Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Here are some things that dont seem to fit and need further investigation. ( or need a real one in the first place)

>>>In the early-'70s, Gimlin took part in lawsuits to get rights to the film.

Why did he have to sue for that which he already had or is this for the money UNDER his rights he allegedly wasnt getting? Has anyone ever produced any paperwork establishing this as fact?

>>>Eventually, Rene Dahinden got about 51% of the film rights (the still photos from the film) and Patricia Patterson, Roger Patterson's widow, got 49% (the actual film rights). Gimlin really didn't want a whole lot to do with the film itself, so he sold his portion of the rights to Dahinden for $26.00.

This doesnt jive either. According to the LOC, PP didnt come on the CR until 96. ( she could have inhereted them from RP if his will stated such but if she did, she would have had to be a seller and sign off when BG and his wife sold whatever to RD) and according to the LOC, BG didnt sell his "rights' to anyone for any price.

>>>Patterson allegedly had sold and resold the same film rights to different parties. Moreover, he had cut Bob Gimlin out of the profits from the start because Gimlin would not leave his work and private life to promote the film full-time. After convincing De Atley to sign over his 33 percent share in 1970, Patterson routinely sold film rights as if he were the sole owner, even though Gimlin legally owned 33 percent.

Not according to the LOC. They might have agreed to cut the profits in 3rds but BG never surrendered any of his right and any sales RP made without his signature ( unless he was ONLY selling his 50%) would be prosecutable fraud and declared null and void.

>>>In return, Dahinden would become a partner with Gimlin, sharing half of whatever film rights Gimlin had after the lawsuit was settled. On February 6, 1976, Patterson's widow settled out of court, leaving Gimlin and Dahinden with exclusive publication rights plus 51 percent ownership of the film itself.

anyone ever SEE any documentation of this? If RD had 51% along with BG- what was this purchase in 78?

>>>Dahinden sought out all contracts he could find related to the film. He became a one-man collection agency. He sued Acropolis Books, American National (Film) Enterprises, Simon and Schuster, Gulf and Western, Metromedia, and several other parties that allegedly had made the mistake of believing Patterson's sole-ownership pitch.

How can he sue for something he never owned? ( it says the film, not the portion he purchased) Sue by proxy?

>>>Gimlin signed over his entire rights to Dahinden for ten dollars on September 29, 1978, leaving Dahinden with a majority ownership in the film.



Not according to the LOC. According to that, he AND his wife sold a portion of the film identified as "filmstrip" and BG "renewed" his CR in 1996 ( and apparently allowed PP to be put on it as there is no record of transfer due to probate from RP to her- but there could be) Any paperwork ever actually seen outlining any of this?


Somethings not right here. Who got the royalties from all this? ( the books, movies, TV stuff) anyone know?
 

LC Control No.: 92506200

Type of Material: Moving Image or Slide/Transparency
Main Title: Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California (1967).

Published/Created: 1967.

Related Names: Copyright Collection (Library of Congress) DLC » More like this

Related Titles: Bluff Creek, California (1967)-

Description: 1 reel of 1 : sd., col. ; 16 mm. ref print.

Notes: Copyright: Robert Gimlin & Mrs. Roger Patterson. DCR 1967; PUB 26Oct67; REG 24Feb83; PA 175-821.

Acquisition Source: Received: 9/6/83; ref print; copyright deposit--No agree; Copyright Collection.

LC Classification: FAB 6107 (ref print)

Copyright Registration No.: PA175-821 U.S. Copyright Office



Thats what it says- its a reel ( I wonder if its a full reel with all tapes or just the one with the alleged BF on it)

It was sent in 83 and the name is Mrs. RP so my question is: is this when BG put her name on it or did it come from settlement,probate or what?

Looks like the original has been located. ( or at least the registered copy- I wonder if its been edited?)
 
OK, dumb question time.

The LOC records Honest Bob as holding copyright with RP from Day 1. It comes up time to renew. PP wants to renew. Could she renew the CR on her own without Honest Bob? IOW, if PP filed renewal and Honest Bob had forgotten to do so would she have then become the sole CR holder? Or would she have had to go across town and gotten Honest Bob to file for renewal as well?
I am already smelling a big stinking dead rat here but if PP could have renewed on her own without Honest Bob then the rat becomes even stinkier.

OTOH, if he had to file renewal as well to make PP's copyright valid then footers could claim he did it just to help out RP's widow and he doestn't take any money for the film. (Yeah, right!)


No, she CANNOT just up and put her name on something she NEVER registered in the first place.

It had to come from:

Inheritance from RP's will or estate

court order or settlement agreement

BG's good graces, sale,gift

since in 1978 the CR was extended by statute from 28 yrs to 67 years, they shouldnt have had to renew in 96.

Another question. Somebody close needs to go to the LOC and check out the film and report on it
 
Did we find the "original" PGF?

Could it be?

Someone close to DC needs to go check this out and report
 
RayG.

"Yes, I believe all copies have been manipulated, edited, modified, revised, adapted, corrected, changed, arranged, altered, amended, or adjusted from the original complete film unless they show the entire original and complete film."

So, in theory, the Patterson film could actually be an outtake of Raquel Welsh in 10Million BC with extra fur added to her bikini?

Bill

Bill, I have endeavored not to engage in fallacious straw men, or appeals to ridicule, I encourage you to do the same..

I'm saying if the original were merely copied with no manipulation, the copy and the original should both be the same length and reflect the same total content. However, whoever copied* the original film, ended up with copies that are not the same length, and do not reflect the total content of the original film.

Would you agree that if the copies are shorter and do not reflect the same total content of the original, some sort of editing was involved? If not, how do you account for the discrepancy?

RayG

* (freely substitute any of the following if you wish: edited, manipulated, modified, revised, adapted, corrected, changed, arranged, altered, amended, or adjusted)
 
Another question. Somebody close needs to go to the LOC and check out the film and report on it


Darn straight. Anyone on the board live close enuff to do so?

Could we be so lucky this reel has all the extra (missing) goodies on it?

Longtabber, I think your locating the CR info tonite has opened up a whole new level for investigation.

Wonder what the BFF is making of all this about now?

ETA: I decided to check to see if the LOC had a copy of the film while reading about copyright on Wiki where it stated CR materials on often placed on file with the LOC.

Anyway, another question popped into my head. Why was it so important to place the reel into the LOC in 1983. Why then? Why at all since according to Wiki it is not absolutely necessary to do so. Why?
 
Last edited:
I'm sure other sites will take all the credit just like with the ParcherFoot.

Its definitely opened up a lot of questions and legitimate suspicions about the film, claims about it and certain peoples "reliability", honesty and forthrightness.

Wouldnt it be something for an investigator ( having beer) located a reference copy of the holy grail of bf-dom and started the process of verification of whats really what after 40 years of effort?

nah, couldnt happen
 
ETA: I decided to check to see if the LOC had a copy of the film while reading about copyright on Wiki where it stated CR materials on often placed on file with the LOC.

Anyway, another question popped into my head. Why was it so important to place the reel into the LOC in 1983. Why then? Why at all since according to Wiki it is not absolutely necessary to do so. Why?

You can bet your life it has money at the end of it whatever it is.

Granted its voluntary so why then? That might be determined by whats on it but theres a REASON it was. Someone is protecting their rights about something and something triggered it in or near that timeframe.

Now, theres no way to know if this is the true original, or has it been edited or has the RD sale excluded or what.

What we DO know is that something prompted this and this film is 'claimed' as the original ( and if it wasnt, it is now since its the official reference copy)

Someone either did this to ensure getting money in a future tense for sales or either for a lawsuit.

Need to start searching for events near the registration date.

Theres a document and money trail here and its got BG all over it.
 
Apparently, the Dahinden boys are still making money with what they have. As recently as 2005, National Geographic went to them for something.

Stock Footage:

Bigfoot Footage - Patricia Patterson
Bigfoot Footage - Patricia Patterson and Erik & Martin Dahinden

At 7:22.


I guess P. Patterson couldn't supply everything they wanted. I suspect the cast display scene used by NG came from the Dahindens. Maybe more.


Longtabber said:
Now to RD- it says BG ( and wife)sold & transferred the "filmstrip". Thats a DIFFERENT name than the original copyright so thats a DIFFERENT thing. ( could be frames, slides, a section of the film or whatever- you would need to see a BOS to see exactly what it was and terms/conditions) and P pattersons name is NOT on that.

Maybe this 'filmstrip' is the 2nd Roll. Murphy says it's a 15' strip. I think it contains the plaster pour, trackway pan and Roger displaying the casts.
 
LC Control No.: 92506200

Type of Material: Moving Image or Slide/Transparency
Main Title: Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California (1967).

Published/Created: 1967.

Related Names: Copyright Collection (Library of Congress) DLC » More like this

Related Titles: Bluff Creek, California (1967)-

Description: 1 reel of 1 : sd., col. ; 16 mm. ref print.

Notes: Copyright: Robert Gimlin & Mrs. Roger Patterson. DCR 1967; PUB 26Oct67; REG 24Feb83; PA 175-821.

Acquisition Source: Received: 9/6/83; ref print; copyright deposit--No agree; Copyright Collection.

LC Classification: FAB 6107 (ref print)

Copyright Registration No.: PA175-821 U.S. Copyright Office



Thats what it says- its a reel ( I wonder if its a full reel with all tapes or just the one with the alleged BF on it)

It was sent in 83 and the name is Mrs. RP so my question is: is this when BG put her name on it or did it come from settlement,probate or what?

Looks like the original has been located. ( or at least the registered copy- I wonder if its been edited?)

The "1983" may be a huge problem. It may be a manipulated copy was copyrighted with the orginal being destroyed.
 
Last edited:
More foot fun...


83d3464c.jpg
 
Could be, we need to go to the LOC and search for what exactly RD bought and owns as well as what the rest is. ( if thats recorded)

Then someone needs to ask for contracts, agreements etc because is "all" RD purchased was this second roll, then ALL film/frames of the PGF are owned under CR and ALWAYS have been by BG ( and RP/PP) and NONE of them are "public" regardless of who says what or urban legend dictates.

I know one thing, as of this discovery tonight, I REFUSE to believe ANY story about money,ownership, royalties, licenses et al regarding the PGF UNLESS someone produces LEGALLY ACCEPTABLE verifiable documentation.
 
Too bad LashL isn't a bigfoot thread poster. She could probably offer some useful insights into this.
 
The "1983" may be a huge problem. It may be a manipulated copy was copyrighted with the orginal being destroyed.


It very well could be but my gut tells me it isnt for this reason.

It was done seemingly "out of the blue" ( and obviously never openly discussed or "someone" in BF-dom would have known there was a supposed "original" out there)

Its registered as the original- so if it differed from the "original"- that could be construed as perjury and fraud as well as throw some of it ( the PGF) into the public domain ( its free then)

If my gut is right- this was done for money ( not to protect reputation) and as such, it should have everything on it. ( if it wasnt done for a financial need, why send it in the first place 17 years after the fact? If it was so "important' to send it, why not get a file copy back in 67 and send it in a few weeks later?)

I believe there was an 'event" ( involving money) that prompted this that either hasnt come to light or wasnt looked into in enough detail. This "sending" was either to MAKE money or to PROTECT money.

Theres an untold story here
 
So you see, we haven't wrung everything out of the PGF/bigfoot sponge yet, folks. Not by a long shot. So quit asking us to stop discussing it. :D

Its a Liestopper thing- got to get to the bottom of it and I think the PGF "line up" just got "Gottliebed"

LOL
 
Ray G:

"Bill, I have endeavored not to engage in fallacious straw men, or appeals to ridicule, I encourage you to do the same.."

I generally try to do the same, and will respond to your encouragement.

"I'm saying if the original were merely copied with no manipulation, the copy and the original should both be the same length and reflect the same total content. However, whoever copied* the original film, ended up with copies that are not the same length, and do not reflect the total content of the original film.

Would you agree that if the copies are shorter and do not reflect the same total content of the original, some sort of editing was involved? If not, how do you account for the discrepancy?"


Ray:

Given the original is a 100' reel, I'd assume a master copy would be sent to the lab intact with instructions to just dupe it, all 100 feet, instead of asking a lab to cue up a certain part, or send the lab only a 23' or so segment. If the dupes for master copies were 23' instead of 100', I'd be curious of why, because the duping cost wouldn't have been significantly greater to run the whole reel.

I could see a second gen. copy such as the reported TV master, could have been shortened, simply because that's all the client wants.

This would be my expectation as not suspicious. Something other would make me wonder why. But having no specific knowledge of the length of various copies, I hesitate to go further speculating.

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom