Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
yes, I have them, but not uploaded. Somebody on this forum emailed me a while back offering to upload them here, (I still can't figure it out or have the time) and all that got passed me...who was that...is the offer still good?
Otherwise I can upload them on the website and send you all a link...but not today.....

Patty does not go down in the first part of the film, she flails and bends forward and almost goes down but we don't see it for the splicing and this is towards the last of the 'less than 50 seconds' she is filmed out of a 8 minute roll of film. That roll has been so hacked up, it's ridiculous. I would give anything to see what was edited.
Wouldn't we all?
B.

When Bob Gimlin recounts the events of that day, he never mentions Patty falling or even stumbling
 
Not much more seriously at all. Why would they? There's no requirement that anyone confess to hoaxes on their deathbed simply because someone in the past may have done so. Is this a new branch of bigfoot science?

And Indeed , when a bit younger and with my dark humour, I had planned to confess something jsut for fun (nothing bad though).

And for recall, one UFO guy dead recently made such deathbed non-confession, in IMHO an attempt to make himself well known even after death.
 
Bobbie, you should be able to attach images to your posts here. You can do it from images on your hard drive (or a disc drive) or from a website. When you compose a post look for the little paperclip icon. Clicking that will give you a menu window showing size limitations and browse functions.
 
Melissa Hovey has been trying to recreate these "casting effects" by the guy's casting instructions.
QUOTE]

Dude, that was soooooo not smart mentioning Melissa's casting to Wolftrax. Have you been living under a rock? Run for your life!
 
Bill mentioned over at BFF that he saw over 500' of film made by Patterson ...

Who wants to bet that this didn't include Patterson's 1961 gorilla suit test footage (as claimed by Harvey Anderson). I also doubt that he saw the still pictures of someone in a Bigfoot suit that Duane Anderson claimed Patterson took
 
Melissa Hovey has been trying to recreate these "casting effects" by the guy's casting instructions.
http://txsasquatch.blogspot.com/2008/09/reference-page-for-casting-articles.html

You might want to check these out for more detail on why that's a poor argument. Oh, and here's what Jimmy Chilcutt has to say on the matter of casting artifacts. Any further discussion of the matter should be done over here.

Were you the person who brought up the Skookum cast and Sierra sounds? If so, discussion of those topics would be better suited at the Skookum cast thread or this bigfoot audio thread.
 
No they haven't been shown to be casting artifacts. There is a guy claiming they are, but he doesn't follow the exact same casting methods as the original casters do

Melissa Hovey has been trying to recreate these "casting effects" by the guy's casting instructions.
http://txsasquatch.blogspot.com/2008/09/reference-page-for-casting-articles.html

Wow. You got a pronounced case of Bigfoot enthusiasm. You are barking way up the wrong tree talking about some guy making claims. Do footers in West Virginia not pay attention or what? Matt Crowleys experiments have been replicated by two Bigfoot proponents (wolftrax and Bittermonk) so oops for you. Try to keep up, you're in Thunderdome now.
 
Additional footage should include at least one demonstration (fake) Bigfoot trackway made by Patterson. He told both Dahinden and Krantz that he created fake tracks, cast them, and filmed it to be part of his documentary. The thing is, he told those guys about two different demos. For Krantz, he said that he made and filmed the demo trackway at Bluff Creek not long before he claimed to encounter Patty. This is why there is always the nagging question of whether the plaster pour scene is a staged demo or what is claimed to be the actual trackway of Patty.

So it could be that there are three different scenes of Bigfoot trackways and plaster pouring:

1. Track demo scene A in Washington? (as told to Dahinden).
2. Track demo scene B at Bluff Creek (as told to Krantz).
3. Patty trackway at Bluff Creek post-encounter.


ETA: Of course, creating fake Bigfoot tracks at Bluff Creek (as told to Krantz) a couple days before Patty means that Patterson had whatever tools necessary to create fake tracks with him.
 
Last edited:
kitakaze said:
Who suggested that the suit was used for Patty (as opposed to the mask)?

That would be me. I offered that option as a counter for Bill Munns' claim that no fur costumes capable of fitting a person in the 7 foot range existed that the time that could be altered/reused for Patty. What crowlogic fails to realize is that the costume depicts an ape-man wearing a caveman-style fur covering. Assuming that Mr. Munns is correct for a moment regarding the height, use of this costume would require removing the fur caveman vest from the costume and cleaning/repainting/adding hair to the mask. However, I think it would be good to film a recreation of the costume at the distance estimated for Patty under similar filming conditions to see how the Tauren suit would like and if it would look like Patty. I should note that I'm not married to the idea and that there are other ways for a costume of such size to have been created.

jhunter1163 said:
Haven't most of the special-effects people who have studied the PGF, people who know a suit when they see one, concluded that the subject of the PGF is a guy in a suit? (the exception being Bill Munns)

That's mostly correct. To add to Vort's list of Chris Walas, Stan Winston, and Rick Baker:

Verne Langdon
Bob Burns (Gorilla suit actor)
John Vulich
Tom Savini
Steve Myers

I think a few other FX artists were contacted about the PGF and had their comments posted in the BFF. However, I can't find that particular thread at the moment.

To my knowledge, the only other person in the field (note counting Prohaska, since he is suspected of helping create the Patty suit) who shares Mr. Munns' view is some indie makeup guy whose name I can't remember. I think I found out about him in an article on the PGF on bigfootencounters.

I should note that Brian Penikas once said something to the effect of the following during a discussion of extending the length of one's arms using costumes:

Oh, and I think Prohaska's time estimate was around 10 hours or so.

The Patterson footage does not have that shortened upper arm, which creeps me out!! Could it be the real deal?

However, he made no other arguments for it being real and does not seem to know about the arm length illusion that's been noted here numerous times. I might try might try contacting him at some point in the future about that (and other issues).

wvbig said:
This is where I think the idea of it being a guy in a suit, runs into direct conflict with what has been reported about Roger Patterson. That he was broke. I would think if it was a guy in a suit, it would've been debunked years ago unless it was a very very good custom made suit. Very very good custom made suit=$$$$$$$$$$$ So how would a guy who was broke come up with that caliber of costume?

Since you've already been informed of the Radford loan, I figured I'd show you this Wikipedia quotation cited from page 300 of Greg Long's The Making of Bigfoot:

Some decades after the Patterson-Gimlin film's publicity, Greg Long interviewed people who described Patterson as a liar, a conman, and sometimes worse. Pat Mason, Glen Koelling, Bob Swanson and Vilma Radford claimed Patterson never repaid loans they made to him for various Bigfoot-related ventures. Radford alone had corroborative evidence: A $700 promissory note "for expenses in connection with filming of 'Bigfoot: Americas Abominable Snowman. (sic)'"

Let's pretend for a moment that all the other loans were real and that they were all for $700. All four loans added together would've given Patterson $2,800!

wvbig said:
In a discussion over on BFF or NABF, someone did some checking & found out stretchable fake fur like would be needed to move so life-like over the musculature, wasn't available in 1967. Although Janos P.'s statement about gluing the hair on a costume does sound like something someone with a little inside info might say. And I would think that would work in place of stretchable fur fabric

As previously noted, that was Bill Munns. The problem with that argument is that he himself said that while premade 4-way stretch furcloth didn't exist then, he did say that material like it could be made from stretchable fabric ventilated with fake fur could work the same way. Look at the bottom of this for more on the matter.

wvbig said:
1)Animatronics didn't exist in 1967

This 1964 article proves that's not true. Similarly, searching for "animatronic" on the Trademark Electronic Search System at this site will give you a record for audio-animatronics that was registered in 1967 (After being filed in 1964). Since I can't hotlink the result, I'll provide the following information so that others can easily identify the record when they use the search function:

Serial Number: 72192128
Reg. Number: 0828370
Word Mark: AUDIO-ANIMATRONICS

But, as others have noted, this is a moot point since nobody is saying that the Patty suit would have used animatronics.

2)If it is a suit, it's good enough to have built in padding for musculature & doesn't sag anywhere

So? Costumes like that exist. For example, the costume used in the 1966 film "War of the Gargantuas" look sag-free to me. Making built-in padding is not a problem at all (I forget who deserves credit for originally finding this).

wvbig said:
These two confessions indicate a pattern among people of older generations.

No they don't. You've already been shown that the fairy hoaxers confessed prior to their death and the Surgeon photo hoaxer died without confessing. It was his stepson who confessed after being confronted about it by a suspicious researcher.

Let's not forget that the Piltdown man hoaxer went to the grave without confessing, as did bigfoot hoaxers Ivan Marx and Ray Wallace.

makaya325 said:
The scientific community never accepted the surgeons photo as a hoax. They thought it might have been a duck or a log.

I think you're misremembering an old post of mine. Although it's true that the misidentification theories were more numerous than the hoax theories, there was speculation that it was a hoax. This was presumably due to people not wanting to accuse the man credited with taking the picture as lying and the obscurity of the second Surgeon photo. Said photograph revealed differences that showed the pictures could not have been taken in the matter they had claimed to have been (thus revealing more support for it being a hoax). While we're on the matter, I'd like to note that any arguments about toy submarines or plastic wood not existing then (and thus rendering the hoax argument implausible) are laughably wrong.

bobbieshort said:
It may jiggle like a real animal but the tell-tale characteristic that makes it a suit and not the real deal is the ridiculous thickness of the fur; Patty on the other hand is barely haired

Actually, there are many suits that use short fur. Here's a list of all the films/tv shows that I'm aware of that feature such costumes:

"Go and Get It" (1920)
"The Lost World" (1925)
"Half Human" (1955)
"King Kong vs. Godzilla" (1962)
"War of the Gargantuas" (1966)
"Ultra Q" (1966-1967, TV Series)
"King Kong Escapes" (1967)
Ivan Marx "cripplefoot" film (1971) - Fur is said to be shorter than Patty's
"Ike! Godman" (1972-1973, TV Series)
"Ike! Greenman" (1973-1974, TV Series)
"Queen Kong" (1976)
"A*P*E" (1976)
"Shaolin Invincibles" (1977)
"Earth Girls are Easy" (1988)
Harley/Hutch Hoffman Bigfoot film (2005) - used to promote "Searching for Santa"

Also worthy of note is the reconstructed Gaira costume in the direct-to-DVD episodes of "Ike! Godman" made for the semi-recent Japanese DVD release. I should also point out that this list is far from definitive and there could be many other films and TV shows with short-furred apes, werewolves, bears, etc. costumes. Oh, and the above-mentioned Japanse TV shows used recycled (and sometimes altered versions) of suits from some of the movies in the list.

and under her arms and thoratic region, there are worn spots where the body rubs against itself.

Correct me if I'm wrong here, but didn't Bill Miller argue those were actually light and shadows using this image?

wvbig said:
I've never heard him say anything about being close to "Patty" when they first saw her. If they were, what took them so long to start filming? YouTube has a clip of the film in its original, unenhanced state. Not enlarged or anything & she looks to be about 100 yds from the camera

Go on Youtube and search for "Shooting the Bigfoot." This should lead you to an upload of an episode of "The X Creatures" that deals with the PGF. At one point, they do a recreation of the shooting conditions (but not of Patty, they just used a preexisting costume) that shows the distance between Patterson and Patty.

Drewbot said:
But according to Roger Patterson, didn't Patty take off running "Just like you and me"?

Bob Gimlin said Patty ran in the "Wandering Woodspersons" section here. However, he says the opposite here. Also, I found a comment about Patty by Bob Gimlin (4:40ish) in this video that could be useful.
 
Last edited:
Do you mean things MK has discovered about the film?

That would be some of what Bobbie is referring to. Bobbie supports the idea that Roger and Bobe rode out that day and blasted some Bigfoot. MK thinks Patty was a type of human. Hey, wait a minute. You think Bigfoot is a type of primitive human as well who can speak:

For those who aren't sure what Bigfoot is. Since it walks primarily bipedally, has a foot closer resembling a humans than an apes, appears to have a human-like buttocks, some believe it's capable of speech, & all the colors of them that people have reported seeing, are naturally occuring human hair colors. I believe Bigfoot is a primative form of human.

http://steventitchenell.tripod.com/wvbig/

You think there are talking Bigfoots running around West Virginia uncatalogued by modern science? Wow. That's a highly bizarre thing to believe in. Do you believe in ghosts, chupacabras, and alien visitation as well?

Yes, yes. Don't tell me...

...in 1975 I saw what was at the time, a U.F.O. But in 1988 when the government released film of the Stealth Bomber, I realized that's what I saw in 1975. Ever since then, I feel confident that U.F.O.'s are top secret aircraft of our military & possibly other terrestrial militaries.

http://www.thescienceforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=180301

I mean straight-up alien visitation. Do you dismiss the evidence for that while accepting Bigfoot?

You think Gigantopithecus is related to Homo erectus. Are you wonky or what? BTW, your research is very weak:

Another hypothesis is that Bigfoot is either Gigantopithecus blacki or a descendant of Giganto, which is generally believed to have been an ape that lived in Asia & is presumed to have died out approximately 300,000 years ago. These two hypotheses however, are not necessarily in conflict with one another. A German Anatomist & Anthropologist named Dr. Franz Weinreich (1873-1948) believed Giganto was actually Hominidae and not Pongidae. He based this hypothesis on the similarities between the occlusal surfaces of the teeth of Giganto and those of Pithecanthropus & Sinanthropus. Both of which were hominids

http://steventitchenell.tripod.com/wvbig/

That would be Franz Weidenreich, brilliance. If you're going to flail lthat guy's name all over the internet in support of your Bigfoot pondering, at least get his name right. Also you list Pithecanthropus and Sinanthropus. These are old names more commonly known as Java Man and Peking Man respectively. You apparently have some reason for presenting these as separate species and don't have a clue about Homo erectus and human evolution. Weidenreich was a very smart guy. He recognized the Piltdown Man as a hoax three decades before the rest of paleoanthropology caught up with him. He wasn't perfect, though. He proposed the Weidenreich Theory of Human Evolution. The Weidenreich Theory states that human races have evolved independently in the Old World from Homo erectus to Homo sapiens. This is almost certainly not the case as we have plenty of reliable evidence that modern Homo sapiens displaced species such as Homo erectus and Homo neanderthalensis. More importantly for your ideas about Gigantopithecus and Homo erectus being related you need to check the following information from my link:

Professor Weidenreich also renamed Gigantopithecus blacki to Giganthropus blacki, based on a theory that primitive forms of man were much larger than the more recent ones. However, as this theory is contradictory to the Cope-Deperet rule (which states that in straight evolution lines of non-flying animals the size of species increases, not the other way round), it was rejected by Professor Dr. von Koenigswald when he returned from the Japanese concentration camp after the Second World War.

Here's you on a science forum:

Steven said:
A German Anatomist & Anthropologist named Dr. Franz Weinreich (1873-
1948) believed Gigantopithecus blacki was actually Hominidae and not Pongidae. Therefore it should have been called Gigantanthropus He based his
hypothesis on similarities between the occlusal surfaces of the teeth of
Giganto and those of Pithecanthropus & Sinanthropus. I believe this is significan't because it could unite those Bigfoot researchers who subscribe to the Giganto hypothesis with those who subscribe to the hypothesis that Bigfoot is a hominid.
http://www.returnoftheniphilim.com/PhotoAntediluvianGiant.html

note: If the link doesn't work, do a Google search for "Antediluvian Giant" & click on the first result.

Steven said:
With all due respect. Have you put any effort at all into studying the phenomenon?
_________________
Steven

http://www.thescienceforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=150124

See, you can show up on a science forum and blindside some people with your piss-poor research and be condescending about if they've studied Bigfoot but you're in Thunderdome now and we eat Bigfoot enthusiasts who don't do their homework like you for lunch. You might want to scoot back to your West Virginia Bigfoot Investigations Group website and fix that up because the next time somebody googles "Franz Weireich" or the correct "Franz Weidenreich" and "Bigfoot" one of the top hits they'll get is you getting served by me.

Enjoy and welcome to Thunderdome.
 
Last edited:
That would be some of what Bobbie is referring to. Bobbie supports the idea that Roger and Bobe rode out that day and blasted some Bigfoot. MK thinks Patty was a type of human. Hey, wait a minute. You think Bigfoot is a type of primitive human as well who can speak:



http://steventitchenell.tripod.com/wvbig/

You think there are talking Bigfoots running around West Virginia uncatalogued by modern science? Wow. That's a highly bizarre thing to believe in. Do you believe in ghosts, chupacabras, and alien visitation as well?

Yes, yes. Don't tell me...



http://www.thescienceforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=180301

I mean straight-up alien visitation. Do you dismiss the evidence for that while accepting Bigfoot?

You think Gigantopithecus is related to Homo erectus. Are you wonky or what? BTW, your research is very weak:



http://steventitchenell.tripod.com/wvbig/

That would be Franz Weidenreich, brilliance. If you're going to flail lthat guy's name all over the internet in support of your Bigfoot pondering, at least get his name right. Also you list Pithecanthropus and Sinanthropus. These are old names more commonly known as Java Man and Peking Man respectively. You apparently have some reason for presenting these as separate species and don't have a clue about Homo erectus and human evolution. Weidenreich was a very smart guy. He recognized the Piltdown Man as a hoax three decades before the rest of paleoanthropology caught up with him. He wasn't perfect, though. He proposed the Weidenreich Theory of Human Evolution. The Weidenreich Theory states that human races have evolved independently in the Old World from Homo erectus to Homo sapiens. This is almost certainly not the case as we have plenty of reliable evidence that modern Homo sapiens displaced species such as Homo erectus and Homo neanderthalensis. More importantly for your ideas about Gigantopithecus and Homo erectus being related you need to check the following information from my link:



Here's you on a science forum:





http://www.thescienceforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=150124

See, you can show up on a science forum and blindside some people with your piss-poor research and be condescending about if they've studied Bigfoot but you're in Thunderdome now and we eat Bigfoot enthusiasts who don't do their homework like you for lunch. You might want to scoot back to your West Virginia Bigfoot Investigations Group website and fix that up because the next time somebody googles "Franz Weireich" or the correct "Franz Weidenreich" and "Bigfoot" one of the top hits they'll get is you getting served by me.

Enjoy and welcome to Thunderdome.

I got the spelling and the names Sinanthropus & Pithecanthropus from the Antedeluvian Giants page. You Bigfoot skeptics think any research that comes up with something different is poor research. What about the belief that human lfe started in Africa? Now they have that 47 million year old primate fossil from Germany. Which research is wrong? That which says human life began in Africa? Or that which has Identified the fossil?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Crowlogic
Really what do you expect to find? It ain't gonna happen sugar!

The better question is what are they afraid we'll find?
 
I got the spelling and the names Sinanthropus & Pithecanthropus from the Antedeluvian Giants page.

In other words you didn't do your research beyond that and had no idea that you were looking at antiquated terms for a single species (Homo erectus). Nor did you check into the reliability of Weidenreich's idea or even verify specifically what it was. You just thought you had a neato way to try and unite the ape vs primitive human debate amongst Bigfoot enthusiasts and off to the races you went.

You Bigfoot skeptics think any research that comes up with something different is poor research.

No, we think poor research is poor research. Suck it up and don't be so sloppy next time. Unless, that is, you want someone like me to come along and school you making you look lazy and addled by Bigfoot confirmation bias just like I'm doing now.

What about the belief that human lfe started in Africa? Now they have that 47 million year old primate fossil from Germany. Which research is wrong? That which says human life began in Africa? Or that which has Identified the fossil?

I fell down.

Steven, you just did a lemming run right off the ledge of intelligent discussion. Read very carefully what you just wrote. Footers like you aren't helping your community out with this kind of hair-brained thinking.
 
Last edited:
kitakaze wrote:
No, we think poor research is poor research.

Suck it up and don't be so sloppy next time.

Unless, that is, you want someone like me to come along and school you making you look lazy and addled by Bigfoot confirmation bias just like I'm doing now.


Let's see.......what did kitakaze do, when he first saw this "gem" of 'evidential engineering'....(custom-tailored evidence......'made to fit...while-you-wait'...;) )...



GooGooGaaGaa99.gif




My post, about it...

Thanks, wolftrax, for posting yet another piece of "skeptical" nonsense/BS. :)


Here is the animated-gif slowed down. The key frame is the one with the added shadow...


GooGooGaaGaa99.gif




Here....I highlighted exactly where we can see what a complete piece of nonsense/BS the "shadow illusion" truly is....:)

Look inside the circles, where one shows the white background directly beside Patty's hand....and the other one shows the black shadow of the doll hand, itself...


GooGooGaaGaa9999.gif




"Ooops" for "skepticism"! :)



And kitakaze's (skeptical woo-dance of joy) reaction to the BS gif...


Holy cow, wolftrax, that is an awesome redux of Spektator's doll hand demo.



A slightly more appropriate response woud have been this.....


Holy cow-flop, wolfy, that is an awesome redux of Spektator's doll hand demo



But, the most appropriate repsonse to it, would have been...


It's 100% pure Cow-flop!




Suck it up and don't be so sloppy next time........Thunder-butt! ;)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom