Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would love to go to the SFB and express skepticism in an articulate, effective, and civil manner in response to Larry Battson's silly assertions regarding Bigfoot, PGF, and scientific proof but the cultoids threw me out for going to the SFB and expressing skepticism in an articulate, effective, and civil manner.QUOTE]

Would you like some cheese with that whine? Move on and get over it.
 
Last edited:
It is written in the forum rules and guidelines. Yes you can read and do read them before you register.

Could you please be specific about the rule #1 - # 14 that prohibits members from quoting posts from SBF on other forums ?

I see a caution ( not included in the rules ) against making the management unhappy, by criticizing the SFB or it's members on other forums ..

Is that what you are referring to ?

I would agree that refraining from such behavior is the right thing to do on any forum .
 
I'd suggest a new thread- regarding SFB, if all y'all want to talk about it.

I'd much rather talk about STOMACH BOOBS and The new 1 MILLION YEARS BC theory that is on Cryptomundo.

I asked a hollywood costume expert what he thought about the Ray Harryhausen theory, and he said

Hollywood Costume Expert said:
considering Ray lives in London and has lived there his whole life, it is far-fetched any "cowboy" would be sophisticated enough to go over the pond for a monkey costume when Hollywood had a ton of them at the time.

Also, if your "cowboy" happens to be the tall fella who lived and worked at Corriganville when Ray "Crash" Corrigan ruled the roost (and owned it to boot!), it would be FAR more likely those guys would throw something together.
 
kitakaze wrote:
What is the purpose for the SFB to hide and try and forbid its members from quoting posts from the board elsewhere?


Melissa should re-name her Board to "Tidy-Talk Bigfoot Forum"...


"Where our Speech is highly-regulated, controlled, adjusted.....and just plain "Under My Loving Thumb"...:rolleyes:..


In a word.....'Tidy'!!" :)
 
I'd say if the Georgia Boyz gave Bigfootery a kick in the nuts


Yes and no. It caused a great number of people to check out the (then) current status of Bigfoot and Bigfootery. All kinds of Bigfoot forums were suddenly swamped and the BFF and Cryptomundo crashed. Tons of new accounts were registered at BFF. Look for folks with registrations from around August 13, 2008 and shortly thereafter. Suddenly, many people who had never really looked at Bigfootery... did. From that larger set came a smaller set who decided that they would now "become" Bigfoot believers, in spite of, and because of, the Georgia Hoax. I'm proposing that there now are believers who would not be in that same position if the infamous Press Conference had never happened. Is that a pat on the back instead of a kick in the nuts? Again, it may depend on how you look at it.
 
Could you please be specific about the rule #1 - # 14 that prohibits members from quoting posts from SBF on other forums ?

I see a caution ( not included in the rules ) against making the management unhappy, by criticizing the SFB or it's members on other forums ..

Is that what you are referring to ?

I would agree that refraining from such behavior is the right thing to do on any forum .

The rules are cross posted here by the ever busy troll Kitakaze.

Check post 2389 in this very thread. Rule 3. If you have a problem with the rules, or a problem understanding the rules, please take that up with the owner of that site. Like Drew said this thread has been hijacked enough.
 
If kitikaze is posting helpful and informative information, as WGBH fully allows above, then he does not fit the definition of a "troll", which is defined as an evasive, ambiguous drive-by poster. In contrast to that term, kitikaze repeatedly posts links (not always in the form of videos! ;)) supporting his arguments, which are well-thought-out, unambiguous and clearly worded. He also answers direct questions, does not run from an argument, and is intellectually honest to the point that he admits mistakes and ameliorates them.

None of this is trollish behavior. If WGBH would like to support his contention that kitikaze is a troll, I invite him to post links or quotes that show this to be true. You cannot call someone a troll because they disagree with your position and expect the community to roll over and accept this.
 
The rules are cross posted here by the ever busy troll Kitakaze.....
In uber simple terms, you're a ******* IDIOT John Cartwright. And no, of course I don't have to defend Kitakaze, AND I'M NOT - I'm pointing out your absolute and complete inability to intelligently deduce what's 'real' from what's 'fantasy'. It's now totally obvious you couldn't find left field with a map. I'm also now officially embarrassed I've given you so much encouragement, slack and <gasp> support over the years when you have proven in the one sentence above that you genuinely deserved NONE of it. I offered you good luck in a post above, but you need far more than what a 'discussion forum' and 'a dwindling amount of Bigfoot friends' can give you.
 
In uber simple terms, you're a ******* IDIOT John Cartwright. And no, of course I don't have to defend Kitakaze, AND I'M NOT - I'm pointing out your absolute and complete inability to intelligently deduce what's 'real' from what's 'fantasy'. It's now totally obvious you couldn't find left field with a map. I'm also now officially embarrassed I've given you so much encouragement, slack and <gasp> support over the years when you have proven in the one sentence above that you genuinely deserved NONE of it. I offered you good luck in a post above, but you need far more than what a 'discussion forum' and 'a dwindling amount of Bigfoot friends' can give you.

Interesting. You accuse me of not having the ability to intelligently deduce "real from what is fantasy" while hurling profane insults. Please be more specific. I value your opinion and do listen to what you have to say. It is also sad you feel embarrassed for acting kind.
 
Melissa should re-name her Board to "Tidy-Talk Bigfoot Forum"...


"Where our Speech is highly-regulated, controlled, adjusted.....and just plain "Under My Loving Thumb"...:rolleyes:..

In a word.....'Tidy'!!" :)

I'm... in.. full... agreement... with... Sweaty...

1000 showers.
 
John, I'll make an appropriate thread for this discussion. Just because I think some of your friends have poor critical thinking skills and behave in a cultish manner does not mean that I'm a troll or that you have to feel personally offended.

Sorry, back to stomach boobs...
 
I would love to go to the SFB and express skepticism in an articulate, effective, and civil manner in response to Larry Battson's silly assertions regarding Bigfoot, PGF, and scientific proof but the cultoids threw me out for going to the SFB and expressing skepticism in an articulate, effective, and civil manner. They call that "trolling".

You are not alone LOL
 
Kitakaze said:
Hmmm... I don't know if I'd call it a shot in the arm. I'd say if the Georgia Boyz gave Bigfootery a kick in the nuts, The Munns Report gave it a big, fat punch in the head.

I'm referring to Bigfootery in general and not just the folks in places like the BFF. I'd imagine that to people interested in cryptozoology who don't post in those sorts of places (or bother to do research) could find Bill Munns' statements regarding the Patterson-Gimlin film to be convincing.

From what I've seen, most of the upper echelons of Bigfootery have been very cool towards Bill's report. It seems to me that it's more the dumber ones like your Mulders, your Spazmos, your Night Stalkers, etc or groupies like The Hovercraft who will wave it around.

You raise a good point here. I'm also surprised by the lack of references to the Munns Report on Wikipedia and that more people aren't barging in here to challenge skeptics about it like they did with the "Bigfoot DNA" found at that Canadian cabin.

Atomic, let me ask you a favour as a fellow digger. The last thing missing from the Patty Smasher is a source for Bob Gimlin having been in New York with Patterson dressed in full-out Apache regalia, getting fed up with the routine, and being replaced by an actor.

I believe that Dfoot mentioned it a few times here, which means that he probably read about it in Greg Long's book. In this post, he notes an interview which seems to describe the meeting you're referring to:

Dfoot said:
JACK OLIPHANT is interviewed. He was the publicist that PAT MASON set Roger up with to promote the film. Oliphant describes the New York event and says Patterson and Gimlin were con men. DeAtley was there and paid for the filghts. DeAtley talks about all sorts of things he had to pay for. Did he save plane tickets for people to view decades later? Of course not. Who would?

Cowboy and Indian clothes, plane tickets, huge sums of money, contracts and documents, all are discussed in Long's book. All of it is twisted around or omitted by the Bigfooters who want to keep Patty real no matter what. Don't get it from them. Read the book.

Not only does this post offer more brief comments about the New York meeting, but it also provides an interesting "Patty vs. Tauren" picture that might be of use in arguments regarding head shapes.

Dfoot said:
GREG LONG interviewed OLIPHANT and MASON about the New York event. MERRITT told Long he was ticked off because they didn't even tell him they were going and he thought he was a partner in the film making part of Roger's productions.

For his part DEATLEY says he spent a week and a half with Patterson and Gimlin in Los Angeles. He says he had to "structure up the deal". About New York he recalls buying a bunch of new clothes for both Patterson and Gimlin and he remembers Patterson going on the JOEY BISHOP SHOW to promote his adventures. Long specifically asks him about Gimlin being dressed up as an Indian at a New York party set up by Oliphant to attract investors. He says his usual line: "I can't recall. I can't say it didn't happen."

It might be possible that DeAtley's wife (Roger's sister) could have kept some photo or something from the New York event (if they took any). It seems that only one single possible investor showed up and the whole thing was a bust. After that Gimlin's wife put her foot down and he no longer showed up. It became the Patterson-DeAtley film show and they never bothered to inform Mason or Merritt of this.

I imagine that the fake Bob Gimlin is mentioned in the book as well. As I recall, the most accepted story is that Bob Gimlin's wife forced him to stop doing Bigfoot-related stuff due to embarassment. I also recall that when the issue of the fake Gimlin was brought up at the BFF, a few there were very eager to argue that any contradictory statements made by Gimlin were really the work of the fake. Speaking of the BFF, the thread "Bob Gimlin's role" might be of use.

Also, page 87 of the PGF 411 has some comments by Dfoot regarding Gimlin dressing up in Native American gear.

I'm not sure if any of these three sites deal with Gimlin's dressing up, but they're still worth a look.

I was going to just post the entire thing here but I'm considering having a friend help me to create a Patty Smasher website but before I go ahead I'd like to have that last bit I've been after.

Awesome! Good luck with that.

And yet there are still fools out there trying to argue the MDF and Skookum cast.

And don't forge the Jacobs photos!

Drewbot said:
The new 1 MILLION YEARS BC theory that is on Cryptomundo.

Wait, what? Who came up with that one?

I asked a hollywood costume expert what he thought about the Ray Harryhausen theory,

Someone thinks Ray Harryhausen made the suit? I believe he only did stop-motion animation puppets, not costumes.

Hollywood Costume Expert via Drewbot said:
considering Ray lives in London and has lived there his whole life,

I can't say for sure whether or not Mr. Harryhausen lives in London now, but I know that he most certainly did not live there his entire life.

it is far-fetched any "cowboy" would be sophisticated enough to go over the pond for a monkey costume when Hollywood had a ton of them at the time.

Well, technically some Hollywood contact of the cowboy could have come up the idea. But I must stress that what little I currently know about the 1 MILLION YEARS BC theory doesn't convince me enough to argue hard for this.

Also, if your "cowboy" happens to be the tall fella who lived and worked at Corriganville when Ray "Crash" Corrigan ruled the roost (and owned it to boot!), it would be FAR more likely those guys would throw something together.

Interesting, a non-Dfoot member of the Hollywood community who brought up the Coriganville connection.

William Parcher said:
Did we ever do this link to Corriganville?

I think Dfoot might've linked to that once.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom