Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
As AMM said, I'd be interested to hear a lawyer's perspective on why they are blatantly wrong. The forms are very simple. Title, date of publication, authors, claimants.

Do small variations or typos count? Various LoC records refer to the title as "Bigfoot" versus "Big Foot". The film itself says "Big Foot". The Agreement of Sale and Transfer from the Gimlins to Dahinden has one instance where the name is spelled "Gimlim".

I can give you specifics when I get back and can assimilate the information I left hanging before I got deployed and had to put the project on hold ( hard to get things done from the middle of Hell) but in short.

The only thing thats "blatantly wrong" is Johnson's claims that the PGF is in the public domain.

>>>Do small variations or typos count? Various LoC records refer to the title as "Bigfoot" versus "Big Foot". The film itself says "Big Foot". The Agreement of Sale and Transfer from the Gimlins to Dahinden has one instance where the name is spelled "Gimlim

No, the only times such things would matter would be on percentages of infringement and that doesnt apply here.

Heres the short list without a ton of legal mumbo jumbo

The PGF film was copyrighted. What it was titled doesnt really matter- he could have called it "Rogers Big Bluff Creek adventure" and that has no bearing on the images because thats the source of the copyrighted material- a title is just for indexing and cataloging.

The film has also been adjudicated in a court of law ( that superceeds everything-including the LOC if it were challenged as the LOC makes it clear they are NOT a legal body but merely a repository and date stamp for records)

So, lets make sure the right questions are being addressed.

1) is the PGF in the public domain- clearly NO

2) who owns it- thats where the letter of Wa law, survivorship and contract law come into play. ( and what we are looking into) Thats still up in the air

3) ALL current research ( which as of this posting is INCOMPLETE and not fully independantly verified) indicates that Patricia Patterson owns the film and all rights in full.

4) The Gimlin/Dahindin sale/transfer/whatever- That sale did factually occur. No question about it. The question isnt "did it happen" but "is it LEGALLY solvent" and thats whats being currently ( altho stalled at the moment due to current circumstances) looked into.
 
I just put together an animated-gif of Patty and Jim....at the same point in their walks....right next to a piece of wood...(or, something that at least looks like a piece of wood :) )...


PattyJimWalkAG5.gif




I used the stump, highlighted in red, to scale the two images.

One thing to note, is that Patty walked in front of the wood, while Jim walked right behind it.


In this comparison, Patty's 'walking height' appears to very closely match Jim's 'walking height'.


More......later...:rolleyes:...
 
Last edited:
I just put together an animated-gif of Patty and Jim....at the same point in their walks....right next to a piece of wood...(or, something that at least looks like a piece of wood :) )...


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Jim%20McClarin/PattyJimWalkAG5.gif[/qimg]



I used the stump, highlighted in red, to scale the two images.

One thing to note, is that Patty walked in front of the wood, while Jim walked right behind it.


In this comparison, Patty's 'walking height' appears to very closely match Jim's 'walking height'.


More......later...:rolleyes:...

Your GIF shows that Mclarin is taller than Patty. Boy, Sweaty, what a great way to revive this mystery! :rolleyes:
 
Your GIF shows that Mclarin is taller than Patty. Boy, Sweaty, what a great way to revive this mystery! :rolleyes:


Can you show how you determined that, Mak??


The tops of their heads appear to be at the same level, to me.



There are different factors to consider, concerning how their 'body heights' compare.
One is that Jim is further away from the spot where Roger was standing, than Patty is...since he is behind the piece of wood.

That factor would tend to make Patty appear taller than she would if Jim was standing in the exact same spot as Patty....i.e...in front of the wood.



Another factor to consider is the fact that Jim's posture is more upright than Patty's....between his back, and his legs being 'less bent' than Patty's.

That factor tends to make Patty appear shorter than she would if she was standing as upright as Jim is.
 
Last edited:
Can you show how you determined that, Mak??

When it showed Mclarin, I put the tip of my mouse on top of his head, and it then flipped to patty, who was clearly shorter than where my arrow was
 
And then....there's 'body width'...and depth....(massiveness ;) )


Oh, and just for fun......place your mouse cursor right at Patty's fingertips.....and wait for Jim's short arms to appear. :)
 
Last edited:
When it showed Mclarin, I put the tip of my mouse on top of his head, and it then flipped to patty, who was clearly shorter than where my arrow was


I don't know, Mak....you must have a different Brand monitor than I do...



EDITED: to respond to the post directly below....(seems impossible...don't it?! :cool:)...


Different monitors, Mak......that explains it...:boggled:.
 
Last edited:
In brief, Mr. Yeti, that "piece of wood" (or whatever it is) you're using to scale the images could easily have moved, owing to flooding or wind, between the time the P-G footage was shot and the time the McClarin pics were snapped. This distorts the presumed distance of the subject from the camera, and throws off the accuracy of any comparison analysis we might care to make. Also, as I've pointed out repeatedly elsewhere, different lens sizes -- in both the camera and the enlarger -- will distort the apparent height of a given subject, so that, again, any comparison analysis between the two that does not include certain knowledge of the lenses used is, in a word, worthless. Also, in each of the two images, the "tree stump" is in a different position relative to the subject, to the camera and to the slender tree in the background. Did the stump somehow move? If it did, it cannot be used to scale the images, since it might be closer or farther from the camera and therefore larger or smaller in the frame respectively. Also, a fur suit can easily add bulk and the illusion of mass to the performer inside. Thanks for the effort, but your comparison is a-scientific and illogical in the extreme.
 
Thanks for the effort, but your comparison is a-scientific and illogical in the extreme

Would you consider it "a-scientific" if Sweaty was setting out to show that Patty was a man in a suit?
 
In brief, Mr. Yeti, that "piece of wood" (or whatever it is) you're using to scale the images could easily have moved, owing to flooding or wind, between the time the P-G footage was shot and the time the McClarin pics were snapped. This distorts the presumed distance of the subject from the camera, and throws off the accuracy of any comparison analysis we might care to make. Also, as I've pointed out repeatedly elsewhere, different lens sizes -- in both the camera and the enlarger -- will distort the apparent height of a given subject, so that, again, any comparison analysis between the two that does not include certain knowledge of the lenses used is, in a word, worthless. Also, in each of the two images, the "tree stump" is in a different position relative to the subject, to the camera and to the slender tree in the background. Did the stump somehow move? If it did, it cannot be used to scale the images, since it might be closer or farther from the camera and therefore larger or smaller in the frame respectively. Also, a fur suit can easily add bulk and the illusion of mass to the performer inside. Thanks for the effort, but your comparison is a-scientific and illogical in the extreme.

Vortigern99,
The part I bolded and italicised is what made the two pictures look distorted. Especially the stump and the slender tree. I wonder how the pictures could be compared when the comparative "stumps" are different shapes and move from picture to picture.
The slender tree seems to be completely upright in one picture and listing a little in the other picture. If the pictures could be put on top of each other, match the surroundings exactly could they be used as a comparison?
 
Vortigern99,
The part I bolded and italicised is what made the two pictures look distorted. Especially the stump and the slender tree. I wonder how the pictures could be compared when the comparative "stumps" are different shapes and move from picture to picture.
The slender tree seems to be completely upright in one picture and listing a little in the other picture. If the pictures could be put on top of each other, match the surroundings exactly could they be used as a comparison?

It's probably only the position of the photographer(s) that changes from image to image. It's impossible to be certain, but it looks as though the stump is in the same place geographically speaking, and the camera has moved back and to the left from P-G to McClarin. Then again, the "stump" might not be rooted to the ground at all and has simply moved along with the other debris on the sandbar. Since it's impossible to determine the truth one way or the other, the images cannot be accurately measured or compared.
 
It's probably only the position of the photographer(s) that changes from image to image. It's impossible to be certain, but it looks as though the stump is in the same place geographically speaking, and the camera has moved back and to the left from P-G to McClarin. Then again, the "stump" might not be rooted to the ground at all and has simply moved along with the other debris on the sandbar. Since it's impossible to determine the truth one way or the other, the images cannot be accurately measured or compared.

Oh! I see it now. Back and to the left. It's strange I made the assumption that both cameras were in the right spot, but the lenses were different.
Must be Munns on my mind! LOL
 
Patterson capturing the beast, while getting closer, really skews the height estimates, and makes it harder to compare an object for scale
 
In brief, Mr. Yeti, that "piece of wood" (or whatever it is) you're using to scale the images could easily have moved, owing to flooding or wind, between the time the P-G footage was shot and the time the McClarin pics were snapped.


Perhaps....but, in all probability, it didn't move.


In this PG Film frame, the 'wood's' orientation (it runs lengthwise side-to-side, in the image, as opposed to front-to-back)....appears to be exactly the same as in the McClarin image....and, in addition, in both images, it also appears to be slightly higher on it's left side...


PattyStone4FullStride-1.jpg
McClarinStone4B.jpg



If the wood had actually moved since the PG Film was shot...it's orientation would most likely have changed.




Also, as I've pointed out repeatedly elsewhere, different lens sizes -- in both the camera and the enlarger -- will distort the apparent height of a given subject, so that, again, any comparison analysis between the two that does not include certain knowledge of the lenses used is, in a word, worthless.



A gift...:)....for Vort, and Astro...


Invalid2.jpg




Feel free to use it, anytime you see a comparison involving Patty. :covereyes



Also, a fur suit can easily add bulk and the illusion of mass to the performer inside.

You're right, Vort! It can.
 
Last edited:
Patterson capturing the beast, while getting closer, really skews the height estimates, and makes it harder to compare an object for scale
Rubbish.

Using true photogrammetrical methods, overlapping frames of the same subjects shot with the same camera/lens, but in different shooting positions makes it EASIER to determine position and height of the subject.

In fact that last sentence practically describes a photogrammetrical method.
 
Kilaak Kommander said:
As AMM said, I'd be interested to hear a lawyer's perspective on why they are blatantly wrong. The forms are very simple. Title, date of publication, authors, claimants.

Thanks for the input!

Getting back on topic, my brother recently convinced me to watch an episode of "Real Chance of Love 2: Back in the Saddle" (after telling me that it was the most absurdly over-the-top reality show ever). So imagine my surprise when one of the hosts made fun of a contestant's walk by doing an imitation of the Patty walk and carrying out a Bigfoot statue in that pose. Judging from this episode, said host seems to have a strong fondness for Bigfoot.
 
Rubbish.

Using true photogrammetrical methods, overlapping frames of the same subjects shot with the same camera/lens, but in different shooting positions makes it EASIER to determine position and height of the subject.

In fact that last sentence practically describes a photogrammetrical method.


Thank you EHocking. I think I am getting closer to understanding this now.
:)
 
Thanks for the input!

Getting back on topic, my brother recently convinced me to watch an episode of "Real Chance of Love 2: Back in the Saddle" (after telling me that it was the most absurdly over-the-top reality show ever). So imagine my surprise when one of the hosts made fun of a contestant's walk by doing an imitation of the Patty walk and carrying out a Bigfoot statue in that pose. Judging from this episode, said host seems to have a strong fondness for Bigfoot.


I will admit I watch these foolish shows. When RCL said they were going after Bigfoot, I about fell out of my chair.
I never thought anyone on this forum would mention it. So glad you did AMM.
Yes, I am a grown woman but these show are funny and entertaining, especially since the brothers have gotten a sense of humor about themselves.
:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom