Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is some documentation of some agreement between Dahinden and Gimlin dated 1974. This may have been the force behind the lawsuit which was filed the following year.

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=4916&hl=gimlin+dahinden[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_197054947ecddd3200.jpg[/qimg]

First of all, nothing in that document transfers OWNERSHIP or COPYRIGHT of the PGF film to Dahinden.( under law, copyright can only be transferred by specific inclusion of copyright and thats not specified in this document)

>>> and to own and administer the RESULTS of such investigation

Even Gerry Spence couldnt twist that to mean ownership in whole or part of the PGF or its Copyright.

This "MOA" is all but legally useless for anything for the following reasons.

It refers to a partnership yet doesnt define terms/conditions etc of said partnership ( including assignment ability to heirs and dissolution) so if there wasnt a full partnership agreement, its unenforcable because its undefinable. Even if by some miracle it could be, unless there was a transfer or assignment clause in a partnership agreement, the "partnership" would automatically disolve upon the death of a principle.

>>> equal owner in the partnership and its assets

That means they are equal owners of the assets of the partnership. Nothing in this MOA identifies the PGF as a physical asset of the PARTNERSHIP. ( and if you believe Gimlin, he never had a copy of the physical film[ RP had all the copies except what was given to others] so he couldnt "give" that which he didnt have.

Its important to remember that ownership of the PHYSICAL film ( the original) and ownership of copyright are NOT the same thing. By every account, RP was the SOLE owner of the "original" PGF. ( One would think that there would be an agreement giving both of them equal ownership of the original or at least give BG a 1st gen copy directly from the master when it was developed- but theres no indication this ever occured)
( Its no different that if an author wrote a book and gave it to you- you own the physical "book" [ paper,ink,binding and words] but you still dont have copyright)

So, even if a copy were included in this partnership, that couldnt be construed to give RD ANY claim ( legal or otherwise) to the original because BG was never the OWNER of it.

This is why its a dangerous thing ( from a legal standpoint) for laymen to draft agreements. This document is all but meaningless.
 
The part that says "this agreement binds both parties to the actions of one of the parties", May have been necessary for RD to act as BG's legal bulldog, because RD couldn't file lawsuits on BG's behalf unless he could show he was a legal representative of BG.
 
I'm curious about this...


Bigfoot; By Roger Patterson & Robert E. Gimlin.

Type of Work: Entry not found.
Document Number: V1838P200
Date of Recordation: 1981-04-08
Entire Copyright Document: V1838P200-201
Date of Execution: 29Sep78; date of cert.: 26Mar81
Title: Bigfoot; filmstrip / By Roger Patterson & Robert E. Gimlin.
Notes: Agreement of sale and transfer.
Party 1: Robert E. Gimlin & Judy L. Gimlin.
Party 2: Rene Dahinden.

Names: Gimlin, Robert E.
Gimlin, Judy L.
Dahinden, Rene


Gimlin sold and transferred a "filmstrip" to Dahinden. What was that? I don't think Bob Strain provided an answer from Gimlin last night. Maybe he didn't ask.
 
The part that says "this agreement binds both parties to the actions of one of the parties", May have been necessary for RD to act as BG's legal bulldog, because RD couldn't file lawsuits on BG's behalf unless he could show he was a legal representative of BG.

That agreement couldnt suffice for that because its too badly written and vague plus in order for RD to do anything on BG's behalf, he would have to have a Power Of Attorney.

Does anyone have the DOCKET numbers of any of these alleged legal actions?
( or are they like everything else, storied BELIEVED to be true)

or at least know what jurisdiction(s) they were allegedly filed in?
 
Dahinden lived in Canada. I wonder if they have a searchable Copyright database to see if anything shows up there.
 
I'm curious about this...
Gimlin sold and transferred a "filmstrip" to Dahinden. What was that? I don't think Bob Strain provided an answer from Gimlin last night. Maybe he didn't ask.

Thats one of the things we are going to look for because heres the quandry.

There is ONE original film copyrighted ( only one in the camera and all copies are generations of "the one" for CR purposes) and a 50-50 copyright.

So, all known information suggests that RP alone was the SOLE owner of the original. ( deals involving usage,distribution and the like dont transfer asset ownership unless specified in the arrangement) ( BG is on record saying he never owned the physical film and I dont remember ever hearing that he even had a personal copy)

So, if BG never owned the PHYSICAL film ( in whole or part) then he couldnt legally sell a "filmstrip" ( whatever thats identified as) to anyone. ALL he could sell would be his copyright over that portion of the film.

Now, assuming the film wasnt legitimately sold by RP ( which still wouldnt affect his copyright rights and if he sold them, all he could sell was his 50%, BG still retained his) ownership of that film ( as with the rest of personal property) to his heirs ( presumably spouse) and she would retain it at 100% of the film and his 50% of the copyright.

So, how could BG sell something he never had? How could he sell 100% of a copyright ( for this filmstrip) which is a subset of a master that he only had 50% interest in? ( and he didnt own the physical film)

Something simply doesnt jive here.
 
So, how could BG sell something he never had? How could he sell 100% of a copyright ( for this filmstrip) which is a subset of a master that he only had 50% interest in? ( and he didnt own the physical film)

Something simply doesnt jive here.


Maybe the filmstrip is the "2nd Roll". The PGF registered to the copyright office is one minute long and presumably contains only the Patty walk. The 2nd Roll is only known (said) to contain the plaster pour, trackway pan, stomp test and cast display scenes. Murphy said that Dahinden possessed a 15' length of film. That would be about 30-40 seconds. It isn't part of the registered PGF film because that would make it longer than one minute.
 
Just to be clear the LOC lists 3 entries online which reference some portion of the PGF.

http://cocatalog.loc.gov/cgi-bin/Pw...dis1A_SX3DEbw7qfR9NY&SEQ=20081216154719&SID=2
1.
Bigfoot; By Roger Patterson & Robert E. Gimlin.
Type of Work: Recorded Document
Document Number: V1838P200
Date of Recordation: 1981-04-08
Entire Copyright Document: V1838P200-201
Date of Execution: 29Sep78; date of cert.: 26Mar81
Title: Bigfoot; filmstrip / By Roger Patterson & Robert E. Gimlin.
Notes: Agreement of sale and transfer.
Party 1: Robert E. Gimlin & Judy L. Gimlin.
Party 2: Rene Dahinden.

Names: Gimlin, Robert E.
Gimlin, Judy L.
Dahinden, Rene

Re: #2 below- Note the date of the film publication- 10/26/67 How does this fit into the timeline?

http://cocatalog.loc.gov/cgi-bin/Pw...2Vr_V2n7IXF3avPCv-ta&SEQ=20081216155823&SID=2
2.
Bigfoot--Bluff Creek, Ca. 1967. Photographer, Roger Patterson, assistant...

Type of Work: Motion Picture
Registration Number / Date: RE0000718448 / 1996-04-01
Renewal registration for: PA0000175821 / 1967-10-26
Title: Bigfoot--Bluff Creek, Ca. 1967. Photographer, Roger Patterson, assistant photographer, Robert Gimlin.
Notes: Motion picture.
Copyright Claimant: Patricia Patterson (W) & Robert Gimlin (A)
Copyright Note: C.O. correspondence.

Variant title: Bigfoot--Bluff Creek, Ca. 1967.
Names: Patterson, Roger
Gimlin, Robert
Patterson, Patricia

#3- This is the original copyright request for the motion picture I believe. Note BobG and PatPat are registering their copyright in 1983, 16 years after the films publication. I wonder what the 4 pages of documentation are.
http://cocatalog.loc.gov/cgi-bin/Pw...RtteLqZQ6rm__sOY9cy6&SEQ=20081216160408&SID=2

Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California [1967].

Type of Work: Motion Picture
Registration Number / Date: PA0000175821 / 1983-02-24
Title: Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California [1967].
Imprint: [Canada : s.n.], c1967.
Description: 1 film reel (ca. 1 min.) : si., col. ; 16 mm.
Notes: Deposit includes descriptive material (4 p.)
Copyright Claimant: Robert Gimlin & Mrs. Roger Patterson
Date of Creation: 1967
Date of Publication: 1967-10-26
Authorship on Application: photographers: Roger Patterson & Robert Gimlin.
Copyright Note: C.O. correspondence.

Names: Patterson, Mrs. Roger
Gimlin, Robert, 1931-
Patterson, Roger, 1933-1972
 
One thing Drew ( just speculating- we wont know until we get on the ground and go "fiche"ing LOL)

They could be different works INCLUDING parts of the original ( and since they have different numbers, I tend to think thats likely) or separate works built on the original.

I was told when i called that when someone lawfully alters an original from its original form ( not editing, cropping and such as thats still the "original") they have created a "new' work based on the other and as such it needs to be secured.

Thats just a guess at this point.

WP, I thought the same thing but it goes back to my post way back- was the original film copyrighted the single roll with patty or was it all rolls combined?

If its just the patty roll, then BG never had copyright ( or anything else) to sell to anyone regarding the second roll. Then, if he never has ownership and possession/dominion over the film, how could he sell it in the first place?
 
Here is some documentation of some agreement between Dahinden and Gimlin dated 1974. This may have been the force behind the lawsuit which was filed the following year.

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=4916&hl=gimlin+dahinden[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_197054947ecddd3200.jpg[/qimg]
In states where I have had something notarized, the notary had some time of stamp or seal . I don't see anything like that on this document .
Not a requirement in WA at the time ( or now ? ) ?
 
WP, I thought the same thing but it goes back to my post way back- was the original film copyrighted the single roll with patty or was it all rolls combined?

If it's only one minute, then it's probably only the Patty walk scene. That scene lasts for almost exactly 60 seconds. This is only 24 feet from a 100 foot roll, and we are told that that roll was exhausted in the camera.

I have seen the following scenes from Patterson's camera:

1. Bob Heironimus & Jerry Merritt riding down an incline with a packhorse in tow.

2. Roger Patterson riding a horse carrying binoculars with a dog walking alongside. No packhorse.

3. Roger Patterson riding a horse pulling a packhorse. Appears to be Bluff Creek.

4. Bob Gimlin riding a horse (appears to be Bob Heironimus' horse) pulling a packhorse. Appears to be at Bluff Creek.

5. The Patty Walk. About 1 minute.

6. Roger Patterson pouring plaster into large tracks.

7. Camera pans across a trackway with one track filled with plaster.

8. Roger Patterson displaying two plaster casts that are attributed to Patty.

Am I missing any? BG said the stomp test was filmed too.


If its just the patty roll, then BG never had copyright ( or anything else) to sell to anyone regarding the second roll. Then, if he never has ownership and possession/dominion over the film, how could he sell it in the first place?


BG may have had physical possession of the scenes commonly called the "2nd Roll". Those are not part of the registered copyrighted PGF (1 minute). He may have sold/transferred those scenes (as a filmstrip) to RD... whether he had a legal right to or not.
 
In states where I have had something notarized, the notary had some time of stamp or seal . I don't see anything like that on this document .
Not a requirement in WA at the time ( or now ? ) ?

It depends on the individual state but in most instances all they have to have is their notary comission card from the state. Some types of documents require a stamp/seal but thats because of the nature of the document.

Most of us at the firm are notaries and we exclusively use embossing stamps but thats only for security. ( Back in the 90's I used the traditional stamps and a buddy of mine lifted one from a document and stamped others to prove to me it could be lifted/cloned- needless to say I destroyed my ink stamps and went 100% emboss with everything from that day to present)
 
Taking a break from CR

Found this over on BFF:

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=24228&st=99&start=99

QUOTE(wiiawiwb @ Dec 16 2008, 07:21 AM)
If you haven't done so already I would encourage you to read as much of the PGF section of the massge board as possible. I would start with all of the Bill Munns "Creature Suit Analysis Parts 1 - 12". Then I would pour through the threads that discuss various mechanical/anatomical analysis of the PGF.

These are not an overnight read but provide the best analysis of the PGF any where. I couldn't walk away from these without thinking there is as much proof as I will get short of a body.


Very good advice. I second that
.


Now Bill keeps telling us he hasn't reached any conclusions but the believers seem to think his critter suit analysis bolsters Patty being a real critter.
 
Was it necessary to load and unload film in the dark? No. The film has a long leader and trailer that prevents light damage. As long as you do not pull too much of the leader or trailer off, or open the camera mid-roll, or do something else that's stupid, the film will be fine if loaded and unloaded in daylight.

Can the K-100 be hand cranked forward and reverse? Yes. Forward and up to 2 feet in reverse. There was an Accessory Hand Crank Attachment available.

Can the K-100 be motor driven? Yes, there was an Accessory Motor Drive Shaft available.

Can the K-100 be locked in the run position? Yes.

Can the K-100 use single and double perf film? Yes.

Could sound have been added to the PGF? Yes, it could have been done post processing. Kodak offered a Sonotrack coating service for 16mm single or double perf Kodachrome film.
 
I'm just curious, Gigantofootecus, as to what kind of potential you see if not ruling out or making a human extremely unlikely?

BTW, I think we have the same hometown. Have you ever joined or plan to join any of the BFRO Vancouver Island expeditions?
Do not presume to tell me who I am. You think no one else knows how to measure a photo? I am not as interested in BF as some. It is the film that interests me. The "potential" I see is to establish the bloody body dimensions. What the hell else? Then let the chips fall where they may. You must be a bit paranoid as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom