LONGTABBER PE
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2008
- Messages
- 1,528
As AMM said, I'd be interested to hear a lawyer's perspective on why they are blatantly wrong. The forms are very simple. Title, date of publication, authors, claimants.
Do small variations or typos count? Various LoC records refer to the title as "Bigfoot" versus "Big Foot". The film itself says "Big Foot". The Agreement of Sale and Transfer from the Gimlins to Dahinden has one instance where the name is spelled "Gimlim".
I can give you specifics when I get back and can assimilate the information I left hanging before I got deployed and had to put the project on hold ( hard to get things done from the middle of Hell) but in short.
The only thing thats "blatantly wrong" is Johnson's claims that the PGF is in the public domain.
>>>Do small variations or typos count? Various LoC records refer to the title as "Bigfoot" versus "Big Foot". The film itself says "Big Foot". The Agreement of Sale and Transfer from the Gimlins to Dahinden has one instance where the name is spelled "Gimlim
No, the only times such things would matter would be on percentages of infringement and that doesnt apply here.
Heres the short list without a ton of legal mumbo jumbo
The PGF film was copyrighted. What it was titled doesnt really matter- he could have called it "Rogers Big Bluff Creek adventure" and that has no bearing on the images because thats the source of the copyrighted material- a title is just for indexing and cataloging.
The film has also been adjudicated in a court of law ( that superceeds everything-including the LOC if it were challenged as the LOC makes it clear they are NOT a legal body but merely a repository and date stamp for records)
So, lets make sure the right questions are being addressed.
1) is the PGF in the public domain- clearly NO
2) who owns it- thats where the letter of Wa law, survivorship and contract law come into play. ( and what we are looking into) Thats still up in the air
3) ALL current research ( which as of this posting is INCOMPLETE and not fully independantly verified) indicates that Patricia Patterson owns the film and all rights in full.
4) The Gimlin/Dahindin sale/transfer/whatever- That sale did factually occur. No question about it. The question isnt "did it happen" but "is it LEGALLY solvent" and thats whats being currently ( altho stalled at the moment due to current circumstances) looked into.
.