BBC says Al Qaida is fake

You mean like when the History Channel plays "Loose Change"?

It's not about bias. It's about facts. If the documentary states that "Al Qaeda" was invented by US intelligence, that's not a matter of "bias". It's a matter of it being true, or a lie.

All information I'm aware of indicates it's a lie. In which case the BBC is lying.

I would be very happy to see "factual" broadcasters censoring their programmes so they only broadcast things that were true. That's what they're SUPPOSED to do. It's something they seem to have all forgotten.

-Gumboot
I disagree, but you've been answered fully later on in the thread so I won't repeat the same things.

What annoys me most about this documentary is that CT'ers have twisted it and tied it in with 9/11. That's the reason I posted this message on another forum, the poster I was replying to was claiming Al Qaida doesn't exist and this somehow proves 9/11 was a inside job.

BTW I don't think it needs me to point out that there is a huge difference between the factual nature of this documentary and Loose Change! If you have any problems with this documentary maybe you should take it up with Adam Curtis, his email address is at the bottom of this page, although I don't know if it's still valid.
 
What annoys me most about this documentary is that CT'ers have twisted it and tied it in with 9/11.



That really shouldn't surprise you. CTers are good at that. :p

I just want to reiterate I haven't seen the documentary, and I don't know what it is about. I was responding to what others claimed it was saying, hence why I said "If the documentary is saying X".

:)

I'm also really not surprised that CTers think a documentary is saying something it isn't.

-Gumboot
 
Brodski, to answer your Al-Qaeda statement about OBL using it in the past

An october 2001 interview, OBL talks about his past

BIN LADEN: This has nothing to do with this poor servant of God, nor with the al Qaeda organization. We are the children of an Islamic nation whose leader is Mohammed.

We have one religion, one God, one book, one prophet, one nation. Our book teaches us to be brothers of a faith. All the Muslims are brothers. The name "al Qaeda" was established a long time ago by mere chance. The late Abu Ebeida El-Banashiri established the training camps for our mujahedeen against Russia's terrorism. We used to call the training camp al Qaeda [meaning "the base" in English]. And the name stayed. We speak about the conscience of the nation; we are the sons of the nation. We brothers in Islam from the Middle East, Philippines, Malaysia, India, Pakistan and as far as Mauritania.

http://archives.cnn.com/2002/WORLD/asiapcf/south/02/05/binladen.transcript/index.html
 
The late Abu Ebeida El-Banashiri established the training camps for our mujahedeen against Russia's terrorism. We used to call the training camp al Qaeda [meaning "the base" in English].

This is also explained within the documentary - but they claim nevertheless that the name was invented by the us. :boggled:
 
Brodski, to answer your Al-Qaeda statement about OBL using it in the past

An october 2001 interview, OBL talks about his past



http://archives.cnn.com/2002/WORLD/asiapcf/south/02/05/binladen.transcript/index.html

And do you trust him on this?
Part of the hypothesis under discussion is that OBL himself has lied about and exaggerated the size and reach of ther AL Quieda organization, in order to capitalize on the mythology which was floating around. Has anyone been able to come up with an example, prior to January 2001, of OBL using the term?
 
And do you trust him on this?
Part of the hypothesis under discussion is that OBL himself has lied about and exaggerated the size and reach of ther AL Quieda organization, in order to capitalize on the mythology which was floating around. Has anyone been able to come up with an example, prior to January 2001, of OBL using the term?

That´s the problem i had with this claim. OBL was fascinated that the americans thought he has an organisation called AQ and it´s a world-wide network. So he joined "the party" with the people who were celebrating this myth. :boggled:
 
<snip>
Osama became the manager of Saudi money and Arab manpower being poured into Afghanistan. This included a vast network of fundraising organisations in the US, including the MAK network. Ultimately Osama assassinated the leader of MAK and took over the organisation itself. This became Al Qaeda.
<snip>

Well I've heard that before, that Bin Laden had something to do with the assassination of Abdallah Azzam. But is that a fact that could be verified to some extent or is it just a rumour? Do you have a source to confirm this?
 
If you mean Jason Burke, you should know that he is one of the many people interviewed in the documentary.

Yes, that's why it reminded me of the fact that I have the book at home. The book, which I also wonder about- if anyone here read it, for example, and what they think of it.
 
I just want to reiterate I haven't seen the documentary, and I don't know what it is about.
The introduction to the first episode of The Power of Nightmares is contained in the following quote-box. This statement introduces Curtis' thesis.

In the past, politicians promised to create a better world. They had different ways of achieving this. But their power and authority came from the optimistic visions they offered to their people. Those dreams failed. And today, people have lost faith in ideologies. Increasingly, politicians are seen simply as managers of public life.

But now, they have discovered a new role that restores their power and authority. Instead of delivering dreams, politicians now promise to protect us from nightmares. They say that they will rescue us from dreadful dangers that we cannot see and do not understand. And the greatest danger of all is international terrorism. A powerful and sinister network, with sleeper cells in countries across the world. A threat that needs to be fought by a war on terror.

But much of this threat is a fantasy, which has been exaggerated and distorted by politicians. It’s a dark illusion that has spread, unquestioned, through governments around the world, the security services, and the international media.
This is a series of films about how and why that fantasy was created, and who it benefits. At the heart of the story are two groups: the American neoconservatives, and the radical Islamists. Both were idealists who were born out of the failure of the liberal dream to build a better world. And both had a very similar explanation for what caused that failure. These two groups have changed the world, but not in the way that either intended. Together, they created today’s nightmare vision of a secret, organized evil that threatens the world. A fantasy that politicians then found restored their power and authority in a disillusioned age. And those with the darkest fears became the most powerful.
The documentary shows how the neo-conservatives in the U.S. (including Leo Strauss) learned in the 20th century that the public can be manipulated by emotional appeals (mostly fear). They saw the rise of fascism in Europe as a product of this manipulation, but decided that to preserve "democracy" in North America, the public would have to be manipulated here by the good guys. For example, the Soviets were made out to be more dangerous in the 1970's and 1980's than they really were. The public are seen as too stupid or complacent or self-obsessed to be willing to fight, unless you scare the bejeezuz out of them.

Meanwhile, Western politicians learned from the 1960's that you can't build a Great Society. But you can't get elected being a boring placeholder manager, either. So, casting oneself as a Great Protector of the People is a good image to cultivate if you want to gain or stay in office.

Meanwhile, in the Islamic world, secular leftist and nationalist movements were being defeated. The only opposition to the dictators and kings was the Islamic supremacists, such as the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt. These groups were horrified by the increasing presence of "corrupt" Western culture, such as television, music, and fashion, and they thought that the Umma was being led astray. Stries against the corrupters would rally the people to their true faith. Leaders such as Sadat were assassinated and the Shah overthrown to preserve traditional ways of life.

However, none of these kinds of events led to the people waking up and destroying the cultural pollution. They still liked their American TV shows; so they became the enemy. The Islamic supremacists started attacking them for being insufficiently pure. During the 1990's, this lost the jihadists even more support, and internal disagreements weakened them further.

September 11, 2001 was an answer to the prayers of both the neoconservatives and the Islamic supremacists. For the former, it highlighted the kind of threat they think they need to keep "their" public afraid, united, and mobilized. For the latter, it refocused the threat as an outside force, sparked a militarized reaction, and thus highlighted the kind of threat they think they need to keep "their" public afraid, united, and mobilized.

That's basically what I remember as the main argument of the Curtis' series.

And I'll add this: I've never heard "Baby, It's Cold Outside" the same way since.
 
That´s the problem i had with this claim. OBL was fascinated that the americans thought he has an organisation called AQ and it´s a world-wide network. So he joined "the party" with the people who were celebrating this myth. :boggled:

You see this at lot in wars, each side exaggerates both their own power and the power of their enemy, it is excellent propaganda for both sides. there is no suggestion of any cooperation between OBL and the US in this matter, it's just the way which both sides tend to behave, and neither side gains from contradicting the other on this matter at this stage.
 
You see this at lot in wars, each side exaggerates both their own power and the power of their enemy, it is excellent propaganda for both sides. there is no suggestion of any cooperation between OBL and the US in this matter, it's just the way which both sides tend to behave, and neither side gains from contradicting the other on this matter at this stage.

So the documentary and it´s claims could be true?
 
That´s the problem i had with this claim. OBL was fascinated that the americans thought he has an organisation called AQ and it´s a world-wide network. So he joined "the party" with the people who were celebrating this myth. :boggled:

I don't know if this has been pointed out before, but people in the "Mafia" never call the "Mafia", the "Mafia".

Its really what attorneys general have taken to call a gorup of organised crime families or gropus that opearte in a specific manner.

That doesn't mean the mafia doesn't exist.
 
So the documentary and it´s claims could be true?

I find them plausible. The thing is what is claimed in the documentary isn't what the CTers claim, it's the cock-up and opportunist theory of history, not the the conspiracy theory, which is put forward.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom