Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do not presume to tell me who I am. You think no one else knows how to measure a photo? I am not as interested in BF as some. It is the film that interests me. The "potential" I see is to establish the bloody body dimensions. What the hell else? Then let the chips fall where they may. You must be a bit paranoid as well.

You're right, I must be paranoid. I didn't realize that Longtabber is actually debating with two separate geomaticists on the BFF and JREF.:rolleyes:

Astrophotographer did a good job establishing the dimensions but I already showed you that.
 
Last edited:
Dropped in on Drew's thread over on the BFF and learned that ole BG is the salt of the earth. The salt of the earth I tell ya! We evil scoftics should be ashamed of ourselves. He's the salt of the earth I tell ya! He's never made any money off the PGF 'cause he says so. Salt of the earth I tell ya!
Don't forget that this same guy who is praising Gimlin praised Moneymaker and called him a good friend as well.:D
Another scam artist that this guy has praised is Ron Morehead of the famous "Sierra Sounds" recordings (and other tall tales).
In other words - this guy's opinion is pretty worthless.
He's just another groupie who loves to name drop.
 
RB@BFF said:
Yeah… Hairy Man is correct… including the part about RB being awesome… (I know that’s what she was thinking)…

It was great to speak with my good friend Bob Gimlin this evening… I owe ya’ll a debt of gratitude for prodding me into it… it’s been a couple of months since we visited… which is way too long…

Simply stated, that man is the salt of the Earth… especially after all the crap he’s been through surrounding this film… and yet, there are those that not only doubt his honesty and sincerity… but can sleep at night after calling that man a liar… you should all be ashamed of yourselves…
Bob Gimlin has never made anything off that film… except for perhaps the ten bucks to make it official… and no one but some lameass spunkwad would blame him for that…

Anything ever made from the film has been on Al DeAtley's, the Patterson’s, or perhaps the Dahinden’s part… Bob Gimlin does not know nor does he care… he has washed his hands of it…

The most lasting words I shall remember from the conversation with him this evening were when he said to me, “Al and Roger may have ended up with all the money from that film, but I ended up with all the friends.”

Like I said… salt of the Earth…

So… at this point… all I can add is… no one important really gives a crap who believes the film is authentic or not… including me…


[edited to add] Ray... Being awarded something and collecting it from a widow are two different issues... like I said... salt of the Earth...

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?s=&showtopic=24472&view=findpost&p=506101

I'm riddled with guilt, I doubt RB's salt lick.
 
LT, that was a nice discover. I agree, however, with crow - chances are that only the standard PGF is there. Its most important contribution is to -once again- demonstrate that PGF's fishy smell just won't go away. On the contrary - it keeps getting worse, regardless of the ammount of salt one tries to dump over it.

But never mind. Tru bleevers will keep smelling roses.

Hey, K., how does it feel like having so many speculatons about your real personna floating around in the net?
 
Hey, K., how does it feel like having so many speculatons about your real personna floating around in the net?

Like a star!:cool:

For one thing it makes me wonder what it's like for Michael Dennet, Benjamin Radford, David Daegling, and tube. I wonder if they get BFRO/Matt Moneymaker legal threats and NSA supermole theories too.

I'll tell you though, if there's any kids out there thinking about being a Bigfoot skepticism, there's waaay more money and girls in music. :D



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=49WX0oQ6z1E
 
For one thing it makes me wonder what it's like for Michael Dennet, Benjamin Radford, David Daegling, and tube. I wonder if they get BFRO/Matt Moneymaker legal threats and NSA supermole theories too.


Don't get cocky kid. There were plenty of NSA accusations to go around back in the NEIL era.

Some developments in the BFF thread. Some of the Heavy hitters are putting in cameos.
 
LT, that was a nice discover. I agree, however, with crow - chances are that only the standard PGF is there. Its most important contribution is to -once again- demonstrate that PGF's fishy smell just won't go away. On the contrary - it keeps getting worse, regardless of the ammount of salt one tries to dump over it.

It will be next week or so before we can get there but I'm expecting to find nothing but a short snippit to ID the PGF and nothing more. Honestly, none of us expect to find any "film" ( and personally I believe the original has been lost/destroyed or cut up on the editing floor- but I dont know that)

We are looking at the documentation of several things to see what is and isnt true and starting at the beginning.

Heres a short group of things that dont add up ( at least not with what we currently have)

1) How did BG get the copyright in the first place when it was filed a week after the filming in 67? ( thats the first one) The camera/film was owned/rented by RP, RP shot the film and BG was just along to help him. If those claims are correct ( I tend to believe they are) then RP owned the PGF as his work lock,stock, barrel,body and soul at 100%. ( just like any other work of any other author/photographer) So, I ask how/why did BG get 50% in the first place. Either RP had to give/sell it to him ( for whatever reasons) OR there was a business arrangement where they were equal partners and that gave BG the 50%. Without 1 of those 2 scenarios- theres no way under color of law that BG would have any claim against the PGF or its copyright.

2) the first lawsuit ( to get his share of revenue)- That shores up 1 above because if BG could not PROVE he had copyright/ownership and legal entitlement- theres no basis for a suit under color of law so just the fact a case was filed and went into preliminary litigation proves the suit had merit and establishes that BG did in fact own either rights to the usage of the film, film proper and copyright. ( otherwise, the suit would have been dismissed due to lack of grounds and it would have ended there)

3) Now enter RD- Its been said ( in several versions) that RD had an arrangement with BG, sued on his behalf, bought rights from BG and all that. Go back to 1 above, you cant "sell" something you dont own in full or part and have dominion over. ( to do so without that is called fraud) That means the film AND copyright. ( those are 2 different entities)

4) its been said that this "agreement" ( be it adjudicated or out of court or whatever) from 2 above gave BG/RD 51% and PP 49% of the film,revenue etc. If thats accurate then they Co owned it but for BG to get the 51%, he had to PROVE to the court he was ENTITLED to it ( see 1 above) or no court in this land would have given him anything.

Theres a question there too. if this 51-49 split is true, then that puts 3 into question because the MOA and CR show BG alone ( and his wife) and no mention of PP in the sale/transfer. If the "split" is true and decided legally then BG cant sell ANYTHING on his own ( other than his interest and rights) but that doesnt negate hers. So if 4 is accurate, then RD cant possibly own anything more than BG's 51%. ( whatever thats defined as)

5) this later suit that went Federal- I find it odd that a state level suit went Federal because there would be no need unless it involved diversity of jurisdiction ( an out of state entity that wasnt under Wa law) or a federal law. I know from experience that in todays dollars, even a minor action starts around $50k ( Federal Court is NOT cheap) and somebody had to PAY. Why would anyone put forth that kind of money for a film/copyright with no financial gain in mind?

6) then later ( after all of the above) RD is awarded 51% as a result of 5 above.

Something isnt quite right here thats why seeing the actual documentation is key
 
The camera/film was owned/rented by RP, RP shot the film and BG was just along to help him. If those claims are correct ( I tend to believe they are) then RP owned the PGF as his work lock,stock, barrel,body and soul at 100%.

I don't know if it matters, but...

It is possible that Gimlin was doing the filming for:


William Parcher said:
1. Bob Heironimus & Jerry Merritt riding down an incline with a packhorse in tow.

2. Roger Patterson riding a horse carrying binoculars with a dog walking alongside. No packhorse.

3. Roger Patterson riding a horse pulling a packhorse. Appears to be Bluff Creek.

6. Roger Patterson pouring plaster into large tracks.

7. Camera pans across a trackway with one track filled with plaster.

8. Roger Patterson displaying two plaster casts that are attributed to Patty.
 
A good con artist has the ability to get complete strangers to sympathize with them. If they were unable to do that – they wouldn’t be a good con artist.

Just a quick internet search brought up this case of a trio scamming Home Depot out of an estimated million dollars. The following is taken from the article: (my bolding and underlining)

Davenport grew up without parents and spent much of his adult life working as a civil engineer all over the world, according to his attorney, Daniel Horowitz.

What is clear is that the three charmed practically everyone they met, including lawyers and the police. "They're really the salt of the earth," Horowitz says.


http://www.weitzlux.com/interest/news/scamartist_1171.html

When somebody starts blithering about an individual being “the salt of the earth” – I check my wallet…;)
 
Last edited:
Do we have anything showing that there was a copyright registered in 1967?

If it was registered in 1967, why the 1983 filing?

Was it because the original from 1967(Which I have not seen) contained Al DeAtley as the copyright holder? And the 1983 filing was to correct this inaccuracy?

ALSO,
Was the deal for $10 dollars between BG and RD, for the 50% of the partnership? or for BG's 50% stake in the film revenue? Maybe BG was just selling RD his 50% of the 1974 partnership agreement, and not selling his 50% stake in the film revenue, + if it was just relinquishing the claim on the film revenue, then Bob Gimlin via the partnership agreement would still get 50% of whatever RD took in as the new claimant on the film revenue.

BobG giving up his rights to the film, would not affect his rights as a partner to RD, and he would be entitled to the 50% of the revenue, per the agreement in 1974.
 
Last edited:
That is referencing the original publishing date of 1967, but wasn't filed until 1983 THAT IS MY POINT!!
Relevance:
Type of Work: Entry not found.
Registration Number / Date: PA0000175821 / 1983-02-24
Title: Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California [1967].
Imprint: [Canada : s.n.], c1967.
Description: 1 film reel (ca. 1 min.) : si., col. ; 16 mm.
Notes: Deposit includes descriptive material (4 p.)
Copyright Claimant: Robert Gimlin & Mrs. Roger Patterson
Date of Creation: 1967
Date of Publication: 1967-10-26
Authorship on Application: photographers: Roger Patterson & Robert Gimlin.
Copyright Note: C.O. correspondence
.
 
Last edited:
No, from the other link

>>Renewal registration for: PA0000175821 / 1967-10-26

Thats when the ORIGINAL was filed ( on 26 Oct 67)- subsequent renewals carry the latest date but reference the original date. ( because CR starts from the last date of registration)
 
That one was filed in 1996. It is referencing the publishing date of 1967, thus the 28 year renewal from the date of publication. Note: it says renewal for PA0000175821 which is the 1983 filing. There is no 1967 filing, the date of publication is the date of the implied copyright. That is why they keep referencing it. You don't need to file to get the copyright, it is implied when you make the film/book/photo or whatever.

RE0000718448 / 1996-04-01
Renewal registration for: PA0000175821 / 1967-10-26
Title: Bigfoot--Bluff Creek, Ca. 1967. Photographer, Roger Patterson, assistant photographer, Robert Gimlin.
Notes: Motion picture.
Copyright Claimant: Patricia Patterson (W) & Robert Gimlin (A)
Copyright Note: C.O. correspondence.

Variant title: Bigfoot--Bluff Creek, Ca. 1967.
 
Last edited:
That one was filed in 1996. It is referencing the publishing date of 1967, thus the 28 year renewal from the date of publication. Note: it says renewal for PA0000175821 which is the 1983 filing. There is no 1967 filing, the date of publication is the date of the implied copyright. That is why they keep referencing it. You don't need to file to get the copyright, it is implied when you make the film/book/photo or whatever.


Yes it was ( according to the person on the phone) but a fine point here ( bolding)

Thats true TODAY in 2008 but was not the law in 1967. Back then, they had to file for it and thats where that filing date comes from. its outlined in the LOC circular circ22 that can be downloaded from the HP
 
http://www.copyright-laws.com/pgs/copyright-basics.html
Under the law in effect before 1978, copyright was secured either on the date a work was published with notice of copyright or on the date of registration if the work was registered in unpublished form. In either case, copyright endured for a first term of 28 years from the date on which it was secured. During the last (28th) year of the first term, the copyright was eligible for renewal. The copyright law extends the renewal term from 28 to 67 years for copyrights in existence on January 1, 1978.
However, for works copyrighted prior to January 1, 1964, the copyright still must have been renewed in the 28th calendar year to receive the 67-year period of added protection. The amending legislation enacted June 26, 1992, automatically extends this second term for works first copyrighted between January 1, 1964, and December 31, 1977. For more detailed information on the copyright term, write or call the Copyright Office and request Circular 15a, "Duration of Copyright," and Circular 15t, "Extension of Copyright Terms."
 
Exactly, it was secured unpublished on the 26th then when the laws changed, it was extended. Thats one of the things to verify when boots hit the ground.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom