BBC says Al Qaida is fake

If this is what the doco is saying I think we can feel fairly certain that it is full of BS ;)

So there is evidence that the name "Al Qaida" was invented by OBL and co? I didn´t find any source confirming this.

Wiki ENG says something different to Wiki DE.

Al-Qaeda or Al-Qaida (القاعدة, translit: al-Qā`ida; "the foundation", "the base" or "the database"). Robin Cook, former Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs of the United Kingdom and member of the House of Commons representative, said that "Al-Qaeda" states "literally ‘the database' and was originally the computer file of the thousands of mujahideen who were recruited and trained with help from the CIA to defeat the Russians." [5]

According to former French Military Intelligence official Pierre Henry Bunel , "Al-Qaeda" was an early form of intranet, that was used by Islamic nations and influential families to communicate with each other. It was also used by the "American agent," Osama bin Laden to send coded or covert messages back to his CIA handlers from Afghanistan. [6]

German Wiki states it was a guy named Abdallah Azzam, a jihad-theologian.

And French Wiki even talks about the "Made by US-Intelligence"-theory concerning the roots.

:boggled:
 
I've seen the BBC documentary, and what I took away was that Al-Qaeda was like a terrorism "foundation", if you will. It provides "grants" and maybe "seminars" on how to do terrorism, but the cells it generates are autonomous. They might coordinate communication among various cells, but decentralization is at the heart of its business model. It gives the organization certain weaknesses, but makes it extremely difficult to stamp out.
 
No no, they say Osama exists but Al Qaida as worldwide terrornetwork is a complete fairytale. :confused:

I'm not sure when this documentary was made, but that's partially true of a decade or so ago. Al Qaeda, and particularly OBL, has rapidly grown in power and influence over most Islamic extremists since 9/11.

So there is evidence that the name "Al Qaida" was invented by OBL and co? I didn´t find any source confirming this.

Wiki ENG says something different to Wiki DE.

In addition to what others have posted, there's numerous documentations of OBL and his subordinates using the name Al Qaeda to describe themselves. So, IMO, whether or not they came up with the name, which they apparently did, isn't relevant to claiming whether or not they exist as they use the name themselves.
 
I'm not sure when this documentary was made, but that's partially true of a decade or so ago. Al Qaeda, and particularly OBL, has rapidly grown in power and influence over most Islamic extremists since 9/11.

I think it was aired the first time in 2004.

In addition to what others have posted, there's numerous documentations of OBL and his subordinates using the name Al Qaeda to describe themselves. So, IMO, whether or not they came up with the name, which they apparently did, isn't relevant to claiming whether or not they exist as they use the name themselves.

No, they say OBL adopted the name "Al Qaida" after he realized that this was the name americans gave his organization.
 
I thought the documentary (all 3 parts) was well done and very convincing. If anyone has any factual objections I'd be interested in hearing them, but otherwise it's simply a matter of disagreeing with what appear to be very sound arguments.
 
The BBC needs to make up it's mind on the subject. In July and August last year, it aired a series of three documentaries under the banner "The New Al-Qaeda", explaining how Al-Qaeda has evolved. I don't think the films are available on the net, but a description of the content can be found here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/4683403.stm

Or just read their own "Investgating Al-Qaeda" webpage:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/world/2001/war_on_terror/

I can't let the subject of OBL and Al-Qaeda go by without a link to JREF member Karim's film, "The Paladin of Jihad":

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8073634249820550181
 
No, they say OBL adopted the name "Al Qaida" after he realized that this was the name americans gave his organization.



Oddly enough, I've often heard cited that the term "Al Qaeda" was not used in the CIA or FBI until very late in the piece - perhaps even after the African Embassy Bombings in 1998. This is usually used as evidence of how far behind the "game" they were - in other words, Osama and the Mujahedeen formed Al Qaeda in the very early 90's (91?) and although US intelligence was aware of something going on, it took them 7 years to even find out the NAME of the organisation.

-Gumboot
 
BBC would say you're fake if it made them money. Are you fake?

The Documentry has little in the way of merchenideing opertunities and the BBC doesn't carry ads so it is hard to see how it could make them money.
 
The Documentry has little in the way of merchenideing opertunities and the BBC doesn't carry ads so it is hard to see how it could make them money.


Because they sell the documentary...

Duh.

-Gumboot
 
According to the documentary "National Geographic: Inside 9/11" the network was named "Al Qaeda" in 1988, just after they forced out the Russians from Afghanastan. "Al Qeada" = "The Base"
 
The BBC needs to make up it's mind on the subject. In July and August last year, it aired a series of three documentaries under the banner "The New Al-Qaeda", explaining how Al-Qaeda has evolved. I don't think the films are available on the net, but a description of the content can be found here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/4683403.stm

Or just read their own "Investgating Al-Qaeda" webpage:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/world/2001/war_on_terror/

I can't let the subject of OBL and Al-Qaeda go by without a link to JREF member Karim's film, "The Paladin of Jihad":

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8073634249820550181

You are confusing the BBC's news output with it's programming output. These programmes were not news broadcasts.
 
A CT'ist on another forum posted a similar link to a video on YouTube taken from the same documentary, here was my reply...

Spins said:
What this documentary (it's actually called "The Power of Nightmares") was trying to say is that since Al-Qaeda has no clear structure, and there are also doubts about exactly how many members make up the organization (I'd guess a couple of thousand at the most), and it appears it's members are scattered across the globe. Does this fail to meet the governments description of the widespread entity that is Al-Qaeda, the answer is probably yes!

By Al-Qaeda members I don't mean someone who is a Bin Laden sympathizer or wears a Bin Laden t-shirt or has Bin Laden wallpaper on their desktop, these people probably number in the millions.

This doesn't mean Al-Qaeda doesn't exist or that other forms of radical Islam don't exist (some of which are affiliated with Al-Qaeda); just the government's definition of Al-Qaeda as a widespread global organization is exaggerated.

Since it only took 40 or so members of Al-Qaeda (or whatever you want to call them, it doesn't really matter) to plan, finance, and carry out the attacks on 9/11 then IMO it doesn't matter about the size of the organization, it's the will to carry out these attacks, for this reason they are rightly seen as a legitimate terrorist threat.

What you probably also fail to realise is that this documentary set out to compare the rise of American neoconservatives and radical Islam, and actually asserts that both are closely related. That some popular beliefs about both of these groups are inaccurate, and that both movements have benefited from exaggerating the scale of the terrorist threat.

Also I'd just like to add that the writer and producer of the documentary does not believe 9/11 was an inside job...

Q: Do you believe it possible that the American Neo-Cons engineered the 9/11 atrocity as a catalyst for their program?

Cliff Babbs, Daventry

A: No.

...taken from here.
 
Because they sell the documentary...

Duh.

-Gumboot

Are you certain? Many of "the BBC's" programmes are not in fact the BBCs to sell - the BBC will have just bought certain broadcast rights. In this particular instance I do not know if this is a BBC owned programme or not.
 
You are confusing the BBC's news output with it's programming output. These programmes were not news broadcasts.
Yes, it was not a news broadcast it was a 3 part documentary series first shown on BBC 2 back in 2004.
 
Are you certain? Many of "the BBC's" programmes are not in fact the BBCs to sell - the BBC will have just bought certain broadcast rights. In this particular instance I do not know if this is a BBC owned programme or not.


Of course. I am working on the assumption that the original statements of it being a BBC Documentary are accurate. This premise is the basis of this particular strain of the thread.

-Andrew

ETA:

According to IMDB the documentary was produced by the BBC.
 
Last edited:
Of course. I am working on the assumption that the original statements of it being a BBC Documentary are accurate. This premise is the basis of this particular strain of the thread.

-Andrew

It's common usage to call an independent produced documentary a "BBC documentary" even if the BBC does not have the rights to sell it - the term "BBC documentary" really doesn't tell you anything more then it was broadcast on the BBC.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom