yrreg, I
am ready to talk God and no God. Lets do that. But, can't we do it without "essay type test" questions where you will only speak to those who answer your specific questions with the answer you want to hear?
Instead of asking things like:
do you have a brain?
does your brain work?
does your brain experience intelligence?
do you use your brain to know realities outside the mind?
does knowledge come from a foundation of previous knowledge?
what is empirical evidence?
are communications satellites produced by manufacturers?
Why don't you just say something like:
"I propose that the moon is empirical evidence for the existence of God because man, through the foundation of previous knowledge, knows he did not manufacture the moon and he can sense this reality, which is outside his mind, through using the intelligence of the working brain that he has."
or whatever the heck it is that you are actually trying to prove.
At that point arguments can be made either for or against your proposition. That's how most forums work. If you want to turn all of us into "test subjects" for your own personal study on how atheists react to certain stimuli, I'm afraid every topic you post will end up like this one.
If you want to know what the atheist thinks, ask. Then listen to the answer. If you want the atheist to adopt your position on an issue then present your case, with all supporting evidence, right from the start.
You accuse atheists of tergiversation but this word has more than one meaning:
From 5 dictionaries:
1. To use evasions or ambiguities; equivocate. To be evasive or ambiguous. To be deliberately ambiguous or unclear in order to mislead or withhold information. Trying to avoid giving a straight answer to a straight question. Someone trying to weasel out of an untenable position. To be ambivalent or indecisive. To equivocate using subterfuge; to deliberately obfuscate.
2. To change sides; apostatize. To change sides or loyalties. Abandon one's beliefs or allegiances. A deserter from a party, a renegade or apostate. To reverse position, to apostatize, to go over to the other side. To abandon one's cause or party usually to join another.
Don't you WANT the atheists to tergiversate? Don't you WANT them to reverse their position and abandon atheism? Don't you WANT them to desert atheism and join the other side?
I know this thread is probably dead but I'm posting this anyway, just in case you actually DO want to talk God and no God.