Bad Effects of Allopathic Medicines?

Mojo said:
Have you ever seen a serious scientific journal? They tend not to be illustrated with the authors' holiday snaps.

As for "who were the persons on which the trial was conducted," proper doctors are concerned with something called patient confidentiality. It was immediately obvious from the opening post in this thread that Homeo Man is not remotely bothered by issues of confidentiality, and neither, apparently, are you.

This has hit the nail on the head. In the UK any consultant breaching this code of ethics, would be instantly struck off by the GMC. The lady in the photo appears to be homeless or at the very least extremely poor, one must ask how several private operations could be afforded.
 
Murthy.

Please stick around and argue. You were able to communicate a lot better than the current lot. And if I disagreed with you, it was nothing personal. It was just that I thought that you were wrong.
 
Gavinimurthy said:
Hi Hans

Thanks for improving my vocabulary.:)

You are one of the sensible lot. I wish everybody is as polite as you are despite difference of opinions.

Murthy
Ehrm, I suggest you look up the word (in both spellings) before you use it ;).

If you were to come here and conduct serious debate, you would find that most would be both polite and respectful. As least after a while. The problem is, we have grown a bit fed up with the "debate" tactics of the majority of visiting homeopaths, so tempers might be a bit short.

Hans
 
Gavinimurthy

Aurgings/TTTT are liked here. Homeopathy works, not liked. Any step towards progress/positive of homeopathy is much unliked & taken otherwise here. Exept homeopathic & other alt. Systems positives, if you will discuss other aspects, you would find people here doing serious debate & most would be both polite and respectful. So just take care. Still I encourage you to visit here as;

Homeopathy may not yet be an "absolute" system but is with least adversities, wheras modern/other systems are also not "absolute" but can be with much adversities.
 
Kumar said:
Homeopathy works, not liked. Any step towards progress/positive of homeopathy is much unliked & taken otherwise here.
Kumar, please stop trying to misrepresent the views of people posting on this forum. If homeopathy worked, I would consider it to be a wonderful system. The trouble is that it doesn't work, and that is why it isn't liked.

As for "any step towards progress/positive of homeopathy," homeopathy has had 200 years to come up with the goods, but still hasn't made any appreciable progress. In fact, it continues to ignore real progress that has been made by real medicine during that time.
Homeopathy may not yet be an "absolute" system but is with least adversities, wheras modern/other systems are also not "absolute" but can be with much adversities.
If you think homeopathy has "least adversities," how do you account for the terrible side-effects of a homeopathic remedy being described here by Homeopath Syed?
Anacradium Orintale-200, Dr.Asad Zaheer took a dose TDS daily and upon 10th day when he woke up he was covered with papules and pustules all over the body. . The eruption followed the path of veins everywhere. It took 21 days to anti-dote it and restore health.
 
Its no use if I cite my books to you..! Our latest confirmation proving is with Anacradium Orintale-200, Dr.Asad Zaheer took a dose TDS daily and upon 10th day when he woke up he was covered with papules and pustules all over the body. . The eruption followed the path of veins everywhere. It took 21 days to anti-dote it and restore health. Why not you buy a bottle of Anac-200 and start taking a dose every day ?

Afterall 200 potency is far leaner than any poison to be effective ..!

Pls look at bolded words, which you have not mentioned in yor previous post. These were proving symptoms.

Anyway, if you agree to it, it proves homeopathic effects.;)
 
Kumar said:
Pls look at bolded words, which you have not mentioned in yor previous post. These were proving symptoms.

Anyway, if you agree to it, it proves homeopathic effects.;)
Mojo didn't say he agreed. He just pointed out that homeopaths don't consider homeopathy to be "with least adversities," so you can shut up about it.
 
Kumar said:
Pls look at bolded words, which you have not mentioned in yor previous post. These were proving symptoms.

Anyway, if you agree to it, it proves homeopathic effects.;)
So what if they were proving symptoms? The story describes an alleged severe adverse reaction to a homoeopathic remedy.

And if you dismiss that as mere coincidence, then that proves all so-called "effects" of homoeoapthic remedies are only coincidence.

Which is what we've been telling you since day 1.

(BSM is in New York, so he can't shoot me till he gets back!)

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
So what if they were proving symptoms? The story describes an alleged severe adverse reaction to a homoeopathic remedy.

And if you dismiss that as mere coincidence, then that proves all so-called "effects" of homoeoapthic remedies are only coincidence.

Which is what we've been telling you since day 1.

(BSM is in New York, so he can't shoot me till he gets back!)

Rolfe.

What are proving symptoms & how these are developed? As such, you can count all proving symptoms, aggravations etc. as side effects. This proves effects, but adversities are counted in patients. On individuality & homeopathic theory basis, it indicates that a patient with these symptoms can be cured by this remedy with least adversities.

( I shall not like/pursue that BSM may shoot you on his coming back for which you fear/care too much). :D
 
Dr.Asad Zaheer took a dose TDS daily
What means "TDS"?

How did they nurse him back into health? With homoeopathic remedies? I wonder how effective they were, when it took 20 days to cure him, when I would have expected a couple of weeks with just not taking the mixture that gave him the symptoms.

And do they prove by letting a single healthy person take a rememdy, and if he gets into trouble, the remedy works?

From my standpoint, he should not have shown any reaction at all, so if he did, I suspect that Pakistani homoeopaths have real problems with quality control!

As far as I understand, if Dr. Asad trusts his own procedure, and he is willing to do the trick again, he could win the million dollars by successively drinking 20 bottles, and only show a reaction on the one that contains the homoeopathic remedy. Seems easy, and should be worth the trouble.
 
Homeopathic materia medica is based on proving symptoms, symptoms noticed on accidental ingestion or by history of any substance. If you want to count alike it, you can count whole MM.
 
Kumar said:
What are proving symptoms & how these are developed?
Proving symptoms are imaginary symptoms that homeopaths claim are produced when a remedy is administered to a subject. Somehow, the remedy knows whether it is supposed to cause proving symptoms or cure existing symptoms; further evidence supporting Rolfe's contention that homeopathy is a form of sympathetic magic.
 
Mojo said:
Proving symptoms are imaginary symptoms that homeopaths claim are produced when a remedy is administered to a subject. Somehow, the remedy knows whether it is supposed to cause proving symptoms or cure existing symptoms; further evidence supporting Rolfe's contention that homeopathy is a form of sympathetic magic.

Any substance can be difficient, balance or in excess in different individual, so adding, removing or stumulating can make different symptoms in different individuals--healthy or diseased, related to that substance.

About consideration, regulation & control of so mentioned effect of remedies;

NaCl, Sugar, most of foods etc. can also produce various symptoms or side effects--but not considered for control, regulation etc..??
 
Kumar said:
What are proving symptoms & how these are developed? As such, you can count all proving symptoms, aggravations etc. as side effects.
Since side-effects are basically unpleasant effects of a treatment that you would prefer not to have, then all proving and aggravation symptoms (and the "healing crisis") are by definition side-effects. Of course, only if the remedy actually caused them. But then, you are convinced that it did.
Kumar said:
This proves effects, but adversities are counted in patients. On individuality & homeopathic theory basis, it indicates that a patient with these symptoms can be cured by this remedy with least adversities.
So, supposing a homoeopath gives a patient the wrong remedy, and they then "prove" it? That's an adversity.

I would also refer you to the work of Hentschel, Reports of Complications in Homoeoapthic Treatment (1998), where the risk of an adverse reaction to homoeopathic treatment is put at 39.7%. In what way is that "least adversities"?

Adverse reactions to (or following) homoeopathic treatment are not formally reported and collected as they are for real medicines. Therefore it isn't possible simply to look up the statistics and find out how common this is. This allows people like Kumar, who are in total denial, to pretend that these reactions don't exist.

However, they do. You can dismiss them by saying that they were simply coincidence, and not actually caused by the remedy, but if you do that then by the same token you dismiss all the positive sequelae as simply coincidence, and not caused by the remedy either.

Rolfe.
 
"About consideration, regulation & control of so mentioned effect of remedies;

NaCl, Sugar, most of foods etc. can also produce various symptoms or side effects--but not considered for control, regulation etc..??"

Rolfe, although I have already indicated your doubts in my above previous posting, it is the quantity which may matter for any adversities. If quantity is too low--to produce some symptoms but not the adversities, how can you count them for control/regualtion/adversities. If you want to consider it, all substances in some excess/optomal quantity can be with adversities but still mosts are not controlled/regulated for adversities.

Anyway good chance for you: test systematically, the effects & adversities by HRs.:D Also check claimed complete cure & complete health by HRs. :)
 
Kumar, considering that homeopathic remedies used for proving have no molecules of the testing substance anyway, the whole thing is completely in the prover's imagination all the time. They are not only fooling themselves, they are fooling the gullible twits like yourself who believe them.
 
It is really strange, to quote something, which says homeopathy does produce negative effects, and simultaneously try to argue that it doesn't work.

We are saying homeopathy works, and in a few cases, may produce undesirable effects. But, most of the times, these 'negative' effects can be easily reversed, which is not that easy, in the modern medicine.

Either, you stick to your concept of homeopathy is just water, and hence can do neither good nor bad, and stop highlighting the few articles/posts which talk about the negative effects of homeopathy,

or

accept that homeopathy works, and start publicising its negative effects.

You can't do the both, simultaneously. What sort of logic it is? May be some of the pundits out there, can tell what is the correct word for this double talk?

Murthy
 
Gavinimurthy said:
It is really strange, to quote something, which says homeopathy does produce negative effects, and simultaneously try to argue that it doesn't work.

We are saying homeopathy works, and in a few cases, may produce undesirable effects. But, most of the times, these 'negative' effects can be easily reversed, which is not that easy, in the modern medicine.

Either, you stick to your concept of homeopathy is just water, and hence can do neither good nor bad, and stop highlighting the few articles/posts which talk about the negative effects of homeopathy,

or

accept that homeopathy works, and start publicising its negative effects.

You can't do the both, simultaneously. What sort of logic it is? May be some of the pundits out there, can tell what is the correct word for this double talk?

Murthy

Rejecting homeopathy does not mean that you have to argue that homeopathy has no effect. The arguments I have read here seem to suggest:

1) Properly constructed homeopathic products of the standard dilutions contain no molecules of the active ingredient. This is basic science and agreed by almost everyone.

2) Any effect that is recorded as a result of taking one of these products is therefore either:

2A) a reaction to the carrier (water or sugar pill or whatever).

2B) a placebo effect.

2C) a simple mistake.

2D) a reaction to an impurity in the product (i.e. it wasn't constructed properly).

2E) related to some homeopathic property of the solution.

Effect 2E) seems to be rejected by most posters here due to lack of scientific evidence.

This post is simply my opinion and I may have missed an effect, I may have used the incorrect terminology as well.
 
gtc said:
Rejecting homeopathy does not mean that you have to argue that homeopathy has no effect. The arguments I have read here seem to suggest:

1) Properly constructed homeopathic products of the standard dilutions contain no molecules of the active ingredient. This is basic science and agreed by almost everyone.

2) Any effect that is recorded as a result of taking one of these products is therefore either:

2A) a reaction to the carrier (water or sugar pill or whatever).

2B) a placebo effect.

2C) a simple mistake.

2D) a reaction to an impurity in the product (i.e. it wasn't constructed properly).

2E) related to some homeopathic property of the solution.

Effect 2E) seems to be rejected by most posters here due to lack of scientific evidence.

This post is simply my opinion and I may have missed an effect, I may have used the incorrect terminology as well.
You forgot another reason for there being an effect: It was recorded as an effect of the remedy BY MISTAKE.

For example, the prover has eaten or drunk something clearly likely to affect them while taking a remedy, or becomes ill, or has an allergic reaction to something, or some other external factor, all completely unrelated to the whole proving exercise. However they then mistakenly attribute the symptoms of their illness or allergy or whatever to the remedy they are trying to prove.

For example, a prover starts proving a remedy, and later in the day steps clumsily to avoid the cat, trips over the doormat, bumps their arm on the door frame, and gets a big painful bruise. This incident is then noted in the proving notes, and thus this remedy is forever after noted as causing "unsteadiness on the feet, bruising, pains in the arm". What is not mentioned are the added issues of "klutziness", "cat", and "door mat", but that is incidental, it seems.
 
Sorry, I meant for the case were an effect was wrongly attributed to the homepathic remedy to be covered by 2C).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom