MRC_Hans
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2002
- Messages
- 24,967
Double talk is an excellent term. However, it is the double-talk of homeopaths, and this is what we are pointing out.Gavinimurthy said:*snip*
Either, you stick to your concept of homeopathy is just water, and hence can do neither good nor bad, and stop highlighting the few articles/posts which talk about the negative effects of homeopathy,
or
accept that homeopathy works, and start publicising its negative effects.
You can't do the both, simultaneously. What sort of logic it is? May be some of the pundits out there, can tell what is the correct word for this double talk?
Murthy
As you rightly note, we consider homeopathic remedies to be without any effect whatsoever, but homeopaths claim that they do have an effect and here the double-talk comes in:
You talk endlessly about the side-effects of "allopathy" and claim that homeopathy has none. Yet, you talk about aggravations and proving effects, and when we suggest proving tests, you are suddenly deeply worried about the implications for the poor test subjects.
So when we point out the problem of homeopathic side-effects, we are using the (well accepted) debating method called reducto ad absurdum, that is, we take your position and show its inconsistencies.
So, in short: Yes, the position is inconsistent, but it is your position.
Hans