Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
For a guy who doesn't want attention he sure is hosting quite a bash next year. what's with that?

Consider shows such as MonsterQuest which have had to rely on old and rare interviews with BG. He's gradually warming to all the people who have been so kind to him. His party is like a big thank-you to them. It allows him to return the kindness they've shown him. He has no overwhelming reason to tell anyone he hoaxed anything.
 
GT, it's a particular kind of attention he is comfortable with. Bigfooter gatherings are about support for the PGF and Gimlin. There may be PGF skeptics in the crowd, but they ain't gonna get vocal about it.
 
He's gradually warming to all the people who have been so kind to him. His party is like a big thank-you to them.

He has never spoken to Bill Munns - somebody else invited him to the "friends" party. Bob's closest friends may be telling him who his friends are. They may also be telling him who his "enemies" are. That is unless Gimlin lurks all the forums himself.
 
One big reason why you don't see BG doing BF documentary interviews - Who's to say he doesn't end up being across from someone who's done in-depth research and has difficult questions for him. No way, Jose.
 
He has never spoken to Bill Munns - somebody else invited him to the "friends" party. Bob's closest friends may be telling him who his friends are. They may also be telling him who his "enemies" are.

Bingo. I bet Bob would rather watch football, NASCAR, and Animal Planet than even attempt to wade in to the Terrordrome or anywhere else in BF netdom.
 
The following confirms that the original registration was not until 1983. Note the filing falls under "Later deposit and registration" Hope this helps LT

If I'm reading this right, the earliest LoC records regarding the PGF will actually be the RD "filmstrip" filing, correct?
 
Unless it is filed under something else, and by a different claimant, i.e. Bigfoot Bob, or they filed the copyright as owned by Bigfoot Enterprises, A.N.E., or something like that.
 
Thanks for all of that. It raises more questions.

The 12 Cibachromes look different when compared to the film. The process allows altering colors and this has been done it seems by Bruce Bonney. Because the process creates a paper print, one can then do paint or ink touch-ups/modifications upon the print itself. I believe this was done on the Cibachrome Frame 352 to give the impression of a curled right hand. Other PGF Cibas from Bonney have a distinct blue color "wash" and this makes them different compared to the film.

Your search may be incomplete unless it includes the Canada Copyright archives. Dahinden lived there and some of his CRs may be registered in Canada, not the USA.

WP and Drew, the legal beagle has responded ( with the caveat that this is just a general observation unless and until actual documentation is obtained)

1) Depending on the actual filing paperwork and any samples- there might be a legal question as to what the PGF actually "is" in the first place. ( theres a big difference between the full work[whatever that is/was] and what was filed as copyrighted material) she said in case of a motion picture, there needs to be a reference copy attached to show what the title represents. A copyright could be assigned back then with just the "working title" but then the legal question then becomes "what film is attached to this title" ( it could be the raw copy, an edited post production copy, combination of successive rolls or almost anything) She said if theres no original on file from 67 or narrative,script or "something" identifying exactly "what" constitutes the PGF then that puts everything up for a legal challenge. ( she said basically you have copyright when you film something but thats a LONG way from being able to PROVE you have it[ which is why you register to begin with] if you are challenged. She said if theres no reference copy filed in 67, she could assemble clips from the PGF, call it whatever[ different name], swear she filmed those scenes, copyright it and that would survive ANY legal challenge from anyone UNLESS someone with a copyright could PROVE she didnt and that would require them producing a visual record of what was copyrighted in the first place.)

She then went on to say that might be what that other filing Drew is talking about with this film short was probably about that I sent her. ( she said that somebody had to supply a visual record of something)

Then she relates that if there is no specific identifier of what the original was/is- then anyone with a copy of the film can file their copy and claim it as their work and the RP/BG "PGF" is something else and unless one of the copyright owners has the original- they would play hell contesting it because they may own a copyright of a film "called' the PGF but if they cant PROVE what the film has on it, they would have a very weak legal position to dispute the claim.

As to the stills, she said that the first question is are these "prints" legally a generational reproduction from the original or new exclusive works of their own after being modified by whatever process. ( that could be a legal challenge of its own if they would be considered generational originals and those same images are still in a copyrighted film) She said a copy of the original and the final product would have to be compared by accepted legal tests such as the "abstractions test', "patterns test","extrinsic/intrinsic" test ,"totality" test ,"subtractive" test and possibly the new "abstraction-filtration-comparison test".
 
If I'm reading this right, the earliest LoC records regarding the PGF will actually be the RD "filmstrip" filing, correct?

Not according to what they told me. The person there said that anything before 78 ( or whenever) would require a manual search. After what I just found out, there might be an even bigger problem now.

If this IS the first filing with a visual sample, ONLY what is on that film is considered the "original" work and anything not on it might be up for grabs but RD's work has a different number and the question will be what is described under his CR and whats on the film.
 
Depending on the actual filing paperwork and any samples- there might be a legal question as to what the PGF actually "is" in the first place. ( theres a big difference between the full work[whatever that is/was] and what was filed as copyrighted material) she said in case of a motion picture, there needs to be a reference copy attached to show what the title represents. A copyright could be assigned back then with just the "working title" but then the legal question then becomes "what film is attached to this title" ( it could be the raw copy, an edited post production copy, combination of successive rolls or almost anything) She said if theres no original on file from 67 or narrative,script or "something" identifying exactly "what" constitutes the PGF then that puts everything up for a legal challenge.


Found on the header strip of the film copy used by National Geographic "Is It Real? - Bigfoot". Note that "Big foot" is written on the celluloid and coincides with the movie title registered with the Copyright Office and the Library of Congress.


b80e99c7.jpg
2e376e01.jpg
 
Found on the header strip of the film copy used by National Geographic "Is It Real? - Bigfoot". Note that "Big foot" is written on the celluloid and coincides with the movie title registered with the Copyright Office and the Library of Congress.


http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/b80e99c7.jpg http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/2e376e01.jpg

Good eye. That's the kind of careful examination that has to go on when anything this radical is being passed around as real. That's what a real researcher into a subject does.

If only Green had considered for a moment that his "raw unedited copy" showed the frames facing two different directions he might have saved himself a lot of time and pain.

But like DeAtley said, these guys were ready to buy it as soon as they walked in because they'd already been laughed at over the Wallace prints.
 
Good eye. That's the kind of careful examination that has to go on when anything this radical is being passed around as real. That's what a real researcher into a subject does.

It was a joint effort to arrive at those header scripts. It's all in the 411 PGF.

If only Green had considered for a moment that his "raw unedited copy" showed the frames facing two different directions he might have saved himself a lot of time and pain.

You may know that a 'spokesperson' for Green at BFF says that the frames are not flipped on his copy. Said that some program producer flipped them for whatever reason.
 
I wonder if the clip on Truth or Scare is the same leader? It probably is, but it would be interesting if it isn't. I just never can seem to catch the show again to get a good look at the leader...
 
You may know that a 'spokesperson' for Green at BFF says that the frames are not flipped on his copy. Said that some program producer flipped them for whatever reason.

I suppose someone might have flipped a frame in a copy of the film as a sort of "watermark" that would uniquely ID the one given to NG if someone made an unauthorized copy of it.

I know that sounds kind of wacky...just a theory.

Of course, it is just as likely that someone spliced the film to the header backwards, realized their error and carelessly left behind a single frame on the header. It is the first frame, right?
 
NG watermarks their entire production with their logo (a small yellow rectangle) which you can see in the above header strips.

More than one frame at the beginning is flipped. Stand by for more details about that.

Edit: There are no flipped frames in the NG production. Flipped frames are seen in a different program using John Green's copy. Still stand by for more details on that one.
 
Last edited:
She said if theres no original on file from 67 or narrative,script or "something" identifying exactly "what" constitutes the PGF then that puts everything up for a legal challenge. ( she said basically you have copyright when you film something but thats a LONG way from being able to PROVE you have it[ which is why you register to begin with] if you are challenged. She said if theres no reference copy filed in 67, she could assemble clips from the PGF, call it whatever[ different name], swear she filmed those scenes, copyright it and that would survive ANY legal challenge from anyone UNLESS someone with a copyright could PROVE she didnt and that would require them producing a visual record of what was copyrighted in the first place.)

I don't think she has thought this part through. Given the time restraints she was working under - that's not surprising.

My new career in the music industry has taught me a lot about copyright issues because a lot of people claim to have had their work copied and want a piece of the millions made from a hit song. The few successes always spawn a lot of dreamers who become the victims of lawyers who come up with grandiose schemes that cannot survive a sober second thought.

It is true that anybody could conceivably swear that they filmed the scenes as depicted in what is known as the PGF.
Proving it would be a huge obstacle. (No matter how much they swear they did ;) )

The onus would have to be on the claimant - as they would be the one challenging the status quo.

1) We have witnesses and film evidence that place P&G on scene, on or about, the dates in question.
The new person claiming to be the copyright holder would have to be able to successfully challenge (disprove) that accepted fact AND place themselves on scene of the film that they have (hypothetically) spliced together - prior to the first showing of the film in Seattle.
That would involve providing the place and time they claim the film was shot and mustering enough evidence to overthrow P&G's evidence.
Not bloody likely.

2) The new person swearing that the film was their work would have to come up with a pretty darn convincing reason not to have come forward for 41 years to make their claim. That is going to be pretty tough sell - no matter what story they come up with.

3) Whether or not the original PGF (or parts thereof) would have to brought into play would depend on whether the judge thought there was enough evidence to actually bring the matter to trial which would be based on the evidence brought forward by the new claimant.
Given points 1 & 2 above - I do not see a hope in hell of anybody getting the hypothetical case proposed by the lawyer to trial – much less overturning the status quo copyright.

Also - any copyright can be given, sold, or bartered to anyone else.
Copyright can be given to somebody without them even being involved in the actual creation of what is copyrighted. A famous case of this is the song “In Another’s Eyes”. John Peppard never wrote a lick of the lyrics or music - but Garth Brooks decided that he should get the third writing credit (one third copyright) because the song came from a discussion he had with Peppard. Peppard continues to make huge $$$ off the royalties. (This was told to me by Peppard himself in the 12 Bar Cafe on Denmark Street in London in 2006).
There need not be a paper trail for copyright - nor does it have to be listed in any copyright office. A lot of writers do not copyright songs because of the expense involved. A lot of songs involves a lot of copyright fees. A pretty standard trick of the trade is to send yourself a copy of your work via registered mail and not open it unless the work is contested.

The paperwork is to protect everybody's asses - not make it legal.
 
Flipped frames on the Discovery Channel.

It starts with Patterson on horseback pulling a packhorse (0:00-0:04) from right to left. In other productions showing this scene, he rides from left to right. At 0:22 you will see the first few frames showing Patty (very hard to see) and the flowing creek and fallen tree/root system. This then flips in less than one second to the proper orientation (0:23).

Note: It is possible that that all frames are flipped from 0:00-0:23. We cannot say for certain because the various riding and scenery scenes have no global frame of reference. We can say that the Patty walk scene is properly oriented (not flipped) because the site was surveyed afterwards. You will hear Green's narration, and the sound of a running projector. If the Discovery Channel parked a cameraman in front of the movie screen, and we are seeing the projected celluloid film being videotaped - then it becomes more likely that Green's celluloid film really does have flipped frames. The alternative is that the producers decided to flip some or all of the scenes prior to 0:23.

Part 2 with computer stabilization.
 
Last edited:
Rock, you are correct and i greatly truncated the statements and took some "license" but heres 1 piece of information referencing information.

>>>Also - any copyright can be given, sold, or bartered to anyone else.
Copyright can be given to somebody without them even being involved in the actual creation of what is copyrighted.


I have been sent a document that is "possibly" the court order. ( I cant say for certain until we get someone to the courthouse and pull a certified true copy) If it is, theres a bigger problem.
 
Flipped frames on the Discovery Channel.

It starts with Patterson on horseback pulling a packhorse (0:00-0:04) from right to left. In other productions showing this scene, he rides from left to right. At 0:22 you will see the first few frames showing Patty (very hard to see) and the flowing creek and fallen tree/root system. This then flips in less than one second to the proper orientation (0:23).

Note: It is possible that that all frames are flipped from 0:00-0:23. We cannot say for certain because the various riding and scenery scenes have no global frame of reference. We can say that the Patty walk scene is properly oriented (not flipped) because the site was surveyed afterwards. You will hear Green's narration, and the sound of a running projector. If the Discovery Channel parked a cameraman in front of the movie screen, and we are seeing the projected celluloid film being videotaped - then it becomes more likely that Green's celluloid film really does have flipped frames. The alternative is that the producers decided to flip some or all of the scenes prior to 0:23.

Part 2 with computer stabilization.

Thanks for pointing that out. I had thought that the flipped frames were on the NG footage.

The NG footage seems to start out looking at the ground and then swings up to Patty. The Discovery Channel version seems to lack that piece....

I remain utterly confused.
 
Thanks for pointing that out. I had thought that the flipped frames were on the NG footage.

I understand. I was talking about the NG footage (with the header script) and Dfoot came in with the comment about flipped frames. Both of us knew these are seen in the Discovery Channel, not NG.

The NG footage seems to start out looking at the ground and then swings up to Patty. The Discovery Channel version seems to lack that piece....

That's right. The NG footage is different. Again, we cannot yet know if this is because the producers messed with what they were given by the source of the footage, or not.

I remain utterly confused.

It's about to get worse for you. I'll give you a visual puzzle. Here is the NG footage of the PGF. The relevant part is at 1:48-2:54. You already noticed that the start if different than that in NG. But watch closely and see if you can find something really strange and difficult to explain about this footage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom