autism-vaccine link?

I'd personally prefer pharmaceutical companies to play a large role in vaccine recommendations as they have the information and personnel required to make vital decisions about them.


I feel you are far too trusting of pharmaceutical companies. Pharmaceutical companies are businesses and must make a profit. And the bigger the profit the better, otherwise their investors will vote with their feet. I am not saying anything about pharmaceutical companies here that I wouldn't also say for any other business.
They clearly cannot both make and sell the vaccines AND determine their use. The separation between the two must be real and transparent.

They tend to want to make sure their stuff works right considering the money that goes into making, testing, and distributing them, and that includes to their own children.


But a big reason why they do is to ensure that their vaccines get onto the schedule. If you take that incentive away from them by letting them determine the use of their own vaccines, we will all pay for the consequences sooner or later. I'm not talking about deliberate harm here, but you know how money speaks.

We're lucky that any even want to be involved with vaccines anymore at all considering all the headaches it brings.


They probably would not, except for the fact that the government has protected them from litigation by way of the vaccine injury compensation scheme. This was necessary in order to keep the vaccines research running.
 
Last edited:
Where did I say you said that?
I thought you'd be interested because of our previous debate about pneumovax.;)

Mind you, as BJ said, my attempt at irony failed because the JCVI will undoubtedly, as he says, now recommend yearly boosters!:rolleyes:

Sorry Deetee, my misunderstanding of your previous post.

I think the bias is in the direction the question of vaccination is viewed.

I get the impression medical professionals, in general, want to recommend a particular vaccination, and look for a good reason why they should not. I tend to view the question the other way round.
 
Down here medical professionals tend to get pretty defensive at the mention of pharmaceutrical company influence. ABC radio did a piece some weeks back about how pharmaceutical company sponsors get to choose the speakers at medical professionals' CME (continuing medical education) activities. You get the impression form listening to the medical professionals who attend these functions that it is not possible for them to be influenced. I suppose the pharmaceutical company does all this out of the knidness of their hearts. :rolleyes:

In the above example, certain specialists who had been speakers at the CME events later felt it necessary to defend themselves, saying that they did not even know that the pharmaceutical company put their name forward. Which is sort of beside the point. Others had actually been tutored by the pharmaceutical company on how to present their talk!
But, yes, it is a matter of degree.

It's pretty clear that simply believing you cannot be influenced is wrong (I suppose you could insist on references, but please dont. I have a lot of work I'm supposed to do today. :)), regardless of what some physicians will say if put into a position where they become defensive. And your point about "the kindness of their hearts" is spot-on. Pharmaceutical companies are the experts when it comes to influence, so if you want to know what works and what doesn't, just follow their lead.

Are there really no acceptable answers?

Of course there are acceptable answers. I meant that there are no acceptable answers if your position is similar to the positions that have been taken by those participating in this thread.

What about some fairly strictly enforced quidelines/restrictions by the covering professional organisations? Might this not provide provide some useful answers to the problem of pharmaceutical company influence?
And I'm still wondering why it is not possible to keep pharmaceutical companies at arms length. Instead of pharmaceutical companies paying directly, the money could be put into a pool (raised as a levy?) and distributed by an independant committee for whatever they determine is the best use of resources.

What do you think of these guidelines?

http://ipcme.med.ubc.ca/Asset111.aspx

Linda
 
I'd personally prefer pharmaceutical companies to play a large role in vaccine recommendations as they have the information and personnel required to make vital decisions about them.

No. No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

We already know that despite our best intentions (and pharmaceutical companies do not always have the best intentions, either), we cannot help but be biased by all sorts of influences (subtle or otherwise). Our best defense is to maintain a system where where we take steps to ensure independence.

They tend to want to make sure their stuff works right considering the money that goes into making, testing, and distributing them, and that includes to their own children.

That's true, but it doesn't prevent those people in the field from being influenced by confirmation and attribution bias.

We're lucky that any even want to be involved with vaccines anymore at all considering all the headaches it brings. They have rules they have to follow, unlike the quacks that go on and on about miraculous food supplements.

The freakish double standards and hypocrisy reserved for people who actually have to know how their stuff works is insane compared to the leeway quacks have. It really boggles the mind.

Exactly. If we start with the knowledge that these people are just like us, it becomes obvious that something is going on that is different from an information gap, or even a committment to the usefulness of the scientific method. I think Beth's idea about credibility and trust is a good part of it.

Linda
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Of course there are acceptable answers. I meant that there are no acceptable answers if your position is similar to the positions that have been taken by those participating in this thread.

<snip>

Wow! A mind reader too! Is there no end to your talents?

:)
 
Ivor the Engineer said:
<snip>

Of course there are acceptable answers. I meant that there are no acceptable answers if your position is similar to the positions that have been taken by those participating in this thread.

<snip>

Wow! A mind reader too! Is there no end to your talents?

:)

I would prefer to believe you and would love to be proven wrong on this point. I'm trying not to let wishful thinking influence my opinion, though.

Linda
 
I just find it hilarious that vaccine makers are so distrusted with our health in spite their vast knowledge base, but supplement makers with no knowledge base have no laws at all and are more trusted by laypersons. What makes supplement sellers so trustworthy?

I'd trust the person who has all those laws to abide by compared to supplement makers, but most of the population seems to be of the opposite opinion. So, keep letting hucksters tell you their products will build up your immune system without having to prove or demonstrate reasons for it, and keep distrusting the vaccine makers even though they have to prove their products deliver the protection for actual reasons that can be demonstrated.


I'm just more trusting of the staff in pharmaceutical companies than the hucksters selling us flaky alternatives who tell us not to trust pharmaceutical companies.
 
I just find it hilarious that vaccine makers are so distrusted with our health in spite their vast knowledge base, but supplement makers with no knowledge base have no laws at all and are more trusted by laypersons. What makes supplement sellers so trustworthy?

That's the key question right there. However, I don't think hilarity is an appropriate response, unless you think you are somehow immune to the same flaws in thinking that lead to that result (hint: you're not).

I'd trust the person who has all those laws to abide by compared to supplement makers, but most of the population seems to be of the opposite opinion. So, keep letting hucksters tell you their products will build up your immune system without having to prove or demonstrate reasons for it, and keep distrusting the vaccine makers even though they have to prove their products deliver the protection for actual reasons that can be demonstrated.

I'm just more trusting of the staff in pharmaceutical companies than the hucksters selling us flaky alternatives who tell us not to trust pharmaceutical companies.

I think regulations help, but I think motivation is key. And maybe it's the same thing, as fulfilling regulations is a form of directed motivation. I think that we place our trust where we perceive congruence in what motivates us. Supplement makers have done a very good job of hiding their real motivations and presenting a false picture that corresponds to those of their target audience.

Linda
 
Huh? What was easy?

Linda

A direct answer to a direct question. :)

What I'm finding difficult to understand is what expertise medical professionals have that professionals from other fields do not, which makes them the most (only?) suitable experts to decide which vaccinations to recommend.

Surely by the time the evidence is being considered, it should be in a format which most people with sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method should be able to make reasonable decisions from?

I'm also a bit puzzled by the presence of the lay member(s) on most of the panels. If they haven't got sufficient knowledge to make reasonable decisions from (or even understand) the evidence (an accusation SG likes to hurl at me every so often:)), surely all they do is add noise to the decision making process?
 
Surely by the time the evidence is being considered, it should be in a format which most people with sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method should be able to make reasonable decisions from?


You say that like it is not such a difficult thing to have sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method. Of course, it depends on what you mean by "sufficient". How would you determine that a person has "sufficient" knowledge to make these decisions. And do not some individuals have much greater knowedge and background than others and would they therefore have a greater chance of making correct decisions.
I have a layman's knowledge of quantum physics, but I'm not going to presume that the importance of my view of the copenhagen interpretation is within a bull's roar of that of an actual physicist.

I'm also a bit puzzled by the presence of the lay member(s) on most of the panels. If they haven't got sufficient knowledge to make reasonable decisions from (or even understand) the evidence (an accusation SG likes to hurl at me every so often:)), surely all they do is add noise to the decision making process?


That's what I'd like to know. I think it is just being "politically correct". Patient representatives demand it and, if they are loud enough politically, they get it.
 
Last edited:
You say that like it is not such a difficult thing to have sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method.

I don't think it is. There are plenty of experts in various scientific disciplines who use statistics, often at a much more advanced level than medical professionals.

Of course, it depends on what you mean by "sufficient". How would you determine that a person has "sufficient" knowledge to make these decisions.

Do you think you have sufficient knowledge to give informed consent for a medical procedure?

And do not some individuals have much greater knowedge and background than others and would they therefore have a greater chance of making correct decisions.

Do you think there is a threshold in knowledge and experience beyond which most people could be considered capable of making correct decisions?

I have a layman's knowledge of quantum physics, but I'm not going to presume that the importance of my view of the copenhagen interpretation is within a bull's roar of that of an actual physicist.

How is that similar to the level at which the evidence is reviewed at meetings held by say the JVIC or ACIP?
 
What do you think of these guidelines?
http://ipcme.med.ubc.ca/Asset111.aspx


As "guidelines" they sound fine, but I wonder how closely even the authors of the guidelines, let alone the others for whom they are intended and who had no input and who may not even have actually read them, actually practice what they preach, as opposed to having them sitting there as an ideal to but which they will find plenty of reasons and justifications to let slide in their everyday working lives.

In other words, do the guidelines have any teeth?
Are there any penalties for professionals who do not conform?
Is anyone even looking to see that the profession does conform?

Even then, there is the question of hidden or unrecognised influence. Physicians who deny that they are susceptible to influence are possibly just not recognising the fact that they are being influenced. In fact, I think it would be true to say that "hidden influence" is what the pharmaceutical companies would strive for as being the most effective by the very fact of it being hidden and hence denied by the very physicians they are influencing.


 
And I am still wondering why educational activities for medical professionals cannot be organised free of any sponsorship or involvement by the pharmaceutical industry. Maybe there won't be a free meal but...
 
I don't think it is. There are plenty of experts in various scientific disciplines who use statistics, often at a much more advanced level than medical professionals.


Well I was actually referring to "experts in the scientific method and statistics" are opposed to those who have a "layperson's understanding". I would agree that probably most medical professionals do not fit the bill and many would have no better than a layperson's understanding of the scientific method and statistics. They are hopefully not the medical professionals making the decisions about vaccines.

Do you think you have sufficient knowledge to give informed consent for a medical procedure?


It depends on the medical procedure.
And it depends on the person giving the informed consent.
If a physician tells a plumber that, on the basis of his symptoms, his blood test and his exercise ECG, he should have coronary bypass surgery, is that patient really in a position to discuss that decision with him? Even if he takes a few months long service leave to read up all about coronary heart disease and coronary bypass surgery, will he be in any better position? In that case, is he ever really in a position to give informed consent?

Do you think there is a threshold in knowledge and experience beyond which most people could be considered capable of making correct decisions?


Again, it depends on the person and the thing being decided.
And, again, the greater the knowledge, experience and background that person has with the particular thing being decided, the greater the chance that that person will make the correct decision. Do you disagree?

How is that similar to the level at which the evidence is reviewed at meetings held by say the JVIC or ACIP


How is it not?
The experts have a working knowledge, the layperson - and this is an exaggeration - understands only what he has read.
 
As "guidelines" they sound fine, but I wonder how closely even the authors of the guidelines, let alone the others for whom they are intended and who had no input and who may not even have actually read them, actually practice what they preach, as opposed to having them sitting there as an ideal to but which they will find plenty of reasons and justifications to let slide in their everyday working lives.

In other words, do the guidelines have any teeth?
Are there any penalties for professionals who do not conform?
Is anyone even looking to see that the profession does conform?

There is something involving Guido and a wet noodle...

Even then, there is the question of hidden or unrecognised influence. Physicians who deny that they are susceptible to influence are possibly just not recognising the fact that they are being influenced.

Which is why changing the source of the influence makes more sense than depending upon people acting contrary to their nature.

Linda
 
And I am still wondering why educational activities for medical professionals cannot be organised free of any sponsorship or involvement by the pharmaceutical industry. Maybe there won't be a free meal but...

It's not the meals. It's the affordability of the venue and services. Conferences that aren't subsidized with advertising revenue will be more expensive and of lower calibre. Fewer people will come and the advantages to patient care that come with the educational/professional opportunities conferences offer, will be reduced. They certainly can and should be organized independent of involvement from the pharmaceutical industry. But sponsorship doesn't have to affect that and is arguably more beneficial to patient care than not.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom