Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
What?! Are you suggesting that you don't find value in discussions about whether or not Sasquatch keeps pets?

Of course there is value in that. By seeing who particiaptes such discussions, one can deduce who the real looney tunes are - as opposed to those who are merely eccentric or flat out stupid.:rolleyes:
 
I've pointed out one or twice that the Title says " Legend Meets Science ",
and nothing about the results of that meeting..
... a fitting sub title would be ( .... and gets it's butt kicked . )
 
I'm still chewing on the thought of the oft repeated story, that
Gimlin gets no money from the film, and this is one of the main
arguments, that he has no reason to lie.

Longtabber - If Gimlin ever admitted that Bob H was in the suit -
would that entitle BH to a piece of the pie ?
... Or at least form a reasonable basis for litigation ?
 
I see what you're getting at. Does a credited actor have a reasonable claim to the income related to the film?(As opposed to a nature film of a beast of the woods) And does the claim that BobG gets nothing from the film have any weight?

Also, does the income from the film go up, or down, if the film is admitted to be the Greatest hoax of the 20th century?
 
Last edited:
I'm still chewing on the thought of the oft repeated story, that
Gimlin gets no money from the film, and this is one of the main
arguments, that he has no reason to lie.

Longtabber - If Gimlin ever admitted that Bob H was in the suit -
would that entitle BH to a piece of the pie ?
... Or at least form a reasonable basis for litigation ?


Right now, EVERYTHING BG has said is under the microscope because what is DOCUMENTED by the US govt doesnt jive with all the urban legends and one thing is for sure. They HAD to FILL OUT applications, SIGN them and send in money to register so theres ZERO question of some kind of "accident".

Rule 1 in LE investigations- Follow the money and documention

Rule 2- NEVER violate rule 1

>>>If Gimlin ever admitted that Bob H was in the suit -
would that entitle BH to a piece of the pie ?
... Or at least form a reasonable basis for litigation


No, BH would only have a claim if there was an enforcable agreement or contract for his performance. ( and he would have to PROVE he was in the suit) Heres the kicker tho- IF ( and thats a mile long) he did have an agreement ( and depending on what it said) he COULD have grounds for being paid royalties from each usage of his image but that would be a legal fight for sure. ( like the actor who was physically in the Darth Vader suit)

I would guess that given that any statute of limitations has run out and the fact BH never filed an action- he either wasnt in the suit, has no enforcable agreement or simply couldnt meet the burden of proof.

Heres the devil in the detail: ( and now makes me believe fully the PGF is a staged production- I know in the past I have stated it was 51-49 in FAVOR of it being a BF but that has officially changed as of yesterday)

My new belief is that this was in fact a staged production with RP and BG acting as EQUAL partners in the shooting and subsequent business dealings. Heres why:

1) In the ORIGINAL filing- BOTH men HAD to sign and send the forms. ( there is no way around that)

IF this was a sole RP venture and BG was just "helping"- RP "rented" the camera and all that. By every legal right in the US, the "film" belonged to him ALONE. He took it and owned it.

( example- I own a car and me, rock and kk form a taxi service and agree to split the money. [ like the claim of RP, BG and De Atley in business] and we screw each other in the business deal or go out of business. Sure there may be grounds for suit over monies but my deed and title to the car doesnt come into play)

Now, if RP "knew" he filmed the "real" BF- he KNEW he had money in the bank and it was all his by every applicable law in this nation. Now with RP's ALLEGED reputation, he just "gave" CR to BG?

Then it was filed in 6 DAYS ( so they had to express it out there probably) and that didnt leave a lot of time for long winded negotiations between RP and BG. ( that tells me they already had an agreement, a plan and had already researched how to copyright, secure the forms from a library etc)

Then BG dressed in NA "lore" and helped with the marketing. ( sounds like an agreement to me)

I know people say theres enough "circumstantial" evidence in the PGF to convict someone in a court of law ( and they are right) and theres enough circumstantial evidence ( actually stronger here due to having OFFICIAL US Govt documentation) to make a good case of calling the PGF a deliberate,orchestrated fake BF film.

Lot of new research needs to be done because theres still a lot of pieces missing and questions that need answering and historical legends/interviews that need REEVALUATION before conclusions are drawn.

Thanks to those who have PM'd me and are willing to put boots on the ground.
 
On December 10th, I posed this question to DamnDirtyApe
Drew said:
DDA-

Any chance of a spontaneous confession from BobG at the Roundup? Maybe he produces the suit or something like that? I think this would be the perfect chance for him to do it.

Even he doesn't seem totally against the possibility!
DDA said:
There is always a chance that anything can happen. Hold your breath and I'll get back with ya

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=24400
 
Did we find the "original" PGF?

Could it be?

Someone close to DC needs to go check this out and report

Having had a number of things copywritten and sent to LOC I'd say the chances that what's there is THE PGF is about 1000,000-1. Most likely its a version that would have been for general consumption. In other words same old PGF.
 
Wonder what the BFF is making of all this about now?

Drew just started a thread there. I suspect that the theory that Gimlin is presently profiting because of copyright is going to be treated as an extraordinary claim. The topic can be dropped or not pursued until proof is presented that he is making money.

A cadre of famous Bigfooters regard Gimlin as an honest American legend. They run block for him. We may see it in action, without a single public word being said by Gimlin about the question.
 
Drew just started a thread there. I suspect that the theory that Gimlin is presently profiting because of copyright is going to be treated as an extraordinary claim. The topic can be dropped or not pursued until proof is presented that he is making money.

A cadre of famous Bigfooters regard Gimlin as an honest American legend. They run block for him. We may see it in action, without a single public word being said by Gimlin about the question.

Thats the first reaction I would expect as well and it stands to reason.

All this talk about the film missing, him selling his rights etc, his claims et al could really suffer now.

One thing is for certain. BG's own words from various interviews stand in direct contradiction as to what the official records show. His much vaunted "honesty" is now in legitimate question. ( Makes me want to go back and reassess BH's suit claims now- even if he wasnt in the suit, what else does he know?)

On the file copy

I'm about 50-50 on whether its the "original" PGF or the public copy as Crow believes. ( the fact it was sent in 83 alone draws suspicion as to its authenticity and originality)

One thing tho- its "filed" as the "original" and as such its "legally" the original if in literal fact not so its worth viewing to see what the "filed copy" shows.

To me, the bigger question is still what in 1983 "prompted" the action in the first place? I am having a difficult time accepting it was an "oops, I just forgot and need to do it" moment.

I still believe it was provoked by an incident and has to do with money.
 
On the file copy

I'm about 50-50 on whether its the "original" PGF or the public copy as Crow believes. ( the fact it was sent in 83 alone draws suspicion as to its authenticity and originality)

One thing tho- its "filed" as the "original" and as such its "legally" the original if in literal fact not so its worth viewing to see what the "filed copy" shows.

To me, the bigger question is still what in 1983 "prompted" the action in the first place? I am having a difficult time accepting it was an "oops, I just forgot and need to do it" moment.

I still believe it was provoked by an incident and has to do with money.

I'm 65/35 that there is more on the LOC reel than the patty walk. 1983 was an information dark age. Heck, it took 41 years for someone to think to check the CR and you did that online Longtabber. It is not unreasonable that in 1983 PP and BG had no way of prediciting that the LOC archives could be checked so easily. So, it was a good bet in 1983 to send ALL film to the LOC. Especially if there is an incident that has escaped general knowledge.

I don't expect to see footage of BH putting on the suit but their could be a smoking gun included that screams hoax.
 
Has anyone contacted BH regarding all the questions generated on this site? Why don't we make THE list and go talk to the guy? He may know what happened in 1983. Didn't Patterson die in 1972?
 
Well? Are you holding your breath?

I think you missed his point.

No, I got the point. I was simply pointing out through the use of Sarcasm, that Bigfootry has no worries about BobG coming clean at the conference.
 
The wagons are circling

Trying to say that BG isnt aware he is still the registered CR owner ( yet he renewed in 96- how could he be "unaware' of that when HE sent it in?)

Then theres talk about the 76 lawsuit ( whatever the outcome, it apparently didnt involve alteration of CR ownership)

Then theres talk that Dahinden "won" CR in 76? ( what cause of action did he have?)

People need to understand that those applications ( WITH SIGNATURES) are also on file and available for microfich search so what will the "company line" be when there are real signatures as late as 96? ( did he forget he signed it?)

The plot thickens
 
Has anyone contacted BH regarding all the questions generated on this site? Why don't we make THE list and go talk to the guy? He may know what happened in 1983. Didn't Patterson die in 1972?

I have a suspicion that BG really wont be receptive to a legitimate critical investigative interview where he may get cornered because he will have to explain why the lawful copyright record of the USLOC doesnt reflect any/all of the accounts given in previous interviews.
 
... and putting words and thoughts into Gimlin's mouth and mind.


Also now: Gimlin sold his rights to Dahinden for...

A) $1
B) $10
C) $26

Take your pick. They are all part of the PGF lore.


Yet none of them are reflected in the OFFICIAL record.

Maybe we need to start a PGFgate or Bigfootgate thread.
 
Looks like a washout on the LOC reel

Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California [1967].
Relevance:
Type of Work: Motion Picture
Registration Number / Date: PA0000175821 / 1983-02-24
Title: Big Foot--Bluff Creek, California [1967].
Imprint: [Canada : s.n.], c1967.
Description: 1 film reel (ca. 1 min.) : si., col. ; 16 mm.
Notes: Deposit includes descriptive material (4 p.)
Copyright Claimant: Robert Gimlin & Mrs. Roger Patterson
Date of Creation: 1967
Date of Publication: 1967-10-26
Authorship on Application: photographers: Roger Patterson & Robert Gimlin.
Copyright Note: C.O. correspondence.

Names: Patterson, Mrs. Roger
Gimlin, Robert, 1931
Patterson, Roger, 1933-1972


No smoking gun. Darn.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom