BBC says Al Qaida is fake

Darat said:
You are confusing the BBC's news output with it's programming output. These programmes were not news broadcasts
.

True, Darat, but the Power of Nightmares, and the two other items I've linked to, appear in BBC webpages headed "BBC News", as does the CTs beloved "Hijack 'suspects' still alive and well" BBC webpage. Though in the case of the latter, I've no idea whether the story was broadcast at all, or in what form.
 
The BBC needs to make up it's mind on the subject. In July and August last year, it aired a series of three documentaries under the banner "The New Al-Qaeda", explaining how Al-Qaeda has evolved. I don't think the films are available on the net, but a description of the content can be found here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/4683403.stm

Or just read their own "Investgating Al-Qaeda" webpage:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/world/2001/war_on_terror/

I can't let the subject of OBL and Al-Qaeda go by without a link to JREF member Karim's film, "The Paladin of Jihad":

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8073634249820550181
The BBC isn't biased in any way, they'll show programs from all points-of-view. Also I'd just like to point out for anyone who doesn't get the BBC channels, the BBC isn't just about news...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/whatson/

I think maybe the title of the thread should have been...

"3 part BBC documentary series written and produced by Adam Curtis says Al-Qaida is fake!"

...to avoid confusion. :D
 
This is also a good documentary called "I met Osama Bin Laden"...

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/3570751.stm

...it's been a while since I've seen this one but I do remember the reporter mentioning that Bin Laden had a kidney problem, although he didn't need dialysis it seemed because he met up with him in the Tora Bora mountain range. The only thing he said was he sipped green tea constantly throughout the day to ease his condition and keep his kidneys clean.
 
Because they sell the documentary...

Duh.

-Gumboot

They could but there are better ways for them to make money. There is little evidence that the BBC is influence by finacial issues (beyond initial cost) in the makeing of programs of this type.
 
Al Qeida has existed since 1988 according to the 9/11 commission and other reports. The CIA wasn't aware of it until 1996. Until 1996, they thought OBL just financed attacks. In reality thats all he does. 9/11 was planned by KSL, executed by the 19 suicide bombers and financed by OBL.
 
The BBC isn't biased in any way, they'll show programs from all points-of-view.

You sure we watch the same BBC?

Lack of bias doesn't mean "generaly says things I agree with". Which broadly, I did with the power of nightmares. The common current of Islamic terror groups is not taking orders from Bin Laden like Bond villain henchmen, it is a literalistic reading of Islam. I would argue that this in fact makes the situation far more dangerous, as the basis of their emnity for the west is deeply ingrained the faith shared by peaceful Muslims. Qutb didn't pull that interpretaion out of thin air.
 
Last edited:
You sure we watch the same BBC?

Lack of bias doesn't mean "generaly says things I agree with". Which broadly, I did with the power of nightmares. The common current of Islamic terror groups is not taking orders from Bin Laden like Bond villain henchmen, it is a literalistic reading of Islam. I would argue that this in fact makes the situation far more dangerous, as the basis of their emnity for the west is deeply ingrained the faith shared by peaceful Muslims. Qutb didn't pull that interpretaion out of thin air.
Too much political correctness is a problem throughout the UK not just the BBC.

Curtis has also stated: "Something extraordinary has happened to American TV since September 11. A head of the leading networks who had better remain nameless said to me that there was no way they could show it. He said, 'Who are you to say this?' and then he added, 'We would get slaughtered if we put this out.' When I was in New York I took a DVD to the head of documentaries at HBO. I still haven't heard from him."

There have been equally damming documentaries on OBL and Al Qaida on the BBC in the past, maybe I should have said they are less biased than most news organizations because nobody is 100% un-biased. For example in the UK it's not PC to criticize Islam, but it's OK to criticize Christianity.
 
Last edited:
I think maybe the title of the thread should have been...

"3 part BBC documentary series written and produced by Adam Curtis says Al-Qaida is fake!"

...to avoid confusion. :D


The series was produced by the BBC.

I used to uphold the BBC as one of the rare less-bias sources of information. However these days I would consider them just as biased and sensationalist-eager as any American broadcaster. I'm not sure if this is a shift at the BBC itself, or simply me discovering a bias that was always there.

-Gumboot
 

The BBC are more willing to show documentaries such as the "Power of Nightmares" than most American TV networks, then the viewer is left to decide whether it was accurate or not, rather than being unnecessarily censored beforehand.



You mean like when the History Channel plays "Loose Change"?

It's not about bias. It's about facts. If the documentary states that "Al Qaeda" was invented by US intelligence, that's not a matter of "bias". It's a matter of it being true, or a lie.

All information I'm aware of indicates it's a lie. In which case the BBC is lying.

I would be very happy to see "factual" broadcasters censoring their programmes so they only broadcast things that were true. That's what they're SUPPOSED to do. It's something they seem to have all forgotten.

-Gumboot
 
For example in the UK it's not PC to criticize Islam, but it's OK to criticize Christianity.

In germany it´s the same behavior. Criticism against jewish people is nearly a taboo, against other ethnic groups unpopular but against the western world in general no problem at all - even if seldom. Okay, america is evil number one today as far i see it beside the old middle-east criticism.

BTW: What about the critisism within the us. What is politically incorrect today and what not?
 
The documentary is very specific about the alleged roots of the term. From the transcript (beginning of part 3):

VO: In January, 2001, a trial began in a Manhattan courtroom of four men accused of the embassy bombings in east Africa. But the Americans had also decided to prosecute bin Laden in his absence. But to do this under American law, the prosecutors needed evidence of a criminal organisation because, as with the Mafia, that would allow them to prosecute the head of the organisation even if he could not be linked directly to the crime. And the evidence for that organisation was provided for them by an ex-associate of bin Laden’s called Jamal al-Fadl.

JASON BURKE , AUTHOR, “AL QAEDA” : During the investigation of the 1998 bombings, there is a walk-in source, Jamal al-Fadl, who is a Sudanese militant who was with bin Laden in the early 90s, who has been passed around a whole series of Middle East secret services, none of whom want much to do with him, and who ends up in America and is taken on by—uh—the American government, effectively, as a key prosecution witness and is given a huge amount of American taxpayers’ money at the same time. And his account is used as raw material to build up a picture of Al Qaeda. The picture that the FBI want to build up is one that will fit the existing laws that they will have to use to prosecute those responsible for the bombing. Now, those laws were drawn up to counteract organised crime: the Mafia, drugs crime, crimes where people being a member of an organisation is extremely important. You have to have an organisation to get a prosecution. And you have al-Fadl and a number of other witness, a number of other sources, who are happy to feed into this. You’ve got material that, looked at in a certain way, can be seen to show this organisation’s existence. You put the two together and you get what is the first bin Laden myth—the first Al Qaeda myth. And because it’s one of the first, it’s extremely influential.

VO: The picture al-Fadl drew for the Americans of bin Laden was of an all-powerful figure at the head of a large terrorist network that had an organised network of control. He also said that bin Laden had given this network a name: “Al Qaeda.” It was a dramatic and powerful picture of bin Laden, but it bore little relationship to the truth.

[ EXCERPT, CNN EXCLUSIVE VIDEO : BIN LADEN AND SOLDIERS ]

VO: The reality was that bin Laden and Ayman Zawahiri had become the focus of a loose association of disillusioned Islamist militants who were attracted by the new strategy. But there was no organisation. These were militants who mostly planned their own operations and looked to bin Laden for funding and assistance. He was not their commander. There is also no evidence that bin Laden used the term “Al Qaeda” to refer to the name of a group until after September the 11th, when he realized that this was the term the Americans have given it.

[ CUT TO MANHATTAN SKYLINE ]

VO: In reality, Jamal al-Fadl was on the run from bin Laden, having stolen money from him. In return for his evidence, the Americans gave him witness protection in America and hundreds of thousands of dollars. Many lawyers at the trial believed that al-Fadl exaggerated and lied to give the Americans the picture of a terrorist organisation that they needed to prosecute bin Laden.

SAM SCHMIDT , DEFENCE LAWYER EMBASSY BOMBINGS TRIAL: And there were selective portions of al-Fadl’s testimony that I believe was false, to help support the picture that he helped the Americans join together. I think he lied in a number of specific testimony about a unified image of what this organisation was. It made Al Qaeda the new Mafia or the new Communists. It made them identifiable as a group and therefore made it easier to prosecute any person associated with Al Qaeda for any acts or statements made by bin Laden—who talked a lot.

BURKE : The idea—which is critical to the FBI’s prosecution—that bin Laden ran a coherent organisation with operatives and cells all around the world of which you could be a member is a myth. There is no Al Qaeda organisation. There is no international network with a leader, with cadres who will unquestioningly obey orders, with tentacles that stretch out to sleeper cells in America, in Africa, in Europe. That idea of a coherent, structured terrorist network with an organised capability simply does not exist.

VO: What did exist was a powerful idea that was about to inspire a single, devastating act that would lead the whole world into believing the myth that had begun to be constructed in the Manhattan courtroom.

[ CUT TO MANHATTAN SKYLINE : WORLD TRADE CENTER TOWERS . ONE TOWER HAS BEEN HIT , AND IS ON FIRE .]

For me, part one was the most interesting as it lays out the origins of the muslim brotherhood on one side, the neo-cons on the other and the similarities in their ideologies. "The rise of the politics of fear", as the subtitle says.
 
You mean like when the History Channel plays "Loose Change"?

It's not about bias. It's about facts. If the documentary states that "Al Qaeda" was invented by US intelligence, that's not a matter of "bias". It's a matter of it being true, or a lie.

All information I'm aware of indicates it's a lie. In which case the BBC is lying.

I would be very happy to see "factual" broadcasters censoring their programmes so they only broadcast things that were true. That's what they're SUPPOSED to do. It's something they seem to have all forgotten.

-Gumboot

It´s hard to see whats wrong or right if fiction is mixed with real facts - but i use to accept the BBC as usefull and well researching source without being sceptic all the time. So what is true within this docu and what not - especially concerning the Neocons?
 
Here is what I understand to be the sequence of events. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

1980's -- The U.S. government supports mujehadeen forces who are from Afghanistan, in their war against the Soviets. Meanwhile, and seperately, Osama bin Laden of Saudi Arabia supports a smaller force of non-Afghan Arab fighters in Afghanistan.

[Doesn't this mean that bin Laden and the future Al Qaeda were not funded or created by the U.S. CIA?]

1988 -- The Soviets leave Afghanistan. Bin Laden and Ayman Zawahiri re-invent their foreign-fighters network into a new organization with a new mission. A new name for the new group is coined: "Al Qaeda"

OSAMA BIN LADEN, OCTOBER 2001: "The name 'al Qaeda' was established a long time ago by mere chance. The late Abu Ebeida El-Banashiri established the training camps for our mujahedeen against Russia's terrorism. We used to call the training camp al Qaeda [meaning 'the base' in English]. And the name stayed."
http://archives.cnn.com/2002/WORLD/asiapcf/south/02/05/binladen.transcript/index.html

I have alse heard it said (but I don't remember where), that this name was also a kind of pun. The group needed to keep track of its fighters, for logistical purposes and for issuing payment to survivors when its agents were killed. They kept track of everything with a computerized database. Is this correct?

February 1998: The World Islamic Front declares its jihad. I see no mention of the name "Al Qaeda". But I also see that unlike the other presenters, bin Laden's name is not followed by the name of an affiliated organization.
http://www.fas.org/irp/world/para/docs/980223-fatwa.htm

August 1998: Bombings of U.S. embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam.

2004: The BBC ...
... airs a documentary produced by Adam Curtis ...
... which quotes Sam Schmidt and Jason Burke ...
... who make controversial claims ...
... about how the U.S. government pursued Al Qaeda in court.

Schmidt was a defense lawyer in the Embassy Bombings Trial. Burke is a journalist with the British Sunday newspaper The Observer, and the author of Al-Qaeda: Casting a Shadow of Terror (2003).
http://silt3.com/index.php?id=586
See an excerpt of Burke's book at http://observer.guardian.co.uk/worldview/story/0,,996509,00.html

It seems from what I read that Burke is saying that Islamic supremacist terrorism is real and dangerous. But al Qaeda is more a method or process, now franchised and used as name to invoke notoriety, and less a formal organization with a defined structure and hierarchy (like a standard state military). Saying this is not the same thing as saying that this network/franchise/label/movement doesn't exist.
 
Here is what I understand to be the sequence of events. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

1980's -- The U.S. government supports mujehadeen forces who are from Afghanistan, in their war against the Soviets. Meanwhile, and seperately, Osama bin Laden of Saudi Arabia supports a smaller force of non-Afghan Arab fighters in Afghanistan.


I think there was a bit more to it than that. From what I understand the non-Afghani presence during the war was substantial - with both British and American intelligence agencies bringing large numbers of Arab fighters into Pakistan to be trained.

That seems to be the origin of OBL's involvement - Pakistan wanted a Saudi prince representing them in the operations, to make it "official". The Saudis weren't keen on that, but compromised by sending Osama - not a member of the royal family, but a member of a very closely linked and wealthy Saudi family.

Osama became the manager of Saudi money and Arab manpower being poured into Afghanistan. This included a vast network of fundraising organisations in the US, including the MAK network. Ultimately Osama assassinated the leader of MAK and took over the organisation itself. This became Al Qaeda.

The problem arose because the ideology that got foreign Arabs to fight in Afghanistan was a crusade to protect Islam. So once that battle was won, it was natural they were attracted to other conflicts that threatened Islam.

When Iraq invaded Kuwait and threatened Saudi Arabia this was their ultimate duty to defend their faith. Except the Saudis chose to be protected by the US instead - a big slap in the face of the Mujahedeen. Hence they declared war on the US and became more active in fights around the world - Bosnia, Chechnya, Somalia, and so forth.

-Gumboot

ETA. It is worth noting that the tactics of terrorism have been fundamental elements of Arab warfare for a very long time. It was hardly a new thing for Al Qaeda to employ such tactics.
 
It's not about bias. It's about facts. If the documentary states that "Al Qaeda" was invented by US intelligence, that's not a matter of "bias". It's a matter of it being true, or a lie.

But that is n to what the documentary says at all, it's point is that OBL funds terrorism, he funds and organizes terrorist training camps, and there are threats from Islamic terrorists. However there is no organized terrorist group, just a loose association of fanatics, and a brand name. The documentary claims that initially (under th Clinton Administration) the cohesiveness of OBLs terror network was over-hyped so that he could be prosecuted for the Embassy bombings under legislation originally designed to tackle organized crime. The idea of a vast, cohesive network is a much better "story" than the idea of a loose affiliation of terrorists, so that's the one which the Politicians and the media went with.
The documentary then argues that OBL recognized the power of this story himself, and so he started to bolster the Al Quieda "army" myth himself, when in reality all he does is provide funds and facilitate training.
One way to falsify this theory is to show anywhere where OBL himself used the term Al; Quieda before 2001. That's not to say that what we now refer to as Al Quieda wasn't around prior to 2001, it's just that he didn't use that name until the US (for understandable reasons) built the name up to represent more than it really did.

It is important to stress that this is not a conspiracy film, far from it, there is absolutely no suggestion that anyone other than fanatical islamists where behind 9/11, and all the other terrorist acts which have been pinned on them.
The film doesn't even argue that politicians deliberately sat down nd planned how to make Al Quieda more frightening, it was just a natural consequence of people hearing what they expected and wanted to here, and politicians expressing themselves in ways which where designed to gain the maximum public support. There is no Machiavellian prince pulling the strings.

I really would recommend anyone in this thread watch the film, it's well made and it deserves better than the spin the CTers are putting on it, because it doesn't support their claims at all.
 
There is no Machiavellian prince pulling the strings.

I really would recommend anyone in this thread watch the film, it's well made and it deserves better than the spin the CTers are putting on it, because it doesn't support their claims at all.



You're such a spoil sport...:mad:

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom