Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, my little gang of rabble-rousers is getting pretty big, Sweaty, and I feel like flaunting them. Enjoy...

Hi- New guy here. Still slowly working my way through different threads so please allow a little ignorance on the background here as I catch up.

Am I understanding correctly that you think these images show that the PG figure and Bob H. can accommodate the same skeleton? Aside from the myriad optical issues, it looks to me like the skeleton (which I'm assuming is the same) fits neither body correctly. Can you please direct me to wherever the best quality versions of these are and also wherever you have explained your contention.

Thanks.
 
No, that would be'''

The skeleton can accommodate the PG figure and Bob H. ....

What you see is what you get ... Please feel free to show otherwise ..


" I don't think it looks right ... " doesn't count ...
 
This is not entirely true. Mud slinging has taken place on BOTH sides of this argument. You can reference this on the Bigfoot Discussions forum also. Melissa is a close friend of mine and I am not making excuses for her here.

Both sides of the argument have acted juvenile at times including myself. Does Mr. Crowley calling Melissa " a Bigfoot Groupie" ring any bells there Wolfie?

This was never a serious argument about casting, it was just used as a weapon by people who cannot get along to attack each other.

Both sides? Show me where JohnWS has insulted Melissa.

Matt Crowley calling Melissa a groupie has nothing to do with JohnWS or anybody else, for that matter. Furthermore, Melissa did initiate the insults well before Matt calling her that. She repeatedly fabricated and manipulated false accusations against Matt as well as accused him of avoiding any random question she would make up on the spot. She initiated it, and she got a response that she deserved.

And that is what you are seeing now happening with JohnWS. Show me where he has insulted her, he hasn't. She has just initiated it.

This isn't about "Sides". This isn't a volleyball game.

Wait a minute here, is this John Cartwright?
 
Last edited:
Please feel free to show otherwise ..

" I don't think it looks right ... " doesn't count ...

Relax, I'll get there. I just want to first make sure I have the best images and understand the contention- and that we all understand an exercise like this is not science. In the meantime you may want to check your biases and take a closer look at those images (and everyone please refrain from calling me a BF "believer" because I am not.)
 
Hi- New guy here. Still slowly working my way through different threads so please allow a little ignorance on the background here as I catch up.

Am I understanding correctly that you think these images show that the PG figure and Bob H. can accommodate the same skeleton? Aside from the myriad optical issues, it looks to me like the skeleton (which I'm assuming is the same) fits neither body correctly. Can you please direct me to wherever the best quality versions of these are and also wherever you have explained your contention.

Thanks.

It's a generic skeleton provided by the Poser7 figure-creation software, overlaid onto pics of both Bob H and the P-G figure by Mangler. Since every individual has different proportions, the generic skeleton is not a perfect match for either subject. However, it's close enough to both to show that both "Patty" and Bob H are well within the range of normal human variation with regard to limb proportions.
 
Relax, I'll get there. I just want to first make sure I have the best images and understand the contention- and that we all understand an exercise like this is not science. In the meantime you may want to check your biases and take a closer look at those images (and everyone please refrain from calling me a BF "believer" because I am not.)

No one has mentioned ' believer ' besides you, in this thread, since before you showed up .. ....

Was that a preemptive strike ?
 
Thanks Vortigern99. Are there bigger versions somewhere? Is this or any similar software a free download by any chance?

However, it's close enough to both to show that both "Patty" and Bob H are well within the range of normal human variation with regard to limb proportions.

You're entitled to your opinion but I really don't see how anyone can objectively arrive at this conclusion based on these images and with no effort to show what human variation actually is. I was thinking of playing with these images but it's probably not worthwhile as everyone seems to see what they want. Sure the skeleton "fits" inside both bodies if that's all anyone is looking at, but it actually matches quite poorly at some of the important places- in my view. I'm not really sure a critique can be done without some level of subjectivity so I would just caution anyone from citing this as any sort of evidence that Bob H's skeleton fits inside the figure- though I'm not yet assuming that was the original claim.

It's an interesting exercise but, for me, it proves nothing.

Yes Greg that was preemptive. I don't want to be dismissed because of anyone's prejudices.
 
Both sides? Show me where JohnWS has insulted Melissa.

Matt Crowley calling Melissa a groupie has nothing to do with JohnWS or anybody else, for that matter. Furthermore, Melissa did initiate the insults well before Matt calling her that. She repeatedly fabricated and manipulated false accusations against Matt as well as accused him of avoiding any random question she would make up on the spot. She initiated it, and she got a response that she deserved.

And that is what you are seeing now happening with JohnWS. Show me where he has insulted her, he hasn't. She has just initiated it.

This isn't about "Sides". This isn't a volleyball game.

Wait a minute here, is this John Cartwright?

Yes it is me Wolftrax. Never said JohnWS did anything. And Again can we just drop it please? Jeez... get over it.
 
Hey, you are the one who brought it up.

That's like me saying "Hey John, remember that time that you said I supported a hoaxer when in reality I refused to condemn him without more evidence; or the various times that you insulted me; or how about all the different identities you made trying to hassle the Bigfoot Discussions board; all because you like to make sides and be a part of a group and impress the few friends you have instead of having the courage to be and think like an individual? But hey, let's drop it, please."
 
Last edited:
Ok, quick synopsis. For a few years Melissa claimed that she could not replicate Matt Crowley's results, she could not get artifacts. However, it was apparent from her tests that she was not using the same substrate as Matt, that bieng pumice or also called volcanic ash. This substrate was shown by Matt to produce ridge like patterns in plaster that matched what is alleged to be dermal ridges on one of the Onion Mtn. casts, CA-19.

DesertYeti, a geologist, then clarified that this was a process of dessication,the substrate absorbed the water from the plaster slurry before it cured. He also identified other substrates that he had observed this same effect.

I then did Matt's test, followed it as directed, and also got casting artifacts that resembled what are alleged to be dermal ridges in CA-19.

Bittermonk then replicated Matt's experiment and got the same result.

Melissa then finally a few years later did the experiment using pumice, but claimed that she did not get artifacts. She posted a small photo of her cast without any details or closeups. She also used her own foot mixing her own dermals with any artifacts that might be there, therefore she did not have a control. I would have to actually see a closeup of her photos, but it does look like there are artifacts there, though the photo is so small and such low resolution it would be hard to be certain.

Melissa then did a cast and instead of using her hand, she used a spoon or mixing stick (cannot remember which) and did get casting artifacts. Strangely, she didn't use her own foot for this test cast.

Melissa claims that the reason she did not get artifacts was because she had used her hand to mix the slurry instead of a mixing stick or spoon like Matt and I used, and the artifacts were caused by entrained air. However, Bittermonk used his hand when mixing his slurry.

I brought it up Wolftrax? Did you not type this?
 
Last edited:
Thanks Vortigern99. Are there bigger versions somewhere? Is this or any similar software a free download by any chance?



You're entitled to your opinion but I really don't see how anyone can objectively arrive at this conclusion based on these images and with no effort to show what human variation actually is. I was thinking of playing with these images but it's probably not worthwhile as everyone seems to see what they want. Sure the skeleton "fits" inside both bodies if that's all anyone is looking at, but it actually matches quite poorly at some of the important places- in my view. I'm not really sure a critique can be done without some level of subjectivity so I would just caution anyone from citing this as any sort of evidence that Bob H's skeleton fits inside the figure- though I'm not yet assuming that was the original claim.

It's an interesting exercise but, for me, it proves nothing.

Yes Greg that was preemptive. I don't want to be dismissed because of anyone's prejudices.

All you need to do is clearly and specifically point out issues with the fit, that way there can be no room for biases and interpretation. All you've done so far is thrown around generalities.
 
Thanks Vortigern99. Are there bigger versions somewhere? Is this or any similar software a free download by any chance?



You're entitled to your opinion but I really don't see how anyone can objectively arrive at this conclusion based on these images and with no effort to show what human variation actually is. I was thinking of playing with these images but it's probably not worthwhile as everyone seems to see what they want. Sure the skeleton "fits" inside both bodies if that's all anyone is looking at, but it actually matches quite poorly at some of the important places- in my view. I'm not really sure a critique can be done without some level of subjectivity so I would just caution anyone from citing this as any sort of evidence that Bob H's skeleton fits inside the figure- though I'm not yet assuming that was the original claim.

It's an interesting exercise but, for me, it proves nothing.

Yes Greg that was preemptive. I don't want to be dismissed because of anyone's prejudices.

I don't think Poser7 is a free download, but a similar program, DAZ Studio, is free. (I have problems moving the "camera" around with DAZ, but the female figure is imminently posable.) You can type "anatomy software" or "figure drawing software" into a search engine and find a whole host of trials and free downloads, if you're of a mind to do so. Good luck in your quest!

As to my "opinion" that Mangler's Poser7 overlays show that both Bob H and "Patty" fall within the range of human variation, I don't understand the nature of your objection. Allow me to clarify my position:

1. The P7 skeleton has normal human proportions (where "normal" is defined as "conforming to the average human measurement of a given body part" -- where the fingers, for example, extend to mid-thigh of a vertically held arm).

2. The P7 skeleton fits inside of Bob H with slight differences in the limb proportions -- expected, because of the aforementioned range of individual variation in limb measurement.

3. The P7 skeleton also fits inside of "Patty", again with slight differences in limb proportions -- again expected, because of the range of individual variation in limb measurement.

Where is the room for personal opinion here? Where does the skeleton "match quite poorly in some of the important places"? Are not the limb proportions the essence of the disagreement on whether "Patty" is a human being or not? Does not showing that "she" has normal human limb proportions directly rebut the contention that "her" arms are longer than the average persons?

I can assure you that I, for one, am not "seeing what I want", for this simple reason: When I first laid eyes on those overlays, I was still an ardent "believer" in BF and in the legitimacy of the P-G film. My viewing of those images was the first solid strike against that belief.

Far from "seeing what I wanted", I instead encountered what I considered to be the first serious rebuttal to the argument, espoused in such persuasive scientific language by Glickman in the NASI report, that "Patty"'s limb proportions/IM index lay "between a gorilla and a human being". I wanted, and still want, to "believe" in bigfoot, but unfortunately for that desire, the evidence simply does not support the belief.
 
Hey, you are the one who brought it up.

That's like me saying "Hey John, remember that time that you said I supported a hoaxer when in reality I refused to condemn him without more evidence; or the various times that you insulted me; or how about all the different identities you made trying to hassle the Bigfoot Discussions board; all because you like to make sides and be a part of a group and impress the few friends you have instead of having the courage to be and think like an individual? But hey, let's drop it, please."

The two of you will soon be introduced to AAH.
 
No little Kit Dfoot made claims, he never furnished proof of anything. Also Patterson "has not tried anything in over 35 years since he's been dead since 1973. Patterson according to Dfoot "had" tried to fake etc. etc. Keep your tense proper OK.

Dfoot has shown the bff what costume Patterson used, who he used, and why he used it. Read Dfoot's posts. He is credible because he is in the hollywood community.
 
Dfoot has shown the bff what costume Patterson might have used, who he could possibly have used, and speculations as to why he might have used it. Read Dfoot's posts. He is credible in part because he is in the hollywood community and understands the design and application of effects costumes.

Fixed! ;)
 
I brought it up Wolftrax? Did you not type this?

Absolutely. I gave a synopsis of the experiments and what had happened in response to your statements that Matt didn't follow the same procedures as the original casters or that Melissa tried unsuccessfully to replicate the artifacts.

The discussion of casting artifacts or Matt Crowley does not and should not equate the personal tirade Melissa bastardized it into.
 
Last edited:
I suspect that part of Dr. Galen's comments will involve a comparison of the Poser skeleton's skull and the head of Bob H. in the frontal shot. Speaking of which, I'd imagine that the original images (and other data used to create them) could be obtained by PMing the creator, mangler.
 
Vortigern99- My comment about "seeing what one wants" wasn't meant as a slight to you or anyone else, it's more of an observation of the human condition and a reminder how subjective this exercise is- similar to debating what "fits" or not. If you don't see that and consider these overlays comparable to anything scientific than I can't help you.

GT/CS- I realize everyone expects instant results and feedback in this internet age but please be patient. I'm not going to be baited into throwing some sloppy diagram up so am sticking to generalities for the moment. I'm also not promising anything at all, much less anything scientific- we don't need any more of that. But if I can adequately articulate what I'm seeing I will happily share it for everyone to beat on.

Also what is AAH? Guess I need to read more of the new member stuff?

---
Overall, with due respect to him(?) for the effort, I'm surprised Kitakaze could "flaunt" these here seemingly unquestioned, though again, I'm not caught up on his intentions and the history... and I probably will never be now that I've seen your 400 page threads! But skepticism of skepticism is allowed here right?

I see now these are images from Mangler, sorry for being sloppy.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely. I gave a synopsis of the experiments and what had happened in response to your statements that Matt didn't follow the same procedures as the original casters or that Melissa tried unsuccessfully to replicate the artifacts.

Wolftrax, what the heck are you talking about? When did I mention anything about Matt's procedures? I could care less. Again, Bigfoot foot casts are interesting BUT they are not proof anyway. Therefore I am not vested in this argument anyway. Go tilt at windmills somewhere else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom