Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
MK now says he can see Patty's braided hair swing around her face.......
 

Attachments

  • Topknothairbraid (Small).jpg
    Topknothairbraid (Small).jpg
    39.4 KB · Views: 12
Her thigh has become a sack of potatoes, and her foot a flipper. Peyote Vision.

"A still photo can fool the heck out of you." MK Davis on the Tom Biscardi Show.

"I don't spin my films, but nearly everyone except M.K. Davis and Carol Solomon has had serious credibility issues. Go figure." Pat Holbrook (producer of Davis's new film on the PGF) on Cryptozoology.com.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, a quick look back on even the more recent postings to this thread shows Patterson hoaxing pictures of himself "at a campsite" searching for the big monkey. That he was willing to hoax even that image should be an enormous red flag to PGF supporters. The fact that it doesn't says a lot.

Avindair;

Your posts are a welcome change from the recent influx of psychotics and scammers we have experienced. You write well, and summarize the situation thoughtfully.

I realize that even with effective search engines, some of the material that gets posted in various forums can become effectively "buried", or at least very difficult to find. Consequently, I've thrown up yet another webpage devoted to elements of the Bigfoot issue. Here is my latest, a summary of my encounter with Jerry Merritt's niece.

http://orgoneresearch.com/did_roger_patterson_stage_his.htm
 
Given the recent "wrist-band" argument that surfaced again, I felt compelled to point out some pictures that can quickly invalidate some attempts at debunking the PG footage that I read a while ago.



Which skeptic was it again that said primates can't have hairy breasts?:

Female2.jpg



Looks like this little fella is wearing gloves too, notice the wrist bands. He's also got on a mask, you can tell by the folds:

Gloves2.gif



This old-timer is wearing football shoulder pads under that costume...:

Shoulder1.jpg



And finally, I think we found saggy diaper-butt the 2nd!:

Butt1.jpg



Some of these highly touted "flaws" and "anomalies" that would lead skeptics to think man in a suit, can easily be seen & found in nature.
 
The problem is, Bigfoot can't seem to be easily seen & found in nature ..

For that reason, the idea that Patty could be a man-in-a-suit, is more compelling than the idea she is a
Bigfoot ..

No one is arguing that the features seen on Patty cannot be found in nature, it is just being shown that they
certainly don't rule out a suit ....
 
Last edited:
Given the recent "wrist-band" argument that surfaced again, I felt compelled to point out some pictures that can quickly invalidate some attempts at debunking the PG footage that I read a while ago.



Which skeptic was it again that said primates can't have hairy breasts?:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Female2.jpg[/qimg]


Looks like this little fella is wearing gloves too, notice the wrist bands. He's also got on a mask, you can tell by the folds:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Gloves2.gif[/qimg]


This old-timer is wearing football shoulder pads under that costume...:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Shoulder1.jpg[/qimg]


And finally, I think we found saggy diaper-butt the 2nd!:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Butt1.jpg[/qimg]


Some of these highly touted "flaws" and "anomalies" that would lead skeptics to think man in a suit, can easily be seen & found in nature.

Where exactly do you see the wrist bands? All I see is hair.
 
Where exactly do you see the wrist bands? All I see is hair.

Glad you asked that, because all I see on Patty's wrist is hair as well..

Anyway, in my pic. the way the hair is laid back and kind of looks like it wraps around might lead to an illusion of a wrist band, just like in the PG footage is what I'm trying to point out. Again I'm not saying this is compelling evidence, I'm just saying that these things that have pointed out to Patty's being a 'man in a suit' can be found in nature.

Diogenes: Agreed on both counts, bigfoot can't be easily found in nature. If so we would have no discussion. Similarly from my POV, I don't think this fact leads to it being more likely a man in a suit, just leads to the fact that it can't be ruled out.

Again the point of my pictures were just to illustrate that certain anomalies can and do exist. It seems some skeptics didn't believe this was possible.
 
Again the point of my pictures were just to illustrate that certain anomalies can and do exist. It seems some skeptics didn't believe this was possible.

That isn't the important point from my perspective. What is going on is that believers create excuses and diversions for features that may reveal a costume. That means that if it is a suit and there are visual indicators of a suit - the believers will explain this evidence as not being valid. If you can find something similar in a living gorilla then you can't just say it's a suit.

This abuses rationality and reason because a person is deprived of the clues that they could use in identifying a hoax. Think you see an obvious padding flaw in the costume? Nope, it's a thigh hernia on a living Bigfoot.
 
Given the quality of the source material i cant see how someone can say yay or nay to a suit, let alone details on the supposed suit. The source is so tiny and of such poor quality that it effectively becomes a Rorshach inkblot that people superimpose their beliefs on. Skeptics see a guy in a suit and believers see a female sasquatch with pendulous breasts and detailed feet. All we can say for sure us that the guy filmed a hairy biped in a forest, and that's it.

It appears to me that the only reason it hasn't been accepted as completely debunked by now is the rubbish quality and the length of time that has passed since it was taken. For me I'll continue to use the fact that there is absolutely no hard evidence, no specimens and no scientific foundation for the creature as my guide to being skeptical of the whole thing. Show me a bigfoot, live or dead, and put Grandpas home movie away.
 
Given the recent "wrist-band" argument that surfaced again, I felt compelled to point out some pictures that can quickly invalidate some attempts at debunking the PG footage that I read a while ago.
"Quickly invalidate"? Sorry, but I think this is not the case.
First of all, great part of the arguments are related to personal perceptions of the footage (ex: "realism"). As you probably noticed, such alleged "realism" is not perceived by many (myself included). Who's right? Or who's closer to the reality?

This put, lets check the pics.

Which skeptic was it again that said primates can't have hairy breasts?:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Female2.jpg[/qimg]
Look closer. You can see skin underneath the hairs. Patty, from what can be seen at PGF, has a relatively homogeneous hair cover. Her breasts are fully covered by hair. Not to mention that their placement and near immobility look completely artificial for me.

Looks like this little fella is wearing gloves too, notice the wrist bands. He's also got on a mask, you can tell by the folds:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Gloves2.gif[/qimg]
So, the feature can, in your opinion, be a natural feature. But it can also be seen in costumes... This point by itselt is inconclusive.

This old-timer is wearing football shoulder pads under that costume...:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Shoulder1.jpg[/qimg]
Please alow me to pull a common proponent line:
"You've gotta show us it in movment, not in stills":p
The pic, however, does not looks like what we can see at PGF, in my opinion.

I would also like to use the opportunity to point out how inhomogeneous is hair cover and lenght in those apes. Patty, on the other hand, seems to have very homoneous hair when it comes to density, lenght and tone.

And finally, I think we found saggy diaper-butt the 2nd!:

[qimg]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v194/lupisanguinis/Butt1.jpg[/qimg]
This is probably the weakest one.
That butt, contrary to Patty's is not covered with hair. Its a sexual trait developed in certain knuckle-walking apes (and monkeys IIRC); this trait is highly unlikely in bipedal primates.

Some of these highly touted "flaws" and "anomalies" that would lead skeptics to think man in a suit, can easily be seen & found in nature.
Not exactly, I would say, since these features (as well as all others) can be reproduced by costumes with tech from the 60's or before. Adding to this the many other issues pointed before, the default position becomes "hoax". At least, that's the way I see it.

Now, in case you wonder what could make me change my opinion, here are a couple (note that I will only cite evidence, I will not cite proof):
-Footage of stills showing similar creatures; they would not need to be of better quality, they would have however, to come from more credited sources.
-Fossils of creatures in North America whose reconstructions indicated a Patty-like animal.
-A better match between Patty and the renderings based in sighting reports, if the criteria used to make these renderings were solid.

Unfortunately, none of the above are available.
 
I couldn't figure out which BF thread to put this in, so I put it here:

There is a discourse on BFF which shows just how irrational and unreasonable the Bigfooters can be. Ironically, it is in a thread about Bigfoot intelligence.

trgol_99 said:
My thought is, sure if they are real, they must have a very high intelligence to avoid capture/ detection for so long. Don't you think though that one or two might be born stupid and carelessly get caught? Just a thought.

Texas Bigfoot said:
Yep. Probably died before they were adults.

redratsnake said:
Gotta agree with that.

This makes no sense whatsoever. Yep, there are probably careless young Bigfoots that get captured by humans. Yep. No wait - I mean they die before they ever get captured. Yep. The skills required to avoid outright capture, videocameras and leaving your DNA anywhere are the same as such things as avoiding rattlesnakes, sheer cliffs and fatal diseases, etc. Yep.
 
"Quickly invalidate"? Sorry, but I think this is not the case.
First of all, great part of the arguments are related to personal perceptions of the footage (ex: "realism"). As you probably noticed, such alleged "realism" is not perceived by many (myself included). Who's right? Or who's closer to the reality?

This put, lets check the pics.

Look closer. You can see skin underneath the hairs. Patty, from what can be seen at PGF, has a relatively homogeneous hair cover. Her breasts are fully covered by hair. Not to mention that their placement and near immobility look completely artificial for me.

Well, there are some areas that you can see the wearing away of hair, take her calves for instance, also I think there are a few other spots. And again the video is such poor quality, it's hard to tell just how homogeneous or not it is, I'm just saying hair is possible. Also this picture of mine is only 1 gorilla, I'm sure there are others that are "hairier."

I would also like to use the opportunity to point out how inhomogeneous is hair cover and lenght in those apes. Patty, on the other hand, seems to have very homoneous hair when it comes to density, lenght and tone.

I could readily find more sources or pictures of apes that have more homogeneous hair cover. And again, Patty only appears to have homogeneous hair cover, we don't know for sure without having better clarity. And even then I still see some spots on the calves where hair is worn away from walk.

This is probably the weakest one.
That butt, contrary to Patty's is not covered with hair. Its a sexual trait developed in certain knuckle-walking apes (and monkeys IIRC); this trait is highly unlikely in bipedal primates.

I agree with you, this is the weakest of the lot. But I just wanted to make a statement.

Not exactly, I would say, since these features (as well as all others) can be reproduced by costumes with tech from the 60's or before. Adding to this the many other issues pointed before, the default position becomes "hoax". At least, that's the way I see it.

Reproduced using 60's technology? How come I still haven't seen anything even remotely close to the realism of Patty that was made from 60's technology? Please provide a source for that claim.

Now, in case you wonder what could make me change my opinion, here are a couple (note that I will only cite evidence, I will not cite proof):
-Footage of stills showing similar creatures; they would not need to be of better quality, they would have however, to come from more credited sources.
-Fossils of creatures in North America whose reconstructions indicated a Patty-like animal.
-A better match between Patty and the renderings based in sighting reports, if the criteria used to make these renderings were solid.

Unfortunately, none of the above are available.

How about Native American folklore centering around Bigfoot? How about the names they have for them and stories for the creature that would nowadays be described as Bigfoot? I guess we can just forget about them, afterall they smoked the peace pipe all day right? They must be completely dillusional. Please...they have nothing to hide and nothing to lie about at all.

And to Kenny 10 Bellys:
Also you're not going to find a Bigfoot body or bones in the wild b/c do you understand just how quickly the decomposition cycle takes in the wild? Try a matter of days. A body is picked clean and the bugs, nature, and weather take care of the rest. There was a documentary done on this not long back (I can find this if you'd like) and the total time for a large megafauna creature was about a little over a week. (To the analysts that will certainly nit-pick my choice of words, maybe I mean to say large animal and not specifically megafauna). Anyway, all of this having been said, this is assuming that Bigfoot aren't intellegent creatures that may in fact take their dead with them, bury them, or do something for disposal.

The only way you would find a dead one is Road-kill. And if these creatures have spent decades and centuries avoiding us, you think they're stupid enough to hear some huge loud automobile and just run up to this loud noise, and then get hit? No, they can hear that from miles away and would steer well clear, and that's assuming they're even near a road.
 
Last edited:
Well, there are some areas that you can see the wearing away of hair, take her calves for instance, also I think there are a few other spots. And again the video is such poor quality, it's hard to tell just how homogeneous or not it is, I'm just saying hair is possible. Also this picture of mine is only 1 gorilla, I'm sure there are others that are "hairier."

And again, Patty only appears to have homogeneous hair cover, we don't know for sure without having better clarity. And even then I still see some spots on the calves where hair is worn away from walk.

Bob Heironimus is the only person to have publicly confessed to wearing the Patty suit. He might be lying about that. But, his testimony is this...

Roger Patterson took the Patty suit and intentionally clipped/shaved the fur to give it a natural appearance, or at least what he thought would look natural. He was going for a strategic non-homogeneous look I suppose. Bob further states that Patterson also took this suit and rubbed/abraded it in the ground to give it a look of an animal that lives in close contact with this (sitting, kneeling, laying, rolling or whatever). The point was to make it look like a real living Bigfoot.

Some of that may have been lost in the camera distance and resolution. But we do have people seeing this "patchiness" and saying it looks natural. Bob is saying that that look was by design and effort. FWIW.
 
PS: If you believe that BH is telling the truth about what Roger did to the suit, then it has an important implication.

At some point, the fur suit was in a state that compelled Roger to modify the fur. Whether he made it himself, or ordered it from Hollywood, he decided that the fur was too long or thick in certain places to give this natural look he envisioned. It doesn't matter if the fur suit started as a gorilla costume or was made to look like a Bigfoot from the start - Patterson decided to modify the fur of whatever he had. It wasn't quite right, and he proceeded to make it right.
 
When it comes to what could be done with vintage FX tech, check
http://www.gorillamen.com/
Plenty of pics and articles on vintage gorilla suits.
http://www.gorillamen.com/index.php?...T-MYSTERY.html
The links below show af pics and footage of vintage gorilla costumes
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2743757&postcount=5555
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jIv5WfpTojs
http://br.youtube.com/watch?v=sku8_fkFQyc
http://br.youtube.com/watch?v=omYbewLi8mE
Note that none of the cases above is a high-budget film.

It would also be for you interesting to check posts by AtomicMisteryMonster, Dfoot and diogenes on this issue.

Once again, the key point is regarding the perceptions of realism in Patty's figure. There's a major difference in the perceptions of "realism levels" in PGF. Again, I see no such realism.

Patty's hair, again, judging from the stills, seem quite homogeneous and frankly speaking, artificial-looking. I see no reason to suppose it "may not" be homogeneous as it seems to be.

Regarding Native American myths, you may eventually have found already the discussions we had on this subject (Kathy Strain participated also). I fail to see how Native American lore can validate Patty. You will find several mythical wildmen in Native North American lore; their descriptions and behavior are quite variable. Too variable, I would say, to be of any use to validate Patty's figure, unless of course you consider "hairy and bipedal" as enough- I do not.

Note also that some are not tall, while some are not hairy- its actually a big mix. To derive support for Patty among those myths require what I consider to be an arbritrary cherry-picking of characteristics. An this can be a completely flawed methodological approach.

I say one must be very carefull when interpretating myths outside their original context. Myths can not be taken as reliable evidence for the existence of bigfeet or the claim PGF is real or any other crypto.

Myths can behave like mirrors. In some cases, these mirrors will show the images you want to see. Here are some links that can eventually help you to understand a bit more my opinion. I could, for example, make other interpretations, involving or not a real, flesh-and-bones bipedal ape.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2354309&postcount=2201
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2295981&postcount=1050
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2315045&postcount=1264
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2357805&postcount=2309
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1454693&postcount=2554
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1622504&postcount=19
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2304739&postcount=1122
 
...snip... I guess we can just forget about them, afterall they smoked the peace pipe all day right? They must be completely dillusional. Please...they have nothing to hide and nothing to lie about at all...snip...
I just noticed this paragraph. I doubt anyone here -skeptic or not- with a minimum knoweledge about mythology and the human psique would have such a position.

It sounds a bit like that "skeptics say you all who saw UFOs (or bigfeet) are liars" fallacy.

Its mythology. Its not a "lie". Myths are not lies, they are what they are- myths. Even when representing a ficticious entity, a myth is not a lie. Greek mythology has tales about sirens, the hydra, scylla, charybids, etc. None of these creatures are real. And despite of this no one here would say greek mythology is a lie.
 
Last edited:
Points well taken about Native American folklore I suppose, however all myths, folklore, and legend is based on fact at some level. Take it for what it is.

However, Correa Neto and William, your arguments appear to diverge.

Correa Neto:
Patty's hair, again, judging from the stills, seem quite homogeneous and frankly speaking, artificial-looking. I see no reason to suppose it "may not" be homogeneous as it seems to be.

Look closer. You can see skin underneath the hairs. Patty, from what can be seen at PGF, has a relatively homogeneous hair cover.


William Parcher:
At some point, the fur suit was in a state that compelled Roger to modify the fur. Whether he made it himself, or ordered it from Hollywood, he decided that the fur was too long or thick in certain places to give this natural look he envisioned. It doesn't matter if the fur suit started as a gorilla costume or was made to look like a Bigfoot from the start - Patterson decided to modify the fur of whatever he had. It wasn't quite right, and he proceeded to make it right.

Roger Patterson took the Patty suit and intentionally clipped/shaved the fur to give it a natural appearance, or at least what he thought would look natural. He was going for a strategic non-homogeneous look I suppose.

I'm not trying to divert or nit-pick, but it does raise an important issue. So William, by stating that Patterson (via Bob H's input) "admitted" to altering Patty's appearance to make it natural looking, this means that you see it as non-homogeneous as well. However Correa Neto feels otherwise.

Correa, do you still think it looks completely homogeneous?

I still stand by my opinion that Bob Heironimus and the whole lot of them are out for as much media attention and coverage as they can get. Convenient that he waited until Patterson died and that a long time had passed before he came out with this "supposed info."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom