Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Maybe it's causing you some eyesight problems?

oh good, another irrelevent and useless comment. I can add it to my long list of personal attacks by my opponents, regarding this issue.

-eyesight problems.
-evil.
-barbaric.
-child abuse.
-hating children.
-hating babies.
-anti-Semitic.
-Conspiracy Theorist.
...I'm kinda losing track. :(
 
oh good, another irrelevent and useless comment. I can add it to my long list of personal attacks by my opponents, regarding this issue.

-eyesight problems.


You mean you still couldn't read it in bold bright red large type? Or do you intend to evade all the hard questions forever?

http://www.circumstitions.com/Restric/Botched4ga.html

How many cases like this are you OK with?

Rolfe.
 
men without their foreskin are "damaged"...for life? more hyperbole I see. this thread is full of it.

interesting. too bad the scientists & doctors don't agree with you.

I and other circumcised men have a fully-functioning penis. Able to perform all of its required & desired duties.


......by the way, does anyone have a logical argument as to how my circumcised penis is not fully functioning?

Please, please, please read what you respond to.
You accuse others of misrepresenting you, but seem entirely oblivious when you do the same thing.
 
I don't believe that circumcision is a good thing. I also don't think its a bad thing.

I don't believe that removing the clitoral hood is a good thing. I have also seen no evidence yet that its a bad thing.

I don't believe that reducing the size of a clitoris is a good thing or bad thing. It may be helpful, but it may be unneccessary.

My issue is not whether these specific surgeries are good or bad. I see no evidence either way, for the most part.

My issue...is whether parents should have the right to have them performed on their child, without their child's consent.

And until I see good evidence that male-circumcion is indeed harmful, or clitoral reduction is indeed harmful, or removing the clitoral hood is indeed harmful, I shall defer to parental rights.

However, if the motivation of the surgery IS to cause harm, such as to reduce sexual enjoyment, then I DO have a problem with it.

If someone tells me that they want to circumcise their baby boy, because they believe that the foreskin provides additional pleasure, and they want their child's sexual experiences to be painful and unpleasant, and they want my consent....I would NOT give it.

Perhaps my view on these matters is too sophisticated and complicated. If that is the case, I do apologize...but its my opinion and I have the right to it.

Okay, since you seem to lack basic comprehension, and seem to deliberately misconstrue the question:
why do you think it a good thing that parents can do that to their babies, rather than allowing the baby to make the decision when he can give informed consent?
 
prove it.


...or should we just trust your opinion as being the Divine Truth?

Cutting anything off a person is harmful. Some harms are worse than others, but it is still harmful.
But that has already been explained to you.
 
why do you think it a good thing that parents can do that to their babies, rather than allowing the baby to make the decision when he can give informed consent?

because I believe in parental rights. do you believe in parental rights?
 
surgery on an enlarged clitoris, removes something from a person.

are you therefore against clitoral-reduction surgery on babies?
Already answered.
What is it with your reading comprehension?
Or are you truly dishonest?
 
Already answered.

ok, so you are against surgery on an enlarged clitoris, for a baby.

now, why do you want a poor little girl to have to grow up with an enlarged clitoris, that looks like a small penis?

I couldn't imagine growing up with such a thing, if I was a girl. It would be torture. I would question my sexuality, my biology, and I would certainly be made fun of by other girls in communal showers.

why would you want to put a child through such a thing?

:(
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom