Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know - I blocked him the other night. But then I took him off again to see what I was missing. Me - I want the best of both worlds :p. And the right to complain about them equally!
 
There are similarities, among them the rather startling oblique angle of the toes. (What kind of extremity has digits directed at a 45-degree angle from the position of the foot? Is this corroborated by any other track anywhere in BFery?


I may have just found one. Coleman posted a John Green blog and I have never seen this picture before. I put some lines to show the possible angles. Does anyone know the source of this cast he is holding?


09e3eca4.jpg
4636350e.jpg


47169a7f.jpg
 
Last edited:
It just looks exactly the same to me. Straight outer edge, same toe alignment, same angle at the ball on the inside edge. Other than left/right. Looks too exact to me.

I think I even see a little chip or crack on the edge of the cast near the white half moon mark that looks like it may match the print. I think I see a corresponding bit of dirt sticking out from the print at approximately the same spot where the cast is chipped.

I'm wondering if you've found another pair of alderfeet?

Then again, it is late and I am tired. :D
 
It just looks exactly the same to me. Straight outer edge, same toe alignment, same angle at the ball on the inside edge. Other than left/right. Looks too exact to me.

I think I even see a little chip or crack on the edge of the cast near the white half moon mark that looks like it may match the print. I think I see a corresponding bit of dirt sticking out from the print at approximately the same spot where the cast is chipped.

I'm wondering if you've found another pair of alderfeet?

Then again, it is late and I am tired. :D


Those casts Green is holding are a left/right and they are not claimed to come from the Patty trackway. They have odd-angled toes but are still unlike the PGF casts.

green_today.jpg



Here are the 10 casts that Titmus said came from the Patty trackway. They are arranged here as lefts and rights. There are a couple in the bottom row that have the angle-toes. #2 & #3 in the bottom row appear to be identical other than different states of erosion. What pops right out at you is that the collection looks like a hodgepodge of various feet that do not belong to one single bipedal creature.

It is still my opinion that #3 was poured into the track we see in the short filmstrip.


7b4ebade.jpg
 
{Just slipping back in for a surgical strike so this falsehood doesn't slide}
...and Diane [sic] Fossey (S. Weaver) is charged by a male gorilla (an actor in another fine Baker suit) early in Gorillas in Your Midst [sic].

I know it's a small part of your argument, which I don't care to get into, and has little bearing on the PG film (or anything else), but for the record and since it was used as a debate tactic- the above claim is 100% false. Sorry.

Ironically, assuming you aren't being deceitful and weren't careless enough to rely on memory nor watching some non-standard cut of the movie, you my friend were fooled by the editing (which some might suggest questions your observation skills and critical thinking ability.;) ) Nonetheless you should probably be more careful of what you say and who you accuse of being inaccurate, destructible, spurious, baffled, etc. in your displays of confidence here. A little humility never hurts.

With one obvious exception, all of the footage of full body, charging adult male gorillas (aka silverbacks) in 'Gorillas in the Mist' is real footage of actual gorillas cleverly interlaced (sometimes) with close-ups of Baker's costumes. The only full body shots of walking/running, costumed actor(s?) in a silverback suit are at the end of the movie- in the scene where silverback 'Digit' gets killed by poachers- and even there you only see flashes of the whole body. Maybe that's all you need to make your point, but those full body shots are brief- probably because it's painfully obvious that it is a costume- and don't display much locomotion.

Unfortunately I don't have the technology for DVD screen captures so here are descriptions:

*The first charging scene (~20 mins in) is 100% real footage, no costumes at all.

*The second one (~40 min), where Sigourney is actually among gorillas (climbing on her etc.) and then gets sort of charged, is all real gorillas except for one very brief shot of a Baker costume (head and shoulders only) perched next to Sigourney.

*The next gorilla scene (~48 min) where she's approached (no charging) and the silverback yawns is a mix but is all real gorillas in all the full body shots.

*The scene with Brian Brown playing Campbell (~60 min) filming Fossey is 100% real of the silverback climbing down the tree and then charging, and then goes to close-up of a costume, which then interacts with Sigourney for the rest of the scene and can be seen in full (sitting).

*The one other scene of a charging silverback (~90 min), after the students arrive, is the best mix but all the footage showing any legs is a real gorilla, the costume is only shown from about the chest up.

So watch again Vortigern because there is no footage of full-body, charging silverback costumed actors except that last scene where Digit is killed, which again may be what you want to refer to with some readjustment of what you've claimed. In the meantime, bow to Baker's costumes and make-up, but more so to Stuart Baird's editing. He, unlike Baker, was actually nominated for an Oscar for this movie...(though unlike Baker he is still waiting to win one!)
 
I watched the film, and I don't share your idea of "painfully" obvious... And from my attempt to research what you have said above, this "painfully" obvious is not shared either, because nearly all comments I found praise rick baker for having made costume so alike true gorilla.

I find way way way more obvious that Patty is a fake than your "painfully obvious".

ETA: and from the tone I find painfully obvious that you have an axe to grind... Am I the only one to think that ?
 
I'd need to watch the film again, however the following still doesn't appear painfully obvious as a costume (given the fact we know that's what it is). At least it's sharp and in close up - rather than at 102/130/140 ft (have we decided yet) on a fuzzed out 16mm film. Pity we can't see 'Patty' in such detail.



Digit.jpg


ETA: and from the tone I find painfully obvious that you have an axe to grind... Am I the only one to think that ?
No.

ETA again: It should also be noted that after Baker had finished his head sculpture of the silverback he would be expected to match (a specific individual animal from a species known to exist), a different one was actually used in the production.
 
Last edited:
I'd need to watch the film again, however the following still doesn't appear painfully obvious as a costume (given the fact we know that's what it is). At least it's sharp and in close up - rather than at 102/130/140 ft (have we decided yet) on a fuzzed out 16mm film. Pity we can't see 'Patty' in such detail.



[qimg]http://i61.photobucket.com/albums/h72/John_WS/JREF/Digit.jpg[/qimg]


No.

ETA again: It should also be noted that after Baker had finished his head sculpture of the silverback he would be expected to match (a specific individual animal from a species known to exist), a different one was actually used in the production.

The only problems I see are the horizontal wrinkles in the arms, which are similar to the wrinkles in Patty's legs. It looks like we have another piece of evidence that shows Patty is a bloke in a suit.
 
ETA: and from the tone I find painfully obvious that you have an axe to grind...

I have no axe to grind. As a fairly neutral party I just think it's kind of telling that many here pile on the "bigfooters" when they misstep but allow absolute falsehoods for the skeptical side to slip through uncontested, that's all. Just doing what I can to level the playing field on things I know about and keep people honest. Like I said, this argument has very little pertinence in my book and I have no agenda here. You folks sure continue to make me and an open dialog feel welcome here though :rolleyes:.

My reference to "painfully obvious" may have been too strong but was for the big fight scene (and as a movie and not stills), and that description isn't necessarily mutually exclusive to any accolades Baker received- the costumes WERE great, just not perfect. (But you should probably also ask yourself who was making many of those accolades- the same movie critics that thought Baker's King Kong was an animatronic giant?:eye-poppi)

Sculpting his models/costumes on a specific gorilla has little to do with the costume's imperfections. That's mostly Baker's excuse/propaganda/defense against those who could see the differences beyond nose-prints, face wrinkles, gray patches, and other individual subtleties. That said, I'm sure that Baker didn't expect beforehand that his costumes would be interlaced with footage of shorter-haired eastern lowland gorillas (the intense charging footage)!

The bottom line though is, IMO, if one doesn't see it as an obvious costume in that fight scene (and that the charging gorillas are real) maybe they should rethink being in this particular discussion??? Or maybe we should start there rather than talking about a film none of us know the truth about???
 
I have no axe to grind. As a fairly neutral party I just think it's kind of telling that many here pile on the "bigfooters" when they misstep but allow absolute falsehoods for the skeptical side to slip through uncontested, that's all. Just doing what I can to level the playing field on things I know about and keep people honest. Like I said, this argument has very little pertinence in my book and I have no agenda here. You folks sure continue to make me and an open dialog feel welcome here though :rolleyes:.

My reference to "painfully obvious" may have been too strong but was for the big fight scene (and as a movie and not stills), and that description isn't necessarily mutually exclusive to any accolades Baker received- the costumes WERE great, just not perfect. (But you should probably also ask yourself who was making many of those accolades- the same movie critics that thought Baker's King Kong was an animatronic giant?:eye-poppi)

Sculpting his models/costumes on a specific gorilla has little to do with the costume's imperfections. That's mostly Baker's excuse/propaganda/defense against those who could see the differences beyond nose-prints, face wrinkles, gray patches, and other individual subtleties. That said, I'm sure that Baker didn't expect beforehand that his costumes would be interlaced with footage of shorter-haired eastern lowland gorillas (the intense charging footage)!

The bottom line though is, IMO, if one doesn't see it as an obvious costume in that fight scene (and that the charging gorillas are real) maybe they should rethink being in this particular discussion??? Or maybe we should start there rather than talking about a film none of us know the truth about???

Are you always this rude or is this an anomaly and you're just having a bad day?
 
No rudeness was intended and I apologize if it came across otherwise. The smiley thing doesn't come naturally to me but I'm trying. I gather you read the last sentence as snide but it was actually perfectly sincere. I realize that what may be obvious to me and others might not be obvious to everyone so perhaps it would be constructive to go into some detail on the GITM costumes rather than the tiresome PGF debate? Just an honest suggestion. There is probably a wealth of discussion on that here already somewhere so I'll just crawl back into my den and keep rutting around. Sorry for the interruption.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom