Bad Effects of Allopathic Medicines?

Gavinimurthy said:
*snip*
Either, you stick to your concept of homeopathy is just water, and hence can do neither good nor bad, and stop highlighting the few articles/posts which talk about the negative effects of homeopathy,

or

accept that homeopathy works, and start publicising its negative effects.

You can't do the both, simultaneously. What sort of logic it is? May be some of the pundits out there, can tell what is the correct word for this double talk?

Murthy
Double talk is an excellent term. However, it is the double-talk of homeopaths, and this is what we are pointing out.

As you rightly note, we consider homeopathic remedies to be without any effect whatsoever, but homeopaths claim that they do have an effect and here the double-talk comes in:

You talk endlessly about the side-effects of "allopathy" and claim that homeopathy has none. Yet, you talk about aggravations and proving effects, and when we suggest proving tests, you are suddenly deeply worried about the implications for the poor test subjects.

So when we point out the problem of homeopathic side-effects, we are using the (well accepted) debating method called reducto ad absurdum, that is, we take your position and show its inconsistencies.

So, in short: Yes, the position is inconsistent, but it is your position.

Hans
 
gtc said:
Rejecting homeopathy does not mean that you have to argue that homeopathy has no effect. The arguments I have read here seem to suggest:

1) Properly constructed homeopathic products of the standard dilutions contain no molecules of the active ingredient. This is basic science and agreed by almost everyone.

2) Any effect that is recorded as a result of taking one of these products is therefore either:

2A) a reaction to the carrier (water or sugar pill or whatever).

2B) a placebo effect.

2C) a simple mistake.

2D) a reaction to an impurity in the product (i.e. it wasn't constructed properly).

2E) related to some homeopathic property of the solution.

Effect 2E) seems to be rejected by most posters here due to lack of scientific evidence.

This post is simply my opinion and I may have missed an effect, I may have used the incorrect terminology as well.

gtc, good estimation. However some more aspects are to be considered. By Mistake of taking wrong remedy/substance can't be counted here as it is unusual human mistake & can happen in any of our activity but not counted. Other aspects are:-

1A) Lower potencies & triturations contain molecules of active ingredient.

Modification:

2A) a reaction to the carrier-modified/changed structurally or diluted/triturated (water, alcohol, lactose or sugar pill)

2B) a placebo or a self healing effect.

Effect 2E) seems to be rejected by most posters here due to lack of scientific evidence but practical observations & experiances in homeopathic communitiy AND many positive but scoentific tests, studies & evidances EXISTS but not yet made conclusive.

I hope above changes makes perfect sense. You may therefore re-post after making necessary coreections & modification.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Double talk is an excellent term. However, it is the double-talk of homeopaths, and this is what we are pointing out.

As you rightly note, we consider homeopathic remedies to be without any effect whatsoever, but homeopaths claim that they do have an effect and here the double-talk comes in:

You talk endlessly about the side-effects of "allopathy" and claim that homeopathy has none. Yet, you talk about aggravations and proving effects, and when we suggest proving tests, you are suddenly deeply worried about the implications for the poor test subjects.

So when we point out the problem of homeopathic side-effects, we are using the (well accepted) debating method called reducto ad absurdum, that is, we take your position and show its inconsistencies.

So, in short: Yes, the position is inconsistent, but it is your position.

Hans

No one can deny effects+ side effects from any substance--homeopathic or otherwise. But whether those are adverse & toxic to human being or interfere, the human's natural/routine activities substancially, are only countable for control, ban, restrictions or regulations. Otherwise, we may have to think of controling everything--food, water or otherthings. Proving effects, aggravations or effects of remedies are one kind of effects+ side effects, but whether these are adverse or toxic, is to be assessed/measured/considered or thought.

Howecer, To avoid adverse & toxic effects AND to minimise side effects & maximise real effects is the essence & beauty of homeopathy.
 
Kumar,

You have misunderstood my post. I apologise for not being clearer.

A positive or negative 'reaction' that is wrongly attributed to the homeopathic treatment but is really unrelated is a possible reason for noting a reaction.

Likewise a reaction may be due to a fault in the product is also a possibility.

I understand that these things are human nature and not related to homeopathy in particular, I just wished to list them to here as possible reasons for noting a reaction.

If you note a reaction to a homeopathic solution you have to consider that it must (if my list is exhaustive) have been caused by one of the five reasons I list.

In any scientific test, whether it is a test of a homepathic or non-homeopathic product, you have to element all other possibilities before you can conclude that your product was responsible for the effect noted.

It goes without saying that you also have to consider whether the effect was positive or negative.
 
Kumar said:
Howecer, To avoid adverse & toxic effects AND to minimise side effects & maximise real effects is the essence & beauty of homeopathy.
So... some effects that by your own admission can be confused with the placebo effect... that's "maximized"? An effect so small it can't be measured?
 
Kumar said:
Howecer, To avoid adverse & toxic effects AND to minimise side effects & maximise real effects is the essence & beauty of homeopathy.
This is precisely how therapeutic doses of drugs are arrived at: the dose is calculated so as to be small enough to minimise harmful effects as far as possible, while still providing enough of the drug to have the desired effect. This has nothing to do with homeopathy, because homeopathy has no effects at all, adverse or otherwise.
 
gtc, no, I didn't mis-understood anything in your post but I tried to make list as exhaustive/complete/perfect. So just read again & make it perfect

Donks,

Placebo/self healing/initiated effects can be there with any healing substance and can also be confused. We should study these effects very deeply & throughly to avoid unnecessary medications with adversities.

Mojo,

Your/s system & views are not "absolute". Many positives in science, practicalities in observations and experiances about homeopathy are documented & found. Whether these are not yet made conclusive due to some bias or otherwise by science--is a pending aspect not a conclusion.

AS such, Till you are "absolute" in your system or elsewhere, nothing can also be taken as "conclusive" in that also.

Pls tell/show me your "ABSOLUTES" SO "CONCLUSIONS"?:p
 
Kumar said:
*snip*
Your/s system & views are not "absolute". Many positives in science, practicalities in observations and experiances about homeopathy are documented & found. Whether these are not yet made conclusive due to some bias or otherwise by science--is a pending aspect not a conclusion.

AS such, Till you are "absolute" in your system or elsewhere, nothing can also be taken as "conclusive" in that also.

Pls tell/show me your "ABSOLUTES" SO "CONCLUSIONS"?:p
Let us lay down this nonsense once and for all.

Kumar, your definition of "Absolute", correct me if I'm wrong, is "observed in mass for a long time".

Under that definition, the scientific system is absolute.

Even if we use the more cautious definition "Certain beyond reasonable doubt", science is full of absolutes.

It is only using the, in itself absolute, definition "Beyond all doubt" that we must say that nothing, including contemporary science, is absolute. But that "nothing" would certainly also include homeopathy and any other beliefs you happen to entertain.

And to say that we cannot reach a conclusion unless we have absolute knowledge is ridiculous. And, it totally disrupts all of your own arguments.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
Your/s system & views are not "absolute". Many positives in science, practicalities in observations and experiances about homeopathy are documented & found. Whether these are not yet made conclusive due to some bias or otherwise by science--is a pending aspect not a conclusion.

AS such, Till you are "absolute" in your system or elsewhere, nothing can also be taken as "conclusive" in that also.

Pls tell/show me your "ABSOLUTES" SO "CONCLUSIONS"?:p
If the alleged positive observations about homeopathy are still "pending" after 200 years, it is reasonable to draw a conclusion from this and move on.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Let us lay down this nonsense once and for all.

Kumar, your definition of "Absolute", correct me if I'm wrong, is "observed in mass for a long time".

Under that definition, the scientific system is absolute.

Even if we use the more cautious definition "Certain beyond reasonable doubt", science is full of absolutes.

It is only using the, in itself absolute, definition "Beyond all doubt" that we must say that nothing, including contemporary science, is absolute. But that "nothing" would certainly also include homeopathy and any other beliefs you happen to entertain.

And to say that we cannot reach a conclusion unless we have absolute knowledge is ridiculous. And, it totally disrupts all of your own arguments.

Hans

Absolute: free from imperfection

Anyway, I may had tried to some nearby situtions.
 
Kumar said:
Absolute: free from imperfection

Anyway, I may had tried to some nearby situtions.
That is the absolute definition, yes, but you are not using that yourself. You are claiming your "mass ..etc." things to be absolute, which they evidently are not, since it is easy to point out imperfections.

So, essentially, nothing is absolute, so obviously we have to work with less.

Hans
 
Gavinimurthy said:
Either, you stick to your concept of homeopathy is just water, and hence can do neither good nor bad, and stop highlighting the few articles/posts which talk about the negative effects of homeopathy,....
This has been said before, but I just feel like saying it again.

Murthy, the double-think is yours.

You claim that anything good that happens after a homoeopathic remedy is taken, is caused by the remedy. However, you then try to minimise and down-play all the bad things which also happen after taking a homoeopathic remedy. Frequently, we find people like Kumar saying thinks like "homoeopathy has no side-effects", or "homoeopathy has least adversities".

We are merely trying to point out that if you want to take the credit for the good things that happen, you also have to acknowledge that bad things happen, and accept the blame. Although there are no official statistics, we read many reports in your own forums of aggravations and unpleasant proving effects and so on. The only actual publication we can find on the subject estimates the incidence of these at almost 40%.

Yes, indeed, we are very happy to acknowledge that these things are all nothing but coincidence, and that the homoeopathic remedy has not caused any harm at all. But only when you also acknowledge that the good effects are also nothing but coincidence and homoeopathic remedies have not caused any benefit at all.

If you want to claim the coincidental benefit, you have to accept the responsibility for the coincidental harm also, and stop claiming that homoeopathy has no side-effects.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
Murthy, the double-think is yours.

You claim that anything good that happens after a homoeopathic remedy is taken, is caused by the remedy. However, you then try to minimise and down-play all the bad things which also happen after taking a homoeopathic remedy.
Often, it's not even a question of downplaying negative results. If a patients symptoms get worse after being given a remedy, that that is characterised as an "aggravation" or whatever, and it is claimed that it means that the remedy is working.

How homeopathy works:

1) A remedy is administered.

2) If the patient subsequently gets better, homeopaths claim that this means that the remedy worked.

3) If the patient subsequently gets worse, they claim that, er, this means that the remedy worked. :rolleyes:
 
gtc said:
Sorry, I meant for the case were an effect was wrongly attributed to the homepathic remedy to be covered by 2C).
My mistake too! I didn't read it as such, when it was clearly there in your post!

But at least, between us, we have clearly outlined the issues for the more dense among us... ;)
 
Do we have any idea on who this woman is yet or anything else about this case for that matter? Have the ethical questions behind revealing her case and taking her picture without permission been answered yet?
 
Kumar said:
Donks,

Placebo/self healing/initiated effects can be there with any healing substance and can also be confused.
You don't actually know what a placebo is, do you? Or the placebo effect? Do you think it's some miraculous effect that heals people?
We should study these effects very deeply & throughly to avoid unnecessary medications with adversities.
Effects of medications are carefully studied, in DBPC studies.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Let us lay down this nonsense once and for all.

Sorry, it may not be possible till we aceept all in absolute or all incolcusive/non-absolute--modern or old systems.

Kumar, your definition of "Absolute", correct me if I'm wrong, is "observed in mass for a long time".

Under that definition, the scientific system is absolute.


I mentioned some nearby aspects alike persistant, time tested, continuing etc not absolute. However if you endorss your above consideration for absolute then homeopathy is also "observed in mass for a long time"--so absolute. It it not so:D

Even if we use the more cautious definition "Certain beyond reasonable doubt", science is full of absolutes.

It is only using the, in itself absolute, definition "Beyond all doubt" that we must say that nothing, including contemporary science, is absolute. But that "nothing" would certainly also include homeopathy and any other beliefs you happen to entertain.

And to say that we cannot reach a conclusion unless we have absolute knowledge is ridiculous. And, it totally disrupts all of your own arguments.


All these can still be considered as "inconclusive" not perfect. Many studies, tests & observations about homeopathy, if are not made conclusive--hold somewhat similar weightage.;)
 
Kumar said:
Kumar, your definition of "Absolute", correct me if I'm wrong, is "observed in mass for a long time".

Under that definition, the scientific system is absolute.


I mentioned some nearby aspects alike persistant, time tested, continuing etc not absolute. However if you endorss your above consideration for absolute then homeopathy is also "observed in mass for a long time"--so absolute. It it not so:D

Exactly, Kumar. So, according to your definition of "absolute", we have two mutually exclusve, absolute systems. In other words, your defintion does not work.

All these can still be considered as "inconclusive" not perfect. Many studies, tests & observations about homeopathy, if are not made conclusive--hold somewhat similar weightage.;)

No they do not. They are not verified by proper methods, and they are not backed by scientific observation. They are a bunch of anecdotes, at best.

Hans
 
Donks said:
You don't actually know what a placebo is, do you? Or the placebo effect? Do you think it's some miraculous effect that heals people?
I think we have been round this loop MANY times before, so you can probably take it as given that Kumar does not know what a placebo actually is.

FYI, previously he has given the strongest impression he feels it is some tangible substance you can actually isolate and put in a bottle! ;)
 
Zep said:
I think we have been round this loop MANY times before, so you can probably take it as given that Kumar does not know what a placebo actually is.

FYI, previously he has given the strongest impression he feels it is some tangible substance you can actually isolate and put in a bottle! ;)
Well, with Kumar it's hard to find new ground to cover. For every brick in that particular wall, there's somebody who smashed his/her head against it. And got nothing but a headache.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom