Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
47169a7f.jpg

There are similarities, among them the rather startling oblique angle of the toes. (What kind of extremity has digits directed at a 45-degree angle from the position of the foot? Is this corroborated by any other track anywhere in BFery? By any other animal in the world?) Also, the second ("index") toe appears to have a small concavity at its base that recurs in both photograph and cast in the same location.

However, other features of the cast, such as the larger concavity in the approximate center, are not visible in the photograph, perhaps due to deep shadows; and vice versa, such as the soil disturbance below the big toe, which does not appear to recur in the cast.

Verdict: ?
 
And for anyone to imagine that they could take a costumed guy out in the woods and make them walk upright without stumbling, tripping or looking like a man in a costume out of his element is a bit far flung, a stretch beyond the practical.

The writer seems unfamiliar with the concept of rehearsals and actors studying animal movements in preparation for roles.

It takes a great deal of time to get a costumed man to move somewhat realistically and then they take multiple shots of each movement from multiple angles, actually only bits of action, and piece them together to show a complete shot. I know this first hand having been on movie sets both as an extra and as a grip.

He seems to misunderstand the use of "multiple shots from multiple angles." Film scenes tend to follow a script, which requires greater movement and actions (dialogue, etc) than what's seen in the PGF. Also, scenes are also shot that way to provide a greater amount of footage for an editor to work with (multiple takes can also act as a back-up if footage from the desired take goes missing). Patterson, being an amateur filmmaker, would not be expected to know this. Then again, Patterson could have had the person in the suit do multiple takes (filmed or unfilmed) before shooting the footage. Any alternate takes would presumably have been destroyed after the final cut of the PGF was produced.

Plugging in "one take" in a search engine should result in several tales of great results being accomplished in one take.

There is NO movie out that shows a heavily costumed man in a hairy ape-like costume in a wooded area, out of doors (not a film studio) moving for that long a time period, for that great a distance, in one continuous shot that displays the kind of fluid locomotion as seen in the PG film, period!"

The distance part is the main problem with that. In movies, the monster is often seen at a relatively close distance. Although Vortigern99 has provided some possible examples of suits filmed at such a distance, the only movie I can think of where someone is filmed in a hairy costume from a great distance (perhaps even greater than the PGF) is 1953's "Robot Monster." However, I seem to recall that the suit used in that was somewhat baggy and my only copy of the film is an anaglyphic 3D (red and blue) VHS tape from the 80's, which makes it hard to judge the quality of the suit.

As I've noted elsewhere, the various Godzilla suit actors could last several minutes in costume, far longer than what's seen in the PGF (and at presumably greater temperatures).

And I defy the skeptics to reproduce the effect if they feel it was a man in a costume and film it exactly the way it was filmed in 1967.

Okay, you are going to provide funding for such a project? It's only fair seeing as you're the one who proposed it.

Of course, even if a recreation was made and proponents were satisfied, most of them would probably switch to the "Just because special effects artists can recreate it doesn't mean that it's not real" defense.
 
How do you know that Titmus didn't make the tracks himself? If I have to choose between the existence of Bigfoots and folks faking footprints,I know which side I wll come down on.
 
How do you know that Titmus didn't make the tracks himself?


For myself, the story of Bob Titmus is the story of a prolific and devoted Bigfoot hoaxer and propagandist. For a period of time, he made a living off of it. His account of going to Bluff Creek to see the Patty tracks is full of bizarre nonsense. He was there for days (as reported) and could have done almost anything he wanted with whatever he found. We see no photos taken by him. If he saw evidence of hoaxing, I don't think he would say it. I doubt that he ever thought the film was authentic. His self-appointed job was to validate and give credibility to a hoax. If it required some tinkering with the existing "Patty tracks" or making a few new ones amongst the others - he was the man to do it. He had already made many fake tracks himself before going to check out the PGF site. There was no way in hell that Titmus was going to pour rain on the Bigfooter's parade. He was one of them.
 
The distance part is the main problem with that. In movies, the monster is often seen at a relatively close distance. Although Vortigern99 has provided some possible examples of suits filmed at such a distance, the only movie I can think of where someone is filmed in a hairy costume from a great distance (perhaps even greater than the PGF) is 1953's "Robot Monster." However, I seem to recall that the suit used in that was somewhat baggy and my only copy of the film is an anaglyphic 3D (red and blue) VHS tape from the 80's, which makes it hard to judge the quality of the suit.

Insightful post as usual, AMM, but I want to make one correction. Blogsquatcher said "moving for that long a time period, for that great a distance," meaning the span covered by the locomotion of the subject -- not "at" that distance, ie the distance of the subject from the camera, as you have inferred above.

The distance in feet covered by the locomotion of the subject is a requirement that is fully met by both films I mentioned upthread, Greystoke and Gorillas in the Mist.
 
For myself, the story of Bob Titmus is the story of a prolific and devoted Bigfoot hoaxer and propagandist. For a period of time, he made a living off of it. His account of going to Bluff Creek to see the Patty tracks is full of bizarre nonsense. He was there for days (as reported) and could have done almost anything he wanted with whatever he found. We see no photos taken by him. If he saw evidence of hoaxing, I don't think he would say it. I doubt that he ever thought the film was authentic. His self-appointed job was to validate and give credibility to a hoax. If it required some tinkering with the existing "Patty tracks" or making a few new ones amongst the others - he was the man to do it. He had already made many fake tracks himself before going to check out the PGF site. There was no way in hell that Titmus was going to pour rain on the Bigfooter's parade. He was one of them.

I am sorry, but There is no record of Titmus hoaxing anything. He was a professional tracker, and took his job seriously. Even though i felt he was duped by the Patterson tracks, at least he made an honest effort to see what caused it.

18 inch human-like tracks= if not a hoax or bear, what could it be?
 
I am sorry, but There is no record of Titmus hoaxing anything.

I believe William is referring to this incident, where Titmus supposedly witnessed a Bigfoot rampage and yet failed to recovery any evidence from (such as hair samples). Personally, I find his claim of finding a Bigfoot handprint in water to be a bit suspicious.

He was a professional tracker,

Actually, he was a taxidermist. Here's a choice quote regarding his tracking abilities:

He added that he did not claim to be an "expert."

Oh, and here's a possible source for "Salt of the Earth"-style claims.

18 inch human-like tracks= if not a hoax or bear, what could it be?

Tracks from a barefoot person of that size? Depressions in the ground that vaguely resemble aspects of feet? Overlaid tracks of another animal?

Vortigern99 said:
Insightful post as usual, AMM, but I want to make one correction. Blogsquatcher said "moving for that long a time period, for that great a distance," meaning the span covered by the locomotion of the subject -- not "at" that distance, ie the distance of the subject from the camera, as you have inferred above.

Oh, okay! I'm afraid I don't know that distance off the top of my head or know of the exact distances traveled in walking scenes from the various horror movies I've seen, so I can't add on to your examples. At least, not right now...
 
Last edited:
I recently learned something quite extraordinary about makaya325 (a new man). As you may know, mak has said that he's finishing up high school now. He's been a very prolific poster about Bigfoot on forums going back to at least three years ago. We have also been told that he is of Hupa descent (he used the term Hoopa) and is friends with Henner Fahrenbach.

But that is almost nothing compared to what you don't yet know, and it is related to the subject of this thread.



makaya325's Grandfather was friends with Roger Patterson!

That's right. He spoke about it back in December, 2006. I don't know why he didn't let us know since it is such an amazing thing. They were friends in college but then things went bad. Seems that young Patterson was borrowing money from mak's gramp and he got tired of it. Never spoke to Roger again.

Mak, I do think that RP was a hoaxer and conman, but it must be super cool to have a close relative that was his friend. Do you have any other recollections to add?

makaya325 said:
hey my grandfather, who recently passed away, actually known patterson in college. u think im bs ing, but my grandpa was friends with him. he told me that roger was a little bit of a goof, but had a strong belief in bigfoot. he would always talk to my gramps about ol sasquatch. . roger was out to film a documentary about footprints, and actually got lucky and filmed the real thing. using occams razor, and the more simpler explanation that its probably the real thing since its enormous size and its muscles are consistent with the mountain gorilla. plus the mountain gorilla was believed to be a myth reported by pygmys which westerners ignored, until they found one. it lends credence to a possibility of a decendent of an ancient primate living among us...


yea my grandpops used to remember roger as someone who wouldnt pay his bills, and pops lent him some of his money. but gramps got a little sick of roger asking him to borrow some money, so he never talked to patterson again...



PS: Happy Belated Birthday to kitakaze! It was yesterday.
 
Oh, okay! I'm afraid I don't know that distance off the top of my head or know of the exact distances traveled in walking scenes from the various horror movies I've seen, so I can't add on to your examples. At least, not right now...

To be frank, I cannot say I know the exact distances traveled either in the P-G film or in either of my two examples, only that by comparison, Tarzan's "father" (a French mime in a Baker ape suit) trucks a considerable span -- at least as far as Patty -- in a medium long-shot at the end of Act II of Greystoke, and Diane Fossey (S. Weaver) is charged by a male gorilla (an actor in another fine Baker suit) early in Gorillas in Your Midst.

In the latter example, Gorillas, the scene is comprised of multiple angles -- as opposed to a single shot as required by Blogsquatcher. But this is the only unfulfilled requirement to his bafflingly extensive list; and in any case since the Baker suit is seen more closely and from a variety of angles, it can be said with confidence to be superior in detail and craftsmanship to the Patty suit in every way.

What Blogsquatcher might hope to gain by claiming that no movie shows such comparable events is anyone's guess. It isn't an accurate claim, utterly destructible in the face of the most obvious evidence out there -- two huge Hollywood blockbusters from the 1980s -- but even if it were accurate, so what? What would it prove? That no one in Hollywood ever filmed an ape costume, which are known to exist, in a wooded area out of doors, which are known to exist, for a minute in duration, when performers in 200-pound suits (qv Godzilla, thanks again AMM) are known to be able to withstand up to three minutes of shooting time, over a distance of x feet, as though ape suits disintegrate after walking x minus 10 feet? The requirements are absurd, yet fulfilled all the same, and I'm done targeting this Blogsquatching personage, as his claims are too easily thrown down.
 
I recently learned something quite extraordinary about makaya325 (a new man). As you may know, mak has said that he's finishing up high school now. He's been a very prolific poster about Bigfoot on forums going back to at least three years ago. We have also been told that he is of Hupa descent (he used the term Hoopa) and is friends with Henner Fahrenbach.

But that is almost nothing compared to what you don't yet know, and it is related to the subject of this thread.



makaya325's Grandfather was friends with Roger Patterson!

That's right. He spoke about it back in December, 2006. I don't know why he didn't let us know since it is such an amazing thing. They were friends in college but then things went bad. Seems that young Patterson was borrowing money from mak's gramp and he got tired of it. Never spoke to Roger again.

Mak, I do think that RP was a hoaxer and conman, but it must be super cool to have a close relative that was his friend. Do you have any other recollections to add?





PS: Happy Belated Birthday to kitakaze! It was yesterday.

He told me about Patterson being a tiny, giddy little man in college. That was before Patterson went with Merritt into the military. I laugh at myself for believing the pgf showed a real ape instead of the simpler man in a suit explanation. Ever since My grandpa died, i have not really mentioned it to others.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom