Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Daniel Perez has made a rare appearance on BFF to start a new thread titled "STANDING" OR "SQUATTING?", First view of Patty, prior to filming.

It could have been be subtitled "Contradictions and discrepancies in P&G testimonies are not an indication of a hoax".


Perez said:
Knowing the details of the P-G film probably better than anyone,

A little self-promotion. He has stuff for sale.

Roger Patterson: "As we rounded a bend in the trail I caught a glimpse of something huge crouched down by the creek." Perez then explains why Gimlin talks about standing by the creek instead of crouching or squatting. Perez ends the post with "Personally, I don't consider it a serious discrepancy as it can - I firmly believe - be easily explained." All better now.

But Perez has another quote in there...

Some early confirmation of this comes from Peter Byrne’s long defunct newsletter, Bigfoot News, January 1975, page 4: "According to the photographers the creature was squatting in the water at the edge of the stream, when first seen."

Hey Daniel, did you know that Gimlin also recently said she was first seen about 18" from the water? I guess it was Patterson alone who saw her squatting in the water while being thrown from his horse. Gimlin saw nothing until she had already stood up and backed away from the water. All better now.

Hey Daniel, what about the cowboys tracking Patty for 3.5 miles before coming back to cast the footprints? Reporter error that should have read 35 yards. All better now.
 
Daniel Perez has made a rare appearance on BFF to start a new thread titled "STANDING" OR "SQUATTING?", First view of Patty, prior to filming.

It could have been be subtitled "Contradictions and discrepancies in P&G testimonies are not an indication of a hoax".

Oh dear. How do I leave that alone? Yes, I think that Perez was definitely squatting...

A little self-promotion. He has stuff for sale.

I think Greg observation in that thread pretty much summed it up...

Skeptical Greg @ BFF said:
The relevance, is that it was asked in a thread that someone else started, about another apparent contradiction..

On the other hand, the OP looks more like a rhetorical dissertation, to stir up interest in a newsletter that is for sale, rather than to actually discuss the contradiction .. ( ... not implying that there is anything wrong with that )

Nice of P. Beaton to give Perez a nice subtle plug...

P. Beaton @ BFF said:
Skeptical Greg,

No worries, I've already addressed descrepincies an or contradictions regardin' ones ability to recall events of the past.
An I reckon I can see what you're sayin' regardin' Daniels post. As someone who subscribes to that fine newsletter BIGFOOT TIMES, an looks forward to it each month, for only 15 bucks CDN, 14 bucks US, filled with the latest up to date info. on what's goin' on in research, findin's, up comin' BF meets etc. A great monthly read for those interested in the subject...
Oooops...I think I may be ramblin'...

Pat...

BTW, minor non sequitur quibble but P. Beaton's style of posting at the BFF makes me want to vomit in tinfoil and it it. It's really irritating. Reading his posts causes me to hear Gomer Pyle and eefin' in my head. I don't know if he's trying to channel Matthew McConaughey or what but whatever it is, it's turning out badly.
 
This is from a closed PGF thread...

LONGTABBER PE said:
I guess ( I really dont remember the number or what it was supposed to be)

I admit I dont buy the claim that one still from the original just somehow "accidently" escaped copyright and just "appeared" in public domain ( or most other urban legends regarding the PGF, its location and who owns what)

I'm beginning to think the "mystery" is really very simple.

I would like to know any information or explanation of how this one lone frame got to be public domain. ( even tho I dont believe it factually is)

was it not a part of the original film as some claim?

( developing a theory here)


I just found this on CZ.com. John Johnsen/Grendel Films is who produced MK Davis' "documentary" on the PGF.

John Johnsen said:
Yes, the PG Film is in the public domain...solidly.

In my research of the ownership of the Patterson Gimlin Film my attorney (intellectual property board certified) found that the records in the US Copyright Office were beyond screwed up, they were blatantly wrong. Upon my followup he (my attorney) told me that the LAST place to look for property ownership was the copyright office. And, that it was only a records keeping facility, not an absolute guarantee of ownership.
 
I just found this on CZ.com. John Johnsen/Grendel Films is who produced MK Davis' "documentary" on the PGF.

John Johnsen said:
Yes, the PG Film is in the public domain...solidly.

In my research of the ownership of the Patterson Gimlin Film my attorney (intellectual property board certified) found that the records in the US Copyright Office were beyond screwed up, they were blatantly wrong.

I'd love to hear more details about how the records were screwed up so that Longtabber and Kilaak Kommander could provide some insight.

Upon my followup he (my attorney) told me that the LAST place to look for property ownership was the copyright office. And, that it was only a records keeping facility, not an absolute guarantee of ownership.

Although there is some truth in this statement (it is possible to file a false claim), I'm stunned that anyone who's supposed to be intellectual property board certified would completely write off the copyright office by saying it was the last place to look. I should also note that my view on the matter is influenced by incidents where lawyers goofed on saying copyright films were in the public domain.
 
Last edited:
Yes, the PG Film is in the public domain...solidly.

No. it won't be before any number of years.

The US copyright act of ~70 made it so that it stays copyrighted at least 75 years or 50 years after the death of the author (so : at least until 2022) and unless EXPLICITELY transferred to somebody stays with the author and executor after its death. It does *NOT* matter that who get the copyright ownership is unclear, it does not make it public domain. It just MIGHT make dispute more likely in case of licensing and more than 1 claim of ownership. I don#t think this is the case as nobody else that PP claim ownership of the film today, isn't it ?

And i am not up to snuff for the latest copyright extension but I betcha they also apply and make it copyrighted until in the 2050+.

The PGF is *NOT* solidly in the public domain, it is actually not a single bit of it in the public domain.
 
Last edited:
No. it won't be before any number of years.

The US copyright act of ~70 made it so that it stays copyrighted at least 75 years or 50 years after the death of the author (so : at least until 2022) and unless EXPLICITELY transferred to somebody stays with the author and executor after its death.

I think you're referring to the Copyright Act of 1976. Originally, I didn't think that anything "published" prior to the January 1, 1978 effective date qualified for the extension, especially not after taking a little refresher course by reading this. However, further reading led me to this:

For works that received their copyright before 1978, a renewal had to be filed in the work's 28th year with the Library of Congress Copyright Office for its term of protection to be extended.

Which seem to say that it does apply to pre-1978 works under certain conditions.
 
I asked an advertising exec friend to check on it, He thinks he could use it for free in a commercial. Is it perhaps that if the film's use is unchallenged by the copyright holder for x amount of years then it is considered P.D.? Kind of like squatters rights? Anyone know?
 
Is it perhaps that if the film's use is unchallenged by the copyright holder for x amount of years then it is considered P.D.? Kind of like squatters rights? Anyone know?

No, it doesn't work like that with copyrights. However, something like that can happen with trademarks.
 
Last edited:
I asked an advertising exec friend to check on it, He thinks he could use it for free in a commercial. Is it perhaps that if the film's use is unchallenged by the copyright holder for x amount of years then it is considered P.D.? Kind of like squatters rights? Anyone know?

Well, this is flying from memory ( and stalled due to deployment) but as far as we have been able to verify- the copyright of the PGF is fully in effect and belongs to Mrs. Patterson.

The issue regarding the solvency of the sale of Gimlin's "part" to RD is still in the air.
 
Here we go. Somebody had put the wrong Alderfoot in there. Doh! :blush:


Somebody else has put the right Alderfoot in there. Doh! :blush:


9a0e8817.jpg
 
Carried over from the MonsterQuest thread...


Here's the 1st bit that caught my eye..
They feature some guy named David Murphy who has finished a Biography of Patterson.

He says he interviewed over 70 people who knew Patterson & Gimlin, and not one of them did not hold both men in high regard...

I wonder why they didn't consult Greg Long in this regard .. 'Think maybe they contacted him and he declined ?:rolleyes:


David Murphy lecture review on BFF.

In 2004 he began corresponding with Patricia Patterson to coordinate the opportunity to preserve Roger's bigfoot bust. A book was published at the time that vilified Roger's name and reputation and he discussed writing the true story with the permission of Mrs. Patterson.

David showed us photographs of Roger's childhood home, the property where he lived in 1967 and Jerry Merritt's house, a location that involved two sightings noted in Roger's book. He had a photo of Roger's bigfoot restraint made of steel bars that he hoped to utilize once he had tranquilized one.


The book took like forever to write.

Having interviewed more than 45 individuals who had contact at some stage in Roger's life and having recorded over 100 hours of taped testimony, David Murphy has a unique insight into this amazing man's life. You will learn about Roger the family man, rodeo rider, cowboy,acrobat and yes Bigfoot hunter.


MoMoMurphy speaks...

For those that want to mention $10,000 per pop for showing the P/G film, that is wrong information. The $10,000 price was not typical, but was because of the obvious negative view that would be associated with this show. Pat obviously does not want this footage used for a debunking attempt such as this. The film licensing fee is usually far, far less than the fee given. Furthermore, they used at least one still that Pat owns the T.V. rights to that they did not get permission to use. I have first hand experience with Bob H. while visiting Bob G. and I can state that Bob H. acted about as mature as a fourteen year old who was trying to impress someone very hard. Every other phrase out of his mouth was,"F***ING AYEE" while constantly swallowing hard as people tend to do when they are very anxious. In addition, I have interviewed no less than 4 people on tape, 1 who is a friend of Bob H. who have told me the same basic thing, That Bob H. and brothers had a reputation in high school and after for being drinkers, fighters and being full of B.S.

I know some stories about Bob H. and his family that I simply will not repeat because it would hurt others in his family that I don't want to drag into this story, but Bob H. or Honker to his friends has done some not so wonderful things in his life at times.

By the way, if anyone wants to get a private investigator to look into Greg Long's background, I am sure you could find some more people who knew him that would have some more severe things to say about him, beyond just turning in a Movie camera late.

I would also like to clear up one piece of mistaken information. Pat Patterson has not commissioned me to do a book about Roger Patterson. I am doing it fully on my own. I have obtained her support, but this is my project and beyond contact information and some factual data info. Pat Patterson is not influencing this book in a way that she has rights or control over this project. She can only control her own contributions. Anyone wanting to contact me privately may do so by emailing me and requesting contact info.

Thanks!

David Murphy


Even more... yes taking forever...

HarryHenderson said:
If such a book as described really exists and is or will be published soon, I can't see how it wouldn't be one of the most important books on the entire subject to date. I'm of the opinion a great deal of the general public's 'belief' in the idea of Bigfoot™ rests on the PGF. And despite Greg Long's 3rd grade attempt at showing the man was a myth, an 'authorized' insider's take on it could be significant in value and insight, both pro and con. Put me on Bill's list, I wanna be kept posted.
 
"...so yer sayin there's still a chance?" That...the book exists and...it's on it's w...oh wait, it doesn't exist but so wants to...umm, there's still no book?

I'll stick with my original opinion (so kindly posted by WP) and also say: With nary a doubt, I'll re-predict the 'complete and total' demise of Popular Bigfooting™ if somehow someway Roger Patterson was sufficiently proven to be the 'fraud' he really was. And I don't mean any kind of anger towards the man. By hook or crook, he's one of the few that actually got 'the last laugh'. Gotta respect that. Although I am confident he would have given up 'the real clue' long before now had he lived.
 
MoMoMurphy said:
For those that want to mention $10,000 per pop for showing the P/G film, that is wrong information. The $10,000 price was not typical, but was because of the obvious negative view that would be associated with this show. Pat obviously does not want this footage used for a debunking attempt such as this. The film licensing fee is usually far, far less than the fee given.

Surprise, surprise. If you are interested in examining the film for purposes of debunking, you are going to pay through the nose. "Good people" (Pattycakes) can get it for cheap.


I have first hand experience with Bob H. while visiting Bob G. and I can state that Bob H. acted about as mature as a fourteen year old who was trying to impress someone very hard. Every other phrase out of his mouth was,"F***ING AYEE" while constantly swallowing hard as people tend to do when they are very anxious.

It could be a Pavlovian reaction from being exposed to years and hundreds of people insisting that he was not in the Patty costume. But it isn't simply that alone. He is quite aware the nobody has ever produced a Bigfoot body or part to show that the creature exists. Is there no end to these gullible people?


In addition, I have interviewed no less than 4 people on tape, 1 who is a friend of Bob H. who have told me the same basic thing, That Bob H. and brothers had a reputation in high school and after for being drinkers, fighters and being full of B.S.

Gee, sounds like that might be the personality-type of someone willing to participate in a Bigfoot hoax. Doesn't that fit the Bigfooter stereotype of a hoaxer?


I know some stories about Bob H. and his family that I simply will not repeat because it would hurt others in his family that I don't want to drag into this story, but Bob H. or Honker to his friends has done some not so wonderful things in his life at times.

Excellent. Produce a nasty hearsay anecdote and post it on BFF. Be sure to not put it in your book so that the accused parties are powerless to rebut it. That way, it doesn't even "exist" outside of Pattycake gossip chit-chat.

By the way, if anyone wants to get a private investigator to look into Greg Long's background, I am sure you could find some more people who knew him that would have some more severe things to say about him, beyond just turning in a Movie camera late.

Let's put a private investigator on you too MoMo. That way everything is fair and cool, right?

I would also like to clear up one piece of mistaken information. Pat Patterson has not commissioned me to do a book about Roger Patterson. I am doing it fully on my own. I have obtained her support, but this is my project and beyond contact information and some factual data info. Pat Patterson is not influencing this book in a way that she has rights or control over this project. She can only control her own contributions. Anyone wanting to contact me privately may do so by emailing me and requesting contact info.

There is simply no reason to believe that Roger's widow would be biased in describing the man. LOL. He left her with the PGF which has never stopped paying her dividends. Yep, she is even free to give her opinion that the film is a hoax. Why would she be acting this way if she had any reason to think that Roger faked the big one?
 
William Parcher wrote:
MoMoMurphy wrote:

I have first hand experience with Bob H. while visiting Bob G. and I can state that Bob H. acted about as mature as a fourteen year old who was trying to impress someone very hard. Every other phrase out of his mouth was,"F***ING AYEE" while constantly swallowing hard as people tend to do when they are very anxious.



It could be a Pavlovian reaction from being exposed to years and hundreds of people insisting that he was not in the Patty costume.


I think you've seriously misrepresented the situation, William.


The reaction to Bob's "confession" (claim, actually ;) ) has been.....BY FAR....in the positive....not the negative, as you've proposed.

The general public....for the most part....is more than happy to go along with the "hoax" explanations...and to laugh-off the possibility of Bigfoot's existence.

Bob Heironimus hasn't been fighting an 'uphill battle', by any means, over the years.
 
I think you misunderstood, or are misrepresenting what I said.

I'm not denying that there are great numbers of people who now believe that BH was in the suit. When I said "hundreds", I was talking about the diehard Pattycakes that he is exposed to in various ways. MoMo happens to be one of them, but this guy is writing a book to rescue the reputation of Patterson from the evil Greg Long. If I understand what he wrote correctly, he somehow got access to BH for an interview or conversation. During that visit he says that BH acted childish and "every other phrase" included "F'nA". I doubt that that is literally true, but I treated it as if it were true. The Pattycakes that actually seek him out stand some likelihood of being crazy idiots on some sort of vigilante mission. If these expletives were used at all, they were probably for powerful emphasis. So you are saying that Roger was a con man? F'nA right he was! He could get fired-up with the realization that he has yet another believer dolt talking to him. But this guy is writing a book that is obviously intended to undo what Long did.

By reading MoMo's own words (thinking and writing style) on BFF it's easy to start wondering if he could possibly write a book that is any good at all. One post says it's his first book. He is said to have interviewed some 70 people. Odds are that it would include some that Long had already talked to. Is MoMo going to have a bunch of entries that basically say - "He told me the same thing he told Greg Long"? Will he toss those out and only include warm and fuzzy stuff about Roger?
 
David Murphy via William Parcher said:
I have first hand experience with Bob H. while visiting Bob G. and I can state that Bob H. acted about as mature as a fourteen year old who was trying to impress someone very hard. Every other phrase out of his mouth was,"F***ING AYEE" while constantly swallowing hard as people tend to do when they are very anxious.

Who wants to bet that such behavior would be defended to the death if it was exhibited by Patterson or Gimlin?

By the way, if anyone wants to get a private investigator to look into Greg Long's background, I am sure you could find some more people who knew him that would have some more severe things to say about him, beyond just turning in a Movie camera late.

Let me get this straight: he's sure that Greg Long has done things far worse than not returning a movie camera (until a warrant was put out) solely because Long wrote a book that didn't make Patterson look like a saint. :jaw-dropp
 
Looks like we can all find something else to do.

• Some interesting video has been taken of Bigfoot. The most interesting film footage originated from Northern California, but it was recently proven to be fake. Yes, it was a man in a guerrilla suit. Every time film footage and pictures turn out to be practical jokes, the entire Bigfoot scientific community is compromised. Audio is sometimes more interesting, but just as hard to stand the test of the naysayers. • There have even been sightings in Kansas.

http://www.cjonline.com/interact/blog/ksghosttowner09/2009-08-03/aw_sasquatch_we_hardly_knew_ya

Guerrilla suit???
 
Last edited:
I think he meant girlie.

"...While no one was actually killed in the movie, a cat was “scared to death,” and a guy was attacked and thrown through a window at his rental house in the middle of the woods..." They mean that literally? Alright, how do they know that's what killed the cat?

And yes, I think it is time we all moved on. At least from Bigfoot. There is no Bigfoot.
 
John Johnsen said:
Yes, the PG Film is in the public domain...solidly.

In my research of the ownership of the Patterson Gimlin Film my attorney (intellectual property board certified) found that the records in the US Copyright Office were beyond screwed up, they were blatantly wrong. Upon my followup he (my attorney) told me that the LAST place to look for property ownership was the copyright office. And, that it was only a records keeping facility, not an absolute guarantee of ownership.

As AMM said, I'd be interested to hear a lawyer's perspective on why they are blatantly wrong. The forms are very simple. Title, date of publication, authors, claimants.

Do small variations or typos count? Various LoC records refer to the title as "Bigfoot" versus "Big Foot". The film itself says "Big Foot". The Agreement of Sale and Transfer from the Gimlins to Dahinden has one instance where the name is spelled "Gimlim".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom