Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Probably misread or misunderstood my hypothetical I posed to Atheist in the NetHarm thread.

I said 'Hypothetically, what if people with mental illnesses were focusing their hallucinations on the bigfoot phenomenon instead of getting medical help?'

And Atheist said he doesn't answer stupid hypotheticals or something like that.

That might also be it. Nevertheless, I have no doubt there are people like the ones whom I referred to who should lay off the Bigfoot and put some of these in their corn flakes.
 
From BFF. Caddy seems to think that PP holds copyrights to any still frame unless it's one of Dahinden's 12 Cibachromes.

I tend to believe he is correct except that BG owns them too LOL

According to what we have so far ( which still has not been field verified yet so it may change as each new piece of information is gleaned)

The PGF film as a whole was CR by RP and BG in 67. A film is nothing BUT a series of "frames" so whoever owns "the film" owns ALL parts of the film ( each and every frame) and they are ALL "still" frames. ( that would extend to all generational copies in long film or individual copies)

Those "claims" about still versus film are legally insolvent because the "still frames' ARE the PGF. ( just like chapters build a book)

Now, it would make better sense ( and explain the editing) if RD was sold certain frames ( the "filmstrip") to edit them out ( remove them totally and forever). Then he would own those specific frames, they would no longer be in the original work and problem solved.

I'm guessing here obviously but thats along the lines of what I'm expecting to find when we go there.
 
LTPE, IMO if you are correct then Caddy is wrong.

Cibachromes are photographic prints on Ilford Cibachrome paper using the Ilford Cibachrome process. They are a highly specialized, extreme quality print. They are not transparencies.

It is widely said that RD holds the copyright to 12 Cibachrome prints he had made by Bruce Bonney. Though they are derived from the celluloid film, they are unique entities unto themselves and do not look like other still images taken from the film.

What is implied is that RD holds the CR to these seperately from any CR of the film or other still images derived from the film. If PP tried to sell or license one of these 12 Cibachromes (without permission) then she would be violating RD's copyright.

William Parcher said:
Caddy seems to think that PP holds copyrights to any still frame unless it's one of Dahinden's 12 Cibachromes.

The key word in my quote is "unless".
 
WP, I asked one of my LS buddies about it ( who does copyright law stuff) and heres what she said. ( I'm condensing about an hr phone call)

Any part of a copyrighted work ( be it a still from a film or chapter of a book) carries the CR because its a division of the work proper. ( the example she used was words. words cant be copyrighted individually but when in sentence form, the "sentence' can be as its a part of the book) Now, that same exact sentence may be in other works but then its a volume test ( the sentence in relation to the chapter,story or whatever) and thats a legal test when a part of a work is questioned. It doesnt become a separate entity from the original it came from until it is signicantly altered from the original in CONTENT ( such as making an inked drawing from a movie still or even colorizing it) but if that happens ( it had to be under license from the original) its a "new' work and has to be independantly copyrighted.


Now a film ( or frame) is a film whether its frame by frame or in motion. ( she said the concept of someone owning consecutive frames and someone else owning the film as its moving was "preposterious"[ her words] and even if it were some "agreement" every court in this land would rule it invalid because if the owner of the "film moving" stopped the projector showing the image ( as a still) or the projector locked up would be in "violation" and infringiing on the still owners copyright)

Heres how she basically put it to me. ( in any film) -she questions the use of the physical word "copyright" when the proper term would be unlimited user license. ( or any variant). She said in the case of a film, its normal to sell "stills" in the form of a license which doesnt remove the still from the film but the owner of the license has authority( up to whatever limit is set) to use them any way they see fit, sell prints from them and whatever. ( which in essence, they "own" that still) She said thats done all the time and If a person owned the "copyright" ( as in the legal definition of copyright as opposed to license) of a "still" in a film then they would have fractile copyright ownership of the film proper and entitled to a small percentage every time it would be shown provided that still wasnt edited out and their name would have to be added to the copyright of the film proper as long as that still remained in the master work.

After talking to her, I'm wondering if "lay people" wrote these words and used the term copyright when they should have used license. She said that also happens often and IF thats the case here- theres a legal nightmare.

She is going to review whatever we get when we go there and when its done, I'll redact her info and publish whatever she sends as to her analysis.

Its so critical to see the actual filings and the EXACT words used because now ( because if they used the improper language improperly) then these alleged agreements "may" exist but be legally unenforcable and basically worthless if challenged.
 
It doesnt become a separate entity from the original it came from until it is signicantly altered from the original in CONTENT ( such as making an inked drawing from a movie still or even colorizing it) but if that happens ( it had to be under license from the original) its a "new' work and has to be independantly copyrighted.

Thanks for all of that. It raises more questions.

The 12 Cibachromes look different when compared to the film. The process allows altering colors and this has been done it seems by Bruce Bonney. Because the process creates a paper print, one can then do paint or ink touch-ups/modifications upon the print itself. I believe this was done on the Cibachrome Frame 352 to give the impression of a curled right hand. Other PGF Cibas from Bonney have a distinct blue color "wash" and this makes them different compared to the film.

Your search may be incomplete unless it includes the Canada Copyright archives. Dahinden lived there and some of his CRs may be registered in Canada, not the USA.
 
Thanks for all of that. It raises more questions.

The 12 Cibachromes look different when compared to the film. The process allows altering colors and this has been done it seems by Bruce Bonney. Because the process creates a paper print, one can then do paint or ink touch-ups/modifications upon the print itself. I believe this was done on the Cibachrome Frame 352 to give the impression of a curled right hand. Other PGF Cibas from Bonney have a distinct blue color "wash" and this makes them different compared to the film.

Your search may be incomplete unless it includes the Canada Copyright archives. Dahinden lived there and some of his CRs may be registered in Canada, not the USA.

your questions will be addressed ( thats why I hunted for a lawyer I trust with experience in this area)

I'm working on people in Canada ( but dont have anything as of this posting) to research whatever is there but I do know this. Whatever he may or may not have copyrighted originated with this PGF work so theres a paper trail. I'll obviously let the world know what ( if anything) we find
 
I'll throw this into the blender. It may have been posted before, so if it has, my apologies.

Here is a scan of a "plate" that faces page 115 of the paperback edition of Dahinden's Sasquatch book. The copyright listed on my paperback edition is 1973. The caption at the bottom of the three photo montage reads "frames from the Patterson film taken at Bluff Creek of a creature believed to be the elusive Sasquatch. Subsequent scientific analyses have tended more and more to vindicate Patterson's claims that the film was genuine. (By permission of Bob Gimlin)"

Bigfoot.jpg


Dahinden is getting Gimlin's permission in 1973?
 
Longtabber, your current situation in 2008 reminds me of me in early 2005. While my background and credentials do not compare to yours, there are certain similarities:

1. You are interested in Bigfoot. While largely skeptical, there is enough about the subject that keeps you attentive, especially to anything that purports to be hard, tangible, scientific evidence.

2. You discover something that catches your attention, a discrepancy that doesn't seem quite right.

3. You begin to research the issue, all the while being quite open about what you are doing, and willing to share information.

4. What happens next in your case remains to be seen. If it is similar to my case, expect the following:

5. You begin to discover a BUNCH of things, and you begin to achieve a rather complete understanding of the issue.

6. What you discover does not put various "Bigfoot experts" in a positive light.

7. Being that what I was investigating was a rather dry, technical subject, it didn't have the intrinsic emotional value of the Patterson film. But I would be willing to put money on the following prediction:

8. If you discover HARD EVIDENCE in the form of legal documents that puts the Patterson film, and Bob Gimlin in particular in an unfavorable light, expect to become the victim of vitriolic personal attacks and insinuations, almost certainly originating on Bigfoot Forums.

Expect minute asides of yours to be taken out of context. Expect bizarre tangents to take center stage, as a means of distracting from the main message. Expect various "attack dogs" to imply or outright claim you are a liar, or that you have committed crimes.

If on the other hand, Bob Gimlin is TRULY the SALT OF THE EARTH, then Bigfootery should welcome your investigations, as this would EXONERATE him of suspicious activity.

Heck, you should ask Jeff Meldrum, John Green, and Rick Noll to help you find these documents and post them publicly, so all the nasty scoftics will feel ashamed for doubting the word of the SALT OF THE EARTH.
 
Bob Gimlin probably is a good, kind man that is a friend to many. Somewhat ironically, it may be his good-heartedness that is keeping him from confessing. If he were to confess now, many might regard it as being a cruel thing to do.
 
The PGF is bigfootery's 'Shroud of Turin'. No amount of scientific evidence will deter the faithful.

Bob H. has been proven indisputably to have been at Bluff Creek during the filming. He admitted to the hoax.

Honest Bob has been identified as the indian scout who helped Roger track Patty. He even appeared in costume at the original showings of the film.

It's really helpful to the critically thinking masses both pro and con to have the truth come out though. Thanks. Personally, I like the Bigfoot Enterprises angle being studied.
 
The following confirms that the original registration was not until 1983. Note the filing falls under "Later deposit and registration" Hope this helps LT

Type_of_Work: Motion Picture

Search_Information_Required: Registration

Title: Bigfoot Bluff Creek

Author: Roger Patterson

Claimant: Roger Patterson

Year: 1967

Other_Identifying_Information: I have a renewal number of RE0000718448, dated 1996-04-01, a publishing date of 1967-10-26, I am looking for the original copyright registration from 1967.

Co claimant- Robert E. Gimlin

or Possibly a company called- Bigfoot Enterprises.

Date: December 17th, 2008

Address: 11410 Centralia
Redford, MI 48239

And the envelope please (response from LOC search)

-----Original Message-----
From: CopySearch [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Thursday, December 18, 2008 3:55 PM
Subject: Re: Search Request Estimate

The work renewed under RE 718448 was registered under PA 175821 on February 24, 1983. It is considered a later deposit and registration. It was published October 26, 1967. You can find this information on www.copyright.gov under the heading of SEARCH COPYRIGHT RECORDS. Instructions are given on how to search by registration number.

ABOG
Copyright Office
Attn: Records, Research and Certification
Library of Congress
101 Independence Avenue, S.E.
Washington, DC 20559-6000
phone: (202) 707-6850
fax: (202) 252-3485
website: www.copyright.gov
 
Folks, the way I see it, from the Pattyphiles part, it will boil down to some sort of lawyer talk coupled with excuses.
 
Bob Gimlin probably is a good, kind man that is a friend to many. Somewhat ironically, it may be his good-heartedness that is keeping him from confessing. If he were to confess now, many might regard it as being a cruel thing to do.


But the PGF is a hoax and as such BG had to be in on it from the beginning. Now, maybe 41 years ago it started out as a lark and it was all a big joke to him. But based on these lawsuits and CR's it seems ole "Salt of the Earth" Bob quickly became interested in the money the film was making. Maybe he became embittered because his good friend RP cut him out of the $.

IF Longtabbers investigation show Salt of the Earth Bob to be likely receiving money today then his motive for keeping his trap shut is simple: revenue.
 
Clay, I've mentioned before that revenue to BG and PP might be greatly increased if Gimlin confessed. Patricia could claim ignorance (I never knew it was a hoax) and still reap money when folks scramble to license the footage for programs about the hoax. Gimlin could tell you all about the hoax - but not until you sign a payment contract. Bob would probably lose lots of friends, but he would get a new group of friends as well.

He may feel that it isn't worth all of that.
 
He may feel that it isn't worth all of that.

I agree with, WP. I think the reasons BG doesn't confess has nothing to do with money. I think it's a much more simple human element. I think he may have thought about it before but didn't want the kind of attention it would bring. He has referenced in the past that all the attention almost cost him his marriage. Do you think his wife now would want the kind of attention that would come from a confession now?
 
Last edited:
WP/KK,

I think it's about the money but we'll likely never know for sure. SOTE Bob, if he didn't want to be bothered about the PGF, wouldn't show up at BF parties, do interviews, etc. That he has given interviews over the years and shows up at BF wingdings makes me skeptical of his "I don't like the bother" line.

I'll also WAG that no one has ever offered him $ to spill the beans about the hoax. If my WAG is correct, and if he makes $ from the film, he may look at making $ off of revealing the hoax as speculative. IOW, bird in the hand beats two in the bush.

It's all speculation on our parts as to SOTE Bob's motives. We will likely never know the truth.
 
WP/KK,

I think it's about the money but we'll likely never know for sure. SOTE Bob, if he didn't want to be bothered about the PGF, wouldn't show up at BF parties, do interviews, etc. That he has given interviews over the years and shows up at BF wingdings makes me skeptical of his "I don't like the bother" line.

Bob has until recently shunned most attention from the PGF. It's only been in the last few years that he's been more approachable. If he can possibly see some money, not get in the dog house with his wife, have some new friends who idolize him, be a salt lick, and not go down in history as a hoaxer, and have a relatively calm life, why not?
 
I agree with, WP. I think the reasons BG doesn't confess has nothing to do with money. I think it's a much more simple human element. I think he may have thought about it before but didn't want the kind of attention it would bring. He has referenced in the past that all the attention almost cost him his marriage. Do you think his wife now would want the kind of attention that would come from a confession now?

For a guy who doesn't want attention he sure is hosting quite a bash next year. what's with that?
 
Longtabber, your current situation in 2008 reminds me of me in early 2005. While my background and credentials do not compare to yours, there are certain similarities:


8. If you discover HARD EVIDENCE in the form of legal documents that puts the Patterson film, and Bob Gimlin in particular in an unfavorable light, expect to become the victim of vitriolic personal attacks and insinuations, almost certainly originating on Bigfoot Forums.

Expect minute asides of yours to be taken out of context. Expect bizarre tangents to take center stage, as a means of distracting from the main message. Expect various "attack dogs" to imply or outright claim you are a liar, or that you have committed crimes.

If on the other hand, Bob Gimlin is TRULY the SALT OF THE EARTH, then Bigfootery should welcome your investigations, as this would EXONERATE him of suspicious activity.

Heck, you should ask Jeff Meldrum, John Green, and Rick Noll to help you find these documents and post them publicly, so all the nasty scoftics will feel ashamed for doubting the word of the SALT OF THE EARTH.

Yeah, I came to that same conclusion and am preparing for it. Its easy to comment now because we havent actually started so we havent "found" anything and its all speculative discussion now.

I intend to proactively counter the "liar" part simply by transparency and posting whatever we find in unaltered original content. ( if any are located, we are ONLY going to accept copies from official sources and have "certified true copy" or equivalent stamped on them and will list how anyone can obtain them for themselves- the content of any documents will speak for itself)

As far as accusations of crimes, outside of the blogger base of the group, too many people assisting us are lawyers and LE and EVERYTHING we find will be scrutinized before posting. ( that just protects everybody)

As far as personal attacks, I got more ass than most people have teeth and I got more teeth than most people have ass and by creed, we excel at every art and artifice of war.


http://www.sfalx.com/h_sf_creed.htm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom