autism-vaccine link?

Is it working do you think? (see Ivor's link)

Yes. Which link?

Otherwise there may eventually be some nasty bureaucrats looking to do the enforcement for you.

Exactly. If our own interest isn't sufficient, the threat of that sort of extreme punishment serves as extra incentive. ;)

But, if the influence is hidden, how will the individual doctor recognise the influence in order to act on it?

Exactly. That is one of the reasons for making influence transparent and for avoiding the influence in the first place.

If there is no one looking to see if the guidelines are adhered to and enforcing them, how do you prevent, for example, what has been happening in Australia for years where doctors attending CME activities had no idea that the pharmaceutical companies sponsoring the events had an input into the choice of subjects and speakers.

Can you provide some additional details?

Well it seems they are doing the education (marketing in disguise) by default. And they are spending big bucks on it. Why not set up an independent committee and use those big bucks to do it properly.

Because it legitimizes a bad idea. And why would a pharmaceutical company agree to it?

Linda
 
What percentage of patients could be described as capable?

I'm not sure. I'd like to hear what practicing physicians think the answer to this question is.

What characteristics make patients capable?

Being able to understand the information presented to them.

In what situations could they be described as capable?

When their state of health does not interfere with their ability to reason.

What happens if the patient makes a choice and the physician/surgeon disagrees strongly enough to refuse to be a party to carrying out that choice?

If the physician presents options he/she is not willing to perform or assist with, he/she should make that clear to the patient beforehand.

In fact, in most cases, the physician or surgeon will know what the correct choice is for the particular patient and will communicate that to the patient. And quite rightly so. He would not be a responsible professional if he did not do so.

I think I would phrase that as:

"In fact, in most cases, the physician or surgeon will be very confident what the correct choice is for the particular patient..."

Of course they are. That type of medicne can be left to robots. EBM are guidelines. These guidelines have to be interpreted in the context of the individual patient with his or her individual illness and co-morbidities.

I think a robot would do a better job at polypharmacy than many humans.
 

I'm sorry, but the irony of that article (when one bothers to access the original research report) appearing on a page with that title is just too funny. I suppose I should cut them a little slack, since the mistakes were made by the Post. But surely one of the ways to overcome bias is to make sure that the 'facts' on which you base your opinion are not egregious errors?

Linda
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, but the irony of that article (when one bothers to access the original research report) appearing on a page with that title is just too funny. I suppose I should cut them a little slack, since the mistakes were made by the Post. But surely one of the ways to overcome bias is to make sure that the 'facts' on which you base your opinion are not egregious errors?

Linda

:confused:

Which "egregious" errors?

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...ez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

BACKGROUND: The prospect of improving care through increasing professionalism has been gaining momentum among physician organizations. Although there have been efforts to define and promote professionalism, few data are available on physician attitudes toward and conformance with professional norms. OBJECTIVE: To ascertain the extent to which practicing physicians agree with and act consistently with norms of professionalism. DESIGN: National survey using a stratified random sample. SETTING: Medical care in the United States. PARTICIPANTS: 3504 practicing physicians in internal medicine, family practice, pediatrics, surgery, anesthesiology, and cardiology. MEASUREMENTS: Attitudes and behaviors were assessed by using indicators for each domain of professionalism developed by the American College of Physicians and the American Board of Internal Medicine. Of the eligible sampled physicians, 1662 responded, yielding a 58% weighted response rate (adjusting for noneligible physicians). RESULTS: Ninety percent or more of the respondents agreed with specific statements about principles of fair distribution of finite resources, improving access to and quality of care, managing conflicts of interest, and professional self-regulation. Twenty-four percent disagreed that periodic recertification was desirable. Physician behavior did not always reflect the standards they endorsed. For example, although 96% of respondents agreed that physicians should report impaired or incompetent colleagues to relevant authorities, 45% of respondents who encountered such colleagues had not reported them. LIMITATIONS: Our measures of behavior did not capture all activities that may reflect on the norms in question. Furthermore, behaviors were self-reported, and the results may not be generalizable to physicians in specialties not included in the study. CONCLUSION: Physicians agreed with standards of professional behavior promulgated by professional societies. Reported behavior, however, did not always conform to those norms.

I can't access the full text, so perhaps you are referring to another result which was not in the abstract and misreported?

ETA: I think the guy who writes those opinion pieces on the overcomingbias site is a physicians' nemesis: An Economist!
 
Last edited:
A direct answer to a direct question. :)

What I'm finding difficult to understand is what expertise medical professionals have that professionals from other fields do not, which makes them the most (only?) suitable experts to decide which vaccinations to recommend.
Try medical expertise.

Surely by the time the evidence is being considered, it should be in a format which most people with sufficient knowledge of statistics and the scientific method should be able to make reasonable decisions from?
This is incredibly naive. You are saying that one only needs limited knowledge to understand extremely complex issues, that all you need is to be able to understand a single paper in front of you and all those years getting an education and all one's experience don't matter.

Your comments border between purposeful troll behavior and incredible ignorance. I don't picture you are either. But in this case.....


I'm also a bit puzzled by the presence of the lay member(s) on most of the panels. If they haven't got sufficient knowledge to make reasonable decisions from (or even understand) the evidence (an accusation SG likes to hurl at me every so often:)), surely all they do is add noise to the decision making process?
An accusation I made with examples of what you missed by having limited knowledge in a field of expertise that you for some reason are having a hard time recognizing.

What does a doctor need to know to make a medical decision, Ivor? Do you want a provider who learned their skills and profession from reading in their spare time? There are many times when a lay person's contribution to a group is extremely valuable. That doesn't make their opinion sufficient alone.
 
Last edited:
Yes.

Exactly. If our own interest isn't sufficient, the threat of that sort of extreme punishment serves as extra incentive. ;)

Exactly. That is one of the reasons for making influence transparent and for avoiding the influence in the first place.


Okay, it seems you are happy that it's working in the US - that, despite them spending those big bucks, there is no significant influence by the pharmaceutical industry at medical seminars, CME events, and visits to doctors' surgeries. I find that difficult to believe but I hope that is the case.

Can you provide some additional details?


It was a radio program, but it might be transcribed somewhere. But I'm not sure where I would find the commentary on it. If I can find it, I'll post a link if you are interested.

Because it legitimizes a bad idea. And why would a pharmaceutical company agree to it?


If they would not agree with it, and I think they would not, that would just confirm that they are having a significant return on their investment through an influence on doctors' prescribing habits with the present system.
On the other hand, if it's a levy imposed by the government, though, they would have no choice?
 
Originally Posted by BillyJoe
What percentage of patients could be described as capable?
I'm not sure. I'd like to hear what practicing physicians think the answer to this question is.


Strange, I fully expected you to say that ALL patients are capable of understanding the options and making an informed choice. If not, I think you are now agreeing with the rest of us.

What characteristics make patients capable?
Being able to understand the information presented to them.


And what percentage would that be?

In what situations could they be described as capable?
When their state of health does not interfere with their ability to reason.


What about their intellectual capacity?
What about their emotional state?
What about their medical unfamiliarlity?

If the physician presents options he/she is not willing to perform or assist with, he/she should make that clear to the patient beforehand.


I agree. But wouldn't that be perceived as unduly influencing the patient's choice? And then why shouldn't he also present to the patient what he feels is the best course of action?

I think I would phrase that as:
"In fact, in most cases, the physician or surgeon will be very confident what the correct choice is for the particular patient..."


So, shouldn't he communicate that to the patient. If so, what does that mean for undue influence and patient choice?
 
Last edited:
<snip>

This is incredibly naive. You are saying that one only needs limited knowledge to understand extremely complex issues, that all you need is to be able to understand a single paper in front of you and all those years getting an education and all one's experience don't matter.

I’m saying by the time the information gets to the people who are going to decide what to recommend, lots of very clever people have already processed it into a format so that an individual does not need to know the intricate details to make reasonable decisions.

Your comments border between purposeful troll behavior and incredible ignorance. I don't picture you are either. But in this case.....

Something I imagine you and Linda have in common, then.:)

An accusation I made with examples of what you missed by having limited knowledge in a field of expertise that you for some reason are having a hard time recognizing.

You assume I miss them. Just because I don’t post a pubmed abstract or journal link does not automatically mean I have not read it.

What does a doctor need to know to make a medical decision, Ivor?

That depends on the particular type of decision. To make accurate diagnoses: a lot. To decide on appropriate treatment for a confirmed diagnosis: a list of possible treatments and a list of exceptions.

Do you want a provider who learned their skills and profession from reading in their spare time?

I presume this is because I posted a list of (mainly medical) books I was reading. (I knew I’d regret it.:)) No, I want a provider who is interested in what they do.

There are many times when a lay person's contribution to a group is extremely valuable. That doesn't make their opinion sufficient alone.

How could their contribution be extremely valuable? I thought all the information discussed at an ACIP meeting would be over their heads? What could they know that the experts do not?

Even if a lay person did raise a point, what’s to stop the many more experts dismissing their non-expert opinion (in the nicest possible way, of course)?
 
Okay, it seems you are happy that it's working in the US - that, despite them spending those big bucks, there is no significant influence by the pharmaceutical industry at medical seminars, CME events, and visits to doctors' surgeries. I find that difficult to believe but I hope that is the case.

I misunderstood your question. I thought it was referring to the idea of professional self-regulation, rather than whether or not pharmaceutical companies have an influence on physician choices.

Well, look at what we're concerned about. We're not talking about conflict-of-interest, as the direction of the influence would be to give the impression that these choices are in the best interest of the patient. It's not about prescribing antibiotics in order to treat hypertension. It's about brand-name recognition in situations where your choice is six-of-one and half-a-dozen-of-another. If there's otherwise nothing to choose between them, and if other physicians make the same choice in the absence of influence, how can this even be said to be harmful? And yet here we are making guidelines, writing editorials, performing research, exerting peer-pressure, and considering regulations in order to avoid this influence.

It was a radio program, but it might be transcribed somewhere. But I'm not sure where I would find the commentary on it. If I can find it, I'll post a link if you are interested.

It's up to you. If you want me to comment on it, I will. You just didn't give me enough details for me to tell whether it was relevant to the US and whether it supported your conclusion.


Cross-post.

If they would not agree with it, and I think they would not, that would just confirm that they are having a significant return on their investment through an influence on doctors' prescribing habits with the present system.
On the other hand, if it's a levy imposed by the government, though, they would have no choice?

I still don't understand why we should force them to do something they don't want to do, in order to get something from them that we shouldn't want from them in the first place.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Strange, I fully expected you to say that ALL patients are capable of understanding the options and making an informed choice. If not, I think you are now agreeing with the rest of us.

I may be agreeing with you. What do you have in mind?

And what percentage would that be?

I don’t know. It would depend on the complexity of the information being presented and the abilities of the patient. What percentage do you think it is?

What about their intellectual capacity?

Yes, that’s a factor.

What about their emotional state?

And that too.

What about their medical unfamiliarlity?

I don’t think that necessarily has to be a barrier to making reasonable decisions regarding specific health issues.

I agree. But wouldn't that be perceived as unduly influencing the patient's choice?

It could be used to influence the choice of the patient. However, the doctor should make it clear it is their personal point of view.

And then why shouldn't he also present to the patient what he feels is the best course of action?

That’s what physicians are paid for, isn’t it?

So, shouldn't he communicate that to the patient. If so, what does that mean for undue influence and patient choice?

I think a lot of medical errors could be avoided if patients regularly asked “What else could it be / could be done?” followed by “Why have you ruled those options out?”
 
Last edited:
But, if the influence is hidden, how will the individual doctor recognise the influence in order to act on it? If there is no one looking to see if the guidelines are adhered to and enforcing them, how do you prevent, for example, what has been happening in Australia for years where doctors attending CME activities had no idea that the pharmaceutical companies sponsoring the events had an input into the choice of subjects and speakers.

Okay, I've read through the transcript. It's nice to see actual investigative reporting. :)

The physicians used in the story recognized the importance of independence, and were able to correctly identify situations which were or were not independent. While the producers documented several attempts to work up to influencing the actual presentations, they also showed that those attempts were unsuccessful. The producers documented that requirements to ensure independence may have been adequate, but that the requirements were not adhered to through deception. What they didn't get in to is how the College goes about ensuring adherence to their guidelines.

It shows that even though the process failed at two levels - the directors acted in a deceptive manner and the accreditors failed to catch the deception (I could also add that the physicians involved with the institutions partnering with Healthed could/should take some responsibility for their ignorance) - it would have required failure at several more levels (the presenter providing inaccurate or misleading information on the basis of influence, the physician placing undue weight on that information despite notices of sponsorship at the actual presentation and failing to gather additional information, the physician making a recommendation to a patient that would not be made by a physician who was not subject to that influence) before it would have resulted in an action that was not in the patient's best interest. Yet most of the people involved (who were not the ones attempting to perpetuate the deception) were disturbed by the revelation (as were you and I).

It heartens me to see that we are essentially concerned about an issue of primary prevention (preventing those factors which could eventually adversely affect the patient's best interest) (appropriate given the original topic of this thread :)), rather than secondary or tertiary (identifying when the patient's best interests have already been affected) prevention. And it shows that our concerns should be directed at the accrediting bodies, as well as increasing the awareness of physicians involved in the parternerships.

Linda
 
....You assume I miss them. Just because I don’t post a pubmed abstract or journal link does not automatically mean I have not read it.
So the fact you missed an important aspect of something because you don't have a broad background in medicine not only was missed, if we are to go by this comment of yours, when I pointed out the deficiency to you you still didn't get it. Because a citation would have had ZERO to do with it.

See if you can find the two examples I pointed out in your posts, Ivor. Then try that reply again.


...That depends on the particular type of decision. To make accurate diagnoses: a lot. To decide on appropriate treatment for a confirmed diagnosis: a list of possible treatments and a list of exceptions.
We were talking about making recommendations on when to use vaccines for the entire society. How does being qualified to follow the recommendations equal being qualified to make the recommendations?


...I presume this is because I posted a list of (mainly medical) books I was reading. (I knew I’d regret it.:)) No, I want a provider who is interested in what they do.
No, that post had nothing to do with my comments. My comments follow your claim that you know as much as people with expertise in a field, and that the expertise isn't needed, in fact it only serves to bias the expert.


..How could their contribution be extremely valuable? I thought all the information discussed at an ACIP meeting would be over their heads? What could they know that the experts do not?
This is a straw man and since I never made such a claim, there is no reason I need to answer this.


..Even if a lay person did raise a point, what’s to stop the many more experts dismissing their non-expert opinion (in the nicest possible way, of course)?
If the expert opinions were correct to dismiss the lay person's point, then why should they not do so?
 
<snip>

See if you can find the two examples I pointed out in your posts, Ivor. Then try that reply again.

<snip>

I'll address this now, then I'm off to bed.

I've had a look at the thread and I found your novella-sized post (#186 on page 5) in reply to my comment about the cost-effectiveness calculations only using 1-dose in the calculations. You did not address this. What you actually did was assert I misunderstand results and conclusions. For example:

Skeptigirl at her patronising best said:
BTW, here's another lesson in how to misunderstand a medical researhc abstract when you don't have a thorough understanding of a disease.

Epidemiology of varicella-zoster virus in England and Wales

Abstract
Many countries are studying currently the possibility of mass vaccination against varicella. The objective of this study was to provide a complete picture of the pre-vaccine epidemiology of the Varicella-Zoster Virus in England and Wales to aid in the design of immunisation programs. Population-based data including general practitioner sentinel surveillance, hospitalisation data, and death certificates from England and Wales were analysed. The average incidence rates for varicella and zoster between 1991 and 2000 were 1,291 and 373 per 100,000 years, respectively. Overall hospitalisation rates were equal for varicella and zoster (4.5 vs. 4.4 hospitalisation per 100,000 population) with 5 and 8%, respectively, having underlying immunosuppressive conditions. The age-specific proportion of cases hospitalised and length of stay were similar between the two diseases. However, the overall burden of disease is considerably higher for zoster. The number of inpatient days and case-fatality due to zoster are roughly 4 to 6 times greater than for varicella (11 vs. 3 days and 25 vs. 4 deaths per 100,000 case). These results provide base-line estimates should mass varicella vaccination be introduced in England and Wales.

The baseline referred to here is intended to be compared to changes over time with implementation of vaccine programs. The conclusion for this abstract is in the italicized text.

There is not a claim here that primary varicella is not as bad as zoster. If you don't understand the disease, the population affected, the expected course of disease, then you are going to grossly misunderstand what the bolded text means. I can't overemphasize this enough. Nothing here says that without natural boosting, zoster is going to hospitalize or kill more people. Nothing here says that without natural boosting zoster will be more dangerous to people with healthy immune systems. This says nothing of the kind. You cannot assess the increased risk of zoster from decreasing primary chicken pox from the bolded data. You have no denominators. And all those people with zoster also had chicken pox initially. The disease process differs between the two presentations of the infection. The average age and additional disease conditions vary between the two groups.

As a medical practitioner, I don't draw the conclusion from this that having natural virus around boosting people against zoster is better than vaccinating people. I can see why the statement is being misunderstood.

I ask the other physicians and practitioners here to give their take on that bolded text and how it is being misunderstood by Ivor. I'm at a loss for words to explain it in 25 words or less.

All your froth below the quoted abstract where you assert what I misunderstand by the bolded section is pure straw. I know perfectly well what the bolded section means. If you need some help understanding it just say.;)

Now, care to find me a cost-effectiveness study which includes the cost of a 2-dose schedule rather than just a single dose? I've looked and I can't find one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom