[NOTE: My original statements are in italics. Mr. Yeti's replies are in bold. My new responses are in regular text.]
1. Human variation allows different arm lengths among different individuals.
That's right.
But it doesn't matter whether Patty's arms are longer than all of humanity's.....only whether they're longer than the average human's arm length.....and Bob's.
Why? Why should it matter that Patty's arms are longer than the average human's arm length? All we need to show, to support the likelihood of a person in a suit, is that Patty's limb proportions are within human range. You just agreed that human variation would account for such differences. Do you see the contradiction in what you've written?
There is also the matter of suit gloves extending the apparent arm length. There is also the matter of the Poser7 and DAZ figures which show that Patty's limb proportions, even given a suit, are well within the normal range. There is also the matter that this thread is not about Bob H, and I for one am not overly concerned with his claim. It could be anyone, any human person of the right height (whatever that may be) inside of that suit.
2. The "walking woman" has her arm a) angled farther back and b) bent more obliquely at the elbow than the P-G subject.
Sure, it's angled more than Patty's arm is....but not by very much.
And part of that difference is offset by the fact that Patty's hand is angled backwards, while her hand is completely vertical.
All of these factors combine. If the woman's arm is already a little shorter than the person inside the Patty suit's arm, AND it's angled backward so that it's higher on the arc circle that controls arm length, AND Patty's arm is extended by the presence of suit gloves, AND the woman's arm is bent more obliquely, AND the camera angle is lower... do you see where I'm going with this? It offsets and far overcomes any minor gain made by the tilt of Patty's hand.
3. The "walking woman" has her legs held straight; the P-G subject has bent knees.
Even though her legs are straight....they're both extended at an angle...so there's not much of a difference between her leg positions and Patty's, with regards to how they affect the hand's distance to the feet.
That small difference can be measured pretty easily, though. I'll try to do that in the next day or two.
The same is true for the difference in arm angle...that can be measured, and adjusted for, also.
You're missing the point here, I think. If you stand up right now, and put your arm at your side, and bend slightly at the knees, your fingertips are suddenly closer to your knees. It's that simple. If you merely extend your straight leg at an angle, this proximity of fingertips to knees does not occur. Try it! I think you'll be surprised by the result.
4. The camera angles are at different vertical levels.
5. Lens sizes of the cameras and developers, and degree of digital compression involved with scanning both images into a computer are unknown.
But...as more comparisons are done...with similar results....the 'invisible factors', such as the ones you listed....become irrelevant, due to the fact that those factors would (by law of random chance) have to 'equal out'.
That is...."Camera angles"...."Lens size"...."digital compression"...."high tides in Peurto Rico"....would occasionally favor one side, and, occasionally favor the other.
The more comparisons that are done....the less those factors are relevant.
Okay, so that's two so far -- the Bob H comparison and the walking woman. It occurs to me we'll need a lot more data before we start seeing lens size distortion and digital compression factors "equal out" in the favor of your position that Patty has inhumanly long arms. What else ya got?
All of these factors contribute to the visible perception that the P-G subject has longer arms.
Every single time???
How about "Patty's arms".........do they contribute???
Well, yes. I'm addressing Patty's arms in line after line of my analysis. You are reading what I'm writing, aren't you?
6. The placement of the control lines intended to match up the figures for comparison at the P-G subject's head and feet are subjective and arguable.
Note: Everything, in Randi-Land, is arguable.....including whether or not the Patterson Film was actually shot by Roger Patterson.
(Not kidding.....ask Greg about that one. )
Since I'm not especially interested whether Patterson shot the film, that sidebar is rrelevant to the discussion at hand. The matter we're discussing is arguable, Mr. Yeti, because you placed those control lines where you believed they should go, without consideration for the possibility that they could be moved upward or downward by a similarly subjective placement made by another party. If I were to place them, for example, I would bring the top line down considerably, to where I believe a human being's head would fit more reasonably underneath that absurd crest, moving up your hand-line to match the woman's more or less equally.