BTW, here's another lesson in how to misunderstand a medical researhc abstract when you don't have a thorough understanding of a disease.
Epidemiology of varicella-zoster virus in England and Wales
Abstract
Many countries are studying currently the possibility of mass vaccination against varicella. The objective of this study was to provide a complete picture of the pre-vaccine epidemiology of the Varicella-Zoster Virus in England and Wales to aid in the design of immunisation programs. Population-based data including general practitioner sentinel surveillance, hospitalisation data, and death certificates from England and Wales were analysed. The average incidence rates for varicella and zoster between 1991 and 2000 were 1,291 and 373 per 100,000 years, respectively. Overall hospitalisation rates were equal for varicella and zoster (4.5 vs. 4.4 hospitalisation per 100,000 population) with 5 and 8%, respectively, having underlying immunosuppressive conditions. The age-specific proportion of cases hospitalised and length of stay were similar between the two diseases. However, the overall burden of disease is considerably higher for zoster. The number of inpatient days and case-fatality due to zoster are roughly 4 to 6 times greater than for varicella (11 vs. 3 days and 25 vs. 4 deaths per 100,000 case). These results provide base-line estimates should mass varicella vaccination be introduced in England and Wales.
The baseline referred to here is intended to be compared to changes over time with implementation of vaccine programs. The conclusion for this abstract is in the italicized text.
There is not a claim here that primary varicella is not as bad as zoster. If you don't understand the disease, the population affected, the expected course of disease, then you are going to grossly misunderstand what the bolded text means. I can't overemphasize this enough. Nothing here says that without natural boosting, zoster is going to hospitalize or kill more people. Nothing here says that without natural boosting zoster will be more dangerous to people with healthy immune systems. This says nothing of the kind. You cannot assess the increased risk of zoster from decreasing primary chicken pox from the bolded data. You have no denominators. And all those people with zoster also had chicken pox initially. The disease process differs between the two presentations of the infection. The average age and additional disease conditions vary between the two groups.
As a medical practitioner, I don't draw the conclusion from this that having natural virus around boosting people against zoster is better than vaccinating people. I can see why the statement is being misunderstood.
I ask the other physicians and practitioners here to give their take on that bolded text and how it is being misunderstood by Ivor. I'm at a loss for words to explain it in 25 words or less.