Bad Effects of Allopathic Medicines?

This is another seminar in which this Ph.D scholar presented his paper on alternative medicine. Ph.D Scholar Mohsin is presenting shield of excellence to Dr. MAS (on left)

drmasshield4ee.jpg


(picture was taken from WHCC cd)

Now come with your professor, what is his contribution in the field of alternative therapies. What he has done? Where trial was conducted? How did he find the same kind of person having same disease? What are the addressess of those person who were under gone trial?
 
Qureshi1_78 said:
People invite this Scholar in alternative therapies to deliver lectures. In this picture, Dr. MAS is delivering lecture on "alternative therapies" in which he has done Ph.D.

drmaslecture7xa.jpg


We have provided lot of proof with pictures but your professor Ernst never came with evidenses. Who were the persons on which the trial was coducted as said by Homeo Man.
Have you ever seen a serious scientific journal? They tend not to be illustrated with the authors' holiday snaps.

As for "who were the persons on which the trial was conducted," proper doctors are concerned with something called patient confidentiality. It was immediately obvious from the opening post in this thread that Homeo Man is not remotely bothered by issues of confidentiality, and neither, apparently, are you.
 
Qureshi1_78 said:
Now come with your professor, what is his contribution in the field of alternative therapies. What he has done? Where trial was conducted? How did he find the same kind of person having same disease? What are the addressess of those person who were under gone trial?
If you read the actual paper, rather than just the abstract, you will find that, like other properly published peer reviewed studies, it describes the methodology used, so that others can repeat the findings. This is crucially important in that it's how science works. Nullius in verba, and all that...
 
Qureshi1_78 said:
Now come with your professor, what is his contribution in the field of alternative therapies. What he has done?
My dad's bigger than your dad.
Where trial was conducted? How did he find the same kind of person having same disease? What are the addressess of those person who were under gone trial?
wtf? Addresses of people who take part in a trial??

Qureshi, this is all very well, pictures are lovely, etc., but I have to tell you that this is not the kind of thing that's going to convince people here of anything. At all.

The basic thing here is, that if homeopathy works, we must be able to see it working. In your clinic, you presumably believe you see that every day, but, just as with any other treatment, that's not quite good enough evidence - because there's a lack of objectivity, and because without controls improvement could be due to lots of different things.

So, that's what controlled trials are for. They're just about watching the effect of something, in this case a homeopathic treatment, and making sure that other things aren't confusing the issue.

So that's pretty much all people are asking for. Do you know of any controlled trials in homeopathy that are sufficiently well-done that we could consider them? Or did you want to do one yourself to win the million dollars offered on this site? Or maybe you could talk us through how you think homeopathy works?
 
It's easy to see that Qureshi can't even use a simple Internet search engine. Or he would have found out by now that Edzard Ernst is Professor of Complementary Medicine at Exeter University, and that his research these days is done through the Peninsula Medical School. He is German by birth, and grew up in a family where homoeopathy was routinely used. After qualifying as a doctor he did a residency in a homoeopathic hospital and qualified as a homoeopath. He decided to make his career in the scientific study of the claims of alternative medicine, which is how he came to be in Exeter.

There are biographies of him accessible on the Internet (including a good one in the BMJ if they haven't put it on subscription-only now), and I have heard him speak on the radio on several occasions. He's by no means against alternative medicine, but what he wants to do is sort the wheat from the chaff, require the same proof of efficacy and safety as regular medicine, and basically give people information about what actually works and what doesn't. So far, he's never managed to show any effect of homoeopathy, including individualised treatment carried out by trained homoeopaths.

Here is the BMJ article I mentioned. Googling for his name gives about 12,000 hits, many of which are highly informative.

Rolfe.
 
Mojo said:
As for "who were the persons on which the trial was conducted," proper doctors are concerned with something called patient confidentiality.

When you don't find the answers then you take issue of confidentiality?

When the trial was conducted, whether your trial persons know that they are under trial?

If yes, then they have no problem of confidentiality?

When you conduct such trial then you must provide the provers data as Homeopaths have mentioned in Allen key notes proving data otherwise the data is fraud.
 
Qureshi1_78 said:
When the trial was conducted, whether your trial persons know that they are under trial?

If yes, then they have no problem of confidentiality?
Non sequitur. Being willing to participate in a medical trial does not mean being willing to have your ID and medical histiry revealed to all.
 
Donks said:
Non sequitur. Being willing to participate in a medical trial does not mean being willing to have your ID and medical histiry revealed to all.

If you apply a formula on homeo man then why the same principle is not applicable on you? why are you demanding from homeo man to disclose everything of that poor woman who came to him for getting treatment when all other allopaths put her on beggers streat. Why are you demanding their names?
 
Qureshi1_78 said:

Now come with your professor, what is his contribution in the field of alternative therapies. What he has done? Where trial was conducted? How did he find the same kind of person having same disease? What are the addressess of those person who were under gone trial?

Here's my professor. He has much knowledge of drugs and this is a picture of him meeting with the President of the United States who gave him a commendation for this. You can see a gold medal which he carries on his belt. You can visit his website and purchase many CD's and DVD's and learn more of his great knowledge.

elvis-nixon.jpg
 
Kumarclone#3 said:
If you apply a formula on homeo man then why the same principle is not applicable on you? why are you demanding from homeo man to disclose everything of that poor woman who came to him for getting treatment when all other allopaths put her on beggers streat. Why are you demanding their names?
Where did I demand her name?
 
To the topic subject;

Bad Effects of Allopathic Medicines?

Will it not be better/productive to discuss, whether Bad Effects are of Allopathic Medicines OR Bad Effects are from wrong prescription of any healing substance?
 
Qureshi1_78 said:
If you apply a formula on homeo man then why the same principle is not applicable on you? why are you demanding from homeo man to disclose everything of that poor woman who came to him for getting treatment when all other allopaths put her on beggers streat. Why are you demanding their names?
How about a proper medical history and workup, hmmm??? Not too much to ask, surely.

By the way, invariably all individual people who get their cases written up in reputable medical journals are kept anonymous anyway (you understand "anonymous", I take it?). So what is this silly business about people wanting her name?
 
Wow.

I was not coming here , that frequently.

I congratulate my Pakistani brothers and people like Kumar, Barb, and other well meaning friends, for taking the fight seriously.

The number of live threads related to homeopathy, and the general gist of discussion, and the matching of word to word with sceptics, (which I failed to do) ,was amazing, and may it all contribute to the 'understanding of homeopathy' by a large number of curious onlookers, if these so called diehard skeptics can't make head and tail out of it, however best we may try.

May your tribe increase.

Murthy
 
Gavinimurthy said:
Wow.

I was not coming here , that frequently.

I congratulate my Pakistani brothers and people like Kumar, Barb, and other well meaning friends, for taking the fight seriously.

The number of live threads related to homeopathy, and the general gist of discussion, and the matching of word to word with sceptics, (which I failed to do) ,was amazing, and may it all contribute to the 'understanding of homeopathy' by a large number of curious onlookers, if these so called diehard skeptics can't make head and tail out of it, however best we may try.

May your tribe increase.

Murthy
Welcome back.
You think Kumar and the Pakistani homeopaths are doing ok? :D

Edited because I was informed a word I used is racist in England. Them Brits and their slang.
 
Gavinimurthy said:
Wow.

I was not coming here , that frequently.

I congratulate my Pakistani brothers and people like Kumar, Barb, and other well meaning friends, for taking the fight seriously.

The number of live threads related to homeopathy, and the general gist of discussion, and the matching of word to word with sceptics, (which I failed to do) ,was amazing, and may it all contribute to the 'understanding of homeopathy' by a large number of curious onlookers, if these so called diehard skeptics can't make head and tail out of it, however best we may try.
Welcome back, Murthy.

Yes, there are a lot of live threads relating to homeopathy, and the MAS collective have made a lot of posts. Have you read them? The number of posts is not the only indication of how well an argument has been put across; the content is also important.

And this is where the MAS collective, in particular, have been falling down. Despite having arrived on the forum promising to explain homeopathy, the only real attempt MAS has made is in his opening post in the "How homeopathy does work? - 4 Years of DHMS course" thread, when he posted some historical information which many, if not all, of the people discussing homeopathy on the forum already knew, and in an extremely patronising tone (compare it with this opening post of his on the NCH board, with substantially the same content, but, for example, starting "dear students" instead of "dear children"). This hardly indicates a constructive attitude. Apart from this all we've had from them is evasions, distractions and diversions.
 
Gavinimurthy said:
Wow.

I was not coming here , that frequently.

I congratulate my Pakistani brothers and people like Kumar, Barb, and other well meaning friends, for taking the fight seriously.

The number of live threads related to homeopathy, and the general gist of discussion, and the matching of word to word with sceptics, (which I failed to do) ,was amazing, and may it all contribute to the 'understanding of homeopathy' by a large number of curious onlookers, if these so called diehard skeptics can't make head and tail out of it, however best we may try.

May your tribe increase.

Murthy
How anyone could understand something about homeopathy from the incoherent babbling of the asian dumb foundation that's been posting here recently it's a mistery to me. Did you actually read the content of the posts, or just counted them?
 
Perpetual Notion said:
Here's my professor. He has much knowledge of drugs and this is a picture of him meeting with the President of the United States who gave him a commendation for this. You can see a gold medal which he carries on his belt. You can visit his website and purchase many CD's and DVD's and learn more of his great knowledge.

elvis-nixon.jpg
Ahh! So "I'm all shook up" was a song about succussion.

I thank you.
 
Hi Hans

Thanks for improving my vocabulary.:)

You are one of the sensible lot. I wish everybody is as polite as you are despite difference of opinions.

Murthy
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom