Aepervius
Non credunt, semper verificare
That is certainly another indication that there is a problem of consistency between all the data, and certainly no consistency with a 15 lens.
Are there any photos of Vincent and Patterson together? Any letters or other documents?
If that's true, then we're getting in the ballpark of B.Munn's estimate. He says 7'4, right?
It's all conjecture and speculation, but inasmuch as the pics can be compared without knowing the lens sizes and degree of compression, 6'10" doesn't seem out of the question compared to a 5'4" Roger. I guess-timated 6'8", but considering all the distorting/mitigating factors inherent in trying to match up the subjects, a 2-inch give-or-take strikes me as fair.
Say what ye will about his report, Munns at least is using graphics software and mathematical calculations to arrive at his estimate.
It's beginning to look more like he is using his estimate, to arrive at his calculations......
Say what ye will about his report, Munns at least is using graphics software and mathematical calculations to arrive at his estimate.
I'm not following you here. Vort estimates Patty's height at 6'8". Munns estimates her at 7'4". You are saying an 8" difference in their estimates still has them both inside the same ballpark?
1. He must have said that in a forum because I can't find that in his report, though he did mention a 1-2% margin for his 15% of frame estimate for "Patty's" height.I think Bill mentioned that his calculated margin of error is less than 2%. That is nothing like a 6" "room for wiggle".
Bill Munns on BFF said:If you want to continue arguing for a person in a suit, the person would be within 1-2" of the apparent height of the figure, whatever that's determined to be.
My estimate of 7' 4" is "as posed", but I don't see an 18% increase in standing straight up height, as some have argued. I have not computed a "standing height" yet because that requires establishing the leg postures and body angles and then "unfolding" the body to fully upright. I hope to do that, but haven't done so yet.
But keep in mind, I also estimate a plus/minus range of about 1 1/2 % because the formula uses a distance based on measurements which seem to have discrepancies in the same range of eror.
So on the low end of that error range, Patty could be about 7' 2" as posed.
1. He must have said that in a forum because I can't find that in his report, though he did mention a 1-2% margin for his 15% of frame estimate for "Patty's" height.
2. Regardless, whatever he claims as his error is basically meaningless and would need to be substantiated, preferably by someone more used to doing this sort of thing than Bill. He doesn't even know the error of the lens focal length that I can find and I'm sure a number of us here could find a whole bunch of potential error he doesn't even see.
Just my two cents that it's probably not worth debating a couple inches of height until he can give us some verifiable number of what error might actually be. For all we know at this point it could be 7'4" plus or minus 2 feet, right?
My estimate of 7' 4" is "as posed", but I don't see an 18% increase in standing straight up height, as some have argued. I have not computed a "standing height" yet because that requires establishing the leg postures and body angles and then "unfolding" the body to fully upright. I hope to do that, but haven't done so yet.
But keep in mind, I also estimate a plus/minus range of about 1 1/2 % because the formula uses a distance based on measurements which seem to have discrepancies in the same range of eror.
So on the low end of that error range, Patty could be about 7' 2" as posed.
Finally, I would like to remind all that the report clearly states the height estimate is a "preliminary" finding, with aditional work still being done to substantiate the final determination. And because i want to try and do this well, considering all factors and documenting all steps as best I can, taking it from "preliminary" to "final determination" is going slowly.
Bill
If you want to continue arguing for a person in a suit....
What's the point ?
There is no doubt in this community that you will rule out a suit ( for all practical purposes ) .. If you don't rule it out, you will claim it was beyond the known capabilities and resources of RP et al ..
Anyone want to bet the conclusion of the evaluation = suit ?
Hi- New guy here. Still slowly working my way through different threads so please allow a little ignorance on the background here as I catch up.
Am I understanding correctly that you think these images show that the PG figure and Bob H. can accommodate the same skeleton? Aside from the myriad optical issues, it looks to me like the skeleton (which I'm assuming is the same) fits neither body correctly. Can you please direct me to wherever the best quality versions of these are and also wherever you have explained your contention.
Thanks.
Thanks Vortigern99. Are there bigger versions somewhere? Is this or any similar software a free download by any chance?
You're entitled to your opinion but I really don't see how anyone can objectively arrive at this conclusion based on these images and with no effort to show what human variation actually is. I was thinking of playing with these images but it's probably not worthwhile as everyone seems to see what they want. Sure the skeleton "fits" inside both bodies if that's all anyone is looking at, but it actually matches quite poorly at some of the important places- in my view. I'm not really sure a critique can be done without some level of subjectivity so I would just caution anyone from citing this as any sort of evidence that Bob H's skeleton fits inside the figure- though I'm not yet assuming that was the original claim.
It's an interesting exercise but, for me, it proves nothing.
Yes Greg that was preemptive. I don't want to be dismissed because of anyone's prejudices.
Vortigern99- My comment about "seeing what one wants" wasn't meant as a slight to you or anyone else, it's more of an observation of the human condition and a reminder how subjective this exercise is- similar to debating what "fits" or not. If you don't see that and consider these overlays comparable to anything scientific than I can't help you.
GT/CS- I realize everyone expects instant results and feedback in this internet age but please be patient. I'm not going to be baited into throwing some sloppy diagram up so am sticking to generalities for the moment. I'm also not promising anything at all, much less anything scientific- we don't need any more of that. But if I can adequately articulate what I'm seeing I will happily share it for everyone to beat on.
Also what is AAH? Guess I need to read more of the new member stuff?
---
Overall, with due respect to him(?) for the effort, I'm surprised Kitakaze could "flaunt" these here seemingly unquestioned, though again, I'm not caught up on his intentions and the history... and I probably will never be now that I've seen your 400 page threads! But skepticism of skepticism is allowed here right?
I see now these are images from Mangler, sorry for being sloppy.








It doesn't need to be a completely perfect fit, it just needs to show that the same skeleton can match the proportions of both Patty and Bob.
1. He must have said that in a forum because I can't find that in his report, though he did mention a 1-2% margin for his 15% of frame estimate for "Patty's" height.
2. Regardless, whatever he claims as his error is basically meaningless and would need to be substantiated, preferably by someone more used to doing this sort of thing than Bill. He doesn't even know the error of the lens focal length that I can find and I'm sure a number of us here could find a whole bunch of potential error he doesn't even see.
Just my two cents that it's probably not worth debating a couple inches of height until he can give us some verifiable number of what error might actually be. For all we know at this point it could be 7'4" plus or minus 2 feet, right?
This is like expecting Meldrum to produce an objective bigfoot paper, imo.
I think Bill mentioned that his calculated margin of error is less than 2%. That is nothing like a 6" "room for wiggle".
BM on BFF said:And every height calculation I can get out of the 25mm lens specification comes up at 5' or under for the subject height.
Link please.I have done that several times