Whether authentic or not, however, the film was convincing enough to become immediately lucrative to its first legal owners (Gimlin, Patterson and Patterson's brother-in-law, Al De Atley, each owned 33 percent shares when the film was made). Less than two weeks after the film was developed 'Argosy' magazine paid the partnership $3,500 for the first photo rights; by the mid-1970s it had aired on a Smithsonian Institution special, appeared in dozens of books and magazine articles, and formed the substance of an adventure film, 'Bigfoot: The Mysterious Monster', which grossed more than $24 million. (An estimated 60 million people viewed the Smithsonian special alone.) Yet Dahinden, now one of the film's biggest defenders, was not a great fan in the early days.
"I was out to destroy it," he said. "In my mind that was the only way to take that film. I was looking for the guy in the fur suit, the guy who got the payoff." For three years Dahinden investigated Patterson's background and business records, and studied scientists' remarks on the film. When he could dig up no solid evidence that the film was faked, he set out to get a piece of the action for himself.
His second goal proved easier than his first. Roger Patterson died of Hodgkin's disease in 1972, leaving a legacy of potential lawsuits. Patterson allegedly had sold and resold the same film rights to different parties. Moreover, he had cut Bob Gimlin out of the profits from the start because Gimlin would not leave his work and private life to promote the film full-time. After convincing De Atley to sign over his 33 percent share in 1970, Patterson routinely sold film rights as if he were the sole owner, even though Gimlin legally owned 33 percent. Seeing the opportunity that Gimlin was passing up, Dahinden persuaded Gimlin to let him hire an attorney and sue the Patterson estate in 1974.
In return, Dahinden would become a partner with Gimlin, sharing half of whatever film rights Gimlin had after the lawsuit was settled. On February 6, 1976, Patterson's widow settled out of court, leaving Gimlin and Dahinden with exclusive publication rights plus 51 percent ownership of the film itself.
Motivated by the prospect of a half-share of whatever revenues he could prove were rightfully due to Gimlin, Dahinden sought out all contracts he could find related to the film. He became a one-man collection agency. He sued Acropolis Books, American National (Film) Enterprises, Simon and Schuster, Gulf and Western, Metromedia, and several other parties that allegedly had made the mistake of believing Patterson's sole-ownership pitch.
"There were so many crooked deals," recalls Bob Gimlin, who has since returned to a quiet ranching life in Yakima, making only an occasional foray into the woods to search for sasquatches. "Besides the money Rene suddenly decided I had coming, he discovered many stolen films that made their way into movies and books. Rene became like a dog chasing his tail, initiating lawsuit after lawsuit. It was intruding on my private life. I didn't even care about the other lawsuits, but because Rene and I were partners I was being carried along." Embittered and discouraged, Gimlin signed over his entire rights to Dahinden for ten dollars on September 29, 1978, leaving Dahinden with a majority ownership in the film. Even then he never called the film a fabrication, adding "I could've made a lot more money by calling it a fake." (Patterson's widow [Patricia] still owns the remainder.) Since then, Dahinden has managed little more than to pay his legal fees with the settlements he has received, but he has no intention of stopping now. "I'm a great fan of Mao Tse Tung's writings on protracted war," Dahinden says. "Mao looked 20 years ahead; that's what I'm doing. If somebody else finds the Sasquatch first I'm just an 'also ran.' But as soon as that happens, this film will become as important as any 24 feet ever taken."