Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have my doubts you'll get to closely examine the original. The film presently being used isn't going to show conclusive proof of anything, and should have been relegated to the useless pile about 30 years ago.

RayG

Look at it this way. Lets assume for discussions sake the much secret "original" pops up today and its in pristine condition. Lets even say its a bit better focused. ( I'm obviously just speculating on the few seconds we see and not the MIA part because we at least know whats on that part)

Its still just as shakey, not clearly in focus, speed unknown, lens setting unknown, distances unknown, camera height unknown and so forth.

I doubt there will be much difference other than it would be possible to scale the film image a bit better then and have as "relative" size as is possible.
 
I'm just speculating Crow.

Maybe you could speculate on why proponents don't trot out the best evidence to support their position ....

You ought to read this article..
http://www.csicop.org/si/2008-06/dennett.html

Do you think Patty weighed over 1,000 pounds ?

The best guess is that either the master is lost or that there is an ownership/coprwright issue surrounding it. If its lost then so be it. If it does indeed still exist and is incrminating in nature then why hasn't its current custodians offered it to the debunking establisment? The master would be worth a considerable amount of money. So what if it would torpedo the PGF as we know it. The $$$$ would be made and sombody would go laughing all the way to the bank. Now if the camera master is in the hands of someone in the Patterson sphere and it is incriminating then keeping from scrutinity makes perfect sense.

No I don't think Patty weighed 1000lbs. As animal 450. As a bug guy in suit 340. As me in the suit 122 lol!
 
Look at it this way. Lets assume for discussions sake the much secret "original" pops up today and its in pristine condition. Lets even say its a bit better focused. ( I'm obviously just speculating on the few seconds we see and not the MIA part because we at least know whats on that part)

Its still just as shakey, not clearly in focus, speed unknown, lens setting unknown, distances unknown, camera height unknown and so forth.

I doubt there will be much difference other than it would be possible to scale the film image a bit better then and have as "relative" size as is possible.

The biggest difference would be that you'd be looking at the unedited version. You'd be able to see what else was on the film, prior to the bit we've been spoon-fed. It may change nothing, or it may change everything.

This is what Grover Krantz said in Big Footprints (pages 104-105) about the film:

"Since that first time shows a fairly clear picture, it might be guessed that any earlier footage was all of poor quality and was simply discarded as being of no value. If Byrne was correct in reporting that Patterson had 28 feet of film in the camera when the action began, as many as 185 frames could be missing. However, based on the Titmus map of the site there was no space available for more than a handful of missing frames. Only if Patterson had stayed at the beginning point for a little over 10 seconds could those 185 frames have been exposed. But if he had held his position for that portion, the film should have been of fairly good quality and we would have seen it. I can only conclude that this theoretical footage never existed, and Patterson actually had only 23.4 feet of unexposed film in his camera when the action began."

If Byrne is correct, and 185 frames could be missing, who deleted them? Who made the decision the earlier footage was of no value? On the other hand, since Krantz wasn't examining the original film, how could he conclude that the theoretical footage never existed? Even if there were only 23.4 feet of unexposed film left in the camera, what happened to the exposed part prior to those 23.4 feet?

Who examined the original, uncut/unedited version of the film?

Other issues regarding the film were pointed out by Michael Dennett in the latest issue of the Skeptical Inquirer:

According to Patterson and his partner that day, Bob Gimlin, the film was "mailed" from California on a Friday evening (approximately 9 PM) and arrived in Yakima, Washington, the next day. Supposedly processed on Saturday at an unidentified photography lab, the film was viewed by several Bigfoot buffs (including the late Rene Dahinden and John Green) on Sunday. The two surviving witnesses to these events, Bob Gimlin and Patterson's brother-in-law and financial partner Al Detley, have been unable or unwilling to explain how the film got to Yakima so quickly (in an era before overnight couriers), how the film was processed so quickly (in a time when development normally took a week), or even where the processing took place.

Bill, I predict your fiddling with the PGF will not result in any major revelations.

RayG
 
Thats a good point Crow, lets look at the other side ( just as a counter point)

Assuming the master still exists ( I dont know and personally dont care) someone owns it and knows full well what it is. It does have a financial value to it. ( how much? thats in the eye of the beholder but I think all will agree its worth "something")

Depending on which version one believes, the film was either awarded to someone in a bankruptcy settlement or it was outright given/sold/stolen to someone. ( if it still exists, it is either in Mr's P's possession or given/stolen/sold or a part of the settlement)

I kinda rule out "stolen" because I would think if it had been stolen from her or RP- that would be widely known.

Now it comes back to money and copyright. If it still exists that original copyright is somewhere. Since we know the point of origin ( RP had it) that needs to be researched because that will tell you probably where it is if anyone is getting royalties from it.

If we believe the legends- heres the probability model. The truth is in the DOCUMENTATION. ( wherever or IF ever it is)

RP had to either sell it or die with it. ( people talk about Dahinden having a "copyright" for specific frames- he either had copyright[ transfered to him] OR he simply had LICENSE) Without seeing any contract, it sounds to me like he had license but not ownership or copyright.

So, if the ownership and copyright were transfered to him- where is the agreement and the terms? ( did it die with him, was it assignable to heirs?)

If none of that exists for him, ( gotta have some kind of paperwork to prove transfer) then it goes back to RP.

RP either disposed of the film to the defunct company, gave it away, sold it to an unknown 3rd party or assigned it in his will [ if he had no will, it had to be probated by the State and there would be a record of final disposition somewhere]

If he gave it away with no ppw ( which i doubt) then theres a legal quagmire so who is getting paid?

If he sold it, where is the ppw?

If he sold it to the defunct company ( or had any other agreement) then it was discharged in bankruptcy and whoever got it owns it in totality with any prior agreements null and void. ( bankruptcy court is the highest sovereign and if unappealed is FINAL) If thats the case, its a matter of record.

So, follow the money
 
To All:

let's just clear up one thing right now:

Ray G said "I have my doubts you'll get to closely examine the original."

All I ever said was I want to get the
"Best version I can get. Still working on that."

It's even in my quote above Ray's remark.

My only specs are "true full frame and higher than TV D1 resolution, ideally 2K or 4K."

Bill
 
Last edited:
LT yes follow the money. Yet not penny 1 has ever been earned from the camera master once it was edited and copied. I find it impossibly difficult to believe that anyone with the knowledge of what they had and what it could potentially do to deflate the PGF would not have hitched a ride on the gravy train especially when Long was writing his book and the 40th anniversery of the PGF.

That said I was once connected with a recording studio that operated for about a dozen years. Eventually the founding partners had a falling out and the studio closed. Once the decision was made to close the doors an effort was made to contact as many clients as possible and notify them to collect their master tapes if they so desired them. Masters of the nature I'm referring to can only be played on very expensive and specialized machines. All in all we had on the order of 300 master tapes. Of the 300 only about 40-50 people came to collect their masters which BTW they owned not the studio. So after making a public anouncment in both trade papers and conventional newsprint and waiting 60 days all the remaining master tapes were destroyed and disguarded. Did we by then know what was on those master tapes, some of which were 8 or 9 years old? No we didn't and it no longer mattered. In some ways its easier to imagine the PGF camera master as destroyed.
 
To All:

let's just clear up one thing right now:

Ray G said "I have my doubts you'll get to closely examine the original."

All I ever said was I want to get the
"Best version I can get. Still working on that."

And all I'm saying is I have my doubts you'll get to closely examine the original. That means I'm betting you'll have to settle for examining a manipulated copy, that the 'best' version you'll get won't be the original.

RayG
 
LT this is truly a breakthrough! Wonder why nobody else ever thought to go to Library of Congress.
 
Ray G:

'That means I'm betting you'll have to settle for examining a manipulated copy"

So your argument is all copies have been "manipulated"? Manipulated how and by whom? Do you think some copies are not "manipulated"?

Mere copying does not qualify as "manipulating" as far as i know.

Just curious.

And I would concur that it's unlikely I will get to scan or otherwise work with the original. My dreams may be that high, but my expectations certainly are not.

Bill
 
Now if this is correct from the original copyright- Patterson and Gimlin BOTH owned copyright ( no mention of spouse) so it was probably transferred to her after death.

Why would someone renew a copyright in the 90's for a film that no longer exists? ( or that they didnt know where it was)

Why would a co owner of a copyright never get royalties? ( doesnt a check have to be made out to all listed owners except in a prior agreement?)

Something is odd here
 
LT this is truly a breakthrough! Wonder why nobody else ever thought to go to Library of Congress.

It has to do with being a REAL investigator and not one in the BF field. ( and this thread being the first time I ever actually cared about the location of the original and the money path and did a cursory search)

Its right there in black and white ( they didnt waste any time filing as it was only 6 days after the shooting) That tells me while they were rushing the delivery for development and rushing to show- they ( Patterson AND Gimlin) were rushing to file too. I like that "AND" part.

I smell a business arrangement now and NOT a "lucky" film of BF.

My BS indicator is now redlining on SCAM.
 
LT:

"I could say there would be a slim chance IF there was a second camera showing where RP was but thats the problem. Placing Patterson."

You are wrong. The problem is placing the camera, regardless of whether Roger is even in fact holding it.

And the camera, by virtue of taking the image, creates a spatial relationship between itself and with what it films. That spatial relationship can be determined with sufficient image data from multiple locations to allow photogrammetry triangulations. The question is whether the image data is sufficient, and obviously that issue is hotly debated, as we all know.

Bottom line, the weakest point of any proof is the measurements. Their degree of accuracy is the principle data in question. If you keep up with the whole "but we don't have the original film" thing, you can close your mind every time to any prospect of any solution. Nothing I do will pry it open.

For now, I'm done, unless you want the last word.

:)

Bill

And when you conclude, as we know you will, that Patty is real you can sell your work to the real believers.
 
LT:

"Why would someone renew a copyright in the 90's for a film that no longer exists? ( or that they didnt know where it was)"

I'm surprized you're asking this question, because the film exists, in it's copied form, and the images on the copies are as much a part of the copyright as any original.

If it were the original camera film only that was copyrighted, then every Hollywood movie release print would not have any copyright protection. Even if some accident or cause destroys the camera originals of a film, the copyright holder can still enforce the copyright on copies that exist.



Bill
 
LT:

"Why would someone renew a copyright in the 90's for a film that no longer exists? ( or that they didnt know where it was)"

I'm surprized you're asking this question, because the film exists, in it's copied form, and the images on the copies are as much a part of the copyright as any original.

If it were the original camera film only that was copyrighted, then every Hollywood movie release print would not have any copyright protection. Even if some accident or cause destroys the camera originals of a film, the copyright holder can still enforce the copyright on copies that exist.



Bill

I was being rhetorical ( I know its generational)- that isnt the point.
 
Southeast Sasquatch (Henry May)

In the early-'70s, Gimlin took part in lawsuits to get rights to the film. Eventually, Rene Dahinden got about 51% of the film rights (the still photos from the film) and Patricia Patterson, Roger Patterson's widow, got 49% (the actual film rights). Gimlin really didn't want a whole lot to do with the film itself, so he sold his portion of the rights to Dahinden for $26.00.



The Nature of the Beast by Scott Forslund

Whether authentic or not, however, the film was convincing enough to become immediately lucrative to its first legal owners (Gimlin, Patterson and Patterson's brother-in-law, Al De Atley, each owned 33 percent shares when the film was made). Less than two weeks after the film was developed 'Argosy' magazine paid the partnership $3,500 for the first photo rights; by the mid-1970s it had aired on a Smithsonian Institution special, appeared in dozens of books and magazine articles, and formed the substance of an adventure film, 'Bigfoot: The Mysterious Monster', which grossed more than $24 million. (An estimated 60 million people viewed the Smithsonian special alone.) Yet Dahinden, now one of the film's biggest defenders, was not a great fan in the early days.

"I was out to destroy it," he said. "In my mind that was the only way to take that film. I was looking for the guy in the fur suit, the guy who got the payoff." For three years Dahinden investigated Patterson's background and business records, and studied scientists' remarks on the film. When he could dig up no solid evidence that the film was faked, he set out to get a piece of the action for himself.

His second goal proved easier than his first. Roger Patterson died of Hodgkin's disease in 1972, leaving a legacy of potential lawsuits. Patterson allegedly had sold and resold the same film rights to different parties. Moreover, he had cut Bob Gimlin out of the profits from the start because Gimlin would not leave his work and private life to promote the film full-time. After convincing De Atley to sign over his 33 percent share in 1970, Patterson routinely sold film rights as if he were the sole owner, even though Gimlin legally owned 33 percent. Seeing the opportunity that Gimlin was passing up, Dahinden persuaded Gimlin to let him hire an attorney and sue the Patterson estate in 1974.

In return, Dahinden would become a partner with Gimlin, sharing half of whatever film rights Gimlin had after the lawsuit was settled. On February 6, 1976, Patterson's widow settled out of court, leaving Gimlin and Dahinden with exclusive publication rights plus 51 percent ownership of the film itself.

Motivated by the prospect of a half-share of whatever revenues he could prove were rightfully due to Gimlin, Dahinden sought out all contracts he could find related to the film. He became a one-man collection agency. He sued Acropolis Books, American National (Film) Enterprises, Simon and Schuster, Gulf and Western, Metromedia, and several other parties that allegedly had made the mistake of believing Patterson's sole-ownership pitch.

"There were so many crooked deals," recalls Bob Gimlin, who has since returned to a quiet ranching life in Yakima, making only an occasional foray into the woods to search for sasquatches. "Besides the money Rene suddenly decided I had coming, he discovered many stolen films that made their way into movies and books. Rene became like a dog chasing his tail, initiating lawsuit after lawsuit. It was intruding on my private life. I didn't even care about the other lawsuits, but because Rene and I were partners I was being carried along." Embittered and discouraged, Gimlin signed over his entire rights to Dahinden for ten dollars on September 29, 1978, leaving Dahinden with a majority ownership in the film. Even then he never called the film a fabrication, adding "I could've made a lot more money by calling it a fake." (Patterson's widow [Patricia] still owns the remainder.) Since then, Dahinden has managed little more than to pay his legal fees with the settlements he has received, but he has no intention of stopping now. "I'm a great fan of Mao Tse Tung's writings on protracted war," Dahinden says. "Mao looked 20 years ahead; that's what I'm doing. If somebody else finds the Sasquatch first I'm just an 'also ran.' But as soon as that happens, this film will become as important as any 24 feet ever taken."
 
Thats interesting WP because according to the first page of the LOC, RP and BG were the sole owners from day one. It clearly lists the sale to RD.

Now we have all these "other" claims of ownership etc. Why arent they on file?

Since the copyright is co owned- it would take BOTH parties to agree to anything.

It says clearly also that RD only owns the filmSTRIP ( the frames) and not the film proper.

Theres a lot of discreptancy between what the LOC says and all these other claims. I wonder how many of them are live and how many are memorex.

Where are all these transfer agreements? ( I know if they cant be produced and validated the register at the LOC will stand)
 
Ray G:

'That means I'm betting you'll have to settle for examining a manipulated copy"

So your argument is all copies have been "manipulated"? Manipulated how and by whom? Do you think some copies are not "manipulated"?

Mere copying does not qualify as "manipulating" as far as i know.

Just curious.

Yes, I believe all copies have been manipulated, edited, modified, revised, adapted, corrected, changed, arranged, altered, amended, or adjusted from the original complete film unless they show the entire original and complete film.

It's analogous to an investigation where you require a copy of a 10-page document. You ask for a copy, and are sent 8 pages. Those 8 pages may be exact copies from the document, but you're still missing two pages. Are the pages missing from the beginning, the end, or one page from each end? The missing pages may be unimportant or they may be vital, you have no way of knowing.

And yes, I'm asking who manipulated (or if you prefer, edited, modified, revised, adapted, corrected, changed, arranged, altered, amended, or adjusted) the original film?

And we still don't have a suitable explanation for how the film got processed so quickly, where it was processed, or who processed it.

RayG
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom