Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

From another thread:
In this thread, I hope to overcome the divisiveness that certain trolls have sought to impose with their childish accusations and strawman arguments under the guise of investigative interviews, and instead foster understanding between theists and atheists alike.


yrreg is this really what you're attempting to do? Investigative interviews? I thought this was a debate in which arguments and counter arguments were being presented. No wonder this thread is going nowhere. :eusa_wall:



I will attempt to answer all the interview questions, to the best of my ability, so we can move forward.

Question 1 - What do you know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2009 c.e.?

Answer: "The creator of heaven and earth and everything." That's what I've been told.



Question 2 - What exactly is an empirical test by which God must be susceptible to in order that His existence can be established to the satisfaction of atheists?

Answer: A test whose results can be observed and repeated.



Question 3 - What do you think are the organs of man's experiences by which man gets to know realities outside his mind and also inside his mind*?

Answer:
  • Light detecting organs (e.g. eyes)
  • Sound detecting organs (e.g. ears)
  • Chemical detecting organs, gustation (e.g. tongue)
  • Chemical detecting organs, olfaction (e.g. nose)
  • Pressure detecting organs, somatic sensation (e.g. skin)
  • Temperature detecting organs, thermoception (e.g. skin)
  • Pain detecting organs, cutaneous, somatic and visceral

*As for realities inside his mind, I have no idea.




Question 4 - The brain of man experiences consciousness. Yes or No.

Answer: The state known as consciousness is a function of the brain but I don't think man's brain "experiences" its own consciousness in the same way that external stimuli are experienced. If the answer MUST be yes or no, then I pick no.



Question 5 - The brain of man experiences and uses reason. Yes or No.

Answer: Man uses reason, which is a process that our brain is capable of, but I don't think man's brain "experiences" its own ability to reason in the same way that external stimuli are experienced. If the answer MUST be yes or no, then I pick no.



Question 6 - The brain of man experiences and uses intelligence. Yes or No.

Answer: Man is defined as intelligent and the capacity for his intelligence is a function of the brain but I don't think man's brain "experiences" its own intelligence in the same way that external stimuli are experienced. If the answer MUST be yes or no, then I pick no.



Question 7 - Communication satellites are produced by manufacturers. Yes or No.

Answer: Yes



Question 8 - Everything man knows is founded on things he knew before. Yes or No.

Answer: Not necessarily. It would depend on what you mean by "things he knew." If the answer MUST be yes or no, then I pick no.



Question 9 - You have a brain. Yes or No.

Answer: Yes



Question 10 - Come up with a verbal account of empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.

Answer: Information gained by means of observation or experiment that is observable by the senses or otherwise measurable.


yrreg, please, now that all of the above has been answered, how does any of this lead to the conclusion that there is a god? Let's move this discussion forward.
 
Who told you God is dead? I can testify to the truth he is truly not and found through knowing our risen Lord! I would suggest to all you so called atheists to rethink your stance as God is surely never mocked! Die once, live twice!!

What is a "so called" atheist? Is it different from a regular atheist?
 
Who told you God is dead? I can testify to the truth he is truly not and found through knowing our risen Lord! I would suggest to all you so called atheists to rethink your stance as God is surely never mocked! Die once, live twice!!

Always measure twice, cut once.
 
KK always reminds me what is wrong with religion-- it's just so twisted and weird that people feel virtuous and noble for spouting inane platitudes and believing unbelievable things.

Instead of actually doing something good or useful to earn their esteem, they just feel super duper in judging others, believing nonsense, and spreading the inanity around.

If they are truly better people for their faith, I don't think I'd like to know them without faith. But I suspect that, like their god, their morality is a product of their minds.
 
(snip)

If you ask me what I know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists, here is my statement:


God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


That is what I take to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.

Yrreg

Please define "heaven".
 
I concede defeat. I absolutely believe in Poseiden. In fact, I know it is the truth that Poseiden exists. Jeeze, I hope I picked the right god to know exists. This Pascal's wager thing is a tough one. With so many hundreds of gods to choose from it's kind of a crap shoot. Can I change gods at the last minute if I turn out to be wrong. I mean, my heart's in the right place. I just don't know which one to pick so as not to be in the wrong and have to suffer eternal damnation for it. What??? It's your god I'm supposed to be believing in??? But this guy is telling me it's his god I have to believe in and then these other people are telling me some other god. It's all just so confusing. I don't want to be an evil atheist. What do I do? Do I believe what this book says? or that one? Do I worship L. Ron Hubbard??? Should I be a Moonie? Should I have moved to Jone's Town and drank Koolaid? Should I have been a Branch Davidian??? Maybe David Koresh was Jesus and I missed the boat. Please God, don't kill me and make me suffer the flames of hell for all eternity because I can't make the correct, completely arbitrary choice from among the many hundreds available. Please tell me what fairy tale to believe so I don't have to suffer undeserved, relentless agony forever and ever.
 
Last edited:
Please tell me what fairy tale to believe so I don't have to suffer undeserved, relentless agony forever and ever.
You are so screwed. The Flying Spagetti Monster has noticed that He did not appear on your list of finalists, at this point I am not sure if He will accept your conversion.
 
You are so screwed. The Flying Spagetti Monster has noticed that He did not appear on your list of finalists, at this point I am not sure if He will accept your conversion.

Yep. Dude's going to boil for all eternity in lightly salted water.
 
I'm sure it should be "There's an old saying in Tennessee—I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee—that says, fool me once, shame on—shame on you. Fool me—you can't get fooled again". (GWB)

Did we ever get to talk god or no god, or has yrreg abandoned this trainwreck for another thread of no-debate?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom