be of much help, since humans (including those who are trained in deception) can be tracked and humans quite often are hit by cars, shot down and usually found when dead. Unless, of course you propose bigfeet are more intelligent and stealthier than humans. The second part can be plausible. But the first one is a no-go,

Think about it, if you live in the middle of nowhere Canada and actually miraculously shoot yourself a Bigfoot, how would you even begin to transport it, much less care to. ...snip...
Chopp its head, or a hand or a foot. Grab a piece of skin or some bones.

Part of the biggest problem is that there just isn't enough funding and there aren't enough extensive, lengthy field studies to turn up much.
Another reasoning freqently raised and easilly countered. Bigfoot country has been and is still being the target of extensive and lenghty field works. Every single person doing research at what's alleged to be bigfoot country is a potential candidate to be the lucky one. It does not matter if the professional is looking for trees, fungi, deer, gold, etc. A 3m-tall ape is not something easy to miss, regardless of the stealthyness claims.

...snip...I'm just saying that I believe "something" made them tell the stories other than just fear.
OK, I've got no problem with that. I just want to add that this "something" may be something other than an ape unknown to science currently living in North America.
 
Right, Correa. You beat me to it while I'm playing catch-up. What I'm having a hard time comprehending is that if sgoodman72 has already read this thread than why produce so many flawed arguments that we've fully addressed 43 and a half times before?

Doesn't sgood remember the Vancouver Island marmots? The dead bear pictures? The archaeological, paleological, geological reports? Various forest service department's bear, cougar, lynx, etc., population reports?

Yes, really what is so hard to believe about a giant 8ft bipedal primate existing in sufficient breeding numbers from Alaska to Iowa to Florida with international brethren from England, various parts of continental Europe, Asia north, west, east, south, South Africa, Australia, Malaysia... Oh, and don't forget they like to pick through your trash, come into your home, molest your cans of beans with a screwdriver, tear up your dog, eat your cat, throw a pig, scream at you, chat with you, total your car, eat your garlic, come visit you in the city...
 
Last edited:
K., this thread is big and there were a number of looooooooooong bigfoot threads before, quite often discussing the very same things. Its not hard to let one or two things go, specially where flame wars erupt. Every now and then I can't find where we discussed a given issue...
 
My point is this: I would love if a crystal clear photo and film of an unknown, mostly erect hominid showed up on TV tomorrow. I'd be the first saying "Cool! Show me more!" But the simple fact of the matter is that all real research into the matter has turned up nothing but frauds, hucksters, and nonsense.

Sadly, Virginia, in this case there just doesn't appear to be a Santa Clause.

Avindair
I think I can safely say 'ditto' for the rest of us.

Just wanted to extend a friendly welcome to you, Avindair. Nice to have you here.:)
 
K., this thread is big and there were a number of looooooooooong bigfoot threads before, quite often discussing the very same things. Its not hard to let one or two things go, specially where flame wars erupt. Every now and then I can't find where we discussed a given issue...
Quite right. Actually, to be fair, now that I think about it IIRC the dead bear pics were in the Simple Challenge thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom