Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
So far, Door #2 is in the lead by a full length and pulling away from the pack. ( but we are only on the first turn) but there are still 2 other cases out there that we havent seen anything on yet.

Heres the thing, many reports say these other 2 cases ( brought by RD on behalf of BG's interest) were dismissed. 1 for "legal reasons" ( undefined) and the other dismissed with prejudice ( cant even bring it up again with no ruling)

If this order I have seen is in fact legitimate ( its "iffy") ( only referring to the final order, ie the document with no stamps and questionable signatures) then it explains fully why the other 2 were thrown out. In doing so, it opened up another door that was unanticipated when we started looking. ( thus the need to have someone from Wa State who is an expert at probate law and the legal limitations of that states specific terms and conditions of survivorship)

It does appear at this point that Bob Gimlin has been wholly and accurately truthful in all his claims that he got little to no financial benefit from the PGF at all.
Another document ( personal sale and transfer) alleging the sale of "all rights et al" to RD is in the proper format, legal langauage, notarized and even tho not a court order would hold up as legally solvent anywhere if authentic as a contract of sale.
So, the claims that he sold his interest,rights in their totality to RD and washed his hands of it forever appear to be wholly correct as well.

As it stands right now, SOTE Bob is very "salty" and has been honest in all his accounts.

Now, removing him from the picture, the other questions may be radically different from what is currently believed and that answer lies soley in the definition,application and restrictions Washington State Probate law puts on the terms and any statutory limitations applied in the order in question. ( assuming that second order is authentic)

( thats why we are hunting on a 3rd attorney who is intimately familiar with Wa Probate law)

So, unless there is something radically different on file at the CoC from what I have been allowed to read, Mr. Gimlin, his honesty, character and accounts of his involvement ( regarding his not getting almost anything from the PGF as far as benefit [ financial or otherwise] and complete release of his entitlement of anything regarding past,present or future proceeds,ownership et al) are true and correct and always have been.

If he washed his hands of the whole thing why did he file a copyright in 1983? Is that part of your search?
 
While the presence of flipped and repeated frames do exist in the film its not by a long shot an indication of foul play so to speak. It must be understood that film editors are not perfect. This thing has never been handled my let's say a production staff on the level of a Stanley Kubrick. Does anyone really think that a low budget network TV show really would care if a few frames in the beginning were flipped or repeated? I recall watching a show in the late 80's where they referred to Roger Patterson as John Patterson. Heck there is an entirely flipped version of the film shown in Mexico/Latin America that shows up on Youtube.

I myself had taken a bunch of old family photographs to a professional photographer to have scanned and put on disk. I had to go back to the photographer and have a number redone because they were flipped. Frame/image flipping is a lot more common than you think. On a blurry grainy erratic film like the PGF its amazing that it isn't worse in that respect.
 
While the presence of flipped and repeated frames do exist in the film its not by a long shot an indication of foul play so to speak. It must be understood that film editors are not perfect. This thing has never been handled my let's say a production staff on the level of a Stanley Kubrick. Does anyone really think that a low budget network TV show really would care if a few frames in the beginning were flipped or repeated? I recall watching a show in the late 80's where they referred to Roger Patterson as John Patterson. Heck there is an entirely flipped version of the film shown in Mexico/Latin America that shows up on Youtube.

I myself had taken a bunch of old family photographs to a professional photographer to have scanned and put on disk. I had to go back to the photographer and have a number redone because they were flipped. Frame/image flipping is a lot more common than you think. On a blurry grainy erratic film like the PGF its amazing that it isn't worse in that respect.

I think this film may go down in the history books as the most studied and
analyzed film, Maybe it already is...
The apparent edits. To me anyways, do not absolutely point to foul play
But I made some pretty funky edits myself and added music... a lot of fun
 
Last edited:
I think this film may go down in the history books as the most studied and
analyzed film, Maybe it already is...
The apparent edits. To me anyways, do not absolutely point to foul play
But I made some pretty funky edits myself and added music... a lot of fun

I'd put my money on the Zapruder film being the most-analyzed bit of film in history, but the PGF would be a solid #2.

That might be the only solid #2 attributable to Bigfoot.
 
I'd put my money on the Zapruder film being the most-analyzed bit of film in history, but the PGF would be a solid #2.

That might be the only solid #2 attributable to Bigfoot.

I had that film in mind the whole time that I was writing the post.
Being 2nd means that it lost., or it is a lost cause.
Now I want to go and watch JFK stuff again thanx...
 
Last edited:
If he washed his hands of the whole thing why did he file a copyright in 1983? Is that part of your search?


Yes it is and remember, I qualified and specified my remarks as to what I specifically was talking about

>>>regarding his not getting almost anything from the PGF as far as benefit [ financial or otherwise] and complete release of his entitlement of anything regarding past,present or future proceeds,ownership et al

I'm just going in sequence. I dont know if he ( in that being his actual signature on the filing) did in 83 yet.

It really depends on whats filed at the Courthouse and what they verbatim say. ( and what Wa State law says)

This is far from over and evolving as each new data point is discovered
 
The PGF hasn't really been "analyzed" at all, imo.

Certainly not by anyone qualified to analyze it.

Certainly not by anyone both qualified and objective.

The film was apparently already edited the Sunday it was supposedly first shown to Roger by Al.

No one has been allowed to really analyze the original PGF rolls, have they?
 
Sadly, the original films have been stolen by time travelling Venusians who were looking to re-populate their planet with hybrids containing genetic material from giant, hairy, bi-pedal apes.

(Hey - my scenario is just as plausible as the nonsense that is spouted by those supposedly "in the know" about what happened to the originals)
 
Sadly, the original films have been stolen by time travelling Venusians who were looking to re-populate their planet with hybrids containing genetic material from giant, hairy, bi-pedal apes.

(Hey - my scenario is just as plausible as the nonsense that is spouted by those supposedly "in the know" about what happened to the originals)

Well, that certainly explains why bigfoot is now extinct.
 
Lontabber-
You say that BobG probably has no rights relating to the PGF, but anywhere in the court order, does it mention the dissolution of the Partnership agreement between him and Rene D.?
 
Lontabber-
You say that BobG probably has no rights relating to the PGF, but anywhere in the court order, does it mention the dissolution of the Partnership agreement between him and Rene D.?

Remember, in a legal document search- you have to go in "series" because the earlier order generally defines what can/cannot be done in subsequent orders.

The 2 court orders ( yet to be field validated) do not even address RD or anything to do with him.

Now, from what I've heard ( no documentation at all yet) was that at that time ( 76) it was RD who prompted BG to sue and they had some kind of deal going at that time. Whether thats fact,fiction or somewhere inbetween is unknown because I cant find a documented record of that agreement.

Now, move to 78, we DO have that documentation and it has a line in there stating "Whether accruing before or after the date hereof" ( referring to the date of this agreement referenced.

So, if anything, the 1978 transfer/sale agreement reinforces the belief that there was an agreement prior to it.

The 78 agreement is pretty clear and specific. BG sold out in that one. ( I mean everything and its quite clear and in black and white) The 78 agreement is NOT a "partnership agreement" of any sort- its a complete and 100% sell out from one to the other. So, if there was a "partnership" agreement in force between BG and RD prior to this document, it expired upon the signing of this one.


Thats the basis of my saying BG is more likely than not being totally honest in his claims. If the "orders" are true ( yet to be field verified) its a FACT he got nothing prior to that suit. ( thats stated and all parties agreed on it) Its a FACT that he got no financial award from that suit- (it clearly gives him the ability to make money by increased ownership interest and other concessions)

Then the sale/transfer in 78 ( that one is all inclusive). So, the only "window" he had to "make" money was between 76-78. ( and thats where RD had the other deal and was standing in his stead allegedly)

So, when you add all that up ( yet to be field verified)- it does appear he made somewhere between "little" to "nothing" from the PGF.

Heres the questions remaining. ( and the answer will only be found in Washington Law as its the governing jurisdiction of the order)

( this could have all been avoided if the court orders addressed them as they should have and defined the language a bit better)

The order does 2 things ( this is a truncated abridged version of a long order)

1) it gives BG 51% of ownership interest and basically unlimited license to do with that whatever he wishes. ( which normally includes the right to sell his interest to a 3rd party which he obviously did to RD in 78)

2) it CLEARLY states ( twice actually) that PP has "warranty of title" ( that means she actually "owns" the film and all rights associated with it. ( except the ownership INTEREST that BG has and the concessions.

The questions on the table are:( this is why we need someone who specializes in Wa. probate law)

1) could BG sell his "interest" to a 3rd party because the order is basically an unlimited user license. Its clear that BG does NOT "own" the film. ( or ever did)

Normally an individual has full right to sell, give, sublet his ownership interest any way they see fit unless state law doesnt allow for it or it violates another agreement. In this case, the court order doesnt address the issue of sale or transfer. ( one way or the other) Since this order specifies BG and JG by name and gives them by name conditions in "contract" with PP, theres a question of can they transfer under the auspices of this order since PP has clear "warranty of title" and her own conditions and any sale normally allowable could infringe on her interests.

So, depending on Washington law, the sale/transfer COULD be invalid even tho BG and RD signed a legitimate agreement in good faith with full belief that its legally valid.
( important to remember that in ANY state individuals can make any contract they wish and its legally valid EXCEPT when theres another law or condition making it invalid. Thats why you will often see statements such as "if any part of this agreement is found to be invalid/unenforcable the rest remains intact" This is why its always best to have an attorney research the law and draw up the contract)

Now, the second potential monkey in the wrench

2) Survivorship- since this order is basically an unlimited user license ( warranty of title is fully vested with PP in the order) does it survive death of a principle? ( in other words, is it disolved upon death or can it be willed to an heir and remain in effect to perpituity)

If it can be assigned then its pretty safe to believe the RD heirs own it. ( because of the transfer/sale contract) If it cannot be ( thats determined by Washington Law) then even if 1 above is valid legally and the sale could go thru- then the agreement terminated when RD died and those "rights" sold either automatically revert back to BG or revert to PP.

Thats why I need a Washington probate lawyer to talk to.

Its POSSIBLE that everyone "believes" ( in good faith) one thing but thats not the way it really is and nobody realizes it. ( wouldnt be the first time thats happened)
 
LTPE, I don't want to detract from your investigation, but you'll need a time machine to determine if Gimlin did or did not make money in the early days of the PGF marketing. Patterson went around showing the film in theaters and packed the house with folks paying a couple bucks each. There is a story of him in a hotel room with a suitcase full of cash talking about getting rich.

I suppose Roger could have given Bob money back in the days when cash was flowing. I don't think you will find legal documents related to that.
 
e40aabe7.jpg
dcdbd8dd.jpg
 
LTPE, I don't want to detract from your investigation, but you'll need a time machine to determine if Gimlin did or did not make money in the early days of the PGF marketing. Patterson went around showing the film in theaters and packed the house with folks paying a couple bucks each. There is a story of him in a hotel room with a suitcase full of cash talking about getting rich.

I suppose Roger could have given Bob money back in the days when cash was flowing. I don't think you will find legal documents related to that.

I agree and the goal isnt to attempt to see how much ( if anything) he made to any specific amount. I'm sure he made "some" money ( defined as greater than $0) but compared to the other players, it was a small fraction.

I doubt any documentation exists of any payments ( I would believe if any were made, it cash on the barrel anyway)

I'm basing the bulk on my statements on his claims in the suit and the fact they were not contested and he was awarded additional ownership interest/ opportunities than what he was originally entitled to. ( I just figure that if his claims were not true and he had been compensated, the defendants would have contested his claims and the court wouldnt have awarded him above what his original amount was)
 
( I just figure that if his claims were not true and he had been compensated, the defendants would have contested his claims and the court wouldnt have awarded him above what his original amount was)

Unless, of course, the defendants were afraid to divulge the fact that they paid Gimlin in cash.
By arguing that they paid Gimlin in cash - they would be admitting that they had sizeable cash earnings and I doubt very much if anyone declared all the cash earnings made from this film to the IRS.

Excellent work Longtabber!
Given that what you have gleaned so far is true - why do you think Gimlin did give up the rights and potential $$$?
My money is on guilty conscience.
 
Given that what you have gleaned so far is true - why do you think Gimlin did give up the rights and potential $$$? My money is on guilty conscience.

Or protection from fraud lawsuits? If it is later proven to be a hoax, or the 'guy in the suit' confesses with proof... could Gimlin be liable for fraud if he has documented ownership and profits?

Can a person be insulated from fraud allegations if they can't be shown to have profited? Is there such a thing as accessory to fraud? If so, is it still illegal if you yourself can't be shown to have profited?
 
Personal gain or causing harm to another person is the test for fraud cases in Canada.
In Canada, since there is no time limit for prosecuting indictable crimes, he could be charged criminally if he made one dollar. However, the Crown must weigh the "damage" done as well as the alleged "personal gain" and decide if it is in the public's best interest to pursue the matter.
Given the age of the case and the fact that it would be nearly impossible to prove a substantial amount of money earned by Gimlin by the fraud - I can guarantee (based on a few years of specializing in criminal fraud investigations) that there would be no investigation done - much less any charges laid.

As far as civil court - one would have to "prove" (based on a balance of probabilities) that they were "harmed" by the fraud. Such harm would have to be substantial as Canadian courts are far more likely to dismiss such suits as frivolous than American courts.

edited to add: Your point about the protection from lawsuits or criminal prosecution is an interesting one and I would like to see it answered from the US legal perspective. (I imagine that will be complicated by the fact that each state has its own set of laws).
 
Last edited:
Interesting speculations

To Rock:

>>>Given that what you have gleaned so far is true - why do you think Gimlin did give up the rights and potential $$$?
My money is on guilty conscience.


My OPINION ( for whatever thats worth) is that BG wasnt a "businessman" or knew how to market his interest and just got "flustered/overwhelmed by it and threw in the towel to RD. ( what we in the south call a "good old boy" what we affectionately call traditional farmer and other trade types. I know dozens of them who are truly master craftsmen in their "world"[ such as could grow corn in an asphalt parkinglot or can freehand make cabinets with the precision of a CNC] but they stay broke because they dont know the "business side" or how to market their skills)

The reason I believe I'm "in the ballpark" is because of the suit. ( assuming the 2 documents are valid) If those documents are valid, from a legal perspective, BG had the proverbial "gun to her head" and a judges gavel to enforce it as far as both recouping former losses and future gain. The judge made it crystal clear and in NO "uncertain terms" that BG not only had ownership interest but he had it from day 1. His "money" ( and if the claims of RD and all the royalties he got are to be believed, it was in the hundreds of thousands in 70s and 80s dollars) was right there in his hands by every legal right and enforcable under color of law by the court. ( who had the power and authority to seize or otherwise get the funds for him)

I cant believe HIS lawyer ( BG's) didnt explain all this to him so the only possible reason that PP walked out of that court with her ass intact is because BG allowed it. ( I'm not joking, BG had PP et al nailed to the proverbial cross according to those 2 orders and could have walked out of that courtroom a reasonably wealthy man with cash in hand inclusive of past,present and future earnings)

The scenario was, the judge had the gun to her head, BG's finger was on the trigger and US law would have allowed BG to pull the trigger. The only way she got out of it was BG's "good graces". That supports both the "SOTE" claim ( he didnt want to hurt PP because he certainly COULD have) and it somewhat supports RD's claims that BG didnt want any part of it and wasnt a businessman because BG could have just as easily have walked into any "marketing/management firm and let them manage his interests and made a small mint.
 
Or protection from fraud lawsuits? If it is later proven to be a hoax, or the 'guy in the suit' confesses with proof... could Gimlin be liable for fraud if he has documented ownership and profits?

Can a person be insulated from fraud allegations if they can't be shown to have profited? Is there such a thing as accessory to fraud? If so, is it still illegal if you yourself can't be shown to have profited?

Under US law, fraud is both civil and criminal. To prove fraud, its not necessary to show a person profitted but simply was involved knowing it was a fradulent act.

I really dont see any way that claiming the film subject of the PGF is "authentic" would constitute prosecutable fraud under US law in the first place.

They say they filmed a "bigfoot" and they claim its "real"

Theres no taxonomical "legal" definition of what a BF is. ( for that matter, a "bigfoot" could also "legally" be a big truck seen frequenting tractor pulls) so they could say "their" definition of a BF was an actor in a suit. ( fraud must be established by the ability to show its not legitimate in the first place)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom